Germany's competition authority believes one of the quieter clauses in PayPal's merchant terms may be unlawful. On 11 November 2026, the Bundeskartellamt notified PayPal Holdings, Inc., PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l. et Cie. S.C.A. and PayPal Limited of its preliminary assessment of the "Rules about surcharging", under which online shops that accept PayPal may not charge customers anything extra for choosing it. According to the Bundeskartellamt, the prohibition "could restrict competition between various payment services and violate competition law."

The authority is also looking beyond the clause itself. It is weighing whether to order PayPal to surrender the economic benefits it obtained from the possible infringement, a step available under Section 34 of the German Competition Act (GWB). The assessment arrives nearly four years after the Bundeskartellamt opened the proceeding on 23 January 2023. It is not a final decision, and PayPal now has the opportunity to comment.

In Short

Germany's competition authority told PayPal on 11 November 2026 that its rule stopping online shops from charging customers extra for paying with PayPal may break competition law. Because PayPal charges merchants more than most rival payment methods, the authority says shops spread that cost across all their prices, so people paying by card, Klarna, Wero or bank transfer help cover it, and cheaper payment providers find it harder to win customers on price. Nothing changes for shoppers or merchants yet: PayPal can respond, the finding is preliminary, and the authority is considering whether to make PayPal give up the gains it made from the rule.

A contract term since 2018

The case is about a single kind of term. According to the Bundeskartellamt, PayPal's terms and conditions have prohibited merchants from charging their customers extra for paying with PayPal "since 2018." The ban holds "even if they incur higher costs than with other payment methods," the authority wrote, and "according to the present state of the investigations, PayPal has been enforcing this prohibition." PayPal is entitled to terminate the business relationship with merchants who breach it.

That last point matters for how the term operates in practice. A merchant that wanted to add a fee for PayPal payments, as German law would in principle allow, would risk losing PayPal as a payment option altogether. For many shops, that is not a realistic trade. Andreas Mundt, President of the Bundeskartellamt, put it plainly: "For many people, PayPal is a natural way to pay for their online purchases. Many online merchants therefore find it difficult to refrain from offering PayPal as a payment method. At the same time, PayPal is a comparatively expensive payment service for merchants."

How the surcharging rule works, according to the Bundeskartellamt

The authority's release describes the mechanism in five steps.

  1. Checkout integration. A merchant offers PayPal in its online shop. Customers pay through a PayPal account that is linked to a source of payment, such as a credit card or a bank account.
  2. Merchant fees. PayPal charges the merchant for payment processing, as other payment services do. The amount "varies sometimes considerably" depending on the payment method used, and larger merchants negotiate fees individually. According to the authority's current findings, PayPal "charges above-average fees compared to other payment methods."
  3. The prohibition. PayPal's "Rules about surcharging" forbid the merchant from passing that fee directly to PayPal users through an extra charge, even where PayPal costs the merchant more than other methods.
  4. Enforcement. According to the Bundeskartellamt, PayPal has been enforcing the prohibition and can terminate the relationship with merchants who breach it.
  5. Cost spreading. The merchant recovers the cost through the prices of its goods and services, charged to every customer. In the authority's words, merchants "must pass them on to all their customers via the prices for the products and services they offer, including customers who do not use PayPal as payment method." PayPal users, meanwhile, "do not have cost transparency and thus no incentive to use a cheaper method of payment."

Expensive, and hard to refuse

PayPal is, according to the Bundeskartellamt, "one of Germany's most important payment services in online retail," and its market share "is very high compared to other online payment methods." The release gives no figure for that share.

The authority places PayPal within a group of payment methods that grew up specifically for online retail. These methods are easy to build into an online checkout, protect users against misuse of their credentials, protect merchants against non-payment and, in certain cases, offer customers refunds - for example when ordered goods are not delivered - as well as financing options. Besides PayPal, the Bundeskartellamt lists cards from Mastercard and Visa that can be used online, and Klarna. One name is new to the field: "The Wero payment service offered by banks has newly entered the market."

The fee picture is less precise in the 2026 release than in the 2023 one. In January 2023, the authority cited market studies showing that PayPal was "not only the leading online payment scheme in Germany but also one of the most expensive online payment services," and quoted PayPal's own price list: a standard rate in Germany of "2.49%-2.99% of the payment amount plus 34-39 cents per payment." The November 2026 release refers only to "above-average fees" and to individually negotiated rates for larger merchants. No current rate is given.

The table below applies the January 2023 standard rates to three order values. It shows why fixed per-payment charges weigh most heavily on small baskets.

