A judge at the Court of Genoa has refused to stop the commercial use of a set of AI-generated "Italian Brainrot" characters on trading cards, stickers and collectibles, finding in an order dated November 6, 2026 that the people claiming to have created them had not proven enough human creative input to qualify for copyright under Italy's amended copyright law.
The order, signed by Judge Raffaella Gabriel of the court's fifth civil section in case R.G. n. 3178/2026, rejected an urgent application brought by a French rights-management company and two content creators - one Indonesian, the other a Brazilian minor represented by parents - against two companies behind the "Skifidol Italian Brainrot" merchandise. The claimants were ordered, jointly, to pay the respondents €8,059 in legal fees, plus general expenses, VAT and the Italian lawyers' pension contribution.
The decision drew wider attention on November 18, when Turin-based Nicola Berardi, IP and technology counsel at RPLT RP Legalitax, shared the full order on LinkedIn. According to Berardi, "It is the first decision applying the new provision of the Italian Copyright Law on works created with AI." Berardi also cautioned that "This is an interim decision, not a full-scope judgment ruling out copyright for AI-assisted works in general."
In Short
A Genoa judge refused on November 6, 2026 to block trading cards and stickers that used AI-made "Brainrot" characters, because the people who said they created them could not prove enough human creativity behind the images. It is an early court test of Italy's 2025 copyright rewrite, which protects works made with AI only when they are the result of the author's own intellectual work. For anyone who makes, licenses or buys AI-generated characters, the order shows that a short run of generic instructions to ChatGPT, plus a written story of the creative process, did not count as proof of authorship for this court.
A meme economy goes to court
The dispute concerns the online phenomenon the claimants called "Brainrot". According to the order, which summarises their filing, the creators published from the first months of 2025 "short surrealist-style videos of fantasy characters depicting anthropomorphic objects, or hybrids of several animals or of objects and animals" (quotations from the Italian text of the order are PPC Land's translation). Each character carries an invented name, and a narrating voice reads a caption or tells a story over the video. The label "Italian Brainrot", the claimants told the court, "does not indicate the Italian origin of the creators" but refers to the use of Italian or Italian-sounding words in the names and texts.
The scale was large. Characters attributed to the two creators reached "tens or hundreds of millions of views", according to the claimants' account. The Indonesian creator is described as one of the main exponents of a parallel strand known as "Indonesian Brainrot". The video platform on which both creators operated is redacted in the published order.
Money followed the views. The two creators signed exclusive representation and licensing agreements with the French company, which, according to the order, was set up on the initiative of an individual whose name is redacted, to promote artists and digital content creators and manage the exploitation of their intellectual property rights. The Indonesian creator had already signed a similar agreement directly with that individual in May 2025, before the company existed. Through the company, the creators obtained licences for toys, video games and NFTs, as well as influencer marketing agreements. The company also signed a deal with what the order describes as "one of the main video game platforms worldwide", which is not named.
The respondents were a company that, in its own defence, described itself as a leader in collectible products for children since the early 2000s, and its exclusive European licensee for "Skifidol Italian Brainrot" sticker collections, which also acted as exclusive distribution partner in European markets other than Italy for the Alpha series of the trading card game. According to the respondents, the first company launched the trading card game on May 9, 2025 and filed a trademark for the brand. The published order replaces the names of the parties, and of several other people it mentions, with placeholders.
The products at issue, as the claimants listed them, included the trading card game in its Alpha, Beta and Gamma series, binders, boxes and multipacks, 3D figures and, among the Panini products, stickers, albums and the official "Skifidol Italian Brainrot" magazine. The claimants alleged these were "slavish copies" of their characters, sold on a large scale and licensed to third parties without authorisation. The products, they said, carried "©" and "ALL RIGHTS RESERVED" notices in the respondent's name and no attribution to the creators, while marketing presented Italian Brainrot as a phenomenon of Italian origin, or even "100% made in Modena".
There were moral-rights complaints too. The claimants objected to unauthorised reworkings and fusions of their characters, and to their placement alongside other Brainrot characters with content they described as violent, blasphemous, Islamophobic or grossly vulgar. Their own works, they said, were suitable for a very young audience. According to the claimants, the two creators' characters frequently ranked among the five or six that licensees identified as the most attractive to the public.
