A Colombian administrative court has rejected every claim Google LLC brought against the country's data protection authority, ruling on November 5, 2026 that a US company with no legal or physical presence in Colombia still processes personal data there when it places cookies and other identifiers on the phones and computers of people in the country. The judgment leaves standing a set of 2020 orders from the Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio (SIC) that require Google to build a way to obtain, and later prove, the authorization of a parent or legal representative for every user under 18 whose data it processes.
In Short
A court in Bogotá upheld orders that Colombia's data regulator gave Google in 2020, deciding that Colombian privacy law applies to Google because it collects data through cookies on devices in Colombia, even though the company is based in California. That reasoning reaches any foreign platform that tracks people in Colombia, and it puts children and teenagers at the centre: the judges found that Google's Family Link tool is built for children under 13, or the age each country sets, and does not prove that a parent agreed for older teenagers or for people who use Google without an account. If the judgment holds, Google has to show the regulator a parental authorization mechanism for all users under 18, along with a compliant privacy notice, a data policy and registered databases.
What the court decided
The ruling, Sentencia No. 286, was issued by Subsection C of the First Section of the Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca, with Magistrate Ana Margoth Chamorro Benavides writing for a three-judge panel that also included Fabio Iván Afanador García and Luis Norberto Cermeño. It is a first-instance judgment in case 25000-23-41-000-2022-00444-00, an action for annulment and restoration of rights that Google filed on April 8, 2022.
Google had asked the court to annul three SIC resolutions, to declare that the regulator "lacks competence" to issue data protection orders to foreign companies without a Colombian domicile, to order the SIC to stop demanding compliance, and to make the authority publicly retract its statements about Google's non-compliance and about the number of people affected. As a fallback, it asked for partial annulment on the understanding that minors over 14 have a relative capacity to consent to the processing of their data.
The panel denied all of it. According to the judgment, the four pillars of its reasoning were these: Law 1581 of 2012 applies to data processing carried out in Colombian territory regardless of where the controller is domiciled; the SIC's orders are compliance measures, not sanctions; the facts behind them were proven, even though the SIC wrongly presented a count of accounts as a count of people; and opinions the regulator's senior official had published as an academic years earlier did not prove an abuse of power. No costs were ordered, because the suit "raised reasonable legal questions."
The orders that survive
| Order (Resolution 53593 of 2020, as modified on appeal) | What it requires | Legal basis the court identified |
|---|---|---|
| Inform data subjects | Give users the information set out in Article 12 of Law 1581 of 2012, including the processing their data will undergo and its purpose | Law 1581, Article 12 |
| Adopt a data processing policy | Publish a policy with the minimum contents of Article 13 of Decree 1377 of 2013 | Law 1581, Article 17(k); Decree 1377, Article 13 |
| Parental authorization mechanism (Article 3 of the resolution) | Implement a mechanism to obtain the authorization of the legal representatives of all users under 18 | Decree 1074 of 2015, Article 2.2.2.25.2.9 |
| Register databases | Enter Google's databases in the National Registry of Databases | Law 1581, Article 25; Decree 1074, Article 2.2.2.26.1.2, as amended by Decree 090 of 2018 (companies with total assets above 100,000 UVT) |
| Fifth order (revoked in 2021) | Certify, through a third party, the authorizations obtained since 2012 | Revoked by the Superintendente Delegado on appeal as unnecessary |
The judgment states that the resolutions also set deadlines and the form in which compliance must be proven, but it does not reproduce them. Google, the court noted, did not argue that it falls below the 100,000 UVT asset threshold that triggers the registration duty.
How the court disposed of each ground
| Ground raised by Google | Google's argument, as the judgment summarises it | Court's finding |
|---|---|---|
| Breach of the governing rules and lack of competence | Article 2 of Law 1581 reaches only processing in Colombia or foreign controllers bound by treaty, and Google has no domicile in Colombia and does not process data there | Rejected: collecting data through cookies and identifiers on devices in Colombia is processing in Colombian territory, so the SIC was competent |
| Due process, hearing and defence | No sanctioning procedure under Article 47 of the CPACA, a confidential figure disclosed, limited access to the file, no third parties notified, no evidence phase | Rejected: the orders are not sanctions, Google was heard at two administrative levels, and no irregularity was decisive |
| False grounds | Cookies not shown to involve processing in Colombia, Family Link and YouTube Kids ignored, accounts treated as people, the relative capacity of 14 to 18-year-olds ignored, the privacy policy judged arbitrarily | Rejected: counting accounts as people was an "imprecision" with no effect on the orders; the other points failed |
| Irregular issuance and abuse of power | The Superintendente Delegado applied a position fixed before taking office, and Resolution 60478 showed animosity toward Google's lawyer | Rejected: academic columns from 2014 and 2015 did not prove a distorted purpose, and Google never sought the official's recusal |
From a US press release to a Bogotá courtroom
The case did not begin with a complaint from a Colombian child or parent. According to the judgment, Resolution 53593 itself records that the SIC acted after the US Federal Trade Commission's press release of September 4, 2019, which announced that Google and YouTube would pay a record $170 million to settle allegations that the companies collected persistent identifiers from viewers of child-directed channels without parental consent. The appeal resolution, Resolution 60478 of 2021, stated that "to date, there is no complaint from any child or adolescent" about Google's processing of their data, and that the proceeding was opened on the SIC's own initiative.
