Paying with personal data is still paying. That is the reading Advocate General Laila Medina put to the Court of Justice of the European Union on 19 November 2026, in an opinion that would stop traders from describing a service as "free" when consumers must hand over personal data, and consent to its commercial use, in order to get it. The case, C-643/25, turns on a five-word statement that appeared on the German-language registration page of Facebook in February 2015: "Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos" - Facebook is and remains free.

Germany's federation of consumer organisations, the Bundesverband der Verbraucherzentralen und Verbraucherverbände - Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband e.V. (vzbv), has pursued that sentence through three levels of German courts against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, which operates Facebook in the European Union. Two courts in Berlin dismissed the claim, holding that the ban on false "free" claims covers only financial costs. The Bundesgerichtshof, Germany's Federal Court of Justice, then asked Luxembourg to decide what the word "cost" means in the EU's list of commercial practices that are banned in all circumstances. According to the opinion, the answer is that it covers "the disclosure of personal data by the consumer and his or her consent to the use of those data for commercial purposes," unless the data serve only to supply the service or to meet legal obligations.

In Short

An adviser to the EU's top court says a social network that requires people to hand over personal data and agree to its commercial use cannot call itself free under EU consumer law, in a case brought over Facebook's 2015 "Facebook is and remains free" slogan. The reading reaches beyond Meta: point 20 of the EU blacklist applies to every trader selling to consumers, so any app, platform or site whose sign-up data pays for advertising would be affected if the Court agrees. The opinion is not binding, the Court's judges have only now begun deliberating, and Germany's Federal Court of Justice will decide the case itself once they rule.

Five words on a sign-up page

The dispute is old by the standards of digital advertising. According to the opinion, the statement in question was shown on the German-language registration page of the Facebook website in February 2015. The vzbv argued that the service was not free, "since users provide their personal data in exchange for that use," and asked the Landgericht Berlin (Regional Court, Berlin) to order Meta to stop using the statement on its website in dealings with consumers resident in Germany.

The Regional Court dismissed the action on 16 January 2018. It held, according to the opinion, that the German provision transposing the EU rule "applies only where there are hidden costs, in the sense of a direct or indirect payment obligation or a financial burden on the consumer." Handing over personal data and consenting to its processing, the court said, affects consumers "only in his or her immaterial interests, namely the right to self-determination as regards information." The Kammergericht (Higher Regional Court, Berlin) dismissed the vzbv's appeal on 20 December 2019.

The Federal Court of Justice took a less settled view. According to the opinion, it considered that the concept of costs covers "in any event, burdens which diminish the consumer's assets," and that personal data and consent "may be regarded as falling within that concept of costs, since such data constitute a valuable asset for the undertaking that exploits them." Because its decisions cannot be appealed and the answer was not "so obvious as to leave no scope for any reasonable doubt," it stayed the proceedings and referred one question:

"Does the term 'cost' within the meaning of point 20 of Annex I to [Directive 2005/29], in conjunction with Article 5(5) thereof, also cover the disclosure of personal data and consent to their use for commercial purposes?"

Why would a slogan from 2015 still matter more than a decade later? The injunction the vzbv seeks requires the conduct to have been unlawful at two moments: in February 2015, and on the date of the hearing in the Federal Court of Justice, which was held on 3 July 2025. According to the opinion, neither Article 5 of the directive nor point 20 of its annex was changed by the 2019 consumer law overhaul, Directive (EU) 2019/2161, or by the 2024 green transition directive, Directive (EU) 2024/825, whose transposition deadline was 27 March 2026 and whose measures apply from 27 September 2026. The analysis therefore covers both dates.

The rule at issue

The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, Directive 2005/29/EC of 11 May 2005, works on two levels. Most practices are judged case by case against general tests of whether they are misleading or aggressive. Annex I is different: it is a blacklist of practices that are unfair without any such assessment. Recital 17 of the directive states: "These are the only commercial practices which can be deemed to be unfair without a case-by-case assessment against the provisions of Articles 5 to 9. The list may only be modified by revision of the Directive."

The provisions at the centre of the case read as follows.

