Kenya's High Court has set aside a KSh 1,250,000 compensation award that the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) ordered a health clinic to pay a patient who found a CCTV camera mounted in its examination room and pointed at the table where she had undressed for an ultrasound. In a judgment in Nutrihealth Solutions Limited v G.W., Civil Appeal No. E481 of 2024, Justice W.F. Andayi of the Milimani High Court's Civil Appellate Division found that the complaint had never been heard, declared the Data Commissioner's decision invalid and sent the case back for a fresh hearing. The enforcement notice that ordered the clinic to take the camera down stays in force.

The judgment carries a delivery date of November 12, and a second finding in it reaches well beyond one clinic. Section 65 of Kenya's Data Protection Act entitles a person harmed by a breach to compensation. The Act, the judge wrote, never says who decides whether that harm occurred, and it does not hand that job to the Data Commissioner. The power to order compensation sits in a 2021 regulation, not in the statute, and the court said the validity of that regulation has to be tested in judicial review or a constitutional petition, with the Attorney General heard.

In Short

A Kenyan judge cancelled a KSh 1.25 million payout that the country's data protection regulator had ordered a clinic to pay a patient filmed by a camera in an examination room, because the regulator decided the case without giving either side a hearing. The ruling matters to every company that handles personal data in Kenya, because the judge also said the Data Protection Act does not expressly allow the regulator to decide whether someone suffered damage, a power it had used in 184 compensation orders by January 2026, according to Capital FM. The clinic still has to comply with the order to remove the camera, the complaint goes back to the regulator on January 21, 2027, and the bigger question of the regulator's power to award money is left for a separate court case.

The camera in the examination room

The facts come from the judgment's summary of the record. On May 5, 2023, the respondent, identified in the judgment as G.W., attended Nutrihealth Solutions Limited's health facility for an ultrasound procedure. She had to undress and lie on an examination table. When the procedure ended, she saw a CCTV camera mounted in the room "and pointed directly towards the examination table."

The sonographer told her the camera was not working. A doctor at the clinic then told her it was there "only for monitoring purposes without recording," according to the judgment, and declined her request to see the playback of the room for the time of her examination.

She reported the matter at Parklands police station on May 12, 2023, under reference OD 36/12/5/2023. When she returned with a police officer, the clinic refused the officer access to the footage and to the examination room. The police then went to court. In Kibera Magistrates Court Miscellaneous Criminal Case No. E260 of 2023, a police corporal obtained orders to access, inspect and carry away the clinic's "CCTV DVR KIT and components" and the footage of the examination room between 16:00 and 18:00 on May 5, 2023.

The DVR went to the forensic laboratory of the Directorate of Criminal Investigations. Its report, as the judgment records it, found that the footage for the specific hour she was at the clinic "had been overwritten."

That single forensic finding is read two ways in the appeal. For the clinic, it showed that no data about the complainant was held. Its counsel argued that the storage media had been retrieved and that the forensic report confirmed it "did not hold any of the complainant's data." For the complainant, the point was the camera itself and the "lifelong trauma of knowing that there was a possibility that unauthorized parties may have access to footage she did not consent to," as the judgment summarises her complaint.

What the Data Commissioner ordered

She complained to the ODPC on December 11, 2023, according to the first paragraph of the judgment; the complaint was registered as No. 2556 of 2023. Data Commissioner Immaculate Kassait found the clinic liable, ordered it to pay KShs 1,250,000 as compensation and directed that an enforcement notice be issued. The judgment dates the determination both March 8 and March 13, 2024. The enforcement notice is dated March 8, 2024, and was delivered on March 19, 2024.

The enforcement notice imposed six requirements.

No. Requirement in the enforcement notice, as recorded in the judgment
i Uninstall the CCTV camera in the examination room and erase the recordings stored in the DVR machine
ii Install a visible privacy notice at the entrance of the premises stating that CCTV cameras have been installed
iii Conduct a comprehensive data protection impact assessment of all processing activities relating to sensitive personal data
iv Develop and implement internal procedures for data subjects to exercise their rights, and internal incident reporting mechanisms
v Implement data protection by design or by default in all processing of personal and sensitive data
vi Train all staff on the requirements and provisions of the Act within 30 days of receiving the notice

Several of those obligations will be familiar to any data controller working under European rules. The data protection impact assessment and data protection by design duties in items iii and v have direct counterparts in the GDPR, and the "health data" at issue sits in the Kenyan equivalent of what European law calls special category data. Section 2 of Kenya's Act, as the respondent's counsel set out, defines health data to include "data collected in the course of registration for, or provision of health services."

