SiriusXM, Pandora and Stitcher have agreed to a court-supervised overhaul of their podcast transcripts to settle a disability rights lawsuit that the National Association of the Deaf and four deaf and hard-of-hearing plaintiffs filed in Manhattan federal court in December 2021. The proposed consent decree, filed on November 16, 2026 and announced by the plaintiffs' side on November 17, sets out machine transcripts that name speakers and describe sounds, human editing for 30 shows chosen from the companies' 50 highest-earning podcasts, and $1.5 million in payments, almost all of it legal fees. Nothing in it takes effect until Judge Jeannette A. Vargas signs it.
In Short
SiriusXM and its Pandora and Stitcher services have agreed to settle a five-year lawsuit by transcribing new podcast episodes with labeled speakers, described sounds and proper punctuation, and to have people edit the transcripts of 30 shows picked from their 50 biggest earners. The deal matters to deaf and hard-of-hearing listeners, to the creators whose shows SiriusXM distributes or sells ads in, and to rivals that the National Association of the Deaf hopes will treat the deal as a benchmark. Once a judge signs it, the companies have six months, on a best-efforts basis, to build a new transcript system, and the agreement runs for 36 months under court supervision.
What the settlement requires
The announcement went out on November 17, 2026 from New York as a joint release from Disability Rights Advocates, the nonprofit law firm that represented the plaintiffs, and the National Association of the Deaf. It lists press contacts at both organizations, and Podnews republished it on November 18. According to the release, the settlement takes "the form of a consent decree, which was filed yesterday in the Southern District of New York." The court docket lists the document as a proposed consent order, entry number 141, filed on November 16.
A consent decree is a settlement the court turns into an order, which matters here because the 14-page document is enforceable by the judge for its full term. Its own clock does not start on filing. The decree defines its Effective Date as "the date that this Consent Decree is so-ordered by Judge Jeannette A. Vargas," and every deadline in it runs from that day.
According to the release, transcripts of podcasts "owned or licensed" by SiriusXM and Pandora will include three things that machine transcripts often lack: speaker identification; atmospherics, described as "nondialogue audio sounds like sound effects, laughter, and music"; and "proper punctuation, paragraph breaks, and capitalization." The release adds human cleanup, "the use of a person to review and edit a transcript produced by automatic speech recognition," for "30 podcasts to be selected by Plaintiffs from the top 50 revenue-generating podcasts."
The rest of the package, according to the release, covers custom data dictionaries ("lists of words and phrases used in specific podcasts"), an annual review of transcript quality and of the best available transcription vendor, a style guide developed "with the Plaintiffs' feedback," and staff training "on Deaf culture and communication access."
The decree itself goes considerably further than the release. It names the vendors, sets accuracy floors tied to those vendors, splits podcasts into three commercial tiers and lists the timetable in days.
Obligations and deadlines at a glance
| Obligation | Who or what it covers | Deadline or timing | Decree paragraph |
|---|---|---|---|
| Start transcribing new episodes with ElevenLabs Scribe v2 | Owned and Licensed podcasts | From the Effective Date | 28 |
| Start transcribing with Rev | Third-Party podcasts | From the Effective Date | 34 |
| Share first draft of the transcript Style Guide | All three podcast tiers | Within 14 days of the Effective Date | 23 |
| Plaintiffs comment on Style Guide draft | Plaintiffs | 30 days from receipt | 23 |
| Updated Style Guide draft, with reasons for rejected suggestions | Defendants | 30 days after receiving comments | 23 |
| Final Style Guide adopted | Defendants | Within 90 days of receiving comments | 23 |
| Draft internal accessibility Policy and Public Statement | SiriusXM, Pandora, Stitcher | Within 60 days of the Effective Date | 41 |
| Final Policy adopted | Defendants | Within 90 days of receiving comments | 41 |
| Develop and implement the Transcript Enhancement Service (TES) | Defendants | "Reasonable best efforts" within six months of the Effective Date | 21 |
| Written status updates on the TES | Plaintiffs' counsel | Every two months, three in total | 22 |
| Notice that TES work is complete | Plaintiffs' counsel | Within 14 days of completion | 25 |
| List of top 50 revenue-generating English-language podcasts | Plaintiffs | At the end of TES development | 33(a) |
| Plaintiffs pick 30 shows for Human Cleanup | Plaintiffs | Within 30 days of receiving the list | 33(a) |
| New top-50 list for annual re-selection | Plaintiffs | No later than 60 days before each anniversary of the Effective Date | 33(b) |
| Damages to four individual plaintiffs and NAD | Defendants | Within 30 days of the Effective Date or receipt of W-9 forms, whichever is later | 51-52 |
| Attorneys' fees and costs | Defendants | Same 30-day window | 53 |
| Stipulation of dismissal filed | Plaintiffs' counsel | Within 30 days of receiving the payments | 47 |
| Annual training, annual quality evaluation, Annual Report | Defendants | Every year of the term | 37, 44, 45 |
| End of the decree | All parties | 36 months from the Effective Date, extended by any TES extension | 56 |
Every date in the table runs from the judge's signature, so the deadlines are scheduled relative to that event rather than fixed to calendar dates.
