The European Commission today preliminarily found Temu in breach of the Digital Services Act, concluding that the online marketplace has not put in place measures strong enough to keep illegal products away from shoppers in the European Union. According to the Commission, Temu's safeguards amount to "ineffective controls to check the compliance of products; a weak content moderation system; and an ineffective sanction system." The findings are not a final decision. Temu can now read the Commission's investigation file and answer in writing, and only a confirmed breach could bring a fine of up to 6% of the provider's total worldwide annual turnover.
In Short
The European Commission says Temu does too little to keep unsafe and illegal products off its EU marketplace: it asks sellers for safety test reports on only a very small share of products, its moderation looks at listings more than at the goods themselves, and its penalties close single stores while the trader behind them keeps selling through others. The finding is preliminary, so Temu can study the evidence and reply before the Commission decides whether to fine it up to 6% of its worldwide annual turnover and order changes. It is a second case on the same problem, after a €200 million fine in May for failing to assess the risk properly, and this one asks whether Temu actually acts on that risk.
What the Commission found
The case turns on a single obligation. Under Article 35 of the DSA, a very large online platform has to put in place measures that mitigate the systemic risks it has identified on its service. The Commission's preliminary view, set out in a press release published in Brussels under reference IP/26/2463, is that Temu has failed in its obligation "to put in place reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate the risk of illegal products being offered on its platform."
The release sorts its evidence under three headings. None comes with a figure. The Commission writes of a "very small share" of products, of "a large number of serious infringements" and of "a growth in listings," but it publishes no percentages, counts or reference periods. What it does publish is an unusually specific account of where, in its view, Temu's systems are looking in the wrong place.
Controls that stop short of the product
"The Commission preliminarily found that while Temu has controls in place, they do not sufficiently look at whether the products themselves comply with EU safety requirements," the release states. Two examples follow, quoted here in full:
"Temu requires sellers to provide test reports for only a very small share of products, and, even where such a report is required, it is often not checked by Temu."
"While Temu identifies some product categories as high risk (e.g. toys, electronics, cosmetics), it does not prioritise them when carrying out physical checks. In addition, the company has often not followed up on the results of the spot checks, nor has it increased the inspections in view of a growth in listings."
The second example turns Temu's own risk classification against it. The company has labelled toys, electronics and cosmetics as high risk, yet according to the Commission that label does not steer where physical inspections are directed. The categories are familiar from the first case. The €200 million decision in May drew on a mystery shopping exercise in which a very high percentage of chargers bought on Temu failed basic electrical safety tests, while a high percentage of baby toys posed safety risks rated between medium and high severity. Chargers are electronics. Baby toys are toys.
Compliance testing is a cost carried by any seller of those goods in the EU. The Commission's preliminary view is that Temu rarely asks its sellers for proof of it, and often does not read the proof when it does ask. The release does not say how many products Temu inspects physically, where the inspections take place, or who carries them out.
Moderation that reads the listing
"The Commission preliminarily found that Temu's content moderation system does not sufficiently prevent the risk of dissemination of illegal products," according to the release. It gives three examples:
"The moderation system appears to look mainly at the information attached to a product listing and on compliance with Temu's terms and conditions, rather than the safety of the product itself."
"The system that Temu has in place to compare a listing to other listings previously identified as non-compliant does not focus sufficiently on the risk of unsafe products."
"The number of human content moderators has not grown in line with the increase in the number of listings on the platform."
The first example describes a limit that applies to any marketplace. A listing is a bundle of text, images and attributes declared by a seller. Reviewing it can show whether a description breaks the platform's rules; it cannot show whether a charger overheats or a toy contains a restricted substance. The Commission's wording is hedged - the system "appears to look mainly" at listing information - which signals a reading of the evidence rather than a description of Temu's internal design.
The second example concerns what amounts to a matching tool. New listings are compared against listings already identified as non-compliant, the kind of mechanism that can catch a removed product when it resurfaces under a fresh listing. The Commission does not object to the tool's existence. Its complaint is that the tool "does not focus sufficiently on the risk of unsafe products." What the tool focuses on instead, the release does not say.
The third example is about staffing. Temu's first DSA transparency report, published at the end of November 2024, described automated tools working alongside human reviewers, with moderators put through a 10-day classroom training programme. Today's release gives no moderator headcount and no figure for the growth in listings against which the Commission measures it.
There is an overlap with work already under way. The action plan the Commission approved in October requires Temu to assess and explain the limitations and shortcomings of its proactive content moderation system and their effect on recommended products. That plan treats moderation as something Temu must analyse. Today's findings treat the moderation system's weaknesses as a failure of mitigation in their own right.
