The District Court of Amsterdam ruled on October 28, 2026 that it has jurisdiction to hear a Dutch collective action against Booking Holdings Inc. and Agoda Company Pte. Ltd., dismissing challenges from the Delaware-registered parent of the Booking group and its Singapore-based sister platform. The case, brought by Stichting Consumenten Competition Claims on behalf of people living in the Netherlands, accuses the group of using parity clauses that kept hotel prices high and of deploying misleading interface designs on Booking.com and Agoda.com. The interlocutory judgment, published on October 30 under ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:10574, settles only where the case will be heard. Whether any of the accusations are true remains open.

In Short

A Dutch court has decided that Booking's American parent company and Agoda, a Singapore travel site owned by the same group, must defend a consumer class action in Amsterdam instead of having it thrown out for being filed in the wrong country. The case says Booking's pricing rules for hotels pushed up room prices and that both sites used design tricks to mislead people, and it asks for €869 million and €96 million in damages for those two complaints. Nothing has been decided about whether the accusations hold, but the ruling treats a website in Dutch, priced in euros and offering a Dutch bank payment method as aimed at the Netherlands, so its design can be judged there wherever the designers sit.

What the court decided

Judge R.A. Dudok van Heel, sitting alone in case number C/13/781273 / HA ZA 26-1, delivered the judgment earlier than scheduled. The published summary describes the case as a collective damages action under the WAMCA, the Dutch law on mass damages claims brought by representative organisations. Two separate applications were before the court. Agoda asked for a declaration that the Dutch courts lacked jurisdiction over every claim brought against it. Booking Holdings Inc. made a narrower request, contesting jurisdiction only over the consumer law claims.

Both failed. "For the reasons set out below, the Court holds that it has jurisdiction," the judgment states at the outset, and it ends with a single line: "The interlocutory applications are dismissed." Agoda and Booking Holdings Inc. were each ordered to pay the foundation's costs of €1,495, payable within fourteen days of written demand. The main proceedings were listed on the procedural roll of November 25, 2026, when the parties are to make written submissions on how the case continues.

The court opened its assessment with an observation that frames everything that follows. Many international collective actions in the Netherlands, it noted, involve conduct carried out largely abroad. "The present case is different. It is closely connected with the Netherlands and is, to that extent, atypical as regards the jurisdictional applications," according to the judgment. The foundation is Dutch; the hotels signed their parity obligations with Booking.com B.V., an Amsterdam company; the booking websites are in Dutch; and the alleged loss is that of Dutch residents.

The quotations in this article come from an unofficial, non-certified English translation of the Dutch judgment. The binding text is the Dutch original published on Rechtspraak.nl.

Thirteen defendants, two kinds of claim

The foundation sued thirteen companies. Three are Dutch: Booking.com Holding B.V., Booking.com B.V., which operates the Booking.com platform, and Booking.com International B.V. The fourth is Booking Holdings Inc., the ultimate holding company of the group, registered in Delaware. Eight more are local support companies in Germany, Belgium, Austria, France, Italy, Portugal, Spain and Switzerland, which the court calls the European Entities. The thirteenth is Agoda, which according to the judgment "offers a platform for Hotel OTA Services, primarily in the Asian market." Booking Holdings Inc. holds all the shares in Agoda, which makes it a sister company of Booking.com.

The claims fall into two groups. The competition law claims target all thirteen defendants and are brought for a class the foundation calls Consumers I: everyone who lived in the Netherlands at any point since January 1, 2013 and booked a hotel room in Europe online at least once, whether through Booking.com, through another online travel agency or directly on a hotel's own website. The breadth follows from the foundation's argument that the parity obligations stopped hotels from offering lower prices through other channels and so caused consumers to pay higher prices, whichever channel they booked through.

The consumer law claims target four defendants: Booking.com Holding B.V., Booking.com B.V., Booking Holdings Inc. and Agoda. They concern what the foundation describes as dark patterns, which the judgment summarises as "patterns and representations implemented on the Booking.com and Agoda.com platforms to mislead consumers." This class, Consumers II, covers Dutch residents who booked a hotel room online at least once on a Booking group website since January 1, 2013. The foundation originally brought these claims against the European Entities too, then withdrew them while the jurisdiction dispute was under way.