What the claimants asked the court to order
The application was brought as an urgent interim measure under Articles 156 and following and 168 of the Italian copyright law, and Articles 669-bis and 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure - in effect a request for a preliminary injunction ahead of any full trial. The remedies sought were extensive.
| Remedy requested | Detail in the application |
|---|---|
| Injunction | Stop all economic exploitation of the characters in Italy and abroad: production, sale, distribution, online offers, promotional use on websites and social profiles, and licences to third parties |
| Penalty | Not less than €5,000 per violation and €2,000 per day of delay in complying, jointly against both respondents |
| Disclosure | Within 10 days: quantities of Skifidol products sold and invoices; quantities produced and supplier invoices; full list of licensees, distributors, suppliers and partners; sums collected under those agreements; commercial contracts between the respondents and with all others involved |
| Newspaper publication | The operative part of the order in two non-consecutive issues of national dailies such as "Corriere della Sera" and "Il Sole 24 Ore", in characters twice the normal size, within 10 days |
| Online publication | The operative part on the respondents' homepages via a self-executing pop-up banner, and on their Facebook, Instagram and other social profiles, for 30 days |
| Costs | Professional fees plus a 15% flat-rate reimbursement for general expenses, lawyers' pension contribution and VAT |
| Outcome | All rejected on November 6, 2026; claimants ordered to pay €8,059 in respondents' fees plus general expenses, VAT and pension contribution |
The claimants also argued unfair competition under Article 2598 of the Civil Code - slavish imitation, appropriation of merits and parasitic competition. The judge did not examine those claims. According to the order, they were only mentioned in the application "with a reservation to argue them better in the merits proceedings to be brought", with no formal request made.
Article 1, before and after Law 132/2025
The case turned on Article 1 of Italy's copyright statute, Law no. 633 of April 22, 1941. Italy rewrote that article through Law no. 132 of September 23, 2025, the national AI statute whose Article 24 delegation later produced a decree threatening companies with advertising bans for AI-related offences. The order quotes both versions word for word.
| Text of Article 1 (as quoted in the order) | PPC Land translation | |
|---|---|---|
| Before Law 132/2025 | "sono protette ai sensi di questa legge le opere dell'ingegno di carattere creativo che appartengono alla letteratura, alla musica, alle arti figurative, all'architettura, al teatro ed alla cinematografia, qualunque ne sia il modo o la forma di espressione" | "works of the intellect of a creative character belonging to literature, music, the figurative arts, architecture, theatre and cinematography, whatever their mode or form of expression, are protected under this law" |
| After Law 132/2025 | "opere dell'ingegno umano di carattere creativo che appartengono alla letteratura, alla musica, alle arti figurative, all'architettura, al teatro ed alla cinematografia, qualunque ne sia il modo o la forma di espressione, anche laddove create con l'ausilio di strumenti di intelligenza artificiale, purché costituenti risultato del lavoro intellettuale dell'autore" | "works of the human intellect of a creative character belonging to literature, music, the figurative arts, architecture, theatre and cinematography, whatever their mode or form of expression, even where created with the aid of artificial intelligence tools, provided they constitute the result of the author's intellectual work" |
Two changes stand out. The word "umano" - human - now qualifies the intellect behind a protected work. And a new clause admits works made "with the aid of artificial intelligence tools", but only on condition that they are "the result of the author's intellectual work".
Did the amendment lower the bar? Judge Gabriel concluded it did not. The principle of creativity, which "according to legal scholarship, reflects an anthropocentric view of copyright protection", remained unchanged in the rewritten norm, the order states. The new text "reaffirms creativity as the decisive feature" and, while explicitly allowing for AI assistance, "sets the condition that the work be the result of the author's intellectual work."
How the court reached its decision
The order sets out its reasoning in a fixed sequence. According to the text, the judge took these steps:
- Restated the statute. The order quotes Article 1 in its amended and previous form and identifies Law 132/2025 as the source of the change.
- Applied the established creativity test. Citing Italian Supreme Court case law, the judge held that creativity lies "not in the idea at the basis of its realisation, but in the form of its expression", and that a work must reflect "the personality of its author, manifesting the latter's free and creative choices" - a standard the order says matches the case law of the EU Court of Justice.