How the transcript system is meant to work
Read in order, the decree sets out seven stages.
- Machine transcription from day one. From the Effective Date, new episodes of Owned and Licensed podcasts are transcribed with ElevenLabs Scribe v2, which the decree identifies as ElevenLabs' automatic speech recognition model at version 2. Third-Party podcasts go through Rev, a transcription vendor.
- A layer on top of the machine. Within six months, the companies are to build the Transcript Enhancement Service, defined as the software and services that process and improve the raw transcripts, separate speakers, apply speaker labels and format text according to the Style Guide. The obligation is phrased as effort, not guarantee: "Defendants shall use reasonable best efforts to develop and implement the Transcript Enhancement Service within six (6) months of the Effective Date." Extensions are possible for unforeseen circumstances and "shall not be unreasonably withheld," but any extension lengthens the decree.
- A written rulebook. The Style Guide covers formatting, speaker identification, speaker turns, atmospherics, long single-speaker passages, and the handling of stuttering, filler words, curse words and censored words. The plaintiffs comment, the companies explain any suggestion they reject, and the companies keep the final say on wording.
- Humans on 30 shows. Once the enhancement service is running, the decree requires that "Human Cleanup shall be performed on thirty (30) Podcasts selected by Plaintiffs." The selection starts from a list: "Defendants shall provide Plaintiffs with a list of the top fifty (50) revenue-generating English-language Podcasts." The plaintiffs have 30 days to choose. It is a human in the loop arrangement applied to a fixed slice of the catalogue.
- Annual reshuffle. Each year the companies send a fresh top-50 list no later than 60 days before the anniversary of the Effective Date, and the plaintiffs choose 30 again.
- A way out for the humans. If speech recognition improves to the point where the companies conclude Human Cleanup is no longer needed, they may propose ending it, with supporting documentation. The plaintiffs have 30 days to respond, their consent "shall not be unreasonably withheld," and they get no discovery of internal company information for this purpose.
- Complaints and checks. Transcripts or the podcast pages that host them carry a link labeled "Report a problem with the transcript," which leads to a dedicated email address. The same link sits on the SiriusXM help page (siriusxm.com/help), the Pandora help page (help.pandora.com) and the Help pages in both apps. Each year the companies evaluate a sample of transcripts against "word error rate; grammar; Speaker Identification accuracy; the accuracy, labeling, and placement of Atmospherics," plus conformance with formatting rules, and report the results to the plaintiffs' lawyers.
Every transcript must also say how it was made. The decree gives two examples of the label, "by ASR technology with human edits" and "by ASR technology alone," and leaves the exact wording to the companies. Transcripts have to appear on the companies' apps and on siriusxm.com, pandora.com and stitcher.com "in reasonable proximity to the location at which the audio content" plays.
Three tiers of podcasts, three sets of rules
The most commercially revealing part of the decree is how it sorts podcasts. It does not divide shows by genre or popularity but by the contract SiriusXM holds with the creator.
Owned podcasts are those the companies create, produce, own, control and distribute. Licensed podcasts are shows on the services where SiriusXM holds the right to sell ad space under "individually negotiated 'ad rep' agreements with the podcasts' creators." Third-Party podcasts are "any Podcast which Defendants license from third parties pursuant only to a standard licensing agreement," one not individually negotiated with the creator.
| Tier | Definition in the decree | Transcription vendor | Accuracy floor | Speaker labels, atmospherics, formatting | Eligible for Human Cleanup |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owned | Created, produced, owned, controlled and distributed by the companies | ElevenLabs Scribe v2, then the TES | "equal to or greater than that offered by ElevenLabs Scribe v2 as of the Effective Date" | Required | Yes, if among the 30 picked |
| Licensed | Ad sales rights held under individually negotiated "ad rep" agreements | ElevenLabs Scribe v2, then the TES | Same as Owned | Required | Yes, if among the 30 picked |
| Third-Party | Licensed only under a standard, non-negotiated agreement | Rev | "equal to or greater than that offered by Rev as of the Effective Date" | Not required (the quality paragraph covers Owned and Licensed only) | Not addressed in this tier's section |
The accuracy floors are pegged to each vendor's performance on the Effective Date. If the companies switch vendors, they must keep accuracy, speaker identification, atmospherics and formatting at least at the level ElevenLabs Scribe v2 offered at that point, find a replacement for Rev that is at least as accurate, and tell the plaintiffs about any change.