The foundation is asking the court to appoint it exclusive representative for both classes, with a one-month window for people to opt out. Its full list of demands is attached to the judgment as an appendix. The core figures:

Element of the claim Against Amount or term
Damages for Consumers I (parity obligations) All 13 defendants, jointly and severally €869,000,000
Damages for Consumers II (dark patterns) Booking.com B.V., Booking.com Holding B.V., Booking Holdings Inc., Agoda €96,000,000
Combined damages (PPC Land calculation) - €965,000,000
Cost of administering compensation All defendants €6,000,000, or a sum the court considers just
Penalty for breaching either injunction Per breach, per day €5,000,000, capped at €100,000,000
Deadline to stop the conduct All defendants (parity) / four defendants (dark patterns) Four weeks after judgment
Opt-out window for class members - One month from the announcement
Relevant period - From January 1, 2013
Document production period - 2013 to at least June 1, 2025

Both damages figures come with a further demand for more money if the compensation process shows a larger class or more bookings. Any amount left over after distribution would go to non-profit consumer organisations chosen by the foundation. The claim also asks that the foundation be allowed to deduct its costs, "including the remuneration payable to the Funder," from the compensation if the court does not award those costs separately. The funder is not named.

Behind the foundation stands the Consumentenbond, the Dutch consumer association. According to the Consumentenbond, the foundation started the action against Booking on June 26, 2025 with its support, and more than 270,000 people have signed up. The association describes the practices at issue as fake discounts, incomplete prices and invented scarcity, and says participation is on a no cure, no pay basis with a fee capped at 25% of the result. When the claim was launched, Booking.com rejected the allegations and said it was assessing the claim, according to Dutch news agency ANP.

The parity clause record

Most of the factual background in the judgment concerns parity clauses, the contract terms that stop hotels from offering better deals elsewhere. According to the court, Booking.com included a wide parity clause in its hotel agreements until July 1, 2015. Under it, "hotels were not permitted to offer lower prices or better terms anywhere, whether on other platforms or through their own sales channels, than those offered on the Booking.com platform."

After competition authorities in France, Italy and Sweden opened investigations and accepted commitments, Booking.com switched on July 1, 2015 to a narrow parity clause, under which "hotels were not permitted to offer their rooms on more favourable terms through their own channels." The judgment records that this narrow clause had been removed from Booking.com's general terms and conditions "by 2 December 2024 at the latest." Booking was designated a gatekeeper under the Digital Markets Act on May 13, 2024, as PPC Land reported in its coverage of the Etraveli ruling; the judgment does not connect the removal to that designation. The foundation's case also covers what it calls implicit parity obligations, and its demand for documents asks how Booking.com's ranking algorithm handles "the weighting of external prices."

Germany went further. The Bundeskartellamt found on December 22, 2015 that the narrow clause infringed EU and German competition law, and the Bundesgerichtshof upheld that decision on May 18, 2021. A group of German hotels has also sued Booking.com and its German subsidiary in Amsterdam. In that separate case, still pending, the same court referred questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union on February 22, 2023, received answers on September 19, 2024 in Case C-264/23, and gave a further interlocutory judgment on March 4, 2026. In Berlin, a regional court ruled in December 2025 that 1,099 hotels can claim damages from Booking.com over best price clauses; that ruling was declaratory and awarded no sums.

The scale of the platform explains why these clauses matter. By the European Commission's estimate, Booking held 60-70% of the hotel online travel agency market in the European Economic Area in 2022, a figure that resurfaced when the General Court upheld the prohibition of Booking's Etraveli takeover on September 9, 2026.

One more fact in the judgment links this case to advertising. Since at least 2009, Booking.com has run a "Preferred Partner Program" and a "Preferred Partner Program Plus." According to the court, "To participate, hotels must satisfy certain conditions and pay a higher fee (commission). Participation affects the ranking of participating hotels in search results." On October 21, 2026, a week before this judgment, the European Commission opened Digital Services Act proceedings against Booking.com, examining among other things whether listings boosted in search results in exchange for higher commission are clearly labelled as ads.

How the court reached jurisdiction

According to the judgment, the court's route to jurisdiction ran through seven steps, each tied to a specific legal provision.