The regulator sent Google information requests between September 2019 and February 2020, and on February 13, 2020 notified it that an administrative proceeding had opened under Chapter I of Title III of Law 1437 of 2011, Colombia's code of administrative procedure, known as the CPACA.
Three resolutions followed:
| Resolution | Date | Issued by | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| 53593 | September 3, 2020 | Director of Investigation of Personal Data Protection | Issued orders on the processing of personal data Google collects or processes in Colombia, especially that of children and adolescents |
| 14010 | March 16, 2021 | Same director, on reconsideration | Confirmed the orders and clarified that the account figures probably exceed the number of individual users |
| 60478 | September 21, 2021 | Superintendente Delegado for Personal Data Protection, on appeal | Revoked the fifth order and confirmed the rest |
Resolution 60478 became final for Google on October 1, 2021. After a rejected request for direct revocation and a failed attempt at out-of-court conciliation, Google sued on April 8, 2022. The complaint was sent back for correction and admitted only on March 7, 2024. On February 18, 2025, the court refused to suspend the resolutions provisionally, finding at that preliminary stage that through cookies Google "collected personal data of children and adolescents in Colombian territory." On July 14, 2026, it dispensed with an evidence phase and announced an early judgment, and the file went to the magistrate on August 5, 2026. The Public Ministry did not submit an opinion.
Where processing happens, not where the company lives
The heart of the case is a single sentence in Article 2 of Law 1581 of 2012, Colombia's statutory data protection law. In PPC Land's translation, it reads: "This law shall apply to the processing of personal data carried out in Colombian territory or when Colombian legislation is applicable to the Data Controller or Data Processor not established in national territory by virtue of international rules and treaties."
Google's reading was that the first half covers only controllers established in Colombia, and that a foreign company such as itself can be reached only through the second half, via treaties that do not exist. The company stressed that it is incorporated in Delaware, domiciled in California, and has no legal or physical presence in Colombia.
The court read the sentence as two independent tests joined by "or." The first is territorial and looks only at where the processing happens; the second is subjective and lets Colombian law follow a data controller not established in Colombia even to processing abroad, when a rule or treaty says so. Meeting either is enough. "That reading," the judgment says of Google's interpretation, "adds to the rule a requirement it does not contain." If the law reached only companies established in Colombia, the panel reasoned, the territorial test would be redundant.
The judges also turned one of Google's own arguments against it. In its administrative appeal, Google had said the law's application criterion "is objective, insofar as it derives from the place where the processing is carried out, not from the nationality, residence or domicile of the data subject." The court shared that premise, which "leads to examining where the processing occurs and not where the person carrying it out is domiciled."
Two Constitutional Court decisions reinforced the reading. In ruling T-256 of June 12, 2025, the Constitutional Court wrote that "the law applies to whoever collects, uses, stores or processes personal data in Colombian territory, regardless of whether or not they are domiciled in Colombia," and that "through platforms such as Google, Facebook and WhatsApp, the companies that operate them collect personal data in Colombia and to that extent are subject to Colombian legislation." A footnote in that ruling listed Resolution 53593 of 2020, the order under challenge here, among the SIC decisions it relied on. A later decision, T-174 of 2026, repeated that Law 1581 protects data subjects "even when the controller has no physical or legal presence in the country."
The panel added a further layer: under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and Colombia's Childhood and Adolescence Code, where a data protection rule admits more than one reasonable reading, the one that protects minors most effectively must prevail. Even if Article 2 could bear Google's narrow interpretation, it would have to be discarded, because it would leave the data of children in Colombia who use services provided from abroad beyond the reach of Colombian law.
The evidence came from Google
Does a company with no Colombian office process data in Colombia at all? On that factual question, the court relied almost entirely on Google's own statements and documents. The judgment lists five pieces of evidence:
- Google's October 16, 2019 response, in which the company said it "collects personal data from people who may be located in different parts of the world, including Colombia."
- Google's February 11, 2020 account report: in the preceding 28 days, 1,847,592 Google accounts belonging to users under 18, and roughly 39 million accounts belonging to adults, had operated one of its services "from Colombia." Age was presumed from the date of birth users declare when creating an account.
- Google's privacy policy, transcribed in the resolutions, which describes collecting search terms, videos watched, interactions with content and ads, activity on third-party sites and apps, and location, and says Google uses "various technologies to collect and store information, including cookies, pixel tags, local storage, such as browser web storage or application data caches, databases, and server logs." When users are not signed in, the policy says, information is stored "with unique identifiers tied to the browser, application, or device." Family Link's privacy notice tells parents that when a child uses the services, Google collects location data determined by GPS, IP address and device sensor data.