The release's summary, that "transcripts of podcasts that are owned or licensed" will include speaker identification and atmospherics, matches the decree. Shows that reach SiriusXM through standard licenses get a transcript and an accuracy benchmark, but the decree does not attach the speaker and sound requirements to them in the same way.
What is left out
The decree covers less than a reader of the release might assume. Its definition of a podcast is "prerecorded English-language audio content," limited to "audio on-demand content for which Defendants have the express consent of the content creators to create transcriptions." A show whose creator has not consented is outside the definition. So is live radio: the term "does not refer to audio content as it airs on live radio channels," until that content is made available on demand.
The obligation to transcribe applies to "New Episodes," defined as episodes produced and published on or after the Effective Date. Back catalogues are not covered. Non-English shows are not covered. Video podcasts are not addressed at all, even though SiriusXM's recent podcast deals cover video versions of shows. Mei Nishimoto, one of the plaintiffs, framed podcasts in the release as a source of learning "beyond reading materials and captioned videos," a reminder that closed captions on video and transcripts of audio are separate products governed by separate expectations.
Stitcher appears in the decree as a defendant and as a service, through stitcher.com, even though SiriusXM closed the standalone Stitcher app in August 2023. The defendant's corporate name also differs inside the document: the caption reads Stitcher Media Inc., while the signature block reads Stitcher Media, LLC.
The money
According to the decree, the payments break down as follows.
| Payment | Amount | Recipient | Decree paragraph |
|---|---|---|---|
| Damages to each individual plaintiff | $5,000 each | Jazmine Jones, Amber Martin, James Munro, Mei Nishimoto | 51 |
| Damages to the association | $15,000 | National Association of the Deaf, "on behalf of its members" | 52 |
| Attorneys' fees, costs and expenses, including monitoring | $1,465,000 | Disability Rights Advocates, which disburses to NAD | 53 |
| Total (PPC Land calculation) | $1,500,000 |
The decree describes the fee as "a lump sum payment for attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses" covering work through the Effective Date and the monitoring that follows. The four individual plaintiffs receive $20,000 between them, by PPC Land's arithmetic, so damages account for $35,000 of the $1.5 million, about 2.3%.
SiriusXM concedes nothing. The recitals state: "Defendants do not admit wrongdoing or concede liability, nor do they agree that Plaintiffs' allegations have merit." The plaintiffs, for their part, do not concede that their claims lacked merit. In return for the decree, the plaintiffs release claims "related to the accessibility of Defendants' products and services, including the provision of Transcripts," up to the date of the agreement. The release does not stop them from enforcing the decree itself.
Disputes follow a three-step path: a meeting within 30 days of written notice, then the court's own mediation program if the issue is not resolved within 30 days of that meeting, and then a ruling from Judge Vargas if mediation fails within 60 days. The parties will ask the court to keep jurisdiction for the full term.
What the plaintiffs and their advocates said
The release contains no statement from SiriusXM, Pandora or Stitcher. All five quotes come from the plaintiffs and their side.
Amber Martin, a plaintiff, said: "Podcasts are an indispensable media for entertainment and information sharing and it is critical that deaf people have equal access to them. I am glad that Sirius XM will provide high quality transcripts for their podcasts and I look forward to being able to enjoy and recommend them to friends and students."
Mei Nishimoto said: "I am pleased that a settlement has been reached. This expands accessibility for the Deaf community, allowing greater access to podcasts that were previously inaccessible and opening new opportunities for learning beyond reading materials and captioned videos."
James Munro dated the effort to before the filing: "This journey toward podcast accessibility began back in June 2021, and five years later, we're celebrating another important step forward." He thanked the association and its lawyers and added: "We hope this sparks even more change across the podcasting world. Let's make inaccessible podcasts a thing of the past!"
