Germany's highest civil court has put a fabricated quote back on hold. On October 27, 2026, the VI. Civil Senate of the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH) in Karlsruhe suspended case VI ZR 64/24, a dispute over a Facebook meme that attributes a sentence about learning Turkish to a German politician who says she never said it, and referred six questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The questions go well beyond one meme. They ask whether a social network that ranks and recommends posts through an algorithm still counts as a neutral host, whether it can be made to judge by hand whether reworded copies of an unlawful post mean the same thing, and whether the hosting shield protects it from damages claims under the General Data Protection Regulation.

The court's press releases do not name the parties. German media, including the legal news service beck-aktuell and the public broadcaster ZDF, have identified the plaintiff as Renate Künast, the Green Party politician, and the defendant as Meta, the operator of Facebook. The case produced its first judgment in April 2022, and it was suspended once before, in February 2025, so the senate could wait for a different ruling from Luxembourg. That ruling arrived in December 2025. It did not settle the matter, and the BGH has now asked the questions itself.

In Short

Germany's top civil court has paused a lawsuit over a fake quote spread on Facebook and asked the EU's highest court six questions about how far a social network is responsible for what its users post. The answers will matter for every large platform in the EU, because they concern whether ranking and recommending posts by algorithm costs a platform its legal protection as a host, and whether it must check variants of an unlawful post itself instead of waiting for each link to be reported. Until Luxembourg rules, the German case stays frozen, and the question of whether Meta must pay the politician at least 10,000 euros stays open. A regional court in the same city reached its own answer on algorithmic control in a fake-ad case against Meta in September 2026, a ruling that is not final.

What the court decided on October 27

According to press release No. 204/2026, published in Karlsruhe on October 27, 2026, the VI. Civil Senate "über wechselseitige Revisionen verhandelt" - heard cross-appeals - on the same day. The press release frames the issue as the question of which claims people have against the operator of a social network when false statements of fact about them are spread on its platform. Quotations from the court in this article are translated from German by PPC Land.

"Nach ausführlicher Erörterung in der mündlichen Verhandlung hat der VI. Zivilsenat das Verfahren ausgesetzt und dem Gerichtshof der Europäischen Union zur Auslegung des Unionsrechts folgende Fragen zur Vorabentscheidung vorgelegt," the court wrote. After a detailed discussion at the oral hearing, the senate suspended the proceedings and referred the questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling on the interpretation of EU law.

The decision is a Beschluss, an order, dated October 27, 2026. The press release lists the two lower-court decisions under review and points to an earlier press release, No. 199/2026 of October 22, 2026, for the facts and the procedural history. It gives no Court of Justice case number and does not set out the senate's reasoning.

A meme, a sentence and nine URLs

The facts come from the court's October 22 press release, which announced the hearing for 9:30 on October 27. According to that release, the plaintiff is a politician and a member of the German Bundestag. The so-called original meme shows her photograph, her first and last name, the name of her party and the sentence "Integration fängt damit an, dass sie als Deutscher mal türkisch lernen" - roughly, integration starts with Germans learning some Turkish. She says she never said it.

The meme then did what memes do. According to the court, it spread across Facebook through fresh uploads and the platform's share function, under different URLs and in altered versions. Some versions carry captions, and in the examples the court gave, those captions mostly insult her. Finding similar memes can be automated, the court noted. Deciding whether a captioned version means the same thing as the original cannot be done in a purely automated process.

Künast reported the original meme and eight further memes with the same meaning to Meta, supplying the URL for each. Meta removed them gradually, according to the court, and those nine posts are no longer part of the lawsuit. What remains is the broader demand: an order requiring Meta to stop making available all identical or equivalent memes found on Facebook up to the end of the proceedings, without Künast having to give the company the URLs, and non-material damages of at least 10,000 euros.

Meta's position, as the court summarised it, is that as a neutral hosting provider it is only obliged to remove posts that have been specifically identified to it, and that it has no duty to search the platform for further infringing posts. ZDF reported in February 2025 that Meta's lawyers warned of overblocking, the removal of lawful content along with unlawful content. The broadcaster also reported that Künast has fought the false quote since 2015, that she had previously won cases against individual users, and that the organisation HateAid supports her in the proceedings. At the October 2026 hearing, according to beck-aktuell, Künast told the senate that a private individual cannot employ some 30 people to search the world for equivalent posts, and that the work is the company's job.