- An admission about cookies. In a filing during the administrative proceeding, Google's lawyer wrote: "my client has never said that it does not use cookies. Data subjects are transparently informed of the use of these technologies, and as has been explained this is necessary for the correct functioning of Internet browsing."
- Country-specific settings. Age requirements for Google accounts and the operation of Family Link vary by country, and Google told the SIC that "Google Accounts managed with Family Link in Colombia cannot sign in to YouTube. They can only use YouTube Kids as an alternative." For the court, this showed that Google identifies its users in Colombia and adapts its services to them.
Taken together, the judges said, the SIC's position "is not a supposition." Cookies and other identifiers installed on users' devices are the means of gathering information that, because it is tied to an account, a device or a browser, relates to identified or identifiable people and is therefore personal data under Article 3(c) of Law 1581. Because the cookie is placed on, and read from, the device of the person using the service while that person is in Colombia, the collection happens in Colombia, even if storage, analysis and profiling later take place on servers abroad. Resolution 14010 had put it this way: "Although the systematization of the personal data collected does not occur in this territory, the collection of the data that will be analyzed does."
Google offered no technical evidence to rebut what its own policy declared, the court noted, and administrative acts are presumed lawful until annulled.
Why the type of cookie did not matter
Google argued that Colombia has no legal definition of cookies, that the SIC had imported a Spanish criterion based on "means" located in the territory, and that it ignored the classification of cookies into necessary, personalization, analytics and advertising types, and into session and persistent ones. The court found all of this beside the point. Law 1581 "does not regulate technologies, but operations on personal data," and defines processing as "any operation" without regard to the tool used. The classification exists, the judges acknowledged, but "the purpose or duration of a cookie may be relevant for examining whether a specific processing respects the principles of purpose and freedom, but not for determining whether or not there is processing of personal data in Colombia." It is enough that some of the information collected is linked to identifiable people, and the resolutions did not label every cookie as personal data.
Earlier SIC opinions did not help Google either. Concept 14-218349 of 2014 had said that processing by social networks without a Colombian domicile would not fit the law, but such concepts are not binding under Article 28 of Law 1437, and the SIC changed course in a concept of March 3, 2016. Concept 16-172268 of 2016, which Google itself quoted, says that when cookies form a database "the controller must abide by the data protection rules in force in Colombia."
Nor did the SIC's finding that the United States offers adequate data protection exempt Google: under Article 26 of Law 1581, it only permits data to be transferred from Colombia to the US, and does not replace compliance by whoever collects the data in Colombia.
"The whole internet" objection
Google warned that the SIC's theory would extend Colombian law to every website reachable from Colombia. The court disagreed in plain terms: "The territoriality of the law is not predicated on the mere accessibility of a site from Colombia, but on the effective collection of data of persons who use the service in the country through tools that the controller installs on their devices, within the framework of an activity that, as was seen, identifies its Colombian users and adapts to them."
The panel cited the Constitutional Court's warning, in T-256 of 2025, that without connecting factors each state "would assume a kind of universal jurisdiction" over anything that happens in cyberspace. Here, the judges said, the connection exists, because the operation on the data occurs in Colombia.
The judgment then looked abroad, to the GDPR and to enforcement in France, Brazil and the United States, not as binding law but, in its words, to show that "it is neither strange nor disproportionate" for a country to apply its data protection law to a foreign company that collects data from people within its borders.
| Jurisdiction | How the judgment describes the territorial rule | Age at which a minor may consent alone, as cited |
|---|---|---|
| Colombia | Law 1581 applies to processing carried out in Colombian territory, regardless of the controller's domicile | No age: the legal representative authorizes for all under-18s, after hearing the minor |
| European Union | The GDPR applies to controllers outside the EU when processing relates to offering goods or services to people in the EU or monitoring their behaviour; the European Data Protection Board's Guidelines 3/2018 (version 2.0, November 12, 2019) list online tracking through cookies as monitoring | 16, which member states may lower to no less than 13 (Article 8.1) |
| France | The CNIL's restricted committee, in deliberation SAN-2021-023 of December 31, 2021, applied French law to cookie read and write operations by Google LLC and Google Ireland on the devices of Google Search and YouTube users in France, on the basis that they took place in the context of the activities of Google's French establishment | Not cited |
| Brazil | The LGPD (Law 13.709 of August 14, 2018) applies to any company that collects data in Brazil, and treats data as collected in Brazil when the person is in the country at the moment of collection | Parental consent required for children's data (Article 14, paragraph 1) |
| United States | Not a territorial case: the FTC and New York attorney general alleged that Google and YouTube collected persistent identifiers, "commonly known as cookies," from viewers of child-directed channels without notifying parents or obtaining consent (Civil Action No. 1:19-cv-02642, D.D.C.); the judgment notes the matter ended in a settlement, not a ruling on the merits | Not cited |
Why Family Link was not enough
Google argued that the SIC ignored its parental tools, Family Link and YouTube Kids. The court found that the SIC had analyzed both, and that Resolution 60478 had acknowledged their merits in blunt terms: "Good practices are not in question; what is being ordered through Resolution No. 53593 of September 3, 2020 is that the rule be complied with in its entirety." The judges agreed that the tools fall short, for three reasons drawn from Google's own evidence.