Sanctions aimed at the shopfront
The third finding concerns enforcement inside the marketplace. The Commission "also preliminarily found that Temu's sanction system does not effectively target traders; that it is too fragmented; and that it is an insufficient deterrent," according to the release. Evidence, it says, suggests that:
"Sanctions are imposed on individual stores rather than the trader behind them, although a single trader can operate several stores. A trader whose store is closed can therefore keep selling through its other stores."
"Traders can commit a large number of serious infringements, including selling products that fail safety checks, before Temu suspends any of their stores."
This is the most concrete of the three findings. A store is a storefront on the platform; a trader is the business that runs it. When penalties attach to the storefront, closing one store removes a single shop window while the business behind it carries on through the rest. For brand owners and rights holders who report counterfeit or unsafe listings, the distinction decides whether a successful complaint removes a seller or only one of its fronts.
The DSA already obliges marketplaces to collect identifying information on traders before letting them sell, under Article 30 on the traceability of traders. The release does not cite that article. Nor does it say whether Temu holds the data needed to link stores to a single trader and leaves it out of its sanctions, or whether the link is missing. The threshold for suspension is also left unstated: the Commission says only that "a large number" of serious infringements can pass before any store is suspended.
The three findings at a glance
| Area | Commission's preliminary finding | Evidence cited in the release |
|---|---|---|
| Product compliance controls | Controls "do not sufficiently look at whether the products themselves comply with EU safety requirements" | Test reports required for "only a very small share of products" and often not checked; high-risk categories (toys, electronics, cosmetics) not prioritised in physical checks; spot-check results often not followed up; inspections not increased as listings grew |
| Content moderation | System "does not sufficiently prevent the risk of dissemination of illegal products" | Review centred on listing information and terms-and-conditions compliance rather than product safety; listing-comparison system not focused on unsafe products; human moderators not increased in line with listings |
| Sanctions | System "does not effectively target traders," is "too fragmented" and is "an insufficient deterrent" | Sanctions applied per store rather than per trader; traders can commit "a large number of serious infringements" before any store is suspended |
How the procedure runs from here
According to the Commission, the next steps are:
- Temu "now has the possibility to exercise its rights of defence."
- Temu "may examine the documents in the Commission's investigation file and reply in writing to the Commission's preliminary findings."
- In parallel, the European Board for Digital Services, which brings together the national Digital Services Coordinators, is consulted.
- If the Commission's views are "ultimately confirmed," it "may adopt a non-compliance decision."
- Such a decision "can trigger a proportionate fine that may reach up to 6% of the total worldwide annual turnover of the provider and order the provider to take measures to address the breach."
The word "may" sits at both ends of that sequence. The release sets no deadline for Temu's written reply and gives no date for a decision. It also does not say which legal entity counts as "the provider" for the purpose of calculating turnover.
The first Temu case shows what can follow a decision. After the May fine, the Commission ordered Temu to deliver an action plan by August 28, 2026 under the DSA's enhanced supervision rules. The Board gave its opinion, and on October 26 the Commission accepted the plan and gave Temu four months to implement five corrective measures, followed by an external audit. That case took 304 days to move from preliminary findings, adopted on July 28, 2025, to a fine, by PPC Land's count. The Commission has given no timetable for the second.
Two cases, two articles
Today's release draws a clear line between assessing a risk and acting on it. It describes the May decision as holding Temu "in breach of its obligation to conduct an appropriate risk assessment, imposing a fine of €200 million." Today's findings, it says, "concern Temu's obligation to implement concrete risk mitigating measures under Article 35 of the DSA."
| First case | Second case | |
|---|---|---|
| Obligation | Risk assessment (Article 34) | Risk mitigation (Article 35) |
| Preliminary findings | July 28, 2025 | Today |
| Status | Non-compliance decision, May 2026 | Preliminary findings only |
| Outcome so far | €200 million fine; action plan approved October 2026 | None; fine of up to 6% of the provider's worldwide annual turnover possible |
Sources: Commission release IP/26/2463 for the description of both cases and the possible fine; the Article 34 reference and the July 28, 2025 date are from PPC Land's coverage of the action plan, which cited the Commission.
One detail differs from earlier reporting. PPC Land's report on the May fine described that decision as rooted in Articles 34 and 35 of the DSA. The Commission's account today is narrower: it presents the May breach as one of risk assessment only and places the mitigation duty in a separate, still-open case.
Two tracks running side by side
According to the release, "In October 2026, the Commission approved Temu's action plan to remedy the breach for which Temu was fined." That plan, as PPC Land reported, includes an interim risk assessment covering the six months to November 30, 2026, and the national regulators on the Board had judged it only partially adequate before the Commission approved it.