Provision Wording Status
Article 5(5), Directive 2005/29/EC "Annex I contains the list of those commercial practices which shall in all circumstances be regarded as unfair. The same single list shall apply in all Member States and may only be modified by revision of this Directive." Not amended between 2015 and 2025, according to the opinion
Point 20 of Annex I "Describing a product as 'gratis', 'free', 'without charge' or similar if the consumer has to pay anything other than the unavoidable cost of responding to the commercial practice and collecting or paying for delivery of the item." Not amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2161 or Directive (EU) 2024/825; unchanged between 2015 and 2025
Article 2(c), original text "'product' means any goods or service including immovable property, rights and obligations" Applied in February 2015
Article 2(c), as replaced by Article 3(1)(a) of Directive (EU) 2019/2161 "'product' means any good or service including immovable property, digital service and digital content, as well as rights and obligations" Current text
German UWG, annex to Paragraph 3(3), point 21 (version at the material time) Offering a good or service as "gratis", "free of charge", "without cost" or similar, where costs must nevertheless be borne, is unlawful German transposition then in force
German UWG, annex to Paragraph 3(3), point 20 (current version) Now entitled "Misleading advertising claiming that something is free of charge"; such offers are "always unlawful where costs must nevertheless be borne for the good or service concerned" Current German transposition

Medina first settled two threshold points. Running a social network and supplying it to users is a service under Article 2(c), both before and after the 2019 amendment expressly added digital services. Describing that service as free on the registration page is a business-to-consumer commercial practice under Article 2(d), "being a representation directly connected with the promotion of a product." The practice therefore falls within the directive.

Three readings, twenty language versions

The Federal Court of Justice framed its question in terms of "cost" because the German text of point 20 bans a "free" label where the consumer has to bear further costs - "weitere Kosten ... zu tragen hat." Other language versions refer instead to what the consumer "has to pay." Medina treated the concept requiring interpretation as what the consumer "has to pay," and then compared the language versions. They do not agree.

Group What the wording covers Language versions cited Example given in the opinion
1 Payment of a sum of money Bulgarian, Croatian, Estonian, Finnish, Polish, Romanian, Slovenian, Spanish Spanish requires the consumer to "abonar dinero por cualquier concepto distinto" ("pay money for anything other than"), "among the most explicit references to money in any version"
2 A charge of any kind, including non-monetary counter-performance with economic value German, Italian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Portuguese, Slovak German: "weitere Kosten ... zu tragen hat," a verb "denoting the bearing of a burden rather than the payment of a price"
3 Either reading Dutch, English, Greek, Hungarian, Maltese, Swedish English: "if the consumer has to pay anything other than the unavoidable cost," where "pay ordinarily denotes a sum of money but may extend to the supply of other things of value"

Some of the classifications are finely balanced. The Italian terms "pagare" and "costo" suggest money, the opinion concedes, although "their use in a more general sense, denoting any counter-performance, cannot be excluded." The Estonian version includes "ilma rahata," meaning "without money." The Dutch version lists "voor niets," literally "for nothing," and the opinion adds that the expression "betalen met je gegevens" ("to pay with your data") "is in common use in Dutch in the context at issue." The footnotes classify 20 language versions, each list introduced as examples.

The conclusion from the text alone is a stalemate. "Therefore, the wording alone does not make it possible to determine whether counter-performance other than money is covered by that provision," the opinion states. Under settled case law, no single language version can take precedence, so the provision must be read in light of its context and objectives.

The borrowed images of Peek & Cloppenburg

Medina's strongest precedent comes from the same annex. In Peek & Cloppenburg (C-371/20, judgment of 2 September 2021), the Court interpreted point 11 of Annex I, which bans advertorials: "Using editorial content in the media to promote a product where a trader has paid for the promotion without making that clear in the content." The language versions disagreed there too about whether "paid" meant money.

The Court did not limit point 11 to cash. According to the opinion, it held that a trader "pays for" a promotion where it provides "consideration with an asset value, whether in the form of payment of a sum of money or in any other form, provided that there is a definite link between that consideration and the publication." The consideration in that case was the free right to use copyrighted images, which the advertiser made available to a media operator and, as far as the judgment shows, continued to hold.

That detail does a lot of work. "It follows that payment for the purposes of point 11 of Annex I to Directive 2005/29 does not require the person who makes the benefit available to be deprived of it," the opinion states. "By disclosing his or her personal data, the consumer is not deprived of them, just as the advertiser in the Peek & Cloppenburg case was not deprived of the images it made available. Rather, the consumer permits the trader to use those data, and that usage, together with the consent that makes it lawful, is exploited by the trader to finance the service."