First, Family Link is a mechanism for creating accounts for children under 13, or under the age each country sets. Under the Family Link notice the SIC transcribed, once a child turns 13, "or the corresponding age according to the applicable law," the child can choose to manage the account, and the parents then "no longer" have access to it or control over it. That leaves teenagers between that age and 18 uncovered.
Second, teenagers who create and manage their own accounts do so on their own declaration. The YouTube Kids terms transcribed in the resolutions require users under 18 to affirm that they have the permission of a parent or guardian. That, the court held, is not the authorization of a legal representative that Colombian regulation requires, and a minor's unilateral statement gives the company no way to prove it obtained authorization, as Article 17(b) of Law 1581 demands when it requires controllers to "request and keep" a copy of it.
Third, according to Google's own privacy policy, many services can be used without any account, in which case data is collected through identifiers tied to the browser or device, with no age verification or authorization mechanism shown at all.
"Family Link does not meet that requirement for three reasons," the judgment concludes: "it leaves out adolescents, it relies on the age the minor declares, and it does not cover those who use the services without an account." Under Article 26 of Decree 1377 of 2013, the accountability provision that Colombian law calls "demonstrated responsibility," the burden of showing that measures are appropriate and effective sits with the controller, not with the authority. The absence of evidence of such a mechanism, the court said, is a consequence of Google not carrying that burden, not a defect in the SIC's reasoning. The panel also cited the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child's General Comment No. 25 of 2021, under which organizations must verify that parental consent is "given by the parent or caregiver of the child," while stressing that it used the comment only to confirm rules already in force in 2020.
How the authorization rule works
The parental authorization requirement is spread across several instruments. As the judgment describes them, they set out this sequence:
- Purpose test. Processing of the data of children and adolescents must respond to and respect their best interest and ensure respect for their fundamental rights (Article 7 of Law 1581 and Article 2.2.2.25.2.9 of Decree 1074 of 2015, which compiled Article 12 of Decree 1377 of 2013). Article 7 states: "In the Processing, respect for the prevailing rights of children and adolescents shall be ensured."
- Hearing the minor. Once those requirements are met, the regulation provides that "the legal representative of the child or adolescent shall grant the authorization after the minor has exercised the right to be heard, an opinion that shall be assessed taking into account maturity, autonomy and capacity to understand the matter."
- Who counts as a minor. Article 3 of Law 1098 of 2006 defines all persons under 18 as rights holders, children as those aged 0 to 12 and adolescents as those aged 12 to 18. The court held that the data protection regime uses the same terms and draws no distinction between children and adolescents for authorization.
- Proof. The controller must "request and keep" a copy of the authorization (Article 17(b) of Law 1581) and establish mechanisms to obtain it that "guarantee its consultation" (Article 7 of Decree 1377 of 2013, compiled as Article 2.2.2.25.2.4 of Decree 1074).
- Demonstrated responsibility. On request, controllers must be able to show the SIC that they have implemented "appropriate and effective measures," proportionate to the nature of the data and the risks of processing (Article 26 of Decree 1377, compiled as Article 2.2.2.25.6.1 of Decree 1074).
The judgment does not describe what technical form a compliant mechanism would take, and it does not mention any specific age assurance method.
No consent at 14
Google's fallback claim asked the court to recognize that minors over 14 can consent to the processing of their data on their own, relying on the Civil Code, Constitutional Court decisions on adolescent autonomy, medical consent cases and SIC concepts from 2013 and 2018.
The court rejected the claim on six grounds. Data protection law draws no line between children and adolescents. Article 1504 of the Civil Code, as amended by Law 1996 of 2019, describes pubescent minors as relatively incapable, which means that unless a rule allows otherwise they act through their parents, and no rule lets adolescents authorize data processing alone. If the general capacity rules and the special data rules conflicted, Article 9 of Law 1098 would require applying "the rule most favourable to the best interest of the child or adolescent," which the panel identified as the one requiring a legal representative, because it adds a safeguard against processing that, according to Google's own policy, serves among other things to understand which ads users find "most useful." Adolescents' progressive autonomy is respected because the regulation requires that the minor be heard first. The constitutional and medical precedents Google cited concern specific areas and personal decisions, not "the authorization for a company to collect and use their data for commercial purposes." And nothing showed that the orders limit adolescents' freedom of expression, information or education: "The acts do not prevent them from using the services or accessing content."
