A federal magistrate judge in Denver on April 27, 2026 ordered Colorado Attorney General Philip J. Weiser not to enforce the state's artificial intelligence law, or any law replacing it, for violations that occur up to 14 days after the court rules on an injunction motion that xAI has promised but not yet filed. The same two-page minute order gave xAI 28 days from the "final adoption" of implementing rules to file that motion. On November 19, 2026, the Colorado Department of Law adopted those rules, and the question of whether the clock is now running has moved from theory to the calendar.
In Short
A federal court in Colorado has told the state it cannot enforce its AI decision-making law until two weeks after the judge rules on xAI's request to block it, and xAI has to make that request within 28 days of the state finalizing its rules. The order protects every company covered by the law, not only xAI, and it stops the Attorney General from even opening investigations into conduct during that period. Colorado adopted its rules on November 19, so if that date counts as final adoption, xAI's filing is due on December 17, 2026, and enforcement against new conduct then waits on the court's ruling.
What the order says
The minute order, docketed as ECF No. 24 in Civil Action No. 26-cv-01515-DDD-CYC in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, was entered by Magistrate Judge Cyrus Y. Chung. It granted what the court called the parties' "Revised Joint Motion to Vacate Scheduling Conference and Suspend Case Deadlines and Stipulation to Temporarily Stay Enforcement," filed as ECF No. 22. The caption lists X. AI LLC as plaintiff, the United States of America as plaintiff-intervenor, and Weiser as defendant.
Four numbered paragraphs follow. The first sets out what Colorado may not do:
"The defendant shall not initiate enforcement, including but not limited to the initiation of an investigation, for alleged violations of SB24-205 (or any legislation replacing or amending SB24-205 enacted during this legislative session) that occurred or may occur on or before 14 days after the date the Court issues a ruling on xAI's forthcoming motion for a preliminary injunction in this case."
The second places the next move with xAI:
"xAI shall submit a motion for preliminary injunction and, if necessary, file an amended complaint, within 28 days after final adoption of rulemaking implementing SB24-205 or any legislation that may replace or amend SB24-205."
The third paragraph vacated the Scheduling Conference set for June 16, 2026 and ordered that "all case management and other deadlines are STAYED, pending the Court's resolution of xAI's forthcoming motion for preliminary injunction." The fourth denied as moot an earlier version of the motion, ECF No. 18, which xAI and the Attorney General had filed without the United States.
Two features of that first paragraph carry most of the weight. The bar is defined by when an alleged violation took place, not merely by when the state might act. Read literally, conduct occurring on or before the 14th day after the ruling falls outside enforcement under the order, whenever the Attorney General might otherwise have moved. The paragraph also reaches investigations, the step before any formal action.
The court's reasoning ran to a single sentence. After weighing the factors from String Cheese Incident, LLC v. Stylus Shows, Inc., a 2006 District of Colorado decision, the order states: "A stay will not prejudice the plaintiff, who does not oppose the motion, ECF No. 22, will avoid burdening the parties with the costs of litigating, promotes judicial economy and efficiency, does not negatively impact nonparties, and is in the public interest."
The order at a glance
| Paragraph | What it requires | Trigger or period | Status on November 22, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Attorney General may not initiate enforcement, including investigations, for alleged violations of SB 24-205 or legislation replacing or amending it | Covers violations on or before 14 days after the ruling on xAI's preliminary injunction motion | In force; no motion on the docket |
| 2 | xAI files a preliminary injunction motion and, if necessary, an amended complaint | Within 28 days after "final adoption of rulemaking" | Rules adopted November 19; the order does not define final adoption |
| 3 | June 16, 2026 Scheduling Conference vacated; all case management and other deadlines stayed | Until the court resolves the preliminary injunction motion | Stay continues |
| 4 | Original joint motion, ECF No. 18, denied as moot | April 27, 2026 | Replaced by the revised motion, ECF No. 22 |
How the order's sequence works
According to the order, the case moves through four stages before the state can enforce against new conduct.
- Rulemaking. The Attorney General completes rules implementing SB 24-205 or any legislation that replaces or amends it. No enforcement or investigation can be initiated for violations during this period.