Order value Fee at 2.49% + €0.34 Effective rate Fee at 2.99% + €0.39 Effective rate
€20 €0.84 4.19% €0.99 4.94%
€50 €1.58 3.17% €1.88 3.77%
€100 €2.83 2.83% €3.38 3.38%

PPC Land calculation based on the standard German rates the Bundeskartellamt quoted from PayPal's price list on 23 January 2023. Current rates and negotiated rates for larger merchants are not given in the 2026 release and may differ.

What German law allows

The legal backdrop is unusual, and it explains why the authority treats a private contract term as the decisive barrier. Under German law, merchants could in principle charge customers for paying with PayPal, "provided in particular that the charges do not exceed the actual costs incurred by the merchant," according to the Bundeskartellamt. For several cheaper payment methods, the law itself rules out any extra charge.

Payment method Surcharge under German law, per the Bundeskartellamt What stops it
PayPal Allowed in principle, if charges do not exceed the merchant's actual costs PayPal's "Rules about surcharging" (since 2018)
Consumer credit cards Excluded by law Statute
SEPA transfers Excluded by law Statute
SEPA direct debits Excluded by law Statute

The 2023 release pointed to the European rule behind such exclusions. Article 62(4) of the payment services directive, Directive (EU) 2015/2366, bars sellers from requesting separate charges for certain payment methods "which were deemed to involve comparatively low costs." Germany's Federal Court of Justice ruled on 25 March 2021, in case I ZR 203/19, that PayPal does not fall within that provision. During the review of the directive, the Bundeskartellamt had also called, in a statement of 2 August 2022, for the surcharge ban to be abolished for certain card-based payments, "since these payment schemes do not always involve low costs."

Put together, the result is a market in which the payment methods the law treats as cheap cannot carry a surcharge, while the method the authority describes as expensive could carry one under the law but does not, because PayPal's contract forbids it. Merchants, in other words, have no lawful and practical way to show a customer what a given payment method costs them.

How the authority says competition suffers

The Bundeskartellamt's preliminary view is that the prohibition harms competition "in several ways." Merchants "cannot make the cost differences between payment methods visible to their customers, which eliminates possibilities to incentivise the use of cheaper payment services."

The second effect falls on PayPal's rivals. According to the authority, the rule "could in particular make it difficult for other and new providers of payment methods to compete with PayPal." A provider offering lower fees cannot easily convert that advantage into a lower price at checkout, because merchants are limited in how they pass savings on to customers. "As long as PayPal has to be offered without extra charge, consumers have fewer incentives for using another payment method, which would also reduce the competitive pressure on PayPal's merchant fees."

That last clause is the core of the case. Competitive pressure on merchant fees is what normally limits a payment provider's pricing power; if shoppers never see a price difference, a high-fee provider loses fewer transactions to a low-fee one. Mundt framed the goal in those terms: "Our aim is to achieve effective competition between the various providers of payment services. Cheaper providers attracting merchants with lower charges should be able to reap the benefits of these cost advantages when competing for customers. Our preliminary assessment is that PayPal's prohibition to charge customers impedes precisely this type of competition. Ultimately, this would also affect customers, as the costs for payment processing are included in the prices of the goods and services offered."

He was more direct still about cheaper rivals: "Other, cheaper providers would find it more difficult to gain an edge over PayPal. Ultimately, this could also lead to higher prices for consumers."

The preliminary assessment rests on two sets of prohibitions, German and European, applied in parallel.

Provision What it prohibits Cited on 23 January 2023 Cited on 11 November 2026
Section 1 GWB / Article 101(1) TFEU Anti-competitive agreements As a possible additional violation ("might also") Yes
Section 19 GWB / Article 102 TFEU Abuse of a dominant position Yes Yes
Section 20 GWB Abuse of relative or superior market power Yes Yes
Section 34 GWB Basis for disgorgement of economic benefits Not mentioned Under consideration

According to the November release, the prohibition on surcharging "constitutes a possible violation of the prohibition of anti-competitive agreements (Section 1 GWB, Article 101(1) TFEU) and the prohibition of abusive practices under competition law (Sections 19 and 20 GWB, Article 102 TFEU)." In 2023 the authority led with abuse of dominance and of relative or superior market power, adding that PayPal's conduct "might also" breach the cartel prohibition. It also tied the case to "various proceedings already conducted by competition authorities against other online platforms due to so-called most-favoured-nation clauses."

The Section 34 reference is new. "The Bundeskartellamt is also considering a disgorgement of economic benefits obtained as a result of the possible competition law infringement pursuant to Section 34 GWB," the release says. It gives no amount and no period.