The panel acknowledged that the EU and Brazil set different thresholds, as the table above shows. Those differences, the court concluded, confirm that the age of digital consent "is a decision for each legislator," and Colombia's legislator chose parental authorization with a prior hearing of the minor.
Orders are not sanctions
Google argued that the SIC had in effect found it liable without following the sanctioning procedure in Article 47 of the CPACA. The court pointed to the two distinct powers Law 1581 gives the regulator.
| Power | Source in Law 1581 | What it allows |
|---|---|---|
| Instructions and compliance measures | Article 21(b) and (e) | Investigate on its own initiative or on request and "order the measures necessary to make the right of habeas data effective"; give instructions on the measures and procedures needed to bring controllers' operations into line with the law |
| Sanctions | Articles 22, 23 and 24 | Fines, suspension of activities, temporary closure and immediate and definitive closure, graduated under Article 24, imposed only after a separate sanctioning procedure |
Article 22 says the SIC "shall adopt the measures or impose the corresponding sanctions," and the court read the "or" as separating the two. None of the orders to Google, it found, imposes a punishment or creates obligations beyond those already in the law. Resolution 53593 had said the same: "An administrative order is not a sanction, but a measure necessary for the adaptation of the activities or operations of Data Controllers to the provisions of Colombian regulation on personal data protection." Failing to obey the orders could lead to a sanction, the judgment notes, but only after a sanctioning procedure with its own guarantees. The judgment does not quantify any potential fine, although Law 1581 allows fines of up to 2,000 monthly minimum wages.
Under the ordinary procedure that did apply, Google was told what the proceeding was about, answered three information requests, and had its reconsideration request and appeal decided on the merits. It did not show that any evidence it requested was refused, hearings were optional under Article 35 of the CPACA, and no third parties needed to be notified, because the orders protect rather than restrict users' rights.
The account count the SIC got wrong
Google had asked the SIC to keep the number of accounts active from Colombia confidential as a trade secret under Decision 486 of 2000 of the Andean Community. The SIC published the figure, or an approximation of it, in its conclusions, press releases and its programme "SIC Te Ve," and argued on appeal that the number was not secret because Google had published user figures before and because database sizes must be declared in the public National Registry of Databases.
The court found that Google had merely asserted the trade secret without proving its commercial value or the measures taken to protect it. More decisively, irregularities void an act only when they are decisive to the outcome, and the orders would have been the same regardless of the publicity. Media coverage of the resolution before formal notification affected only when the decision took effect, not its validity. Any harm from those disclosures, the judgment says, is a matter for a different proceeding.
On the figures themselves, the court sided partly with Google. The SIC's conclusions in Resolutions 53593 and 60478 and its press releases stated that Google processes the data of 1,847,592 children and adolescents and 38,962,184 adults. Those were accounts, not people, and Google had warned that one person can hold several. Resolution 14010 acknowledged that "the number of Google Accounts mentioned is probably greater than the number of individual users in Colombia," but Resolution 60478 repeated the person count as the first reason for not fully granting Google's appeal.
| Figure in the record | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Google accounts of users under 18 active from Colombia | 1,847,592 | 28 days before February 11, 2020; age based on declared date of birth |
| Google accounts of adults active from Colombia | 39,962,184 in one place, 38,962,184 in another | The judgment flags the discrepancy in Google's transcribed response as immaterial |
| Minors in Colombia's population, per DANE as cited by the SIC | 15,454,633 (31.02%) | Cited in Resolution 53593 to link the orders to the child population |
| Article 12 (Law 1581) disclosure items not met by Google's privacy policy | 14 of 24 | SIC item-by-item review, reiterated in Resolution 60478 |
| Article 13 (Decree 1377) policy content items not met | 10 of 19 | Same review |
| Size of Google's administrative appeal | 84 pages, 124 annexed folios, 15-page supplementary brief | As recorded in Resolution 60478 |
The court called the conflation an "imprecision" but held it was not decisive. None of the orders depends on how many people are affected; the duties to inform, adopt a policy, obtain parental authorization and register databases exist toward each data subject. "The protection that Article 44 of the Constitution guarantees is owed to each child or adolescent," the judgment says, "and does not depend on whether those affected are many or few."
The privacy policy review
Google also called the SIC's assessment of its privacy policy "subjective and arbitrary," arguing that the policy contains a section explaining why Google collects data and that it meets US standards. The court found no factual error. The SIC had checked the policy item by item against Article 12 of Law 1581 and Article 13 of Decree 1377, which require stating "the Processing to which [the] personal data will be subjected and the purpose thereof." A general reference to purposes does not satisfy that requirement, the court held, and Google did not show which of the requirements marked as unmet had in fact been met, nor did it put the section of the policy it relied on before the court in a consultable form. Compliance with US law was irrelevant, since Colombian law governs processing carried out in Colombia.