The Commission had already pointed in the same direction. Its 2021 guidance on the directive (OJ 2021 C 526, p. 1), in section 3.4, "Use of the claim 'free' - No 20," on page 66, does not make a monetary payment a precondition for applying point 20, according to the opinion. It notes that products presented as free are especially common online, that many such services collect users' identity and email address, and that awareness of the economic value of consumer data is growing.

What a Facebook profile is worth

For the economic value of the data, Medina turned to the Court's own description of Facebook. In Meta Platforms and Others (C-252/21, judgment of 4 July 2023), a case about whether a national competition authority may take GDPR compliance into account, the Court found that the social network's business model "was based on financing through online advertising, tailored to individual users according, inter alia, to their consumer behaviour, interests, purchasing power, and personal situation." That advertising depended on profiling, which the opinion describes as "the automated production of detailed user profiles." The Court also observed that access to personal data and the ability to process them "have become significant parameters of competition between undertakings in the digital economy."

From there, the two conditions of Peek & Cloppenburg are met, according to the opinion. The data and the consent "have an asset value in the hands of the trader and serve to finance the service supplied to the consumer." The definite link is present "since registration on that social network is conditional on the provision of those data and on the giving of that consent, while the advertising which the data make possible is what finances the service."

Three EU laws that already call it an exchange

The most systematic part of the opinion is a survey of later EU legislation. Medina is explicit that several of these instruments postdate February 2015 and did not change the meaning of point 20; the point is to show "how the EU legislature has come to characterise the supply of personal data in exchange for a digital service."

Instrument Adopted Provision What it says, according to the opinion
European Electronic Communications Code, Directive (EU) 2018/1972 11 December 2018 Recital 16 Remuneration covers personal data the end user "knowingly provides," information collected without active supply, "such as personal data, including the IP address, or other automatically generated information, such as information collected and transmitted by a cookie," and situations where the end user "is exposed to advertisements as a condition for gaining access to the service"
Digital Content Directive, Directive (EU) 2019/770 20 May 2019 Article 3(1), second subparagraph; recital 24 Applies where the consumer provides personal data, "except where the personal data provided by the consumer are exclusively processed by the trader for the purpose of supplying the digital content or digital service ... or for allowing the trader to comply with legal requirements"
Consumer Rights Directive, Directive 2011/83/EU, as amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2161 25 October 2011; amended 27 November 2019 Article 3(1a); recital 31 of Directive (EU) 2019/2161 Extends the directive to digital services supplied in exchange for personal data, with the same exception

Recital 24 of the Digital Content Directive describes, in Medina's words, "in essence, the situation before the referring court." It says the directive should apply "where the consumer opens a social media account and provides a name and email address that are used for purposes other than solely supplying the digital content or digital service, or other than complying with legal requirements," and where the consumer consents to photographs or posts being "processed by the trader for marketing purposes." Recital 31 of Directive 2019/2161 adds: "Given their similarities and the interchangeability of paid digital services and digital services provided in exchange for personal data, they should be subject to the same rules under that Directive."

There is a tension here, and the opinion does not hide it. The same recital 24 states that "personal data cannot be considered as a commodity." A footnote notes that in the Digital Content Directive the concept of price "extends only to money and to digital representations of value," and that "the provision of personal data is nowhere referred to as a means of counter-performance." Medina reads the directive's exception for data processed solely to supply the service as decisive anyway: "Such an exception shows that the legislature was referring to an exchange."

The conclusion is a consistency argument. "It would be inconsistent to characterise the same commercial reality as involving a counter-performance for the purposes of one or other of those instruments and as free of charge for the purposes of Directive 2005/29," the opinion states. Directive 2019/2161 amended both the Consumer Rights Directive and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive in a single act, and all of these laws rest on the internal market legal basis of Article 114 TFEU or its predecessor, Article 95 EC.

The advertising industry knows this arrangement as the value exchange. On Medina's account, EU legislators have spent the years since 2018 writing it into law as a two-sided bargain.