The clinic's appeal

Nutrihealth appealed through an amended memorandum of appeal dated February 13, 2025. The judgment says it rests on seven grounds and lists six. In summary, the clinic argued that:

  • the Commissioner wrongly found a breach of the rights of access and erasure when, on the clinic's case, it held no data about the complainant;
  • the finding that it processed and stored her data without consent conflicted with forensic reports indicating that no data was collected or stored;
  • the finding of liability under the Act was wrong in law and fact;
  • the compensation award, made together with the enforcement notice under Regulation 14(3)(e) and section 58, was an error of law;
  • compensation is "a judicial function not provided for in the Data Protection Act"; and
  • the Commissioner "does not have judicial powers to order compensation" and Regulation 14(3)(e) is "contra statute with the Parent Act and Article 159 (1)" of the Constitution, which vests judicial authority in courts and tribunals.

Both sides filed written submissions dated April 22, 2025. Counsel for the clinic argued that the right of access under section 26(b) applies only where a controller has collected and stored data, that the burden of proof lay on the complainant, and that the regulator "failed to draw a distinction between the mere presence of surveillance infrastructure and the actual processing or misuse of personal data."

On the power to award money, the clinic's counsel drew on two other African statutes. Under Nigeria's data protection law, counsel submitted, section 48 "expressly vests the commission with power to award compensation." Under section 99(4) of South Africa's data protection law, by contrast, compensation is pursued "as a civil remedy before a court of competent jurisdiction." Kenya's Act, the argument ran, contains neither an express grant like Nigeria's nor a court route like South Africa's, and the gap had been filled by regulation.

Counsel for the complainant relied on Article 31 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to privacy, and on sections 25, 26, 30 and 46 of the Act: transparency, informing data subjects before processing, consent, and processing sensitive data in line with the constitutional right to privacy. On the regulator's power, counsel pointed to section 65, Regulations 14(2) and 14(3), and the High Court's decision in Muthoni v Solpia Kenya Limited t/a Sista Kenya [2025] KEHC 34 (KLR), which held that it was within the Data Commissioner's jurisdiction to grant an award of compensation.

What the court decided

The appeal succeeded in part. The court's orders, and what each left open, break down as follows.

Issue Outcome
Determination, including the KSh 1,250,000 award and the finding of liability Set aside as invalid; remanded to the Data Commissioner for a hearing of the parties "on issues framed"
Enforcement notice dated March 8, 2024 Upheld; "remains in force"
Whether the clinic was liable Not decided; left to the fresh hearing
Whether Regulation 14(3)(e) validly lets the Commissioner order compensation Left open; to be raised in judicial review or a constitutional petition
Costs Each party bears its own
Next step Mention before the Data Commissioner on January 21, 2027, for directions on the hearing

A determination without a hearing

The decisive point was procedural. Quoting the determination itself, the court noted that the Commissioner had written: "This determination is therefore as a result of the complaint as received, the response by the Respondent and investigations conducted by the Office." No hearing of the parties' competing claims on compensation took place.

"I highly doubt that Parliament would have contemplated reposing such judicial or even quasi-judicial authority in the Data Commissioner to be exercised without affording the contesting parties the right to a hearing," Justice Andayi wrote. "Even if a hearing would be conducted, I again doubt that it would be by the same Data Commissioner to be the one investigating, then prosecuting it and then making a determination. That would be against all the rules of natural justice."

The conclusion followed directly. "The failure to follow the above said requisite procedural steps renders the decision of the Data Commissioner invalid," the judgment reads. "Noting that the matter did not proceed through a hearing yet the appellant was condemned to pay compensation, I find that this was a procedural error that needs to be rectified."

Using the appellate powers in section 78(1) of the Civil Procedure Act, which include remanding a case and ordering a new trial, the judge sent the complaint back to the Commissioner "to conduct a hearing of the parties on issues framed and then make a determination."

Compensation: in the regulations, not in the Act

The second strand of the judgment reaches further. The judge walked through the Act's enforcement architecture and described the Commissioner's powers as administrative: investigating complaints, issuing enforcement notices under section 58, issuing penalty notices under section 62, and imposing administrative fines under section 9(1)(f). Section 63 caps a penalty at five million shillings or, for an undertaking, one per cent of the previous financial year's annual turnover, whichever is lower.

