A federal bankruptcy judge in Delaware today ordered the US Trustee to appoint a consumer privacy ombudsman in the Chapter 11 case of Character Technologies, the company behind Character.ai, finding that its planned sale "may involve a transfer of personally identifiable information" as well as "other sensitive personal information of its users." Judge Brendan L. Shannon signed the four-page order, Docket No. 181, after a hearing in Wilmington, at the request of US Trustee Andrew R. Vara and with the company's consent. The ombudsman's report is due no later than seven days before any hearing on a sale, transfer or lease of that information. It goes on the docket under seal first, shown in full only to the court, the company, the creditors' committee's proposed counsel, the state attorneys general and the US Trustee, and becomes public only once redactions are agreed and approved or ordered by the court.
In Short
A judge has ordered that an independent privacy reviewer, known as a consumer privacy ombudsman, be appointed before Character.ai's user data can change hands in the company's bankruptcy sale. The reviewer will tell the court how a sale would affect the people whose information is involved, and it decides which sensitive information beyond names, addresses and email addresses falls within the Bankruptcy Code's definition of personal data for the purposes of its report. The report is due seven days before any sale hearing, which on the current schedule means Thanksgiving Day, November 26, and it stays sealed until the parties or the judge settle what to black out, so the public version may arrive only days before the December 3 hearing.
What the judge signed
The order sits in case 26-11603 (BLS), In re Character Technologies, Inc., in the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. Its title spells out the mechanism: "Order Directing the United States Trustee to Appoint a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman Pursuant to Section 332(a) of the Bankruptcy Code." It carries the reference "Re: D.I. 148," the competing proposed orders the company filed on November 12, and is dated "November 17th, 2026," in Wilmington, under Judge Shannon's name. It brings a consumer privacy ombudsman into the case for the first time.
The recitals explain why the court acted. The order was entered "upon request of Andrew R. Vara, the United States Trustee for Regions 3 and 9" and "as discussed on the record at the hearing held on November 17, 2026." The court found that the company "is pursuing a sale transaction that may involve a transfer of personally identifiable information (as defined in Section 101(41A) of the Bankruptcy Code, 'PII'), as well as other sensitive personal information of its users." It also found that "a hearing pursuant to Section 363(b)(1)(B) of the Bankruptcy Code will, therefore, be required to consider approval of the sale transaction." The final recital reads: "upon consent of the Debtor."
The operative instruction is in the first paragraph. Under section 332(a) and Rule 6004(g)(2) of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure, "the U.S. Trustee is directed to appoint one (1) disinterested person (other than the U.S. Trustee) with the requisite experience applicable to the present case to serve as the consumer privacy ombudsman in the above-captioned Chapter 11 Case."
The order does not name that person. Nor does it name Disney, Smirks and Pangs, Character.ai's app, its chatbots or its users' conversations. The word "users" appears once, in the recital about sensitive personal information.
How the company came to consent
The ombudsman has been the subject of filings since the first week of the case. On October 14, attorneys general from 39 states and the District of Columbia reserved the right to seek one, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai faced 40 attorneys general over who could buy its users' chats. Their notice set out nine conditions for any buyer, among them honoring account-level advertising opt-outs and limiting the use of chats for training and advertising beyond what users had agreed to.
On October 27, the US Trustee objected to the company's bidding procedures (Docket No. 69, according to the docket). The company's reply the same day held that its privacy policy, as in force on the petition date, already permitted the sale and transfer of user data, so no ombudsman was required, while saying it would consent to one under appropriate circumstances, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai kept its $21.7m bid floor for Disney rivals despite 32 states. Two days later, the same coalition of states joined the US Trustee and told the court an ombudsman was necessary if any property holding users' personal information were sold, as PPC Land reported when 39 states and DC said Character.ai user data needed a privacy ombudsman.
The bidding procedures order that followed left the question open. On November 12, the company filed a "Notice of Filing of Competing Proposed Orders Directing the United States Trustee to Appoint a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman," with three exhibits, according to the docket. The notice's title describes every version as an order directing an appointment, which suggests the argument had moved from whether to have an ombudsman to how the role would work. On November 15, PPC Land asked the US Trustee Program about the status of those orders and whether the review would extend to users in the European Union and the United Kingdom. The Justice Department, which runs the program, declined to comment on November 16, and PPC Land added the exchange to its report on how Character.ai users' chats faced a $10m sale to Smirks and Pangs.
The signed order does not describe what separated the competing drafts. What it records is the outcome: a request from the US Trustee, a discussion on the record, and the company's consent.