The weaker party

The objective of the directive points the same way, according to the opinion. EU consumer law starts from the premise that consumers are in a weaker position than traders, particularly on information. "In that context, a consumer who is asked to pay a sum of money knows what he or she gives in return for the service," the opinion states. A consumer who pays in data "is unlikely to be aware of the economic value of what he or she is giving, or of the extent of the advertising to which the disclosure of those data may give rise."

The information gap is therefore widest exactly where point 20 bites. According to the opinion, the imbalance "is particularly pronounced where the counter-performance required of the consumer is not expressed in figures by which its value may be assessed, which is the case with personal data." Limiting point 20 to money would leave the rule toothless online, where free services are often financed "by collecting and exploiting user data rather than charging a price." Such a reading "would deprive point 20 of much of its effect in the very sector in which it is most needed."

Medina also closed off an argument based on how an average consumer understands the word "free." That benchmark belongs to the case-by-case tests in Articles 6 and 7 of the directive and "has no place in the application of Annex I," the opinion states. According to the Court's press release, practices prohibited in all circumstances, including describing a service as free when payment is required, "do not entail an individual assessment of whether the average consumer was actually misled." No survey evidence about what Facebook users believed in 2015 would matter.

How the proposed test works, step by step

According to the opinion, the reading of point 20 it proposes applies in seven steps.

  1. The offering is a product. A social network supplied to users is a service under Article 2(c) of the directive, both in its original wording and in the 2019 version that names digital services and digital content.
  2. The "free" claim is a commercial practice. A statement on a registration page is "a representation directly connected with the promotion of a product" under Article 2(d).
  3. Access requires data and consent. The consumer must disclose personal data and consent to their use for commercial purposes as a condition of using the service.
  4. The data have an asset value for the trader. They enable advertising revenue that finances the service; the consumer keeping the data does not change that.
  5. There is a definite link. Registration is conditional on the data and consent, and the advertising they make possible pays for the service.
  6. The carve-out is checked. Nothing counts as payment where the data are "processed exclusively in order to supply the service in question or to enable the trader to comply with legal requirements to which it is subject." A trader that requires nothing beyond the unavoidable costs named in point 20 may still advertise a service as "free" or "without charge."
  7. No average consumer test applies. Once the conditions are met, the "free" description is unfair in all circumstances, without any assessment of whether consumers were actually misled. Applying the answer to the facts remains the task of the national court.

The carve-out in step 6 follows the exception in Article 3(1) of the Digital Content Directive and Article 3(1a) of the Consumer Rights Directive almost word for word.

Meta's three objections

Meta raised three arguments against a broad reading. Medina rejected each of them.

Meta's argument Medina's response, according to the opinion
Annex I is an exhaustive list that only a revision of the directive can modify, so its entries must be read strictly Article 5(5) reserves to the legislature "the composition of the list - that is, which practices appear in it - and not the meaning of the terms in which each practice is described." The judgments Meta relied on, Plus Warenhandelsgesellschaft (C-304/08) and Compass Banca (C-646/22), concerned national rules banning practices that are not on the list. In Peek & Cloppenburg, the Court read "payment" broadly after expressly recalling that the list is exhaustive
The GDPR, particularly its transparency rules in Article 12 et seq., already protects consumers The GDPR governs the lawfulness and transparency of processing and "is not concerned with the accuracy of a statement concerning the terms on which the service is offered." The two regimes apply cumulatively, as held in Lindenapotheke (C-21/23) and Meta Platforms and Others. Article 3(4) of the directive does not apply, because a trader can comply with the GDPR and refrain from calling a service free at the same time
The freedom to conduct a business (Article 16 of the Charter) and to provide services (Article 56 TFEU) require a narrower reading The argument "is based on a misreading of what is prohibited by point 20 of Annex I." A data-funded trader remains free to tell consumers the terms of its service. "Those freedoms do not confer the right to provide inaccurate descriptions of services." Even if the ban were a limitation, it would be permissible as consumer protection under Article 38 of the Charter, a matter for the national court

The GDPR answer may prove the most quoted part of the opinion. "In accordance with the GDPR, a trader may exhaustively disclose the purposes for which the collected data will be processed and still describe the service to which those data give access as free of charge. The description of a service as 'free of charge' is not itself an act of processing personal data," Medina wrote. A privacy notice, however complete, does not cure a "free" label.