Today's findings arrive 22 days into the four-month implementation window, by PPC Land's count. The result is two tracks running in parallel. In one, Temu is redoing its assessment of the risk of illegal products under supervision. In the other, it must defend itself against a preliminary finding that its measures against that same risk do not work. The period covered by the interim assessment closes on November 30, three days after Black Friday on November 27. The release does not explain how the two tracks interact, or whether measures taken under the action plan will weigh in Temu's defence.
The proceedings themselves are now 747 days old, by PPC Land's count. When the Commission opened them in October 2024, they covered more than illegal products. According to today's release, they were opened "to assess whether Temu may have breached the DSA in areas linked to the sale of illegal products, the potentially addictive design of the service, the systems used to recommend purchases to users, as well as data access for researchers." The release says nothing about where addictive design, recommender systems or researcher access now stand.
Why the marketing community watches Temu's compliance
Temu is a regulatory case, but it is also one of the largest buyers of digital advertising. A March 2024 Wall Street Journal report, cited in PPC Land's coverage of Temu's withdrawal from US Google Shopping, put the 2023 spending of parent company PDD Holdings on Facebook and Instagram ads at about $2 billion, making it Meta's largest advertising client. Temu halted its US Google Shopping campaigns on April 9, 2025, as tariffs on Chinese imports rose.
In Europe, its presence in ad auctions has already been reshaped by trade policy. Smarter Ecommerce data showed the share of roughly 500 European advertisers facing Temu in Google Shopping auctions falling by about half from March 2026, ahead of the EU's €3 per item customs duty that replaced the €150 exemption on July 1, 2026, which had shielded low-value parcels under the EU's de minimis rules.
Today's findings concern product safety rather than advertising. Their commercial relevance lies elsewhere. Retailers that compete with Temu sellers for the same shoppers bear testing and compliance costs that, in the Commission's preliminary view, Temu rarely requires of its sellers. Brand owners that report infringing listings depend on whether a sanction reaches the trader or only a storefront. And if the Commission confirms its view, it can order Temu to change how it checks, moderates and sanctions - changes that would shape what is listed, and therefore what is advertised, on one of the largest marketplaces in the EU.
A crowded docket for marketplaces
Temu is not the only marketplace in the Commission's sights. The Commission fined AliExpress €550 million on July 20, 2026 over failures linked to unsafe and counterfeit products. Shein has faced formal DSA proceedings since February 17, 2026, covering illegal products, addictive design and recommender transparency. On October 21, 2026, the Commission opened proceedings against Booking.com over fake listings, phishing and paid listings not clearly labelled as ads.
Eleven days ago, the same procedure was applied to a social platform: the Commission preliminarily found TikTok in breach of the DSA over the "rabbit hole" effect of its For You feed, with the same right of reply, the same Board consultation and the same 6% ceiling. The first DSA non-compliance decision of all, the €120 million fine against X on December 5, 2025, concerned transparency rather than product safety.
The Commission's statement
The release carries one quote, from Henna Virkkunen, Executive Vice-President for Tech Sovereignty, Security and Democracy:
"Shopping online should not mean risking the purchase of illegal and unsafe products. Under the Digital Services Act, platforms are responsible for protecting users from the risk of illegal content and goods. The preliminary findings against Temu mark another step towards making the online world safer."
The release does not include a response from Temu.
What the release does not say
It gives no figures for the share of products that require test reports, the number of human moderators, the growth in listings or the number of infringements a trader can commit before suspension. It sets no deadline for Temu's reply, offers no estimate of when a decision might come, and names no specific remedies the Commission would expect. It does not report on the other strands of the October 2024 proceedings.