How the process works under the order
According to the order, the ombudsman process has eight steps.
- Appointment. The US Trustee appoints one disinterested person, not the US Trustee, "with the requisite experience applicable to the present case" (paragraph 1). Section 332(a) of the Code sets the outer limit: no later than seven days before the sale hearing begins. Rule 6004(g)(2) requires the US Trustee to give notice of the appointment at least seven days before that hearing.
- Scope of work. "Subject to further order of the Court," the ombudsman performs the functions in section 332(b), "including providing to the Court information to assist the Court in its consideration of the facts, circumstances, and conditions of any and all proposed sales or leases of PII, which may include sensitive personal information determined by CPO to be included within 11 U.S.C. § 101 (41A)(B)(ii)" (paragraph 2).
- The report. The ombudsman files "a complete report (the 'Report') pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 332 and 363(b), including supporting documentation, with the Court no later than seven (7) days prior to any hearing involving the sale, transfer, or lease of PII" (paragraph 3).
- Sealed filing. "The Report shall be initially filed under seal in its entirety" (paragraph 3).
- Redaction talks. The court, the company's counsel, proposed counsel to the official committee of unsecured creditors, counsel to the NAAG Client States, counsel for any other state attorney general that has entered an appearance, and the US Trustee receive the unredacted report "solely for the purpose" of discussing redactions. Sharing it for that purpose waives no privilege or protection (paragraph 3).
- Two-day window. If the parties and the US Trustee cannot agree on a proposed redaction "within two (2) days of the filing of the Report," they "shall jointly apply to the Court for resolution" (paragraph 3).
- Public version. Once an agreement is approved by court order, or the court rules by order on what to redact, "the CPO shall then file on the public docket a copy of the Report with the approved redactions." The parties keep the unredacted version confidential, and the US Trustee "shall not disclose the redacted parts of the Report (if any), consistent with 11 U.S.C. § 107(c)" (paragraph 3).
- Payment. The ombudsman "shall be compensated pursuant to Section 330 of the Bankruptcy Code, the applicable Fed. R. Bankr. P., and Local Rules upon approval by the Court of a request for compensation" (paragraph 6). Under section 330, that means fees paid from the estate after court review.
Two further paragraphs frame the work. Paragraph 5 requires the ombudsman to "comply with Section 332(c) of the Bankruptcy Code," the provision that bars an ombudsman from disclosing personally identifiable information obtained in the role. Paragraph 8 keeps the court's jurisdiction over "the implementation or interpretation of this Order."
Who sees the report, and when
The sealing provisions decide who reads the ombudsman's findings before the sale hearing. The order names five groups beyond the court.
| Recipient of the unredacted report | Basis in the order | Role in the case |
|---|---|---|
| The Bankruptcy Court | Paragraph 3 | Decides any sale of PII under section 363(b)(1)(B) |
| Counsel to the debtor | Paragraph 3 ("counsel to the Debtors") | Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, retention approved November 13 |
| Proposed counsel to the official committee of unsecured creditors | Paragraph 3 | McDermott Will & Schulte LLP; retention application filed November 16, hearing December 15, according to the docket |
| Counsel to the NAAG Client States | Paragraph 3 | The states represented by bankruptcy counsel at the National Association of Attorneys General |
| Counsel for any other state attorney general that has entered an appearance | Paragraph 3 | Texas filed a notice of appearance on November 6 (Docket No. 137); Florida filed a joinder in its own name on October 20 (Docket No. 58) |
| US Trustee | Paragraph 3 | Andrew R. Vara, Regions 3 and 9 |
The list leaves out several parties that have filed on the sale. The bidders are not on it: Disney Worldwide Services, the stalking horse for a technology license, and Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC, the stalking horse for the app, models and user data. Nor are the advocacy groups whose letters about users' chats reached the docket on November 16. PPC Land covered them when Common Sense Media told the judge AI could unmask kids in Character.ai chats, when the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action asked the judge to treat every Character.ai chat as a child's, and when the Consumer Federation of America warned about advertising technology companies and data brokers in What the therapist bot heard. Users themselves are not on the list either.
There is a route for them. Paragraph 4 states that nothing in the order "affects or waives the rights of parties in interest, by motion on notice, (i) to seek access to a document filed under seal or (ii) to seek to unseal a document filed under seal."
