Meta on November 18 set out a three-phase consultation on the business terms it froze earlier this month, and said it expects to take the rewritten text back to news publishers, other stakeholders and regulators in early 2027 before rolling it out. The post, published in the company's newsroom under the title "Our Approach to Updating Our Commercial Terms of Service," gives no effective date. Meta anticipates that the process "may take a few months to complete."
The post also names the dispute that the November 5 pause notice left unmentioned. "We made this decision after hearing concerns from news publishers and other stakeholders about how the proposed updates apply to our web crawlers," according to Meta. The earlier notice, posted in Meta's Business Help Center, spoke only of consulting stakeholders and said nothing about crawling.
In Short
Meta has explained how it plans to rewrite the business terms it put on hold on November 5: it is listening to publishers and industry groups now, will revise the text, and expects to show the new version to publishers, other stakeholders and regulators in early 2027. That matters to every company that advertises on Facebook and Instagram, and most of all to news publishers, who objected that the terms would let Meta's crawlers collect their websites' content. For now nothing changes: the existing terms stay in force, and Meta says account holders will be notified, with time to review, before any new terms take effect.
What the November 18 post says
The post is short - fewer than 400 words under two subheadings - and carries no byline. It opens by recalling that the proposed updates "have been put on hold and that we will revise those proposed changes after a deeper consultation with stakeholders." The verb is revise. Elsewhere Meta writes of work to "refine/modify the planned updates" and of "revising the terms to refine the initially-previewed language." Nothing in the text describes a withdrawal. The language is that of an edit.
Meta filed the post in its newsroom's "Newsroom for Europe, Middle East and Africa" category. Its phrase "commercial terms of service" links to the current Meta Commercial Terms page on facebook.com, and the words "web crawler developer doc" link to Meta's crawler documentation for site owners.
One sentence stands out. In briefings with publishers, according to the post, "we have shared context on how our crawlers work and the potential products that future changes to our terms seek to enable." The terms, in Meta's own framing, exist to make future products possible. Which products? The post does not say, and it does not indicate whether those products would be described in the explainer document it promises.
How the consultation is set to run
According to Meta, the consultation has three phases, followed by a notice to account holders. The post gives the stages in this order:
- Listening to stakeholders. The initial phase "is designed to listen to stakeholder concerns and to identify specific issues and key themes of concern with respect to the previously proposed updates." Meta says it has "already initiated briefings and feedback discussions with news publishers across markets and global industry groups," in which it explained how its crawlers work and the potential products the terms are meant to enable. It expects these conversations "to be ongoing over the next few months."
- Considering feedback. Meta is "gathering stakeholder feedback with the goal of revising the terms to refine the initially-previewed language," and will "continue to review the feedback and prepare revisions to the terms accordingly."
- Further engagement before rollout. "In early 2027, we expect to further engage with news publishers, other stakeholders and regulators on updated terms that come out of this process before they are rolled out." Meta says it will also "develop an accompanying explainer document to put the terms in context and help them understand the proposed changes fully."
- Notice to account holders. "As we typically do, we will notify account holders ahead of the new terms going into effect allowing for a period of review." The length of that period is not stated.
| Stage | What Meta says happens | Who Meta names | Timing in the post |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listening to stakeholders | Identify specific issues and key themes; explain how crawlers work and the potential products the terms seek to enable | News publishers across markets; global industry groups | Started; "ongoing over the next few months" |
| Considering feedback | Gather feedback; prepare revisions to "refine the initially-previewed language" | Stakeholders (unnamed) | No date |
| Further engagement before rollout | Engagement on the updated terms; explainer document | News publishers, other stakeholders, regulators | "Early 2027" |
| Notice | Account holders notified ahead of the effective date, with a period of review | Account holders | Length not stated |
| Whole process | Phased approach | - | "May take a few months to complete" |
The dates overlap. A listening phase that runs "over the next few months" from mid-November and a third phase set for "early 2027" cannot be strictly consecutive, which suggests the stages will run in parallel for part of the time. On PPC Land's reading of the timetable, revised terms could not take effect before the early 2027 engagement round and the notice period that follows it.