- Set a stricter standard for AI. Relying on a 2023 Supreme Court order involving a software-generated image, the judge said the scrutiny of creativity "must be even more rigorous when artificial intelligence tools are used".
- Rejected the list of characters (document 3). This table gave each character's name, alleged publication date, virality, a link and images. It was found to have no probative value, "lacking a signature, an attestation or any other element" that would trace the characters to the people claiming authorship.
- Rejected the written account of the creative process (document 19). This grid, broken down by character, described how each one was made. The judge found its provenance unproven "both subjectively (the person it comes from) and objectively (the source it derives from)", with nothing to show it described the process the alleged authors actually followed.
- Examined the ChatGPT session behind the lead character (document 23). Filed at the hearing of July 28, 2026 and signed by the legal representative of the French company, this document reconstructed the seven steps used on ChatGPT, with material meant to show the records had been extracted from the platform without modification. The judge accepted it might have circumstantial value as a reconstruction matching the JSON files, but held it was "not an indication of an authorial work as required by the legal framework".
- Found no prima facie case and closed the file. With the requirement known as fumus boni iuris - a plausible right - not met under the summary review proper to interim proceedings, the application failed. Costs followed the outcome, set under ministerial decree 147/2022 in the €52,000.01 to €260,000.00 bracket for cases of indeterminate value and medium complexity.
Seven prompts in about fifteen minutes
The most detailed part of the order concerns one character, which the claimants called the most important of those they claimed and on which they rested a fallback request when the hearing came to oral argument. The order's own text redacts the character's name. An exhibit reproduced in the order, headed with the Indonesian creator's online name, labels it "Tung Tung Sahur", and the creator's description in that exhibit calls it "Tungtungtungsahur, often shortened by people to TTS".
That description, written in English with an Italian courtesy translation, explains the idea at length. "I created this character from something very close to everyday life in Indonesia," it begins, going on to describe the wooden slit drum used at neighbourhood security posts and its role in waking people for sahur, the pre-dawn meal during the fasting month. "The workflow started with the name," it adds. The court did not dispute any of this as a story. It found that the story had not been proven.
The prompts themselves told a different tale. The order lists them in Italian, as the claimants presented them, with timestamps for the start of the session and for the final two steps.
| Step | Prompt as quoted in the order | PPC Land translation | Time recorded |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "disegna un pentungan per il sahur con volto e gambe" | "draw a pentungan for sahur with face and legs" | 15:11:28 (start of the process) |
| 2 | "[...] posto di guardia" (partly redacted) | "[...] guard post" | not stated |
| 3 | "Pe[...] to di guardia" (partly obscured) | "[...] guard post" | not stated |
| 4 | "volto umano" | "human face" | not stated |
| 5 | "senza mani, con gambe simili a quelle di un essere umano e un volto umano" | "no hands, with legs similar to those of a human being and a human face" | not stated |
| 6 | "Pentungan posto di guardia, 1 gamba umana" | "Pentungan guard post, 1 human leg" | 15:25:10 |
| 7 | "gamba grossa, viso simile a quello di un essere umano" | "big leg, face similar to that of a human being" | 15:26:15 |
The result of the seventh prompt was discarded and the image produced by the sixth was the one chosen and published. By PPC Land's calculation from the order's timestamps, 13 minutes and 42 seconds elapsed between the start of the session and the sixth prompt, and 14 minutes and 47 seconds to the seventh. The order rounds this to "only 15 minutes".
The judge was blunt about the content. The six - or seven - prompts were "generic in tenor", the order states: "they do not give ChatGPT specific data on the basis of which to outline the character in its concrete appearance", referring only generically to a guard post, a human face and "legs similar to those of a human being", without further detail. As a result, it was not possible to say that the outcome "derives from [the creator's] inputs" and therefore expresses the author's individuality, as the case law requires.
One leg in the prompt, two in the image
Then came the detail that Berardi called "the most striking" in the reasoning. The sixth prompt asked for a character with "1 human leg". The image it produced, which the order reproduces, shows a wooden figure standing on two human legs beside a sign that includes the words "pos ronda".
"This shows that the final form of the work does not represent the author's creative idea," the order states, "as there is no correspondence between the input - corresponding to the idea - and its realisation - which should give concrete form to the work." Together with the other factors, the judge held, that gap ruled out "the configurability of a human work" protectable under the standards set out earlier.