On the fundamental freedoms, the opinion distinguishes the case law Meta invoked, including Vanderborght (C-339/15), Compass Banca and Commission v Poland (C-200/24): those judgments concerned bans on commercial communications that were accurate in substance. "No comparable question arises where the description at issue is, in any event, inaccurate." The press release puts the conclusion in a single sentence: "Businesses remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data, but cannot describe them as 'free' where such consideration is required."

Why this matters for advertising-funded services

Point 20 is not a Meta-specific rule. It binds every trader dealing with consumers in the EU, and the opinion's reasoning attaches to a business model rather than a company: a service that requires personal data and consent at sign-up, and uses those data for purposes beyond running the service, such as advertising. If the Court adopts the reading, the word "free" on a registration page, in an app store listing or in an advertisement for such a service would fall into the category of practices that are unfair without any further test. The Commission's own guidance, as cited in the opinion, notes that services presented as free "are especially common in the online sector."

For Meta in particular, the opinion lands in the middle of a long contest over how Facebook and Instagram are paid for in Europe. Meta announced an ad-free subscription for the EU, EEA and Switzerland on 30 October 2023, priced at 9.99 euros a month on the web and 12.99 euros on iOS and Android, the model critics call pay or okay. The European Data Protection Board concluded in April 2024 that most consent-or-pay models do not meet GDPR standards for valid consent, and Meta filed an annulment action against that opinion at the General Court on 27 June 2024. On 23 April 2025 the Commission fined Meta 200 million euros under the Digital Markets Act over the November 2023 model, and Meta appealed the decision in July 2025, saying it had cut the subscription price by 40% in November 2024.

Consumer law has been part of that contest for some time. In March 2026, BEUC, the European Consumer Organisation, published an analysis arguing that Meta's January 2026 consent flow still breached the DMA, the GDPR and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, and among its complaints was the "free of charge" wording in that flow. Meta's own third DMA compliance report, submitted on 6 March 2026, said its Less Personalized Ads option had been rolled out to all EEA users in January 2026. The opinion in C-643/25 does not address any of those products, but it offers a separate yardstick. Data protection law asks whether consent is valid, and the DMA sets conduct rules for gatekeepers; point 20 asks only whether the word "free" is accurate.

How much are the data worth to the people handing them over? The opinion does not put a figure on it, and its argument rests partly on the fact that no figure is visible to consumers. One reference point comes from France, where a CNIL-commissioned survey of 2,082 people found that between 25% and 48% of internet users would pay 5.50 to 9 euros a month for ad-free versions of digital services, depending on the service. In the UK, Meta priced its ad-free subscription at 2.99 pounds a month on the web when it launched in September 2025.

The claimant is also a familiar name in German advertising litigation. The vzbv won a case in the Regional Court of Cologne on 17 September 2026 that barred Snap from using My AI chat data for advertising without a legal basis, with fines of up to 250,000 euros per breach, and the same chamber banned a Deutsche Telekom campaign that replaced the network name on customers' phones in a judgment the vzbv published on 26 October 2026. Both cases used injunctions, the same remedy the vzbv seeks against Meta.

The timing adds another layer. Eight days before the opinion, on 11 November 2026, the Commission proposed a Digital Fairness Act that would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a directly applicable regulation, an expanded blacklist and Commission fines of up to 6% of worldwide turnover. The European Parliament and the Council still have to agree that text. When the act was still at the consultation stage, IAB Europe and other advertising associations wrote to the Commission in July 2025 arguing that the existing directive, the DSA and the GDPR already covered the concerns behind it. The opinion does not mention the proposal. Its reasoning rests entirely on the 2005 text, read against the laws adopted since.

What the opinion leaves open

The opinion does not say whether Meta still displays the statement, and it does not discuss the subscription Meta has offered in the EU since November 2023 or the Less Personalized Ads option. Its proposed answer covers data the consumer discloses and consent the consumer gives; it does not decide whether data collected passively, such as the cookie and IP address information mentioned in recital 16 of the European Electronic Communications Code, would count as payment on their own. Neither document gives the date of the order for reference or a date for the judgment.

What happens next

An Advocate General's opinion does not bind the Court. "It is the role of the Advocates General to propose to the Court, in complete independence, a legal solution to the cases for which they are responsible," according to the press release, which adds that the judges "are now beginning their deliberations in this case. Judgment will be given at a later date."