  1. Dutch defendants. Booking.com Holding B.V., Booking.com B.V. and Booking.com International B.V. are domiciled in the Netherlands, so Article 2 of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (Rv) gives the Dutch courts jurisdiction over them.
  2. Uncontested competition claims. Booking Holdings Inc. and the European Entities did not contest jurisdiction over the competition law claims. The court took jurisdiction under Article 26 of the Brussels I Recast Regulation for all of them except Booking.com (Schweiz) AG, which falls under Article 24 of the Lugano Convention.
  3. The rulebook for non-EU defendants. For a defendant in the United States and one in Singapore, jurisdiction is governed by Articles 1 to 14 Rv. Because the Dutch legislature drew on Brussels I Recast when writing those rules, they "must, in principle, be interpreted by reference to the CJEU's case law on Brussels I Recast and its predecessors."
  4. Competition claims against Agoda. The court relied on Article 7(1) Rv, which extends jurisdiction over an "anchor defendant" to co-defendants when the claims are closely connected. It did not need to rule on the foundation's alternative ground, Article 6(e) Rv.
  5. Consumer claims against Agoda. The court took jurisdiction under Article 6(e) Rv, which covers tort claims where the harmful event occurred or may occur in the Netherlands.
  6. Consumer claims against Booking Holdings Inc. The same provision applied, on the basis of the group liability alleged under Article 6:166 of the Dutch Civil Code (BW).
  7. Territorial jurisdiction. Article 99 Rv gives the Amsterdam court territorial jurisdiction over the Dutch defendants, and Article 107 Rv extends it to the rest.
Defendant Claims Contested? Ground the court applied
Booking.com Holding B.V., Booking.com B.V., Booking.com International B.V. (Netherlands) Competition; consumer (first two only) No Article 2 Rv
Booking Holdings Inc. (Delaware, US) Competition No Article 26 Brussels I Recast
Booking Holdings Inc. Consumer (dark patterns) Yes Article 6(e) Rv
Seven European Entities (EU) Competition No Article 26 Brussels I Recast
Booking.com (Schweiz) AG (Switzerland) Competition No Article 24 Lugano Convention
Agoda Company Pte. Ltd. (Singapore) Competition Yes Article 7(1) Rv
Agoda Company Pte. Ltd. Consumer (dark patterns) Yes Article 6(e) Rv

Agoda and the parity clauses

Agoda's main argument on the competition claims was that it had nothing to do with Booking.com's contracts. It argued that EU case law leaves no room for what the judgment calls "horizontal liability": holding one subsidiary liable, through a shared parent, for the conduct of its sister company. Agoda described this as an impermissible "two-stage mechanism."

The court disagreed. It started from the CJEU's 2021 Sumal judgment, under which a subsidiary can be liable for an infringement when it forms an economic unit with its parent and there is a specific link between its activity and the subject matter of the infringement. It then applied the presumption, drawn from the 2009 Akzo judgment, that a parent holding 100% of a subsidiary exercises decisive influence over it. Booking Holdings Inc. owns all of both Booking.com and Agoda, and Agoda did not rebut its integration into the group. The foundation pointed to overlapping management positions and to consolidated financial statements that include Agoda's results.

For jurisdiction, the court said, the test is low. Citing the CJEU's April 16, 2026 judgment in the joined Power Cables and Cardboard Packaging cases, it held that "it is sufficient that it cannot be ruled out that the defendants concerned form part of the same undertaking within the meaning of competition law." On that basis: "Contrary to Agoda's submission, the Court considers that lateral or horizontal liability is not excluded." The court noted that academic commentary after Sumal had argued the same point.

Agoda also argued that it plays no part in selling hotel stays through Booking.com, that the two platforms operate independently and that they serve different geographic markets. The court called this an "unduly narrow" reading of Sumal, whose limitation "concerns conglomerate groups operating in different, unrelated economic sectors." Agoda sells hotel rooms through an online platform, the same activity as Booking.com. "There is no additional requirement that Agoda have been directly involved in the alleged infringement or have been able to influence it," according to the judgment. Joint and several liability for competition law infringements creates the close connection Article 7(1) Rv requires, the court added, citing the CJEU's 2015 CDC/Akzo judgment.

The Singapore clause

On the consumer claims, Agoda's first line of defence was its own Terms of Use. According to Agoda, consumers accept those terms when they book, the terms name the courts of Singapore as competent, and the foundation's claims fall within that clause.