Nick Kiego, chief executive officer of the National Association of the Deaf, said the association "is thrilled to announce that the 48 million deaf and hard of hearing people nationwide will now have access to podcasts via SiriusXM and Pandora." He added: "We hope that this settlement will serve as a benchmark for other providers of podcast entertainment opening the doors for deaf and hard of hearing people to fully access, engage in, and enjoy the latest conversations in everything from politics to pop culture."
Emily Roznowski, senior staff attorney at Disability Rights Advocates, said: "Before the Plaintiffs filed this lawsuit, SiriusXM did not provide any transcripts for podcasts on its platforms. Now, SiriusXM and Pandora will have some of the highest quality transcripts in the industry, with speaker labels, atmospherics, and in some cases human editing."
That account of the starting point differs from the one SiriusXM gave in court. In an August 2022 filing reported by Podnews, SiriusXM's lawyers called the case unnecessary and said Stitcher already offered transcripts for some, though not all, podcasts. The decree itself says the companies "shall continue to provide Transcripts," wording that implies some transcripts exist now without describing how many.
Five years in the Southern District of New York
The case, National Association of the Deaf et al. v. Sirius XM Holdings Inc., et al., number 1:21-cv-10542, was filed on December 9, 2021. According to the decree, the complaint alleged violations of Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act, the New York State Human Rights Law and the New York City Human Rights Law. The case page published by Disability Rights Advocates says the companies offered no transcripts for any podcast on their platforms when the suit was filed.
The litigation moved slowly. Settlement discussions in 2023 produced no agreement, according to Radio Ink, which reported in January 2025 that the case had a new judge. The docket shows the reassignment from Judge J. Paul Oetken to Judge Vargas on December 16, 2024. According to the decree, the parties went through private mediation with retired judge Steven M. Gold. The court granted a series of requests to pause the case, with stay orders dated August 7, 2025, February 9, 2026 and April 21, 2026.
On July 29, 2026, Judge Vargas granted another stay to October 30 to let the parties finalize what the order called an agreement in principle, treated a pending motion for judgment on the pleadings as withdrawn, and warned that the court was unlikely to grant further delays. The parties reported on the negotiations on October 23. The plaintiffs and the association signed the decree between November 2 and November 4, and SiriusXM's outside counsel at Jones Day approved it as to form on November 5.
A business built on podcast ad sales
The decree's reliance on "ad rep" agreements and revenue rankings puts SiriusXM's advertising business at the center of an accessibility settlement. That business has grown quickly. SiriusXM reported that podcast revenue climbed 41% during 2025, then 37% year over year in the first quarter of 2026 and 30% in the second. Growth slowed to 20% in the third quarter, when consolidated advertising revenue stalled at $456 million and Pandora lost 2.75 million monthly users.
Much of that growth comes from shows SiriusXM does not make. In October 2025, SiriusXM secured exclusive advertising sales rights across the audio and video editions of the MrBallen podcast. In July 2026, it won exclusive ad rights to The Bald and the Beautiful, a show with more than 770,000 YouTube subscribers, under a three-year deal. Arrangements of this type, in which SiriusXM holds negotiated ad sales rights, are the kind the decree's Licensed tier describes, although the decree names no individual shows. In April, SiriusXM Media also became YouTube's exclusive US audio ad representative, an arrangement over inventory on YouTube's platform rather than on SiriusXM's own services, which the decree covers.
Machine transcription is not new inside SiriusXM's ad operation either. In June 2021, months before the lawsuit, RAIN News reported that SXM Media was using a tool from AdsWizz, SiriusXM's ad technology unit, to bring podcast transcriptions into ad targeting. AdsWizz has continued to extend its podcast tools, and in November it opened audio ads with companion banners in Apple Podcasts video episodes to more publishers.
The 36-month term will run almost entirely under new leadership. SiriusXM named Tubi's Anjali Sud as chief executive earlier in November, succeeding Jennifer Witz.
Why this matters for marketers
For advertisers, the most direct consequence is that more podcast audio will exist as text on SiriusXM's services, including, on the decree's own definition, ad content. A transcript is "the written text of the dialogue and non-dialogue audio content in a Podcast episode." On PPC Land's reading, that definition would take in host-read ads recorded into an episode, although the decree never mentions advertising and says nothing about dynamically inserted spots. Brand claims spoken in an endorsement would then appear as text next to the audio, attributed to a named speaker.
For podcast publishers, the tier system ties transcript quality to the commercial contract. Who decides which shows get the human treatment? The plaintiffs do, from a list ranked by revenue. A creator who signs an individually negotiated ad sales deal with SiriusXM moves into the tier with speaker labels, atmospherics and the possibility of human editing. A creator on a standard license gets a Rev transcript benchmarked only on accuracy. And since the transcription right depends on "express consent of the content creators," publishers decide whether their shows enter the system at all.