- xAI's filing. Within 28 days after "final adoption" of those rules, xAI submits its motion for a preliminary injunction and, if necessary, an amended complaint. The amended complaint matters because the original complaint, filed on April 9, 2026, targeted SB 24-205, a statute that has since been repealed and replaced.
- The ruling. The court decides the motion. All case management and other deadlines stay suspended until then.
- The 14-day tail. The bar on enforcement covers violations through the 14th day after the ruling. What happens after that depends on the ruling itself, which the order does not anticipate.
A broader stay than first proposed
The order did not adopt the first version of the deal. On April 24, 2026, shortly after the court granted the United States' motion to intervene, xAI and the Attorney General filed a joint motion in which the Attorney General's promise not to enforce, including not to investigate, applied only to enforcement against xAI. All three parties then filed the revised motion the same day, asking the court to replace the first one. Its version of the promise contains no reference to any particular company, and the order follows that text. The practical effect is that the stay protects every business covered by the law, not only the plaintiff.
That breadth carries further because of who holds the enforcement power. According to the revised joint motion, the Attorney General "has exclusive authority" to enforce SB 24-205 under section 6-1-1706(1) of the Colorado Revised Statutes. With the only enforcer stayed, SB 24-205 had no one to enforce it during the window.
The revised motion also explains why the parties asked. According to the filing, the Colorado AI Policy Working Group convened by Governor Jared Polis published a draft bill to repeal and replace SB 24-205 on March 17, 2026. Given the chance that replacement legislation would pass during the 2026 Regular Session of the General Assembly, the Attorney General did not intend to issue rules until the session ended, and did not intend to enforce SB 24-205 or any replacement until rulemaking had concluded. The motion described SB 24-205 as becoming effective June 30, 2026.
The procedural path was short. Chief Judge Daniel D. Domenico, to whom the case was reassigned on April 14 after the parties did not all consent to a magistrate judge, referred the revised motion to Magistrate Judge Chung on April 27, and the minute order was entered the same day. The revised motion's signature blocks list Wheeler Trigg O'Donnell and in-house counsel for xAI; lawyers from the Justice Department's Civil Division and Civil Rights Division, including Assistant Attorney General Harmeet K. Dhillon; and First Assistant Attorney General Heather Kelly and Senior Assistant Attorney General Kate Field for Colorado.
Seven months of movement around a stayed case
The courtroom has been quiet since April. The legislature, a federal agency and the Attorney General's office have not.
The Colorado House passed SB 26-189 by 57 votes to 6 on May 9, 2026, repealing and replacing SB 24-205 with a narrower law on automated decision-making technology used in consequential decisions. According to the General Assembly's record, Governor Polis signed it on May 14, 2026. Its substantive obligations begin on January 1, 2027, and it required the Attorney General to complete rulemaking by the same date. PPC Land's coverage of the vote noted it was unclear whether the new law fell outside the scope of the April 27 order. The order's text covers "any legislation replacing or amending SB24-205 enacted during this legislative session," and SB 26-189 is a repeal and replacement, not a simple amendment, though the order does not name it.
Federal pressure did not wait for the court. On July 1, 2026, the Federal Trade Commission released a proposed policy statement that named Colorado's law, as amended by SB 26-189, and argued that conflicting state requirements are impliedly preempted. That statement remains a proposal, not a rule or an enforcement action.
The Attorney General's rulemaking ran through the autumn. Proposed rules were published on August 11, an interim draft followed on October 6, and a public hearing took place on October 26. According to the Colorado Department of Law, the Department adopted the rules on November 19, 2026, covering both SB 26-189 and HB 26-1263, the Conversational Artificial Intelligence Services Act, which the Department calls the Chatbot Safety Act. Among other things, the adopted rules prevent chatbot operators from relying on government identification alone for age assurance. The Department has asked the Attorney General for a formal opinion on the adopted rules. Once that opinion arrives, the rules and the opinion go to the Secretary of State, and the rules become final twenty days after publication, according to the Department.