From October 30 to early 2027
The timetable has moved three times in five weeks. When PPC Land first examined the revised text in October, Meta's new terms granted it the right to crawl advertisers' websites for AI, with continued use of Meta's business tools counting as acceptance from October 30.
| Date | Meta's position | Effective date |
|---|---|---|
| Mid-October 2026 | Revised Commercial Terms published in preview | October 30, 2026 |
| October 23, 2026 | Commercial Terms and Self-Serve Ad Terms postponed | November 20, 2026 |
| October 28, 2026 | Communications chief Andy Stone pledges full consultation, says it could run past November 20 | November 20, 2026, conditional |
| November 5, 2026 | Updates to four sets of terms paused; preview removed; existing terms remain | None |
| November 18, 2026 | Three-phase consultation; further engagement "in early 2027"; notice before rollout | None |
On October 23, Meta delayed its website-crawling terms to November 20 after publisher complaints. Five days later, as the Norwegian court temporarily blocked Meta's new terms after 10 media groups sued, Stone said on X that Meta would not change its policies without a full consultation with industry groups and leaders. Then, on November 5, Meta halted the November 20 terms that would let it crawl business websites, pausing updates to the Meta Commercial Terms, Product Catalog Terms, Self-Serve Ad Terms and Ad Creative Generative AI Terms with no new date.
The November 18 post is narrower in one respect. It refers throughout to "our commercial terms of service" and does not mention the other three sets of terms by name. One of them carried the provision PPC Land reported on October 22, under which Meta would make advertisers solely responsible for its AI ad edits. Whether that liability language goes through the same three phases, or a separate process, is not addressed.
The robots.txt argument
Meta used the post to restate its defence. "Meta follows the industry standard robots.txt mechanism as described in our web crawler developer doc," according to the post. Robots.txt is the plain-text file at the root of a website that tells automated agents which paths they may request. It is a convention, not a contract, and compliance is voluntary.
The documentation the post links to, as PPC Land read it on November 21, lists five Meta crawlers and does not mention the Commercial Terms. Two of the five carry stated exceptions to robots.txt. FacebookExternalHit, which fetches pages people share in order to build link previews, may bypass the file when performing security or integrity checks such as scanning for malware, according to Meta's documentation. Meta-ExternalFetcher, which retrieves individual links at a user's request, may bypass it because those fetches are user-requested.
| Crawler | Purpose, according to Meta's documentation | Robots.txt, according to Meta's documentation |
|---|---|---|
| FacebookExternalHit | Crawls content of an app or website that was shared, such as for link previews | May bypass robots.txt for security or integrity checks |
| Meta-WebIndexer | Improves Meta AI search result quality; allowing it helps Meta cite and link content in Meta AI responses | No exception stated |
| Meta-ExternalAds | Improving advertising and other business-related products and services | No exception stated |
| Meta-ExternalAgent | Training foundation AI models or improving products by indexing content directly | No exception stated |
| Meta-ExternalFetcher | Fetches individual links at a user's request; supports agentic AI functions | May bypass robots.txt because fetches are user-requested |
The page describes the blocking method as adding a disallow rule for the relevant crawler to robots.txt, and warns that crawlers may cache a site's robots.txt for up to 24 hours. It states a preference for industry-standard practices such as robots.txt over non-standard formats such as NoAI tags. It publishes no IP address ranges for verifying that a request comes from Meta.
The structure matters for publishers. Meta-ExternalAgent is documented for both model training and product indexing, the pattern of a mixed-use crawler: a site that disallows it to stay out of training also opts out of whatever indexing it performs. The objection publishers raised in October went beyond crawler etiquette. The European Publishers Council, when it asked the EU to halt Meta's crawling terms before November 20, argued that a robots.txt file is no substitute for a contractual right to refuse, and that sites need to know which agent is acting and on whose behalf. The revised clause would have authorised crawling of domains associated with a business's products by contract. The November 18 post repeats the robots.txt position without engaging that argument.
Other companies have moved towards shared signals in the same period. On October 31, PPC Land reported that Google and Bing backed one robots.txt rule to opt out of AI training.
Courts and a regulator already involved
The third phase is the only place the post mentions regulators, and it names none. One regulator is already investigating, and two courts have ruled.