For the wider market, the stakes are in the benchmark. US podcast ad spend is projected at $3.40 billion in 2026, according to eMarketer figures circulated by the Video Advertising Bureau. The association's chief executive said he hopes the settlement will serve as a benchmark for "other providers of podcast entertainment." A consent decree binds only the parties that sign it. But once approved, a court-supervised document with named vendors, accuracy floors and a human editing quota gives advocates a concrete template to put in front of other platforms.
What the documents do not say
Neither the release nor the decree says how many podcasts or episodes will be transcribed, how many of SiriusXM's shows fall into each tier, what share of podcast revenue the top 50 shows generate, or what the program will cost. The decree does not address video, non-English shows or the back catalogue, and the release carries no comment from SiriusXM.
Key facts
- Source documents: "SiriusXM and Pandora Agree to Provide High-Quality Podcast Transcripts for Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing Consumers," joint release from Disability Rights Advocates and the National Association of the Deaf, dated November 17, 2026, New York; republished by Podnews on November 18, 2026
- Release URL: https://dralegal.org/press/accessible-podcasts-settlement/
- Consent decree: https://dralegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/NADvSXM_ConsentDecree_Accessible.pdf (Exhibit 1, Document 141-1, 14 pages)
- Case: National Association of the Deaf et al. v. Sirius XM Holdings Inc., et al., No. 1:21-cv-10542-JAV, US District Court for the Southern District of New York
- Judge: Jeannette A. Vargas (reassigned from J. Paul Oetken on December 16, 2024)
- Filed: December 9, 2021
- Proposed decree filed: November 16, 2026 (docket entry 141, "Proposed Consent Order")
- Effective Date: the date the decree is so-ordered by Judge Vargas (not set when the settlement was announced)
- Claims alleged: Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act; New York State Human Rights Law; New York City Human Rights Law
- Plaintiffs: National Association of the Deaf (on behalf of itself and its members), Jazmine Jones, Amber Martin, James Munro, Mei Nishimoto
- Defendants: Sirius XM Holdings Inc.; Stitcher Media Inc. (Stitcher Media, LLC in the signature block); Pandora Media LLC
- Counsel: Disability Rights Advocates (plaintiffs); Jones Day (defendants)
- Mediator: Judge Steven M. Gold (Ret.)
- Services covered: the companies' mobile apps and siriusxm.com, pandora.com, stitcher.com
- Vendors named: ElevenLabs Scribe v2 (Owned and Licensed podcasts); Rev (Third-Party podcasts); Coursera (annual training)
- Human Cleanup: 30 shows chosen by plaintiffs from the top 50 revenue-generating English-language podcasts, re-selected yearly
- Complaint link text: "Report a problem with the transcript"
- Term: 36 months from the Effective Date, extendable
- Payments: $5,000 to each of four individual plaintiffs; $15,000 to NAD; $1,465,000 in attorneys' fees and costs
Timeline
- June 2021: James Munro dates the start of the plaintiffs' push for podcast accessibility to this month.
- June 2021: RAIN News reports SXM Media using an AdsWizz tool to bring podcast transcriptions into ad targeting.
- December 9, 2021: The National Association of the Deaf and individual plaintiffs sue SiriusXM, Stitcher and Pandora in the Southern District of New York.
- August 2022: SiriusXM's court filing, reported by Podnews, calls the suit unnecessary and says Stitcher offers transcripts for some podcasts.
- 2023: Settlement talks produce no agreement, according to Radio Ink.
- August 2023: SiriusXM closes the standalone Stitcher app.
- December 16, 2024: The case is reassigned from Judge J. Paul Oetken to Judge Jeannette A. Vargas.
- October 27, 2025: SiriusXM signs an exclusive deal for the MrBallen podcast, including ad sales rights across audio and video.
- February 5, 2026: SiriusXM reports podcast revenue up 41% for 2025.
- August 7, 2025: The court grants a stay of the litigation.
- February 9, 2026: The court grants a joint request to stay litigation deadlines.
- April 21, 2026: The court grants another joint stay.
- April 22, 2026: SiriusXM Media becomes YouTube's exclusive US audio ad representative.
- April 30, 2026: SiriusXM reports first-quarter podcast revenue up 37%.
- July 2026: SiriusXM wins exclusive ad rights to The Bald and the Beautiful.