The definition doing the work
The order's second paragraph hands the ombudsman a determination that will shape the rest of the sale. The Bankruptcy Code defines personally identifiable information in two layers, in section 101(41A). The first covers information an individual gives a debtor in connection with obtaining a product or service from the debtor primarily for personal, family or household purposes: a first name or initial and last name, the address of a physical residence, an electronic address such as an email address, a telephone number dedicated to contacting the individual at that residence, a Social Security account number, or a credit card account number. The second layer, subparagraph (B), applies to information identified in connection with one or more of those items. Its clause (i) covers a birth date, a birth or adoption certificate number and a place of birth. Its clause (ii) is a catch-all for any other information concerning an identified individual that, if disclosed, will result in contacting or identifying that person physically or electronically.
That catch-all is where the order points. Paragraph 2 refers to "sensitive personal information determined by CPO to be included within 11 U.S.C. § 101 (41A)(B)(ii)." The same wording returns in paragraphs 3 and 7. It leaves the ombudsman to say which of the platform's other data, beyond account identifiers, is tied closely enough to an identified user to count.
The question is not abstract for this company. The schedule of assets in the Smirks and Pangs deal covers "Product Data," a category that includes accounts, characters, chat content, advertising and analytics data and training datasets, plus records of consents, advertising opt-outs and age-assurance status, as PPC Land reported when the stalking horse was named. The signed agreement filed on November 16 conditions closing on a sale order that approves the transfer of that data without further consent from third parties, as PPC Land reported this morning when the signed contract showed that Character.ai's $10m sale hinges on moving chats without further consent. Nothing in the order names chats. Whether conversations, characters or advertising profiles linked to an account fall within the catch-all is the call paragraph 2 gives the ombudsman, subject to the court.
The definition matters because of how section 363(b)(1) works. If a debtor's privacy policy in force on the petition date prohibits transferring personally identifiable information to unaffiliated persons, the debtor can sell it only if the sale is consistent with the policy, or if the court, after appointing an ombudsman and holding a hearing, approves the sale with due consideration of the facts and finds no showing that it would violate applicable non-bankruptcy law. Section 332(b) lists what the ombudsman may tell the court: the debtor's privacy policy, the potential losses or gains of privacy to consumers if the sale is approved, the potential costs or benefits to consumers, and potential alternatives that would mitigate privacy losses or costs.
A calendar with little slack
The order sets its deadline by reference to a hearing, not a date. The sale hearing is scheduled for December 3 and 4, after an auction on December 1, as PPC Land reported when the Character.ai sale notice in USA Today left 9 days to object. If that date holds, the report and the latest appointment date under section 332(a) both fall on the same day.
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| November 17, 2026 (Tuesday) | Order directing appointment of the ombudsman entered | Docket No. 181 |
| November 18, 2026, 9:00 p.m. ET | Deadline to object to the Smirks and Pangs stalking horse designation | Bidding procedures order |
| November 24, 2026, noon ET | Bid deadline | Sale notice |
| November 26, 2026 (Thursday, Thanksgiving Day) | Seven days before December 3: latest date for the report under paragraph 3 and for the appointment under section 332(a) | PPC Land calculation |
| Two days after the report is filed | End of the window to agree on redactions before a joint application to the court | Paragraph 3 |
| December 1, 2026, 10:00 a.m. ET | Auction | Sale notice |
| December 3 and 4, 2026, 9:30 a.m. ET | Sale hearing | Sale notice |
| December 31, 2026, 5:00 p.m. ET | Outside date in the Smirks and Pangs agreement | Docket No. 179 |
By PPC Land's count, that leaves nine days between today's order and the report deadline, with the appointment, the review and the report all inside that span. The report would also be due before the auction. On the current calendar, the ombudsman would report on the proposed sales as they stand at that point, before the auction settles who the buyer is.
Redaction adds its own clock. If the report is filed on November 26, two days later is Saturday, November 28, and the public version follows only after an agreed set of redactions is approved by order or the court rules. The December 3 hearing would come at most five days after that window closes.
None of this is fixed. Section 332 and the order both key the deadline to the hearing, so a later hearing moves the report date with it. The company has told the court it cannot fund a long process: in its October reply, it said its liquidity could not support a substantially extended sale, as PPC Land reported at the time.
What the order keeps open
Paragraph 7 is a reservation of rights, and it protects positions on both sides of the October dispute. Nothing in the order, or in any party's agreement to it, counts as:
- "an admission by the Debtor or any party in interest of (i) any failure to comply with applicable privacy policies or (ii) whether any proposed sale or lease of PII, which may include sensitive personal information determined by CPO to be included within 11 U.S.C. § 101 (41A)(B)(ii) complies with such policies";
- a waiver of the company's or any other party's right "to seek further recourse of the Court should any conflict arise related to the appointment and service of a CPO";
- a waiver of "the CPO's ability to seek remedy of this Court should parties fail to provide information and documentation necessary to complete their duties";
- a waiver of any other rights, "including, without limitation, the right to object to the CPO's report or any pending sale transaction."