From Frankfurt to Karlsruhe to Luxembourg

Court Date File number Outcome, according to the BGH
Landgericht Frankfurt am Main (Regional Court) April 8, 2022 2-03 O 188/21 Granted the claim
Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main (Higher Regional Court) January 25, 2024 16 U 65/22 On Meta's appeal, dismissed the damages claim and upheld the injunction; allowed a further appeal
Bundesgerichtshof, VI. Civil Senate February 18, 2025 VI ZR 64/24 Heard the cross-appeals, then suspended the case pending the Court of Justice's ruling in C-492/23
Court of Justice of the European Union December 2, 2025 C-492/23 (Russmedia Digital) Ruled in the Romanian case the BGH had waited for
Bundesgerichtshof, VI. Civil Senate October 27, 2026 VI ZR 64/24 Heard the cross-appeals again, suspended the case and referred six questions to the Court of Justice

The period from the Frankfurt Regional Court's judgment to the referral is four years, six months and 19 days, a PPC Land calculation. The press releases do not state how much the Regional Court awarded, or why the Higher Regional Court rejected the damages claim.

How the case reached Luxembourg

According to the BGH's two press releases, the case moved through nine stages:

  1. Künast reported the original meme and eight equivalent memes to Meta, with a URL for each. Meta removed them gradually.
  2. She sued Meta in Frankfurt for an injunction covering all identical and equivalent memes on Facebook, without the obligation to supply URLs, and for non-material damages of at least 10,000 euros. The Regional Court granted the claim on April 8, 2022.
  3. Meta appealed. On January 25, 2024, the Higher Regional Court dismissed the damages claim, confirmed the injunction and allowed a further appeal on points of law (Revision).
  4. Meta's appeal to the BGH seeks dismissal of the entire claim. Künast filed a cross-appeal, which the court calls an Anschlussrevision, seeking to restore the Regional Court's judgment, including the damages.
  5. The BGH heard the case on February 18, 2025, and suspended it pending the Court of Justice's decision in C-492/23, a reference from a Romanian court.
  6. The Court of Justice decided C-492/23 by judgment of December 2, 2025.
  7. The BGH resumed the case and announced a new hearing on October 22, 2026. According to that announcement, the senate would consider whether the claims could rest on Articles 17 and 82 GDPR and on Articles 6(4) and 8 of the Digital Services Act.
  8. On October 27, 2026, after the hearing, the senate suspended the proceedings again and referred six questions to the Court of Justice.
  9. Once the Court of Justice answers, the BGH will decide the cross-appeals in light of those answers.

From the first suspension to the second hearing took one year, eight months and nine days, according to PPC Land's count.

The six questions, in the court's words

Each of the first three questions describes the same kind of service, a platform for a social network that serves the exchange of opinions and information among its users, "und sich darauf beschränkt, nutzergenerierte Informationen zu speichern und anderen Nutzern zugänglich zu machen, ohne zuvor deren Inhalt zur Kenntnis genommen oder eine inhaltlich-redaktionelle Kontrolle durchgeführt zu haben" - and which confines itself to storing user-generated information and making it accessible to other users, without first having taken note of its content or carried out any editorial control of it. That description is the senate's starting point: a network whose operator, on this account, never sees what is posted before it goes live.

No. EU law at issue Issue in one line
1 Article 4(7) GDPR Is such an operator fully a controller of the personal data in user posts?
2 Articles 12 to 15, Directive 2000/31/EC (E-Commerce Directive) Can it rely on the hosting privileges, and does algorithmic curation rule out hosting status?
3 Articles 3(g)(iii), 3(i) and 6, Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA) When is such a platform a hosting service under the DSA, and does algorithmic curation rule it out?
4 Article 15, E-Commerce Directive Does the ban on general monitoring preclude a duty to assess equivalent content manually?
5 Article 8, DSA The same question under the DSA
6 Article 14(1), E-Commerce Directive; Article 6(1), DSA; Article 82 GDPR Does the hosting privilege apply to GDPR damages claims?