In the United Kingdom, Meta faces a Competition and Markets Authority probe over its planned terms. The investigation opened on October 30, the original effective date, and examines whether Meta abused a dominant position; its case page covers Meta's existing commercial terms as well as revisions, and its initial information-gathering phase was scheduled to run until January 2027. That window closes around the time Meta's early 2027 engagement round is due to start.
Courts in Oslo and São Paulo granted preliminary injunctions before the pause. The Oslo order on October 28 followed a suit by 10 Norwegian media groups. In Brazil, Meta faces a R$1m daily fine if it scrapes Brazilian media sites for AI, under a November 3 order capped at R$100 million that suspends the crawling clause for members of three national media associations. Both orders were framed to last until the courts rule on the cases. The November 18 post mentions neither court.
Why this matters for marketers
The crawling clause was never confined to news sites. As drafted, it reached the websites associated with any business using Meta's products: retailers with product catalogues, app developers, agencies running campaigns for clients. Publishers led the opposition because their archives are the content most exposed to reuse, but the November 18 post, by naming "news publishers across markets" as the first group consulted, puts them at the centre of the process. Retailers and advertisers who are not publishers appear in the post only under "other stakeholders" and as the "account holders" who will be notified.
The admission that the terms "seek to enable" potential products is the most consequential line for that wider group. Meta's crawler documentation already describes agents for Meta AI search, for training foundation models, for advertising and business products, and for agentic features. PPC Land has also followed Meta's agents on the open web, reporting on October 31 that Meta's Muse agent gained a signed ID in a quiet test. The post does not link the terms to any of these. It does confirm that the contract was written with products in mind that Meta has not described publicly.
There is also the question of trust, which PPC Land raised when it argued that the delay to November 20 did not move the trust problem. A three-week postponement became an indefinite pause, and the pause has now become a consultation stretching into 2027, with a promise of an explainer document and a review period. That is a slower process than the one Meta first chose, in which revised terms surfaced in mid-October with an October 30 start date. Whether the text that emerges is materially different is the open question.
What the post leaves open
The post does not name the publishers, industry groups or regulators involved; gives no end date for the first two phases or a length for the review period; does not say whether the Product Catalog Terms, Self-Serve Ad Terms and Ad Creative Generative AI Terms are part of the process; does not describe the potential products; and does not say whether the crawling clause will survive in any form. It is silent on the Oslo and São Paulo orders and on the CMA investigation.
Key facts
- Source document: "Our Approach to Updating Our Commercial Terms of Service," Meta Newsroom, dated November 18, 2026; category "Newsroom for Europe, Middle East and Africa"; no byline
- Source URL: https://about.fb.com/news/2026/11/our-approach-to-updating-our-commercial-terms-of-service/
- Terms concerned: Meta Commercial Terms (described in the post as "our commercial terms of service"); the November 5 pause also covered the Product Catalog Terms, Self-Serve Ad Terms and Ad Creative Generative AI Terms
- Terms in force: the existing Meta Commercial Terms, in effect since March 6, 2024
- Former effective dates: October 30, 2026, then November 20, 2026; paused on November 5, 2026 with no new date
- Consultation phases: Listening to stakeholders; Considering feedback; Further engagement before rollout ("early 2027")
- Commitments: an accompanying explainer document; notice to account holders before the new terms take effect, with a period of review (length not stated)
- Crawler documentation: https://developers.facebook.com/documentation/sharing/webmasters/web-crawlers, listing FacebookExternalHit, Meta-WebIndexer, Meta-ExternalAds, Meta-ExternalAgent and Meta-ExternalFetcher
- Related proceedings: CMA case "Suspected abuse of a dominant position in relation to Meta's commercial terms," opened October 30, 2026; Oslo District Court interim order, October 28, 2026; São Paulo court order in case 4214874-21.2026.8.26.0100, November 3, 2026
Timeline
- March 6, 2024 - Current Meta Commercial Terms take effect
- October 17, 2026 - PPC Land reports that Meta's revised terms grant it the right to crawl advertisers' websites for AI from October 30