The authority has used this kind of remedy recently in e-commerce. In February 2026, it banned Amazon from controlling third-party seller prices on amazon.de and ordered disgorgement of €58.8 million, a case brought under Section 19a GWB as well as Section 19 GWB and Article 102 TFEU. That decision followed a preliminary assessment issued on 2 June 2025, about eight months earlier. The PayPal release does not cite Section 19a.

From 2023 to 2026: what changed

Read side by side, the two releases show a case that has narrowed in its stated scope while widening in its addressees and its possible consequences.

23 January 2023 release 11 November 2026 release
Stage Proceeding initiated Preliminary assessment notified
Addressees PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l et Cie, S.C.A. PayPal Holdings, Inc.; PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l. et Cie. S.C.A.; PayPal Limited
Terms named "Rules about surcharging" and "Presentation of PayPal" in the user agreement applicable in Germany "Rules about surcharging"
Conduct described No lower prices when customers choose a cheaper method; no expressed preference for other methods, and no making them more convenient No extra charge for paying with PayPal; in force since 2018; enforced; termination right for breaches
Fees cited Standard rate of 2.49%-2.99% plus 34-39 cents per payment, from PayPal's price list "Above-average fees"; varies by method; negotiated by larger merchants
Rivals named None Mastercard and Visa cards, Klarna, Wero
Disgorgement Not mentioned Under consideration (Section 34 GWB)
Status Investigation opened Not a final decision; PayPal may comment

The 2023 release described two restrictions. Beyond surcharging, PayPal's "Presentation of PayPal" terms meant that sellers were "not allowed to express a preference for payment methods other than PayPal or, for example, make their use more convenient for customers." The 2023 description of the price restriction also covered discounts: merchants were "not allowed to offer their goods and services at lower prices if customers choose to use a payment method that is cheaper than PayPal." Mundt's 2023 statement referred to merchants being prevented from reflecting cost differences "by imposing surcharges or granting discounts."

The November 2026 release covers surcharges only and does not mention the presentation terms. It does not say whether that part of the investigation has been closed, set aside or simply left out of the announcement. PayPal's own account in late October still covered both: PPC Land reported on 29 October 2026 that PayPal's third-quarter filing described the German proceeding as concerning merchant terms that prohibit surcharging and require parity presentation of PayPal relative to other payment methods, and said PayPal was cooperating. The same filing disclosed a US Federal Trade Commission civil investigative demand, received in September 2026, concerning the advertising, marketing and management of fees and purchase protection.

By PPC Land's count, 1,388 days passed between the opening of the proceeding and the preliminary assessment.

Why the case matters for marketers and merchants

Payment fees rarely appear in conversations about customer acquisition, yet they sit in the same margin as advertising costs. Every order a campaign drives carries a processing fee, and for small baskets, as the 2023 rates show, a fixed per-payment charge can push the effective cost above 4% of the order value. Merchants have been able to see that difference by payment method. Under PayPal's rule, according to the Bundeskartellamt, they have not been allowed to show it to customers.

The checkout is also a source of advertising data. PayPal Ads has built its pitch on that position: in January 2026, Mark Grether, who leads the business, claimed in an interview that PayPal sees about 30% of global commerce, based on data from 30 million merchants and 400 million consumers. That is a commerce media model that depends on PayPal appearing at a large number of checkouts. The Bundeskartellamt's case is about fees and competition between payment services, not advertising. Still, any change that led shoppers to choose other payment methods would also reduce the transactions on which that data business draws.

Klarna, one of the rivals the authority names, runs a similar play. Its 2025 IPO filing showed advertising revenue of $180 million in 2024, up from $13 million in 2020, about 6% of total revenue - income that, much like a retail media network, depends on being present when shoppers buy.

Financing is part of the same contest. The Bundeskartellamt counts financing options among the features of online payment methods, and PayPal has been extending them: in July 2026, PayPal announced instalments at Amazon.de checkout for orders from €30 to €10,000 at an effective annual rate of 11.49%. Which payment options a shopper sees can also depend on the merchant's own systems. An Advocate General's opinion in October 2026 dealt with a retailer's algorithm that withheld invoice and instalment payment from some new customers while still letting them pay up front by credit card or PayPal.

New entrants are the group the authority says the rule hurts most. Wero, which banks offer and which the Bundeskartellamt describes as a new arrival, enters a market where a lower merchant fee cannot be turned into a visible saving for the shopper. Wero is not the only European alternative under discussion: in June 2026, the European Parliament's economic committee voted on holding caps and a 24-month rollout for the digital euro. If merchants gained the freedom to surcharge PayPal, would shoppers switch? The release does not try to answer that, and neither does any figure in it.