The bias claim
Google's last charge was abuse of power. It argued that the resolutions put into effect a personal position that the Superintendente Delegado for Personal Data Protection had taken before joining the SIC, in columns published in 2014 and 2015, in collaboration on Bill 106 of 2015 to extend Law 1581 to international data processing, and in an appearance on "SIC Te Ve." The judgment does not name the official.
The court found no proof of a distorted purpose. The columns, which predated the proceeding by four to five years, addressed the general interpretation of the law and a Spanish case from 2013, not Google's Colombian services, its 2019 and 2020 policies or Family Link. That an academic and, years later, an authority reach the same reading of a rule "is compatible with that reading being correct." Google never sought to recuse the official, the first two resolutions were signed by the Director of Investigation, and the transcript of the "SIC Te Ve" episode of May 24, 2020 did not identify the speaker and said only that Google's information was "in the analysis phase." The Superintendente Delegado had also revoked the fifth order in Google's favour, which the court read as a sign of impartial review. On the tone of some passages in Resolution 60478, the panel said it "does not share" it, but found that tone did not prove any purpose other than protecting minors' data.
Civil society on the SIC's side
By an order of October 28, 2025, confirmed on January 27, 2026, the court admitted three organizations as coadjuvants supporting the SIC: the research centre Dejusticia, the parents' association Red PaPaz and the consumer league Tal Cual. Dejusticia explained how cookies and other tracking tools work and asked that the SIC consider a "dialogic stage" for compliance. Red PaPaz argued that the burden of proving authorization falls on the controller. Tal Cual invoked consumer protection rules and standards on advertising to children. The court used their submissions only where they reinforced the SIC's defence, and declined to rule on consumer protection, food advertising, the dialogue proposal, the corporate structure of Google Colombia Ltda., other tracking techniques or the SIC's treatment of other platforms. It also refused to apply laws adopted after the resolutions, including Law 2489 of 2025, because an administrative act is judged under the law in force when it was issued.
Why this matters for marketers
The case turns a familiar piece of advertising infrastructure into the trigger for national jurisdiction. The court did not find Google subject to Colombian law because its sites are reachable in Colombia or because it earns revenue there; it found that placing and reading identifiers on a device in Colombia is itself collection in Colombia. That logic is not specific to Google. Any ad platform, measurement vendor or publisher that sets cookies, pixels or similar identifiers on devices of people in Colombia, and ties what it gathers to an account, browser or device, fits the same description, and the court went out of its way to say that a cookie's purpose does not change whether the law applies.
The children's dimension may weigh more. Colombian law, as this court reads it, sets no age at which a teenager can authorize data processing alone, which puts it apart from the GDPR's 13-to-16 range and from the COPPA model in the US, which centres on children under 13. In the court's view, self-declared birth dates and under-13 supervision tools are not enough for users aged 13 to 17, and services usable without an account need their own answer. Google's systems are built around age lines that vary by country: in January 2025 the company consolidated its ad protections for children and teens around each jurisdiction's digital age of consent, in July 2025 it began using machine-learning age estimation in the US to switch off ad personalization for likely minors, and in May 2026 it replaced its TFCD and TFUA tags with a TFAT signal that adds a TEEN value to ad requests. The Colombian judgment asks for something different: not an estimate of who is a minor, nor a limit on the ads shown to them, but a parent's authorization, kept on record, for every user under 18.
Colombian law may not stay where this court left it. Statutory Bill No. 282 of 2026, a data protection bill that would fine companies up to 5% of revenue, would make a minor's own consent valid from age 14, with a legal representative's express consent required below that. It would also apply the law to processing related to goods or services offered to people in Colombia, or to monitoring their behaviour, whatever the controller's domicile, and would require foreign controllers to designate a representative before the SIC or open a branch. The bill would write into statute the age line that Google asked the court to read into the current law. Because the panel judged the 2020 orders under the rules in force when they were issued, a later reform would not change this outcome.
The SIC's consent enforcement has had consequences before: the authority fined Rappi COP 298 million in 2019 for being unable to prove that users had authorized the use of their data, a finding that now underpins a group action. Colombian judges have also used Law 1581 to reach other foreign platforms. In May 2026, the Constitutional Court held that X owes journalists due process when it suspends their accounts, adopting what it called a moderate destination-country approach.
Authorities elsewhere are pressing on both fronts. Uganda's data protection office ordered Google to register as a data processor in July 2025, and in September 2026 the High Court of Lagos State ordered Meta to pay the naira equivalent of $100,000 over behavioural advertising, applying Nigerian data protection law to the Delaware company. The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled in June 2026 that member states can require age checks from pornography sites based in other countries. Brazil's ANPD made child protection an enforcement priority in December 2025, published a draft age verification guide in May 2026 that excluded self-declaration from reliable mechanisms, the same weakness the Colombian court found in Family Link, and its investigators recommended R$153.7 million in fines against ByteDance over TikTok children's data in August 2026. The CNIL, whose 2021 decision the Colombian court cited, fined Google €325 million in September 2025 over Gmail ads and cookies.