On the docket itself, almost nothing has happened. According to the court docket, the only filings since April 27 are two motions by counsel to withdraw, filed on October 2 (ECF No. 25) and November 16, 2026 (ECF No. 28), each followed by an order. No motion for a preliminary injunction and no amended complaint appear as of the most recent entry on November 16.
When does the 28-day clock start?
The order hinges on three words it never defines: "final adoption of rulemaking."
If the November 19 adoption counts, xAI's motion is due on December 17, 2026, by PPC Land's calculation. The Department's own description points the other way, since it uses "adopted" for November 19 and reserves "final" for the point twenty days after publication by the Secretary of State. On that reading the deadline falls later, and no publication date has been set. Which reading the parties apply is not stated anywhere on the docket.
The calendar then interacts with the statute in a way that is easy to miss. SB 26-189's obligations begin on January 1, 2027. Because the bar covers violations through the 14th day after the ruling, conduct on January 1 would be open to enforcement only if the court rules on or before December 17, 2026, by PPC Land's calculation. That is the same date as the earliest possible deadline for xAI's motion. Unless xAI files early and the court decides quickly, the stay will extend past the date the new law's duties begin.
Scope is the second open question. The adopted rules implement two statutes. The order refers to SB 24-205 and legislation "replacing or amending" it, and does not mention HB 26-1263, the chatbot law. Whether the stay reaches the chatbot provisions is not addressed in the order.
Why the order matters beyond xAI
For marketers, data providers and ad tech companies, the stay is less about one AI developer than about timing. The Colorado framework governs algorithmic tools that help decide who gets a loan, a job, housing or a place in education, and the adopted rules require companies to explain adverse decisions, including the categories of data sources behind them. Vendors whose data or models feed those decisions have been preparing for obligations that start on January 1, 2027. The April 27 order means the date the law takes effect and the date the state can act on conduct are no longer the same.
The case also sits inside a wider federal challenge to state AI regulation. xAI sued on April 9, 2026, arguing that SB 24-205 violated the First Amendment, along with Dormant Commerce Clause, Due Process and Equal Protection claims. The Justice Department intervened on April 24, 2026 under the Equal Protection Clause, after the Acting Attorney General certified the case as one of general public importance. The FTC proposal added a third line of attack in July. Colorado has kept legislating and writing rules throughout, but the order means none of that work can be enforced against new conduct until a court has ruled on a motion that does not yet exist.
The order leaves several things unsaid. It does not define final adoption, does not name the chatbot statute, sets no date for a ruling, and does not say how the bar interacts with an injunction if one is granted.
Key facts
- Document: Minute Order, ECF No. 24, two pages, filed April 27, 2026
- Case: X. AI LLC v. Philip J. Weiser, Civil Action No. 1:26-cv-01515-DDD-CYC, U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado
- Parties: X. AI LLC (plaintiff); United States of America (plaintiff-intervenor); Philip J. Weiser, Colorado Attorney General (defendant)
- Entered by: Magistrate Judge Cyrus Y. Chung, on referral from Chief Judge Daniel D. Domenico
- Motion granted: Revised Joint Motion to Vacate Scheduling Conference and Suspend Case Deadlines and Stipulation to Temporarily Stay Enforcement, ECF No. 22, filed April 24, 2026
- Motion denied as moot: Original joint motion, ECF No. 18, filed April 24, 2026
- Authority cited: String Cheese Incident, LLC v. Stylus Shows, Inc., No. 02-cv-01934-LTB-PA, 2006 WL 894955 (D. Colo. Mar. 30, 2006)
- Statute named: SB 24-205 (Colorado AI Act), and any legislation replacing or amending it enacted during "this legislative session"
- Replacement statute: SB 26-189, Automated Decision-Making Technology in Consequential Decisions Act; obligations from January 1, 2027
- Not named in the order: HB 26-1263, Conversational Artificial Intelligence Services Act (Chatbot Safety Act)