The first clause matters most for the record. The company consented to the appointment without conceding that its privacy policy bars the sale, and no party that agreed to the order is taken to concede that the sale complies with that policy. The third clause anticipates friction over access: an ombudsman who cannot get the documents needed can go back to the court.
What the order does not say
The order names no ombudsman, sets no budget or fee cap, and gives no date for the appointment beyond what section 332(a) requires. It does not say whether the review extends to users outside the United States, how many users' records are involved (the company's first-day filings put current and past users at about 163 million, and monthly active users at about 12 million), or whether Disney's license, which the company has said gives Disney no access to user data, is within scope. It does not mention minors, chats or advertising.
Why it matters for the marketing industry
Character.ai sold advertising. The chief executive's first-day declaration put monthly ad sales at about $2.5 million against monthly losses of about $8 million, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai disclosed it was losing $8m a month despite $2.5m in monthly ad sales. The assets on offer include ad accounts, advertising and analytics data and opt-out records, and the contracts proposed for assignment to Smirks and Pangs include AppLovin, Moloco, AppsFlyer, Amplitude and Braze. If the ombudsman's report reaches those records, it will be the first independent account on the court record of what a companion chatbot company told its users about their data and what a buyer could do with it.
The order also tests a category the Code's drafters did not have in mind. The definition of personally identifiable information was written around names, addresses and card numbers, and it has no line for conversations with a chatbot. Paragraph 2 lets the ombudsman decide how much of that material, when tied to an identified user, falls inside the catch-all. The public version of the report will show how that call was made.
Other bankruptcy data sales have been built to keep personal data out. In August, PPC Land reported that Google won bankrupt Spirit Airlines' data for $10 million, a lot of deidentified corporate data that left out customer profiles and routed files through a third-party deidentification agent before delivery. The Character.ai sale runs the other way: the stalking horse agreement for the platform includes users' accounts and chats. An ombudsman cannot block a sale. What the ombudsman can do is put the privacy policy, the consequences for users and the alternatives in front of the judge before the sale order on which both stalking horse deals depend.
Key facts
- Document: "Order Directing the United States Trustee to Appoint a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman Pursuant to Section 332(a) of the Bankruptcy Code"
- Docket: In re Character Technologies, Inc., Case No. 26-11603 (BLS), US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, Docket No. 181 (re: D.I. 148), four pages
- Filed and signed: November 17, 2026, Wilmington, Delaware, by US Bankruptcy Judge Brendan L. Shannon
- Requested by: Andrew R. Vara, United States Trustee for Regions 3 and 9
- Hearing: November 17, 2026, "as discussed on the record"
- Debtor's position: "upon consent of the Debtor"
- Legal basis: 11 U.S.C. § 332(a); Fed. R. Bankr. P. 6004(g)(2), under which the US Trustee gives notice of the appointment at least seven days before the sale hearing; sale hearing under 11 U.S.C. § 363(b)(1)(B)
- Ombudsman: one disinterested person, other than the US Trustee; not yet named
- Report deadline: no later than seven days before any hearing on the sale, transfer or lease of PII; November 26, 2026 if the December 3 hearing date holds (PPC Land calculation)
- Sealing: report filed under seal in full; two days to agree redactions, then a joint application to the court; public version after court approval
- Unredacted recipients: court, debtor's counsel, proposed committee counsel, counsel to the NAAG Client States, counsel for other state attorneys general who have appeared, US Trustee
- Scope of PII: 11 U.S.C. § 101(41A), including sensitive personal information the ombudsman determines falls within § 101(41A)(B)(ii)
- Compensation: under 11 U.S.C. § 330, on court approval
- Debtor: Character Technologies, Inc., 700 El Camino Real, Suite 120, P.O. Box 1152, Menlo Park, CA 94025
Timeline
- October 13, 2026: Disney's $20 million stalking horse bid licenses Character.ai's IP, not the app; the chief executive's declaration cites about $2.5 million in monthly ad sales
- October 14, 2026: 39 states and DC set nine conditions for any buyer and reserve the right to seek an ombudsman
- October 20, 2026: Florida joins the states' notice of interest (Docket No. 58)
- October 23, 2026: 32 states object to the bidding procedures
- October 27, 2026: US Trustee objects to the bidding procedures (Docket No. 69); the company says its privacy policy permits the sale of user data but it would consent to an ombudsman under appropriate circumstances