- July 29, 2026: Judge Vargas stays the case to October 30 to let the parties finalize an agreement in principle and warns that further stays are unlikely.
- July 30, 2026: SiriusXM reports second-quarter podcast revenue up 30%.
- September 2026: VAB circulates eMarketer projections of $3.40 billion in US podcast ad spend for 2026.
- October 23, 2026: The parties file a letter on the status of settlement negotiations.
- October 29, 2026: SiriusXM reports third-quarter ad revenue of $456 million and podcast growth of 20%.
- November 2-5, 2026: The plaintiffs sign the decree and Jones Day approves it as to form.
- November 4, 2026: AdsWizz extends its Apple Podcasts video ad tools to more publishers.
- November 2026: SiriusXM names Anjali Sud chief executive, succeeding Jennifer Witz.
- November 16, 2026: The proposed consent decree is filed with the court.
- November 17, 2026: Disability Rights Advocates and the National Association of the Deaf announce the settlement.
- Scheduled, 14 days after the Effective Date: First draft of the transcript Style Guide due to the plaintiffs.
- Scheduled, 60 days after the Effective Date: Draft accessibility Policy and Public Statement due.
- Scheduled, six months after the Effective Date: Target for the Transcript Enhancement Service, followed by the first top-50 list and the selection of 30 shows for Human Cleanup.
- Scheduled, 36 months after the Effective Date: The decree expires unless extended.
Related PPC Land coverage
- Pandora loses 2.75 million monthly users as SiriusXM ad sales stall at $456m - SiriusXM's third-quarter 2026 results, with podcast revenue growth slowing to 20%.
- SiriusXM advertising revenue gains 5% as YouTube deal nears launch - Second-quarter 2026 results, including 30% podcast growth.
- SiriusXM Q1 2026: profit up 20%, podcast ads surge 37%, YouTube deal looms - First-quarter 2026 results and Pandora's falling audience.
- SiriusXM beats guidance with $1.26B free cash flow as podcast ads surge 41% - Full-year 2025 results and the scale of SiriusXM's podcast growth.
- SiriusXM wins exclusive ad rights to podcast with 770,000 YouTube subscribers - A three-year deal giving SiriusXM Media ad sales rights to both audio and video versions of a show.
- SiriusXM secures MrBallen podcast in exclusive deal starting November - The 2025 agreement that brought a large YouTube storyteller's podcast and ad sales to SiriusXM.
- SiriusXM lands YouTube's audio ad rights in a deal that surprised the industry - SiriusXM Media's role as YouTube's exclusive US audio ad representative.
- AdsWizz puts audio ads with banners into Apple Podcasts video episodes - SiriusXM's ad technology unit extends audio campaigns into Apple's video podcasts.
- Podcasts to take 48% of US digital audio ad spend by 2030, VAB report shows - Projections for the US podcast advertising market.
- SiriusXM names Tubi's Anjali Sud CEO as Witz exits after nearly 25 years - The leadership change that will oversee most of the decree's term.
Summary
Who: SiriusXM Holdings, Pandora Media and Stitcher Media, as defendants; the National Association of the Deaf and four deaf and hard-of-hearing plaintiffs, Jazmine Jones, Amber Martin, James Munro and Mei Nishimoto; their lawyers at Disability Rights Advocates; and Judge Jeannette A. Vargas of the Southern District of New York, who must sign the decree.
What: A proposed consent decree that requires machine transcripts of new English-language podcast episodes, with speaker names, described sounds and formatting for shows SiriusXM owns or sells ads in under negotiated deals; human editing of 30 shows picked from the top 50 by revenue; named vendors and accuracy floors; a style guide, training, complaint links and annual reporting; and $1.5 million in payments, of which $1.465 million covers legal fees. The companies admit no wrongdoing.
When: The decree was filed on November 16, 2026 and announced on November 17, 2026. It takes effect when the judge signs it, runs for 36 months from that date, and gives the companies six months to build their transcript enhancement system. The lawsuit was filed on December 9, 2021.
Where: The SiriusXM and Pandora apps and the websites siriusxm.com, pandora.com and stitcher.com, under the supervision of the federal court in Manhattan.
Why: The plaintiffs alleged that the lack of transcripts shut deaf and hard-of-hearing people out of podcasts in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act and New York law. The decree links transcript quality to SiriusXM's advertising contracts and revenue rankings, at a time when podcasts are among its fastest growing ad businesses, and the National Association of the Deaf wants other platforms to treat it as a benchmark.
Discussion