What the releases leave open

The November release does not give PayPal's market share, current fee levels, any estimate of the disgorgement sum or the period it would cover, a deadline for PayPal's response, or the status of the 2023 "Presentation of PayPal" terms. It contains no statement from PayPal.

What happens next

"PayPal now has the opportunity to comment on the Bundeskartellamt's preliminary assessment of the matter. This does not constitute a final decision," according to the authority. The release does not set out the next procedural steps or a timetable.

The authority's recent German cases show that a preliminary assessment can end in different places. In the Amazon case, about eight months separated the preliminary assessment from a prohibition decision with disgorgement. In August 2026, by contrast, the Bundeskartellamt accepted commitments from Apple on its App Tracking Transparency prompt and closed that proceeding with no fine and no finding of infringement, after Apple rejected the authority's preliminary assessment. Which route the PayPal case takes is not yet known.

Key facts

  • Authority: Bundeskartellamt (Federal Cartel Office, Germany); President Andreas Mundt
  • Source document: Press release "Bundeskartellamt: PayPal could be impeding competition between payment services", 11 November 2026, https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Meldung/EN/Pressemitteilungen/2026/11_11_26_Paypal_Abmahnung.html
  • German version: "Bundeskartellamt: PayPal könnte Wettbewerb zwischen Zahlungsdiensten behindern", 11 November 2026, https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Meldung/DE/Pressemitteilungen/2026/11_11_2026_Paypal.html
  • Earlier release: "Bundeskartellamt initiates proceeding against PayPal", 23 January 2023, https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Meldung/EN/Pressemitteilungen/2023/23_01_2023_PayPal.html
  • Addressees (2026): PayPal Holdings, Inc.; PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l. et Cie. S.C.A.; PayPal Limited
  • Addressee (2023): PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l et Cie, S.C.A.
  • Terms at issue: "Rules about surcharging" (2023 and 2026); "Presentation of PayPal" (named in 2023 only), in PayPal's user agreement applicable in Germany
  • Conduct: Prohibition on merchants charging customers extra for paying with PayPal, in PayPal's terms since 2018, enforced, with a right to terminate merchants who breach it
  • Stage: Preliminary assessment notified; PayPal may comment; not a final decision
  • Possible violations: Section 1 GWB and Article 101(1) TFEU; Sections 19 and 20 GWB and Article 102 TFEU
  • Possible remedy: Disgorgement of economic benefits under Section 34 GWB (under consideration; no amount given)
  • Related law: Article 62(4), Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (second payment services directive); Federal Court of Justice judgment of 25 March 2021, I ZR 203/19 (PayPal outside Article 62(4)); Bundeskartellamt statement on the payment services directive review, 2 August 2022, https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Publikation/EN/Stellungnahmen_Opinion/Stellungnahme_PSD2.html
  • PayPal standard rate cited in 2023: 2.49%-2.99% of the payment amount plus 34-39 cents per payment (Germany, per PayPal's price list at the time)
  • Other online payment methods named (2026): Mastercard and Visa cards, Klarna, Wero

Timeline

Summary

Who: The Bundeskartellamt, Germany's competition authority, led by President Andreas Mundt, and three PayPal companies: PayPal Holdings, Inc., PayPal (Europe) S.à.r.l. et Cie. S.C.A. and PayPal Limited. Online merchants in Germany, their customers, and rival payment services including Mastercard and Visa cards, Klarna and Wero are affected.

What: A preliminary assessment that PayPal's "Rules about surcharging", which since 2018 have barred merchants from charging customers extra for paying with PayPal, may breach Section 1 GWB and Article 101(1) TFEU and Sections 19 and 20 GWB and Article 102 TFEU. The authority is also considering disgorgement of economic benefits under Section 34 GWB.

When: The preliminary assessment was notified on 11 November 2026. The proceeding was initiated on 23 January 2023. No date for a final decision has been given.

Where: Germany, covering PayPal's terms for merchants in online retail. The case applies German and EU competition law in parallel.

Why: According to the Bundeskartellamt, PayPal charges merchants above-average fees and has a very high market share among online payment methods. Because merchants cannot pass those fees to PayPal users, they spread them across all prices, shoppers see no cost difference between payment methods, and cheaper or new providers cannot use lower fees to win customers. In the authority's view, that reduces competitive pressure on PayPal's merchant fees and could ultimately raise prices for consumers.