The logic is worth pausing on. The image that was kept contradicted the instruction that produced it. On the court's reasoning, that mismatch meant the character's concrete form had been settled by the tool rather than by the person giving the instructions. In Berardi's words, summarising the point on LinkedIn: "One leg in the prompt, two in the image."
The case law behind the test
The order leans on a dense body of Italian and European authority. None of it is new; what is new is its application to a generative AI image under the amended statute.
| Authority (as cited in the order) | Court | Point relied on |
|---|---|---|
| Cass. 13524/2014; 11953/1993; 5089/2004; 25173/2011; 21172/2011; 20925/2005; 10300/2020 | Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) | Creativity can exist in simple ideas if they are formulated and organised in a personal way; protection attaches to the form of expression, not the idea |
| Cass. 3393/2025 | Italian Supreme Court | A method of representing a story is an idea, not a protected work; authorship cannot attach to an idea separated from its verbal and graphic expression |
| Cass. ordinanza 1107/2023 | Italian Supreme Court | Software-generated image; obiter that using software "is still compatible with the creation of a work of the intellect with a degree of creativity that would only have to be scrutinised more rigorously" |
| Infopaq, C-5/08 (July 16, 2009) | EU Court of Justice | A "work" requires an original subject matter that is the author's own intellectual creation |
| Painer, C-145/10 | EU Court of Justice | Originality requires that the work reflect the author's personality through free and creative choices |
| Renckhoff, C-161/17 (August 7, 2018) | EU Court of Justice | Cited on originality |
| Levola Hengelo, C-310/17 (November 13, 2018) | EU Court of Justice | A work must be identifiable with sufficient precision and objectivity |
| Cofemel, C-683/17 (September 12, 2019) | EU Court of Justice | Originality and identifiability requirements |
| Prague court, case 10 C 13/2023 | Czech court | AI-generated image not a copyright work; the brief behind it is at most a subject or idea. Cited as food for thought, not as binding |
The Prague passage quoted in the order is close to the Genoa facts. "The applicant did not personally create the work, which was produced with the aid of artificial intelligence, and in the course of the proceedings it was not shown on which specific assignment it was based," the Czech court wrote, according to the Italian translation reproduced in the order.
What the respondents argued
The respondents attacked the claim on several fronts, according to the order. The Italian Brainrot phenomenon, they said, is "viral, collective and participatory", made of AI-generated characters continuously reproduced and reworked by users - a description that places it closer to user-generated content than to a catalogue of owned works. The characters claimed were, in their account, available on Wikimedia Commons as public domain content.
They also argued that their trading card game includes about 1,000 characters, so the ones claimed had a marginal weight in the overall product; that most of the contested products were already out of distribution or being withdrawn; that the French company was only incorporated on June 19, 2025, after the products launched; and that there was no urgency, given the time between launch and the application and the absence of remaining stock. They also argued there was no proof linking the two named creators to the holders of the relevant accounts.
The judge did not need to rule on most of this. Because the claimants failed to prove authorship and creativity at the first step, the public domain argument, the identity question and the urgency debate were left unresolved. The order notes that the judge first attempted a settlement, that the parties continued negotiating, and that only after those talks failed did they file further documents and argue the case orally.
Reaction from the legal community
Berardi's post framed the outcome in practical terms. "Describing the creative process is not the same as proving it," the post said, adding that "Ideas, inspirations and a story about creative choices are not enough without reliable evidence." Its conclusion: "keeping the output is not enough."
Not every reader found the decision convincing. Stephanie C., whose profile lists the role of group head of legal and compliance, commented: "I can't help finding the decision a little timid, though." Italy, the comment said, "is the first EU country to have written it into law" through Law 132/2025, and "The legislator opened the door."
Berardi replied that "the Court adopted a rather strict approach, but it is also consistent with the traditionally 'cautious' attitude of Italian Courts towards copyright protection." Berardi pointed to industrial design, where "in Italy, the requirement of artistic value still plays a role in the copyright protection" of design works.
What the order does not settle
The order does not name the parties or the video platform, does not give the date the application was filed, and does not say whether the claimants will challenge it or bring the full case on the merits that their application anticipated. The unfair competition claims, the public domain argument and the question of who holds the accounts remain untested. The original language of the prompts is not stated; the order quotes them in Italian.