Section 65, which grants the right to compensation, comes after the appeal provision in section 64. "This section is silent on who should make a decision regarding compensation," the judgment says. "The Act has no provision for the Data Commissioner to make a 'determination' on infringement of the rights of a data subject." Unlike the sections on enforcement and penalty notices, "there is no express provision under this section donating powers to the Data Commissioner to award the said compensation to an aggrieved person."

The court leaned on a 2026 Court of Appeal decision on statutory jurisdiction, Republic v Retirement Benefits Appeal Tribunal & 2 others [2026] KECA 849 (KLR), which held that a grant of jurisdiction to a tribunal "must, in fact, be an express conferment and not a matter of implication since a tribunal, being a creature of statute, has only such jurisdiction as has been specifically conferred upon it by the statute."

The regulations point the other way. Regulation 14(3) of the complaints regulations lists "an order for compensation to the data subject by the respondent" among the remedies a determination may include, and Regulation 14(5) makes a decision "binding on the parties" and enforceable "as an order of the Court." The clinic's argument that this was ultra vires, the judge found, "is not without merit." The judgment's summary on the point is narrow but pointed: "determination of whether or not a person has suffered damage as a result of the contravention has not been expressly assigned to the Data Commissioner by the Act. The issue needs to be considered further through an appropriate application due to its ramifications."

The judge declined to decide it. The issue had not been before the Commissioner, an appeal is too limited a forum, and a challenge to the validity of the regulations should come "either through a Judicial Review application or as a constitutional petition... where full arguments by parties are made including from the Attorney General." The court also distinguished Muthoni v Solpia, the case the complainant relied on, and the 2023 constitutional petition in the same dispute, [2023] KEHC 22373 (KLR): in neither, the judgment says, was the validity of the regulations before the court.

What stays in force

The clinic did not get everything it asked for. The judge was "satisfied that the Enforcement Notice dated 8th March 2024 was properly made in conformity with the provisions of the Act in relation to the Data Commissioner's administrative powers," and that the Commissioner "has power to ensure compliance" with it. Under section 58(3), as quoted in the judgment, failing to comply with an enforcement notice without reasonable excuse is an offence punishable by a fine of up to five million shillings, imprisonment of up to two years, or both.

Whether the clinic was liable at all is now a matter for the rehearing. The court said it could not consider the clinic's argument that the liability finding rested on speculation, because that would mean entering into the merits of a complaint that is to be heard afresh.

How the complaint process works, according to the Act and Regulations

The judgment quotes the provisions that govern a data protection complaint in Kenya. Read in sequence, they describe the following path.

  1. Complaint. Under section 56(1) and (2), a data subject aggrieved by a decision of any person under the Act may lodge a complaint with the Data Commissioner, orally or in writing.
  2. Deadline. Section 56(5) provides that a complaint to the Data Commissioner is to be investigated and concluded within ninety days.
  3. Investigation. Under section 57(1), the Commissioner may order any person to attend for oral examination or to furnish a sworn written statement. Regulation 13(1) adds the power to issue summons in Form DPC 4, examine any person, administer an oath, require documents and, with a court warrant, enter premises, search and seize material.
  4. Investigation report. Regulation 13(2) requires an investigation report on completion, and Regulation 13(3) says the Commissioner "shall be guided by the provisions of the Fair Administrative Action Act (Cap. 7J)."
  5. Determination. Under Regulation 14(1) and (2), the Commissioner makes a written determination stating the nature of the complaint, a summary of facts and evidence, the decision and its reasons, and "the remedy to which the complainant is entitled."
  6. Remedies. Regulation 14(3) lists an enforcement notice, a penalty notice imposing an administrative fine where an enforcement notice is not complied with, dismissal, a recommendation for prosecution, or "an order for compensation to the data subject by the respondent."
  7. Notice and effect. Regulation 14(4) requires the decision to be communicated in writing within seven days; Regulation 14(5) makes it binding and enforceable as a court order.
  8. Enforcement notice. Section 58(2) requires the notice to name the provision contravened, the measures required and a compliance period "not less than twenty-one days," and to state any right of appeal.
  9. Appeal. Section 64 allows any person against whom administrative action is taken to appeal to the High Court, and Rule 19 sets the window at thirty days from service of the enforcement notice.

The ninety-day clock in step 2 and the hearing the court now requires sit in some tension. In this case, by PPC Land's calculation, the complaint dated December 11, 2023, and the determination dated March 8, 2024, were 88 days apart, inside the statutory limit, or 93 days apart if the March 13 date is used. The judgment does not address how a full hearing fits within that period.