The court did not examine whether the clause is valid or what it covers, because it held that the clause does not reach the foundation at all. "The Foundation is not a party to the agreements concluded between the consumers and Agoda," the judgment states. "A third party is bound by a jurisdiction clause to which it has not consented only if it has succeeded to all the rights and obligations of the original contracting party." The foundation sues under its own right in Article 3:305a BW, the provision that allows representative organisations to bring collective redress actions, and it "has not thereby assumed the consumers' obligations." The conclusion: "The jurisdiction clause cannot be invoked against the Foundation."

Agoda then argued that the claims are contractual, not tortious, so the relevant place is where Agoda provides its service, which it put at Singapore and Bangkok. The court rejected that too. A claim is contractual when the contract must be interpreted to decide whether the conduct was lawful. Here, according to the judgment, it need not be: "The conduct concerns the period before the agreement was concluded." The question is whether dark patterns influenced the consumer's decision to book, and "the content of the agreement between Agoda and the consumer is, in principle, irrelevant."

Where a dark pattern happens

The heart of the ruling is its answer to a question every international website faces: where does a misleading interface cause harm? Agoda said its communication and design choices are developed, implemented and managed in Singapore and Bangkok. It said the website is translated into Dutch on the basis of the user's IP address, which does not mean its offers are aimed at the Dutch market, and that users are redirected to agoda.com.

The court sided with the foundation. It was common ground that users in the Netherlands can search and book on a Dutch-language website with prices in euros. The foundation also said, without contradiction, that "until very recently iDeal was available as a payment method, which presupposes an account with a Dutch bank." Citing the CJEU's 2010 Pammer and Alpenhof judgment, the court found these were sufficient connecting factors to show that Agoda's website is directed at the Netherlands, among other places, and that Agoda intends to attract Dutch customers.

Then came the passage that matters most for anyone who builds or runs consumer websites across borders:

"The fact that decisions about the website's design may be taken outside the Netherlands does not mean that the event giving rise to the damage occurs outside the Netherlands. Dark patterns, if present, are deployed on the website. The alleged event giving rise to the damage occurs only when the user encounters them, namely when visiting the website."

The place of the damage is in the Netherlands too, according to the court, because that is where the consumer visits the site and decides whether to book. That, in the court's words, means the case "does not merely concern 'purely financial loss'." Agoda's point that a Dutch resident might have booked while abroad was set aside for now: the foundation represents residents of the Netherlands, who will predominantly have booked from there, and exceptions are for a later stage.

The holding company argument

Booking Holdings Inc. argued that it is "a non-operating holding company," that Booking.com manages its own brands and does the day-to-day work on the website, and that the conduct complained of is not group conduct. The foundation answered with central management of the website, the parent's consolidated accounts and annual reports, a privacy statement saying Booking Holdings Inc. collects data from its subsidiaries, and overlapping management at Booking.com and the parent.

The court did not decide who is right. It held only that a court assessing jurisdiction must not examine the merits, and that on the material before it "it cannot be concluded in this case that a basis for group or other liability is manifestly absent." Booking Holdings Inc. had contested the foundation's facts "only briefly," and "it would go too far to examine the substance of the case at this stage." Because the dark patterns were found to operate in the Netherlands, Article 6(e) Rv applied. The court left open whether Booking Holdings Inc. also counts as a "trader" under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.

What the foundation wants to see

The jurisdiction ruling does not touch the foundation's demand for documents, but the appendix to the judgment sets it out in full, and it reads like an inventory of a modern conversion stack. The foundation asks for Booking.com's pricing and booking data for Dutch consumers from January 1, 2013 to at least June 1, 2025, financial data on hotel margins and return on capital from 2013 to 2024, and the confidential versions of the German, Spanish and Swiss decisions against Booking.com.

On interface design, the demands are specific. The foundation wants the results of Booking.com's A/B testing, described as "data collected by Booking.com through A/B testing," including the parameters used to assign consumers to groups and "the conversion rates of consumers in the A/B tests, including the conversion rate for each test variant, drop-off rates at each stage of the booking funnel and time to booking for each group." It wants statistics on the robustness of those tests, including p-values and confidence intervals. It seeks "Current and historical source code and script snippets, including JavaScript files," for both websites as offered in the Netherlands, and "Access to the complete Git repository or comparable version management system used by Booking.com, together with server logs showing how and when scripts and patterns were activated and/or modified."