Why it matters for marketing
Generative AI is now part of creative production for many advertisers, and ownership of the output is usually handled in platform terms and contracts. The Genoa order is a reminder that ownership and authorship are separate questions, and that the second one is decided by courts, on evidence.
The reasoning tracks closely with what the US Copyright Office said in January 2025. Its Part 2 report on copyrightability concluded that prompts work essentially as instructions conveying unprotectable ideas, and that AI outputs can be protected only where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements. A Genoa judge, applying a different statute in a different legal tradition, reached a similar destination - and added a point the Copyright Office did not have to make: the evidence of what the human did must itself be reliable.
Platform contracts are moving in the opposite direction on risk. From October 30, 2026, Meta's revised Commercial Terms make advertisers solely responsible for the output of its AI features, including features Meta switches on itself. Back in January 2025, a paper by legal scholars Mark Lemley and Peter Henderson argued that there is little basis for an AI company to claim IP rights in what its models deliver to users. Put the three together and a gap appears: a brand can carry full responsibility for an AI-generated asset while holding no enforceable copyright in it. Is a mascot that cannot be protected still a brand asset? The Genoa order does not answer that, but it narrows the room for assuming the answer is yes.
The case also lands in the middle of the creator economy, where brand deals, licensing and merchandise turn viral characters into revenue. Creator content has become a media asset in its own right, with IAB counting $37 billion of US creator ad spend in 2025. Brainrot is a large part of what feeds that machine: a Kapwing study PPC Land reported found that 33% of 500 YouTube Shorts shown to a new user were brainrot videos. A licensing chain built on AI characters is only as strong as the authorship evidence at its first link, and in Genoa that link broke.
Most of the European litigation PPC Land has followed concerns the input side of generative AI - whether training on protected works infringes. The High Court in London ruled on November 4, 2025 that Stable Diffusion's training did not infringe Getty Images' copyright. A Munich court found against Suno on July 31, 2026 in the GEMA case, setting penalties of up to 250,000 euros per violation. And on November 3, 2026, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar set out three conditions for lawful AI training in the Like Company v Google case before the EU Court of Justice. Genoa sits on the output side: not whether a model may learn from protected works, but whether what it produces can be protected at all. For the companies that sold Skifidol cards, the answer from this court, at this stage, was that the claimants had not shown it could.
The order is interim, the record is thin and the parties are anonymised. Yet the analysis of seven prompts and two legs is likely to be read well beyond Genoa, because it turns an abstract statutory phrase - "the result of the author's intellectual work" - into something a judge can check against a timestamp.
Key facts
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Court | Tribunale di Genova (Court of Genoa), V Sezione Civile (fifth civil section), single judge |
| Judge | Dott.ssa Raffaella Gabriel |
| Case number | R.G. n. 3178/2026 |
| Document | Ordinanza (order) rejecting an interim application |
| Date of order | November 6, 2026 (Genova, 06.11.2026) |
| Hearing referenced | July 28, 2026 (document 23 filed) |
| Legal bases of application | Articles 156 and following and 168 of Law 633/1941 (Italian copyright law); Articles 669-bis and 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure |
| Statute applied | Article 1 of Law no. 633 of April 22, 1941, as amended by Law no. 132 of September 23, 2025 |
| AI tool named | ChatGPT |
| Products at issue | "Skifidol Italian Brainrot" trading card game (Alpha, Beta, Gamma series), binders, boxes, multipacks, 3D figures, stickers, albums, official magazine |
| Trading card game launch | May 9, 2025, according to the respondents |
| Outcome | Application rejected in full; unfair competition claims not examined |
| Costs | €8,059.00 in fees, plus general expenses, VAT and lawyers' pension contribution, payable jointly by the claimants; ministerial decree 147/2022, bracket €52,000.01 to €260,000.00 |
| Parties | Names replaced with placeholders in the published order |
| Commentary | LinkedIn post by Nicola Berardi (RPLT RP Legalitax), November 18, 2026: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/nicolaberardi_tribunale-di-genova-ordinanza-6-novembre-ugcPost-7528593552990388224-5NDl/ |
Timeline
- January 29, 2025 - The US Copyright Office publishes Part 2 of its AI report, finding that prompts alone do not make a user the author of an output