- October 22, 2026 - The AI features section would make advertisers solely responsible for Meta's AI ad edits; the News/Media Alliance gives Meta until October 26 to answer
- October 23, 2026 - Meta moves the Commercial Terms and Self-Serve Ad Terms to November 20
- October 24, 2026 - The European Publishers Council asks the EU to halt the crawling terms before November 20
- October 28, 2026 - The Oslo District Court temporarily blocks the terms; Andy Stone pledges a full consultation
- October 30, 2026 - The CMA opens a formal investigation into Meta's commercial terms
- October 31, 2026 - Google and Bing back one robots.txt rule to opt out of AI training
- November 3, 2026 - A São Paulo court suspends the crawling clause for Brazilian media association members, with a R$1m daily penalty
- November 5, 2026 - Meta pauses updates to four sets of terms with no new date
- November 18, 2026 - Meta publishes its three-phase consultation plan and ties the pause to publishers' concerns about its crawlers
- January 2027 - Scheduled end of the CMA's initial information-gathering phase
- Early 2027 - Meta expects further engagement with news publishers, other stakeholders and regulators on the updated terms, before rollout and a notice period
Related PPC Land coverage
- Meta grants itself the right to crawl advertisers' websites for AI - The original reading of the crawling clause in the revised Commercial Terms.
- Meta's new terms let it crawl business websites to train AI from Oct 30 - Early coverage of the AI training language and the October 30 start date.
- Meta's AI training clause still in Oct 30 terms after report of removal - A check of the UK English preview after reports that the "train" sentence had gone.
- Meta makes advertisers solely responsible for its AI ad edits from Oct 30 - The liability section for AI-altered ads that sat in the same package.
- News/Media Alliance gives Meta until Oct 26 to answer on crawling terms - The US trade body's open letter demanding withdrawal.
- Meta delays website-crawling terms to Nov 20 after publisher complaints - Meta's first postponement.
- Meta delays its AI terms to November 20. The trust problem does not move - Analysis of why the first delay left the dispute unresolved.
- European publishers ask EU to halt Meta's crawling terms before Nov 20 - The European Publishers Council's case that robots.txt is no substitute for a contractual refusal.
- Norwegian court temporarily blocks Meta's new terms after 10 media groups sue - The Oslo interim order and Meta's first consultation pledge.
- Meta faces UK probe over planned terms to use publishers' content for AI - The CMA investigation, which also covers Meta's existing terms.
- Meta faces R$1m daily fine if it scrapes Brazilian media sites for AI - The São Paulo order suspending the crawling clause for Brazilian media association members.
- Meta halts its Nov 20 terms that would let it crawl business websites - The November 5 pause of four sets of terms.
- Meta's Muse agent gains a signed ID in a quiet test, DataDome finds - How Meta's agents identify themselves to websites.
- Google and Bing back one robots.txt rule to opt out of AI training - A shared AI training opt-out signal from other technology companies.
- Meta loses Paris appeal, must share revenue data with French press groups - A separate dispute in which French publishers won against Meta in court.
Summary
Who: Meta, owner of Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp and Threads, and every business that uses its advertising and business tools. The consultation centres on news publishers and global industry groups, with regulators to be included in the final phase.
What: Meta set out a three-phase consultation - listening to stakeholders, considering feedback, and further engagement before rollout - on revisions to its commercial terms, which it paused on November 5. It linked the pause to publishers' concerns about how the terms apply to its web crawlers, restated that it follows robots.txt, said the terms seek to enable potential future products, and promised an explainer document and a notice period before any new terms take effect.
When: The post is dated November 18, 2026. Meta expects listening sessions to continue over the next few months and further engagement on updated terms in early 2027, with the whole process taking "a few months."
Where: Meta published the post in the Europe, Middle East and Africa category of its newsroom. The briefings cover "news publishers across markets," and related proceedings are under way in the United Kingdom, Norway and Brazil.
Why: Meta said it put the updates on hold "after hearing concerns from news publishers and other stakeholders about how the proposed updates apply to our web crawlers," and that it wants "to take our time to get this right." The revised terms had drawn letters from trade bodies, two court orders and a UK competition investigation before the pause.
Discussion