- Enforcement bar: No enforcement or investigation for violations on or before 14 days after the ruling on xAI's preliminary injunction motion
- xAI deadline: 28 days after final adoption of rulemaking; December 17, 2026 if November 19 counts (PPC Land calculation)
- Vacated: Scheduling Conference of June 16, 2026
- Rules: 4 CCR 904-6, adopted November 19, 2026; Attorney General opinion requested; final twenty days after publication
- Docket since the order: ECF No. 25 (October 2, 2026) and ECF No. 28 (November 16, 2026), motions to withdraw as counsel; no preliminary injunction motion as of November 16
Timeline
- May 17, 2024 - Colorado AI Act, SB 24-205, signed
- August 2025 - Special session moves SB 24-205's effective date from February 1 to June 30, 2026
- March 17, 2026 - Colorado AI Policy Working Group publishes a draft bill to repeal and replace SB 24-205
- April 9, 2026 - xAI sues Colorado Attorney General Philip J. Weiser
- April 13, 2026 - Court sets a Scheduling Conference for June 16, 2026
- April 14, 2026 - Case reassigned to Chief Judge Daniel D. Domenico, with Magistrate Judge Cyrus Y. Chung
- April 24, 2026 - Justice Department intervenes in the xAI case; xAI and the Attorney General file a joint motion to stay enforcement (ECF No. 18), then all three parties file the revised motion (ECF No. 22)
- April 27, 2026 - Minute order grants the revised motion, bars enforcement and investigations, and vacates the June 16 conference
- May 9, 2026 - Colorado House passes SB 26-189, 57-6
- May 14, 2026 - Governor Polis signs SB 26-189
- July 1, 2026 - FTC releases proposed policy statement naming Colorado's amended law
- August 11, 2026 - Attorney General publishes proposed rules for SB 26-189 and HB 26-1263
- October 2, 2026 - First motion to withdraw as counsel (ECF No. 25)
- October 6, 2026 - Interim draft rules published
- October 26, 2026 - Public rulemaking hearing
- November 16, 2026 - Second motion to withdraw as counsel (ECF No. 28), the latest docket entry
- November 19, 2026 - Colorado Department of Law adopts the rules
- December 17, 2026 - xAI's motion deadline if the November 19 adoption counts (PPC Land calculation)
- January 1, 2027 - SB 26-189 obligations begin
Related PPC Land coverage
- xAI sues Colorado to block AI bias law, claiming First Amendment violations - The April 9, 2026 complaint against Attorney General Philip J. Weiser that started the case.
- U.S. joins xAI's fight against Colorado's AI bias law - The Justice Department's Equal Protection complaint in intervention, filed April 24, 2026.
- Colorado passes SB 26-189: the AI decision law that rewrites the rules - The May 2026 vote that repealed and replaced the Colorado AI Act and set the January 1, 2027 rulemaking deadline.
- FTC move could force Colorado to rewrite new AI bias law - The FTC's July 2026 proposed policy statement arguing implied preemption of Colorado's amended law.
Summary
Who: Magistrate Judge Cyrus Y. Chung of the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, in a case brought by xAI against Colorado Attorney General Philip J. Weiser, with the United States as plaintiff-intervenor. The order affects every company covered by Colorado's AI decision-making law.
What: A minute order granting a stipulated stay. The Attorney General may not initiate enforcement or investigations for violations of SB 24-205, or legislation replacing or amending it, that occur on or before 14 days after the court rules on xAI's preliminary injunction motion. xAI must file that motion within 28 days after final adoption of implementing rules. All case deadlines are stayed and the June 16, 2026 Scheduling Conference was vacated.
When: The order was entered on April 27, 2026. Colorado adopted implementing rules on November 19, 2026, which puts xAI's deadline at December 17, 2026 if that date counts as final adoption, by PPC Land's calculation. SB 26-189's obligations begin on January 1, 2027.
Where: The U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado in Denver, in Civil Action No. 1:26-cv-01515-DDD-CYC, concerning a Colorado state law.
Why: The parties asked for the stay because Colorado was expected to replace SB 24-205 during the 2026 legislative session and the Attorney General needed to complete rulemaking before enforcing any version of the law. The legislature did replace it with SB 26-189, and the rules now adopted bring the order's 28-day trigger into play, with the court's eventual ruling deciding when Colorado can act on new conduct.
Discussion