- Early 2025 - The Indonesian and Brazilian creators begin publishing Brainrot characters online
- May 2025 - The Indonesian creator signs a representation agreement with the individual who later founds the French rights company
- May 9, 2025 - The respondent launches its trading card game, according to the respondents
- June 19, 2025 - The French rights-management company is incorporated
- June-July 2025 - The respondent grants its European licensee rights for sticker collections
- September 23, 2025 - Italy adopts Law no. 132, its national AI statute, which also amends Article 1 of the copyright law
- November 4, 2025 - The High Court in London rules that Stable Diffusion's training did not infringe Getty Images' copyright
- December 28, 2025 - PPC Land reports Kapwing's finding that 33% of 500 YouTube Shorts shown to a new user were brainrot
- July 28, 2026 - Hearing in Genoa at which the claimants file the reconstruction of the ChatGPT prompt sequence
- July 31, 2026 - Munich court rules against Suno in the GEMA case
- September 9, 2026 - Italy adopts Legislative Decree no. 160 under Article 24 of Law 132/2025, introducing advertising bans for AI-related offences
- October 30, 2026 - Meta's revised Commercial Terms make advertisers solely responsible for AI feature output
- November 3, 2026 - Advocate General Szpunar sets three conditions for AI training in Like Company v Google
- November 6, 2026 - The Court of Genoa rejects the claimants' application and orders them to pay €8,059 in fees
- November 18, 2026 - Nicola Berardi publishes the order on LinkedIn, calling it the first decision applying Italy's new provision on AI-assisted works
Related PPC Land coverage
- US Copyright Office clarifies AI-generated content rules - The January 2025 report that found prompts convey unprotectable ideas and set the human-authorship line for AI outputs in the United States.
- Italian firms face ad bans over AI-generated content offences - Italy's Legislative Decree no. 160 of September 2026, adopted under Law 132/2025, and its sanctions including bans on advertising.
- Meta makes advertisers solely responsible for its AI ad edits from Oct 30 - Meta's revised Commercial Terms shifting responsibility for AI feature output onto advertisers.
- Legal experts warn AI terms of service may prove unenforceable in court - The Lemley and Henderson paper questioning whether AI companies can claim IP rights in their models' outputs.
- High Court rules Stable Diffusion training does not infringe copyright - The November 2025 Getty Images v Stability AI judgment in London.
- Suno loses GEMA case as Munich court sets 250,000 euro penalty per breach - The July 2026 Munich judgment against the AI music generator.
- EU court adviser in Google case backs AI training on 3 conditions - Advocate General Szpunar's November 2026 opinion in case C-250/25.
- One-third of YouTube Shorts feed now consists of AI-generated slop - Kapwing research on the share of brainrot and AI slop in a new user's Shorts feed.
- Creator content is now a media asset - and brands are paying to prove it - How creator content became a paid media asset, with IAB's $37 billion US creator ad spend figure.
- What is AI slop and why advertisers should care about it now - Background on low-quality AI content and its effect on advertisers.
Summary
Who: The Court of Genoa, through Judge Raffaella Gabriel, ruling on an application by a French rights-management company and two content creators, one Indonesian and one a Brazilian minor, against a maker of collectible products for children and its European licensee. Nicola Berardi of RPLT RP Legalitax published and commented on the order.
What: The court refused an urgent injunction against "Skifidol Italian Brainrot" trading cards, stickers and collectibles, finding that the claimants had not proven human creative input in AI-generated characters. Documents listing and describing the characters had no proven origin, and the prompt history for the lead character - six or seven generic ChatGPT prompts over about 15 minutes, with a "1 human leg" instruction producing a two-legged figure - did not show an authorial work. The claimants must pay €8,059 in fees plus charges.
When: The order is dated November 6, 2026, after a hearing on July 28, 2026. Berardi's LinkedIn post appeared on November 18, 2026.
Where: Genoa, Italy, under Article 1 of the Italian copyright law as amended by Law 132/2025. The characters circulated globally online and the products were sold in Italy and other European markets.
Why: The order is an early judicial reading of Italy's new rule that AI-assisted works are protected only when they result from the author's intellectual work. It matters to advertisers, licensors and creators because it treats the evidence of human choices - not the existence of an output - as the basis of any claim, while platforms increasingly place legal responsibility for AI-generated assets on the brands that use them.
Discussion