For advertisers buying audiences in Colombia, the open question is how platforms will show compliance for teenage users, and what happens to data resting on self-declared ages once the SIC asks to see the authorizations.
What the judgment does not settle
The ruling does not reproduce the compliance deadlines set in 2020 or say whether Google has met any of the orders since, it does not describe what a compliant parental authorization mechanism would look like in practice, and it does not say whether Google has appealed or whether the SIC has opened any sanctioning proceeding. It also leaves aside every tracking technique other than those examined in the resolutions and the situation of Google Colombia Ltda.
Key facts
- Court: Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca, Sección Primera, Subsección C (Bogotá)
- Judgment: Sentencia No. 286, first instance (early judgment under Article 182A.1 of Law 1437 of 2011), dated November 5, 2026, signed electronically on the SAMAI platform
- Case number: 25000-23-41-000-2022-00444-00 (action for annulment and restoration of rights)
- Panel: Ana Margoth Chamorro Benavides (writing), Fabio Iván Afanador García, Luis Norberto Cermeño
- Claimant: Google LLC (counsel: Lorenzo Villegas Carrasquilla)
- Defendant: Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio (counsel: Mary Elisa Blanco Quintero)
- Coadjuvants for the SIC: Dejusticia; Corporación Colombiana de Padres y Madres - Red PaPaz; Liga de Consumidores Tal Cual
- Acts challenged: Resolution 53593 of September 3, 2020; Resolution 14010 of March 16, 2021; Resolution 60478 of September 21, 2021 (administrative file 19-202397)
- Outcome: all principal and subsidiary claims denied; no costs
- Core provision: Article 2 of Statutory Law 1581 of 2012 (territorial scope)
- Parental authorization rule: Article 2.2.2.25.2.9 of Decree 1074 of 2015 (formerly Article 12 of Decree 1377 of 2013)
- Constitutional Court decisions relied on: C-748 of 2011, T-256 of 2025 (June 12, 2025), T-174 of 2026
- Origin of the proceeding: FTC press release of September 4, 2019 on the $170 million Google and YouTube settlement (Civil Action No. 1:19-cv-02642, D.D.C.)
- Source document: Sentencia No. 286, Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca, 36 pages, in Spanish
- Quotations: translated from the Spanish original by PPC Land; an unofficial 34-page English translation of the judgment, which describes itself as not official or certified, was also consulted
Timeline
- October 17, 2012: Colombia enacts Statutory Law 1581 on personal data protection.
- June 27, 2013: Decree 1377 of 2013 regulates Law 1581, including the authorization rule for minors' data.
- 2014 and 2015: The future Superintendente Delegado publishes columns on applying data laws to foreign companies.
- May 26, 2015: Decree 1074 of 2015 compiles the data protection regulations.
- March 3, 2016: An SIC concept says the law extends to social network providers established abroad.
- January 18, 2018: Decree 090 of 2018 sets the 100,000 UVT asset threshold for database registration.
- April 25, 2019: The SIC fines Rappi COP 298 million for failing to prove users' authorization.
- September 4, 2019: The FTC announces the $170 million Google and YouTube children's privacy settlement.
- September 5, 2019: The SIC sends Google its first information request.
- October 16, 2019: Google tells the SIC it collects personal data from people in different parts of the world, including Colombia.
- February 11, 2020: Google reports 1,847,592 under-18 accounts and about 39 million adult accounts active from Colombia over 28 days.
- February 13, 2020: The SIC notifies Google that an administrative proceeding has opened.
- May 24, 2020: An episode of "SIC Te Ve" says Google's information is under analysis.
- September 3, 2020: Resolution 53593 issues the orders to Google.
- March 16, 2021: Resolution 14010 confirms the orders on reconsideration.
- September 21, 2021: Resolution 60478 revokes the fifth order and confirms the rest.
- October 1, 2021: The resolutions become final for Google.
- December 31, 2021: The CNIL adopts deliberation SAN-2021-023 on Google's cookies in France.
- January 28, 2022: The SIC rejects Google's request for direct revocation.
- April 8, 2022: Google files its annulment suit.
- March 7, 2024: The court admits the corrected complaint.
- May 3, 2024: The SIC answers the suit.
- January 15, 2025: Google consolidates its ad protections for children and teens.
- February 18, 2025: The court refuses to suspend the resolutions provisionally.
- June 12, 2025: Constitutional Court ruling T-256 of 2025 cites the Google resolution as an example of Law 1581 reaching foreign platforms.
- July 18, 2025: Uganda's data protection office orders Google to register as a data processor.
- July 2025: Google begins machine-learning age estimation in the US to limit ads to likely minors.
- September 1, 2025: The CNIL fines Google €325 million over Gmail ads and cookies.