The provisions at the centre of the dispute

Provision What it says, as quoted or summarised in the judgment
Data Protection Act, s. 8(1)(a) and (f) The Office shall "oversee the implementation of and be responsible for the enforcement of this Act" and "receive and investigate any complaint by any person on infringements of the rights under this Act"
s. 9(1)(c) and (f) The Commissioner may "facilitate conciliation, mediation and negotiation on disputes" and "impose administrative fines for failures to comply with this Act"
s. 56(5) Complaints to be investigated and concluded within 90 days
s. 58(1) to (3) Enforcement notices; compliance period not less than 21 days; non-compliance an offence, fine up to KSh 5 million or up to two years' imprisonment, or both
s. 62 and s. 63 Penalty notices payable to the Office; maximum KSh 5 million or 1% of the previous year's annual turnover for an undertaking, whichever is lower
s. 64 "A person against whom any administrative action is taken by the Data Commissioner, including in enforcement and penalty notices, may appeal to the High Court"
s. 65 Compensation from the data controller or processor to a person who suffers damage from a contravention; silent on who decides, according to the court
Complaints Regulations, reg. 13 Investigation powers; investigation report; guided by the Fair Administrative Action Act
reg. 14(3)(e) "An order for compensation to the data subject by the respondent"
reg. 14(5) Decisions "binding on the parties" and "enforced as an order of the Court"
Rule 19 Appeal against an enforcement notice within thirty days of service
Constitution, Art. 31 and Art. 159(1) Right to privacy; judicial authority vested in courts and tribunals

Why the question matters beyond one clinic

The Kenyan regulator has made compensation a routine part of its work. In January 2026, Capital FM reported that the ODPC had issued 184 compensation orders since the Data Protection Act was enacted in 2019, alongside 357 determinations, 134 enforcement notices and 20 penalty notices from 9,061 complaints, in an article republished by allAfrica. According to that report, Kassait cited the determinations, enforcement notices and penalty notices ahead of the 2026 Data Privacy Day conference in Mombasa. The report gives no total value for the compensation awarded.

Those orders reach marketing directly. In April, PPC Land reported that the ODPC ordered ESHE Community to pay KES 50,000 in compensation to a medical professional whose photo appeared in promotional TikTok and Instagram videos for a health app, in a determination dated February 4, 2026. That determination rested on the same section 65, which covers financial loss and distress. The Nutrihealth judgment does not overturn that award or any other; it was a first appeal in a single case, and it left the validity question undecided. It does, however, give a reasoned High Court view that the Act itself does not assign the damages question to the regulator.

Kenya's regulator has also been widening its reach into advertising technology. In August, PPC Land reported that the ODPC's draft guidance note on artificial intelligence, dated July 2026, would require a data protection impact assessment for eight of 12 illustrative AI uses, including content recommendation on consumer platforms. A regulator that can order assessments, issue enforcement notices and fine, but whose power to award compensation is in doubt, presents companies with a different risk profile from one whose compensation orders are settled law.

Elsewhere in East Africa the line is drawn differently. When Uganda's Personal Data Protection Office ordered Google to register as a data processor in July 2025, the office said it could not award compensation to the four complainants. Nigeria, the jurisdiction the clinic's counsel held up as a model of express statutory power, saw its regulator's dispute with Meta end in a consent judgment and a $32.8 million settlement in the Federal High Court in Abuja, after Meta challenged the commission's final orders in court.

In Europe, compensation under the GDPR is a matter for the courts, and they have set their own thresholds. Germany's Federal Court of Justice held in January 2025 that a GDPR breach alone does not establish damage and a claimant must prove actual harm. In March 2026, the Higher Regional Court in Jena awarded a consumer €3,000 against Meta over Business Tools tracking that included health-related data. The Kenyan clinic's own defence, that a camera without retrievable footage is not processing, echoes the evidential questions those courts have been asked.

Camera cases have also tested regulators in Europe. Estonia's Tallinn Circuit Court backed the Data Protection Inspectorate's order requiring a CCTV operator that filmed a neighbour's property to stop or justify the filming in writing. The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled in December 2025 that body-camera footage is collected directly from the people filmed, so information must be given at the moment of collection. And Switzerland's federal data protection commissioner ordered BLT Baselland Transport to delete its bodycam footage within 30 days, an order now suspended by the operator's appeal. In each of those cases, the dispute turned on what a regulator could require about the cameras themselves; none involved a regulator awarding compensation.