Consent is on the list as well. The foundation asks for "Logs of consent actions performed by users," for "Scripts and documentation concerning cookie loading, both before and after the user grants consent," and for "Access to, or a copy of, the CMP platform used by or on behalf of www.Booking.com and www.Agoda.com, including its settings, such as default selections, the order of choices and the timing of UX elements such as banners." A consent management platform is ordinary equipment for any European website; here it is named as potential evidence.

The remaining items cover segmentation models, the rules that assign users to experimental interfaces, "Evaluation data for dark patterns by target group," management KPI reports, and "Internal benchmarking data comparing interfaces with and without dark patterns." The foundation also wants the ranking algorithm and every internal study, decision and memo on parity obligations and dark patterns from 2013 to June 1, 2025. The production demand is conditional: it applies only if the court does not order the documents produced in the main proceedings under Article 22 Rv. The court has not ruled on any of it.

A litigator's reading

The ruling drew comment from Marco Scialdone, Head of Litigation and Academic Outreach at Euroconsumers, who posted about it on LinkedIn in the days after publication, sharing the English translation and describing it as AI-generated. His profile states that his views are strictly personal. The judgment does not mention Euroconsumers, and the post does not say whether Scialdone or his organisation has any role in the case.

Scialdone wrote that the judgment "deserves attention from anyone working on cross-border collective redress." He singled out two points. The first was the forum clause: "Agoda's contractual jurisdiction clause designating Singapore did not bind the claimant foundation. The foundation acts under its own statutory right, rather than as a party to consumers' contracts." The second was the court's use of targeting: "Second, the Court considered the targeting of Dutch consumers and the location of the alleged online harm when establishing jurisdiction."

He also highlighted the legal basis for reaching the non-EU defendants. "Importantly, jurisdiction over the non-EU defendants was assessed under Dutch procedural law, interpreted in light of Brussels I bis case law." He closed with a policy note: "As Europe considers the future of cross-border collective redress, clearer jurisdictional rules deserve serious attention." And he was careful about what the ruling settles: "The merits remain undecided."

Why the ruling matters for marketers

The court's reasoning turns ordinary localisation into a jurisdictional fact. A Dutch-language interface, prices in euros and a payment method tied to Dutch bank accounts were enough to treat Agoda's site as directed at the Netherlands. The same features sit on almost every international e-commerce or travel site in Europe, and the court treated them as signs of intent to attract local customers, not as side effects of a global product. Where the design team works did not change the outcome.

The ruling also widens who can be pulled into such a case. On the competition claims, a sister company running a separate platform in a separate region was kept in because it is wholly owned by the same parent and works in the same line of business. On the consumer claims, a parent that calls itself a non-operating holding company was kept in because its role could not be ruled out without a trial. Neither finding is a finding of liability, but both mean the companies must now argue the merits in Amsterdam.

For marketing and growth teams, the document demand may be the most striking part of the file. Experiment logs, variant-level conversion rates, funnel drop-off data, CMP settings and frontend commit messages are the working material of performance marketing. In this claim they are framed as the evidence that would show whether interface choices crossed into manipulation. Whether a Dutch court will order their production is a separate question, and it has not been decided.

The case adds to a crowded file for the Booking group. Beyond the Commission's Digital Services Act case and the Etraveli ruling, PPC Land has tracked how travel pricing practices draw enforcement elsewhere: in the United States, the travel app Hopper agreed in July 2026 to pay $35 million to settle FTC allegations over booking fees. Collective actions against large platforms are also multiplying. The UK's Competition Appeal Tribunal certified an opt-out claim worth about £5 billion on behalf of advertisers that bought Google search ads in August 2026, and the same Amsterdam court in March 2026 barred Grok from generating non-consensual nude images in a case brought by a Dutch foundation, using Article 7 Rv to reach US entities. The advertising industry, for its part, argued in July 2025 that rules against dark patterns already exist in the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, the Digital Services Act, the GDPR and the AI Act. The foundation's consumer claims rest on that existing law, from the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive to the Digital Services Act, pursued through a private collective action instead of a regulator.

What happens next

The parties file written submissions on the further conduct of the proceedings at the roll date of November 25, 2026, 28 days after the judgment. The court reserved all further decisions. According to the Consumentenbond, the court must still decide whether the foundation can bring the claim, and the next hearing is expected in the first half of 2027. Only after that would the court reach the merits: whether the parity clauses and the interface designs were unlawful, and whether Dutch consumers suffered the losses the foundation claims.