- October 28, 2025: Dejusticia, Red PaPaz and Tal Cual are admitted as coadjuvants for the SIC.
- December 22, 2025: Brazil's ANPD adds child protection to its enforcement priorities.
- January 27, 2026: The coadjuvant order is confirmed on reconsideration.
- May 15, 2026: Colombia's Constitutional Court rules that X owes journalists due process in account suspensions.
- May 18, 2026: Google replaces TFCD and TFUA with the TFAT signal and its TEEN value.
- May 2026: Brazil's ANPD opens a draft age verification guide to public input.
- June 16, 2026: The CJEU rules that member states can force age checks on foreign pornography sites.
- July 14, 2026: The court dispenses with an evidence phase and announces an early judgment.
- August 5, 2026: The case file goes to the magistrate for judgment.
- August 21, 2026: TikTok's $400 million payment is announced as the Justice Department moves to vacate its 2019 COPPA decree.
- August 24, 2026: Brazilian investigators recommend R$153.7 million in fines against ByteDance over TikTok children's data.
- September 8, 2026: Colombia's Bill No. 282 of 2026, setting 14 as the age of a minor's own consent, appears in the Congressional Gazette.
- September 25, 2026: The High Court of Lagos State orders Meta to pay the naira equivalent of $100,000 over behavioural ads.
- November 5, 2026: The court denies all of Google's claims in Sentencia No. 286.
Related PPC Land coverage
- Colombia's third data bill would fine firms up to 5% of revenue - Bill No. 282 of 2026, which would set 14 as the age of a minor's own consent and require foreign controllers to appoint a representative before the SIC.
- Colombia's court rules X owes journalists due process in account suspensions - The Constitutional Court's May 2026 ruling that applied Colombian rules to X on a destination-country basis.
- Rappi faces claim for 2 minimum wages per Colombian user over consent - A group action built on the SIC's 2019 finding that Rappi could not prove users' authorization.
- Uganda orders Google to register as data processor in landmark privacy ruling - Another data protection authority asserting jurisdiction over Google LLC from outside the US.
- Meta loses Nigerian privacy suit over behavioural ads, must pay $100,000 - A Lagos court applies Nigerian data protection law to a US platform over behavioural advertising.
- Brazil's ANPD releases draft age verification guide open to public input - Brazil's draft guidance that treats self-declared age as unreliable.
- Google tightens advertising rules to protect minors across its platforms - Google's January 2025 consolidation of its ad protections for children and teens.
- Google begins machine learning age detection for ad protections in US - The 2025 US rollout of age estimation that disables ad personalization for likely minors.
- Google's new TFAT signal kills TFCD and TFUA - and finally adds a TEEN tier - How Google's ad request tagging for children and teenagers changed in May 2026.
- YouTube's COPPA deadline hits: what the audience-setting rules really mean - The audience-setting rules that trace back to the 2019 FTC and New York settlement.
- Google fined €325 million by French regulator for Gmail ads and cookie violations - The CNIL's September 2025 sanction against Google over Gmail ads and cookies.
- EU court rules states can force age checks on foreign porn sites - A June 2026 CJEU judgment on national age-check rules for sites based in other countries.
- Brazil's data watchdog adds child protection to enforcement agenda - The ANPD's 2026-2027 enforcement priorities.
- ByteDance faces R$ 153.7 million in fines over TikTok children's data - Brazilian investigators' recommended fines over TikTok's handling of children's data.
- TikTok pays $400 million as DOJ moves to vacate its 2019 COPPA decree - The latest large US children's privacy payment by a platform.
Summary
Who: Google LLC, the claimant; Colombia's Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio, the data protection authority whose orders were challenged; Dejusticia, Red PaPaz and Tal Cual, which intervened on the SIC's side; and a three-judge panel of the Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca led by Magistrate Ana Margoth Chamorro Benavides.
What: A first-instance judgment that rejected Google's suit to annul three SIC resolutions from 2020 and 2021. The court held that Colombian data protection law applies to data processing carried out in Colombia regardless of the controller's domicile, that collecting data through cookies and other identifiers on devices in Colombia is such processing, that the SIC's orders are compliance measures rather than sanctions, and that Google's Family Link and YouTube Kids tools do not satisfy the requirement of parental authorization for all users under 18. The SIC's description of accounts as people was found to be an immaterial error.
When: The judgment is dated November 5, 2026. The resolutions date from September 3, 2020, March 16, 2021 and September 21, 2021, and Google sued on April 8, 2022.
Where: Bogotá, Colombia, in the First Section, Subsection C of the Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca.
Why: The case decides whether a foreign platform without a Colombian office answers to Colombian privacy law when it tracks people in Colombia, and what a company must do to process the data of teenagers there. For advertisers, publishers and ad technology vendors, it ties jurisdiction to the act of placing and reading identifiers on local devices, and sets a parental authorization standard for under-18s that is stricter than the age thresholds used in the EU and the US.
Discussion