How the ruling surfaced

The judgment drew attention on November 16, 2026, when Data Governance Pros Kenya, a LinkedIn page, shared the 20-page text under a question: "Can the Data Commissioner award damages to a person harmed by a data protection violation?" The post's summary matches the judgment. It notes that Regulation 14(3)(e) "expressly lists compensation as a remedy the Commissioner may order," that the court "left open whether the regulation validly confers that power," and that the court indicated "the question should be considered in judicial review or constitutional proceedings."

What the judgment does not say

The text closes with "Delivered, dated and signed on the Virtual Platform, Teams this 12th day of November, 2025," but its electronic signature is dated November 13, 2026, it cites a 2026 Court of Appeal decision and it fixes a mention date of January 21, 2027, which together point to delivery on November 12, 2026; no neutral citation was available to confirm it. The judgment also gives the award as KShs 1,200,000 in one ground of appeal against KShs 1,250,000 elsewhere, dates the complaint email to December 11, 2024, in one paragraph, and does not explain how the Commissioner arrived at the sum. No counsel appeared for the respondent at delivery.

Key facts

  • Case: Nutrihealth Solutions Limited v G.W., Civil Appeal No. E481 of 2024 (HCCA/E481/2024), High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Milimani Civil Appellate Division
  • Judge: Hon. Justice W.F. Andayi
  • Appeal from: determination and enforcement notice in ODPC Complaint No. 2556 of 2023, issued by Data Commissioner Immaculate Kassait
  • Delivery: on the Teams virtual platform; stated in the text as "12th day of November, 2025"; electronic signature dated November 13, 2026, 06:02 (UTC+3)
  • Judiciary document identity: 3034881313840521559327088170; tracking number OO72332026; 20 pages
  • Award set aside: KShs 1,250,000 compensation (KShs 1,200,000 in ground (d) of the appeal)
  • Enforcement notice: dated March 8, 2024, delivered March 19, 2024; upheld and in force
  • Outcome: appeal allowed in part; determination remanded for a hearing; each party bears its own costs
  • Next date: mention before the Data Commissioner on January 21, 2027
  • Key provisions: Data Protection Act (Cap. 411C) sections 8, 9, 56, 57, 58, 62, 63, 64, 65; Data Protection (Complaints Handling Procedure and Enforcement) Regulations, 2021, regulations 13 and 14(3)(e) and 14(5); Rule 19; Civil Procedure Act sections 78 and 79; Constitution Articles 31 and 159(1)
  • Authorities cited: Republic v Retirement Benefits Appeal Tribunal & 2 others [2026] KECA 849 (KLR); Muthoni v Solpia Kenya Limited t/a Sista Kenya [2025] KEHC 34 (KLR) and [2023] KEHC 22373 (KLR); Okiya Omtatah Okoiti & 3 others v Anne Waiguru [2021] eKLR; KELIN & others v Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Education [2016] KEHC 8450
  • Appearances at delivery: Awuor for the appellant; none for the respondent
  • Public post: Data Governance Pros Kenya on LinkedIn, November 16, 2026

Timeline

Summary

Who: Nutrihealth Solutions Limited, a health clinic; G.W., the patient who complained; Data Commissioner Immaculate Kassait and the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner; and Justice W.F. Andayi of the High Court of Kenya. The ruling affects every data controller and processor subject to Kenya's Data Protection Act, including advertisers and platforms facing complaints.

What: The High Court set aside a KShs 1,250,000 compensation award and the determination behind it because the complaint was decided without a hearing, and sent the case back to the regulator. It upheld the enforcement notice requiring the camera's removal and a privacy notice, an impact assessment, data protection by design and staff training. The judge said the Act does not expressly give the Commissioner the power to decide whether a person suffered damage, and left the validity of the regulation that grants it for a judicial review or constitutional petition.

When: The camera incident took place on May 5, 2023, and the determination is dated March 8, 2024. The judgment was delivered on November 12, 2026, according to its signature and internal references, although the text states 2025. The rehearing is listed for a mention on January 21, 2027.

Where: The High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Milimani Civil Appellate Division, on appeal from the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner.

Why: Kenya's regulator has issued at least 184 compensation orders, according to Capital FM, including one over a health app's promotional videos. A High Court finding that the statute does not expressly grant that power, together with a requirement that complaints be heard before money is awarded, changes how such orders are reached and points to a direct challenge to the regulation behind them.