What the judgment does not say

The judgment does not explain how the €869 million and €96 million figures were calculated, does not name the funder, and does not identify the specific interface designs the foundation calls dark patterns. It does not rule on the foundation's admissibility, its appointment as exclusive representative or the document demands. The English translation notes that the source itself refers to the "Digital Markets Act (DSA)" in one passage and that the appendix ends at the heading of item (xi) with no text beneath it. No statement from Booking or Agoda beyond their court submissions is included.

Key facts

  • Court: District Court of Amsterdam (Rechtbank Amsterdam), single judge R.A. Dudok van Heel, registrar C.E.P. Honing
  • Case number: C/13/781273 / HA ZA 26-1
  • ECLI: ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:10574
  • Type: Interlocutory judgment on jurisdiction, first instance, civil law
  • Date of judgment: October 28, 2026 (delivered earlier than scheduled)
  • Date of publication: October 30, 2026, on Rechtspraak.nl
  • Claimant: Stichting Consumenten Competition Claims, Amsterdam (counsel D.F. Berkhout), supported by the Consumentenbond
  • Applicants: Booking Holdings Inc., Delaware (counsel for the Booking defendants M.V.E.E. de Monchy); Agoda Company Pte. Ltd., Singapore (counsel C.E. Schillemans)
  • Outcome: Both jurisdiction applications dismissed; costs of €1,495 each against Agoda and Booking Holdings Inc.
  • Legal bases applied: Articles 2, 6(e), 7(1), 99 and 107 Rv; Article 26 Brussels I Recast (Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012); Article 24 Lugano Convention (2007); Article 3:305a and Article 6:166 BW
  • CJEU case law cited: Sumal (C-882/19, 2021), Power Cables and Cardboard Packaging (C-672/23 and C-673/23, April 16, 2026), Akzo (C-97/08 P, 2009), CDC/Akzo (C-352/13, 2015), Kolassa (C-375/13), Universal Music (C-12/15), Pammer and Alpenhof (C-585/08 and C-144/09), Kalfelis, Löber, Brogsitter, Holterman
  • Claims sought: €869 million (Consumers I, parity obligations), €96 million (Consumers II, dark patterns), €6 million administration costs; injunctions with penalties of €5 million per breach per day up to €100 million
  • Relevant period: from January 1, 2013
  • Procedural history: writs of summons November 13, 2025; interlocutory judgment April 22, 2026; oral hearing September 22, 2026
  • Next step: procedural roll, November 25, 2026
  • Translation used for quotations: unofficial, non-certified English translation of the Dutch judgment

Timeline

Summary

Who: The District Court of Amsterdam, ruling in a collective action brought by Stichting Consumenten Competition Claims, a foundation supported by the Dutch consumer association Consumentenbond, against thirteen companies of the Booking group. The two applicants who lost were Booking Holdings Inc., the group's Delaware parent, and Agoda Company Pte. Ltd., its Singapore-based platform. Marco Scialdone of Euroconsumers commented on the ruling in a personal capacity.

What: An interlocutory judgment holding that the Dutch courts have jurisdiction over the competition law claims against Agoda and the consumer law claims against Agoda and Booking Holdings Inc. The court found that Agoda's Singapore forum clause does not bind the foundation, that dark patterns claims are tort claims, and that the harmful event occurs where Dutch users encounter the websites. The underlying claims seek €869 million over parity clauses and €96 million over dark patterns, plus injunctions and broad document production, including A/B test data, source code and consent management settings.

When: The judgment was delivered on October 28, 2026 and published on October 30, 2026, 349 days after the writs of summons of November 13, 2025. The next procedural step is on November 25, 2026, and the Consumentenbond expects a further hearing in the first half of 2027.

Where: Amsterdam, under Dutch procedural law read in light of EU jurisdiction case law, for consumers resident in the Netherlands who booked hotels online since January 1, 2013.

Why: Booking Holdings Inc. and Agoda argued that a Dutch court could not try claims against a US holding company and a Singapore platform. The court held that the case is closely connected to the Netherlands: the platforms target Dutch users in Dutch, in euros and with Dutch payment methods, and the alleged harm happens on Dutch screens. The merits, including whether any dark patterns existed, remain undecided.