- October 29, 2026: 39 states and DC join the US Trustee and say an ombudsman is necessary
- November 6, 2026: Texas files a notice of appearance (Docket No. 137)
- November 12, 2026: Company files competing proposed orders to appoint an ombudsman (Docket No. 148)
- November 13, 2026: US Trustee objects to Houlihan Lokey's fee
- November 14, 2026: Smirks and Pangs named stalking horse for the app, models and user data at $10 million
- November 16, 2026: Justice Department declines to comment on PPC Land's questions about the ombudsman; letters from Common Sense Media, the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action and the Consumer Federation of America reach the docket; signed Smirks and Pangs agreement filed (Docket No. 179)
- November 17, 2026: Hearing; Judge Shannon orders the US Trustee to appoint a consumer privacy ombudsman (Docket No. 181)
- November 18, 2026: Objection deadline for the Smirks and Pangs designation, 9 p.m. ET
- November 24, 2026: Bid deadline, noon ET
- November 26, 2026: Latest date for the ombudsman's report and appointment if the sale hearing starts December 3 (PPC Land calculation)
- December 1, 2026: Auction
- December 3-4, 2026: Sale hearing
- December 31, 2026: Outside date in the Smirks and Pangs agreement
Related PPC Land coverage
- 39 states and DC say Character.ai user data needs a privacy ombudsman - the states' joinder to the US Trustee's objection, and how sections 332 and 363(b)(1) work.
- Character.ai keeps $21.7m bid floor for Disney rivals despite 32 states - the company's October reply, including its position on its privacy policy and the ombudsman.
- Character.ai faces 40 attorneys general over who can buy its users' chats - the nine conditions the states set for any buyer.
- Character.ai users' chats face a $10m sale to Smirks and Pangs - the stalking horse designation for the app, models and user data, and the US Trustee's no-comment.
- Character.ai's $10m sale hinges on moving chats without further consent - the signed Smirks and Pangs agreement and the sale order terms it requires.
- What the therapist bot heard: Character.ai's chats are on the block - the Consumer Federation of America's letter on ad tech companies, data brokers and therapist bots.
- Character.ai sale contract omits 40 attorneys general's user data conditions - the form purchase agreement for the assets outside Disney's license.
- Character.ai sale notice in USA Today leaves 9 days to object - the published notice with the bid, auction and sale hearing dates.
- Common Sense Media tells judge AI could unmask kids in Character.ai chats - a letter asking for privacy protections for all conversational data.
- Treat every Character.ai chat as a child's, groups ask bankruptcy judge - the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action letter.
- Character.ai's banker faces objection to $2.05m fee on $20m Disney sale - the US Trustee's challenge to Houlihan Lokey's fee terms.
- Character.ai loses $8m a month despite $2.5m in monthly ad sales - the first-day declaration behind the user and advertising figures.
- Google wins bankrupt Spirit Airlines' data for $10 million - an earlier bankruptcy sale of company data.
Summary
Who: Judge Brendan L. Shannon of the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware; Andrew R. Vara, US Trustee for Regions 3 and 9, who requested the order; Character Technologies, Inc., the debtor behind Character.ai, which consented; the state attorneys general, the creditors' committee and the US Trustee, who receive the unredacted report.
What: An order (Docket No. 181) directing the US Trustee to appoint one disinterested consumer privacy ombudsman under section 332(a). The ombudsman reports to the court on any proposed sale or lease of personally identifiable information, including sensitive personal information it determines falls within the Code's catch-all definition. The report is filed under seal, shared with listed parties to agree redactions within two days, and published with court-approved redactions. Rights to object to the report or to any sale are preserved.
When: Signed and filed today, November 17, 2026, after a hearing the same day. The report is due no later than seven days before any hearing on a sale of personal data; with the sale hearing set for December 3 and 4, that is November 26, by PPC Land's count.
Where: Wilmington, Delaware, in case No. 26-11603 (BLS).
Why: The company is pursuing a sale that may transfer users' personally identifiable information and other sensitive personal information, which triggers a hearing under section 363(b)(1)(B). The US Trustee and 39 states and DC argued in October that an ombudsman was necessary; the company, which had said its privacy policy permitted the transfer, consented. The ombudsman's report will be the court's main independent source on what users were promised and what a buyer of their data, including chats and advertising records, could do with it.
Discussion