Key facts
- Source document: European Commission press release, "Commission preliminarily finds Temu in breach of the Digital Services Act for failure to tackle the sale of illegal products," Brussels, November 17, 2026
- Reference: IP/26/2463
- Source URL (print version): https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/document/print/en/ip_26_2463/IP_26_2463_EN.pdf
- Legal basis: Article 35 of the Digital Services Act (risk mitigation)
- Status: Preliminary findings; not a final decision
- Three areas found deficient: product compliance controls; content moderation system; sanction system
- High-risk categories named: toys, electronics, cosmetics
- Next steps: Temu's rights of defence (access to the investigation file, written reply); consultation of the European Board for Digital Services
- Maximum fine if confirmed: up to 6% of the total worldwide annual turnover of the provider, plus an order to take measures to address the breach
- Earlier decision: May 2026, breach of the risk assessment obligation, €200 million fine
- Action plan: approved October 2026 (October 26, according to PPC Land's coverage)
- Proceedings opened: October 2024 (October 31, according to PPC Land's coverage), covering illegal products, addictive design, recommender systems and researcher data access
- Commission official quoted: Henna Virkkunen, Executive Vice-President for Tech Sovereignty, Security and Democracy
- Related Commission items linked in the release: opening of proceedings (https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_24_5622); May 2026 fine (https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_26_1178); action plan acceptance (https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/news/commission-accepts-temus-action-plan-remedy-breach-digital-services-act)
Timeline
- May 31, 2024: Temu designated a very large online platform after reporting more than 45 million EU monthly active users
- October 31, 2024: The Commission opens formal DSA proceedings against Temu
- November 30, 2024: Temu publishes its first DSA transparency report, describing its moderation set-up
- April 9, 2025: Temu halts its US Google Shopping campaigns
- July 28, 2025: Preliminary findings on Temu's risk assessment
- December 5, 2025: The Commission fines X €120 million in the first DSA non-compliance decision
- February 17, 2026: The Commission opens DSA proceedings against Shein
- March 2026: Temu's presence in European Google Shopping auctions starts to fall
- May 28, 2026: The Commission fines Temu €200 million and sets an August 28 action plan deadline
- July 1, 2026: The EU replaces the €150 customs exemption with a €3 per item duty
- July 20, 2026: The Commission fines AliExpress €550 million
- October 21, 2026: The Commission opens DSA proceedings against Booking.com
- October 26, 2026: The Commission approves Temu's action plan, with four months to implement it
- November 6, 2026: Preliminary findings against TikTok over For You feed rabbit holes
- November 17, 2026: The Commission preliminarily finds Temu in breach of Article 35 of the DSA over ineffective product controls, content moderation and sanctions (IP/26/2463)
- November 27, 2026: Black Friday
- November 30, 2026: End of the six-month period covered by Temu's interim risk assessment
Related PPC Land coverage
- Temu faces 4-month EU deadline to redo risk assessment after €200m fine - The October 2026 acceptance of Temu's action plan, its five measures and the Board's verdict that it was only partially adequate.
- EU hits Temu with €200M DSA fine over illegal product risk failures - The May 2026 non-compliance decision, including the mystery shopping results on chargers and baby toys.
- TikTok faces fine of up to 6% over For You feed 'rabbit holes' - The Commission's previous set of DSA preliminary findings, issued eleven days earlier under the same procedure.
- EU fines AliExpress 550 million euros over unsafe product failures - The largest DSA fine so far, against another marketplace, over unsafe and counterfeit products.
- Temu releases content moderation report for EU Digital Services Act - Temu's first DSA transparency report and its description of automated and human moderation.
- Shein faces EU probe over child safety failures and addictive design - The February 2026 proceedings against Temu's closest rival.
- Booking.com faces EU probe over scams and paid listings not labelled as ads - The Commission's October 2026 case on fake listings and unlabelled paid placements.
- European Commission fines X €120 million for transparency violations - The first DSA non-compliance decision.
- Temu's abrupt withdrawal from U.S. Google Shopping - How Temu pulled its US Shopping ads in April 2025 and what it had spent on Meta.
- 3 euro parcel fee cuts Temu ad spend, SHEIN nears full exit - Smarter Ecommerce data on Temu's shrinking Google Shopping presence in Europe.
- EU ends €150 duty exemption, charging Shein and Temu €3 per item - The July 2026 customs change for low-value parcels from Chinese marketplaces.
- Court upholds Zalando very large online platform status under EU Digital Services Act - The September 2025 General Court ruling confirming that a marketplace can carry VLOP obligations.
Summary
Who: The European Commission, acting against Temu, the online marketplace designated a very large online platform under the DSA. Executive Vice-President Henna Virkkunen gave the Commission's statement. The European Board for Digital Services is being consulted. Shoppers in the EU are the people the rules protect; competing retailers, brand owners and advertisers are affected by how Temu checks products and sanctions traders.
What: Preliminary findings that Temu breached its obligation under Article 35 of the DSA to put in place reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate the risk of illegal products. The Commission cites ineffective controls on product compliance, including test reports required for only a very small share of products; a content moderation system focused on listing information rather than product safety, with human moderators not increased in line with listings; and sanctions that hit individual stores rather than the traders behind them.
When: Today, November 17, 2026. The findings come 747 days after the proceedings opened on October 31, 2024, 173 days after the €200 million fine of May 28, 2026 and 22 days after the Commission approved Temu's action plan on October 26.
Where: Brussels, under EU law, applying to Temu's marketplace across the European Union.
Why: The Commission's preliminary view is that Temu's safeguards do not stop illegal and unsafe products from being offered to EU consumers. Temu can now examine the file and reply in writing. If the Commission confirms its views, it can adopt a non-compliance decision with a fine of up to 6% of the provider's total worldwide annual turnover and order Temu to address the breach.
Discussion