When the Court rules, it will not decide the dispute between the vzbv and Meta. Under the preliminary reference procedure, the Federal Court of Justice will resolve the case in accordance with the Court's interpretation, which is, according to the press release, "similarly binding on other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised." An answer on point 20 would therefore apply to "free" claims across all Member States, not only to a Facebook sign-up page in Germany in 2015.

Key facts

  • Case: C-643/25, Bundesverband der Verbraucherzentralen und Verbraucherverbände - Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband e.V. v Meta Platforms Ireland Limited ("'Free' digital service")
  • Referring court: Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice, Germany); hearing on the appeal on a point of law held on 3 July 2025
  • Source document: Opinion of Advocate General Laila Medina, delivered on 19 November 2026; provisional text; original language English
  • Press release: Court of Justice of the European Union press release No 169/26, Luxembourg, 19 November 2026, "Advocate General Medina: A social network is not free when you pay with your data to use it"
  • Where published: CURIA website (curia.europa.eu), on the day of delivery
  • Provisions interpreted: Article 5(5) and point 20 of Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC of 11 May 2005 (Unfair Commercial Practices Directive)
  • Statement at issue: "Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos" ("Facebook is and remains free"), German-language Facebook registration page, February 2015
  • Earlier German decisions: Landgericht Berlin, 16 January 2018 (action dismissed); Kammergericht, 20 December 2019 (appeal dismissed)
  • Proposed answer (verbatim): "Point 20 of Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC ... read in conjunction with Article 5(5) of that directive, must be interpreted as meaning that the term 'cost', within the meaning of that point 20, which refers to what the consumer 'has to pay', covers the disclosure of personal data by the consumer and his or her consent to the use of those data for commercial purposes, provided that those data are not processed exclusively in order to supply the service in question or to enable the trader to comply with legal requirements to which it is subject."
  • Main judgments cited: Peek & Cloppenburg (C-371/20, EU:C:2021:674, 2 September 2021); Meta Platforms and Others (C-252/21, EU:C:2023:537, 4 July 2023); Lindenapotheke (C-21/23, EU:C:2024:846, 4 October 2024); Wind Tre and Vodafone Italia (C-54/17 and C-55/17, EU:C:2018:710); Compass Banca (C-646/22, EU:C:2024:957); Purely Creative and Others (C-428/11, EU:C:2012:651); Plus Warenhandelsgesellschaft (C-304/08, EU:C:2010:12)
  • Other instruments relied on: Directive (EU) 2019/770; Directive 2011/83/EU as amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2161; Directive (EU) 2018/1972; Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR); Commission guidance on Directive 2005/29/EC, OJ 2021 C 526, p. 1, section 3.4
  • Status: Not binding; judges deliberating; no judgment date given

Timeline

Summary

Who: Advocate General Laila Medina of the Court of Justice of the European Union, in a case brought by the German consumer federation vzbv (Bundesverband der Verbraucherzentralen und Verbraucherverbände - Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband e.V.) against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, referred by Germany's Federal Court of Justice.

What: An opinion proposing that the word "cost" in point 20 of Annex I to the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which bans describing a product as "free" if the consumer has to pay anything beyond unavoidable costs, covers the disclosure of personal data and consent to their commercial use, unless the data are processed exclusively to supply the service or to meet legal obligations. Under that reading, a service requiring such data could not be described as free, and Meta's arguments based on the exhaustive blacklist, the GDPR and fundamental freedoms fail.

When: The opinion was delivered on 19 November 2026. The statement at issue, "Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos," appeared in February 2015; German courts dismissed the claim in 2018 and 2019, and the Federal Court of Justice heard the appeal on 3 July 2025. No judgment date has been set.

Where: Luxembourg, at the Court of Justice, in case C-643/25, concerning Facebook's German-language registration page and German consumers, with an interpretation that would bind courts in every EU Member State.

Why: Ad-funded digital services are often marketed as free while being financed by user data. The opinion argues that the data and consent have an asset value for the trader, that later EU laws already treat data-for-service deals as exchanges, and that consumers cannot see the value of what they give up, so a money-only reading would leave point 20 with little effect online. If the Court agrees, the "free" label on such services would be unfair in all circumstances across the EU.