Question 1: who is the controller

The first question asks whether such an operator is "uneingeschränkt datenschutzrechtlich verantwortlich (Art. 4 Nr. 7 DSGVO)" - fully responsible under data protection law as a controller within the meaning of Article 4(7) GDPR. The word uneingeschränkt, without restriction, matters. The senate is not only asking whether a network operator is a controller of personal data in posts it has never seen, but whether that responsibility is complete.

Questions 2 and 3: does the algorithm end the hosting shield

The second question asks whether the operator benefits from the liability privileges in Articles 12 to 15 of the E-Commerce Directive. It then asks whether hosting status is excluded where the operator, "über eine bloße Kategorisierung und Indexierung der Informationen im Hinblick auf ihre bessere Zugänglichkeit hinaus" - beyond merely categorising and indexing the information to make it easier to find - "mittels eines Algorithmus kuratiert, insbesondere gezielt auswählt, ordnet, dem Nutzer präsentiert oder empfiehlt, auch wenn er von diesen Informationen aufgrund der Automatisierung ihrer Verarbeitung keine Kenntnis erlangt". In English: curates it by means of an algorithm, in particular by specifically selecting, ordering, presenting it to the user or recommending it, even if, because the processing is automated, it gains no knowledge of that information.

The third question asks the same about the DSA: under what conditions such a platform falls within the concept of a hosting service under Article 3(g)(iii), (i) and Article 6 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, and whether algorithmic curation of that kind stands in the way.

The final clause of both questions is the crux. A feed algorithm chooses what millions of people see, but no person at the company reads most of the posts it promotes. The senate wants to know which of those facts decides the legal category.

Questions 4 and 5: manual review of equivalent content

The fourth question asks whether Article 15 of the E-Commerce Directive precludes an obligation on the operator to check content "der einem für rechtswidrig erklärten Inhalt möglicherweise sinngleich ist" - which may be equivalent in meaning to content declared unlawful - not only by automated techniques for slightly different wording and similarly minor deviations without considering context, "sondern eigenständig und manuell inhaltlich zu bewerten, insbesondere den Sinngehalt des potentiell sinngleichen Inhalts selbst zu bestimmen". That is: to assess the content independently and manually, and in particular to determine for itself the meaning of the potentially equivalent post. The fifth question repeats the inquiry under Article 8 of the DSA.

These two questions connect directly to the facts. The court's own description of the case says that finding look-alike memes can be automated but judging the meaning of captioned variants cannot. An injunction covering equivalent memes therefore implies human review.

Question 6: GDPR damages and the hosting privilege

The sixth question asks: "Ist das Haftungsprivileg nach Art. 14 Abs. 1 der E-Commerce-Richtlinie und/oder Art. 6 Abs. 1 DSA auf den Anspruch aus Art. 82 DSGVO anwendbar?" Does the liability privilege under Article 14(1) of the E-Commerce Directive and/or Article 6(1) of the DSA apply to the claim under Article 82 GDPR? Article 82 is the GDPR's compensation provision, and Künast's cross-appeal seeks at least 10,000 euros.

Why the questions come in pairs

The duplication between the E-Commerce Directive and the DSA reflects a change in the law while the case was under way. Article 89 of the DSA deleted Articles 12 to 15 of the E-Commerce Directive, the safe harbours for conduits, caches and hosts and the ban on general monitoring, and the DSA's own versions in Articles 4 to 8 have applied since February 17, 2024. The Higher Regional Court ruled on January 25, 2024, 23 days before that date, a PPC Land calculation. Part of the conduct at issue falls under the old regime, while an injunction looking forward would operate under the new one.

Provision What it covers (summary)
Article 4(7) GDPR Defines the controller as the person or body that, alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of processing personal data
Article 17 GDPR The right to erasure
Article 82 GDPR The right to compensation for material or non-material damage caused by an infringement of the regulation
Articles 12 to 15, Directive 2000/31/EC Liability exemptions for mere conduit, caching and hosting, and the ban on imposing general monitoring obligations; deleted by Article 89 DSA
Article 14(1), Directive 2000/31/EC The hosting exemption: no liability without knowledge, provided the host acts expeditiously once it learns of illegal content
Article 3(g)(iii) and 3(i), Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 Definitions of a hosting service and of an online platform
Article 6(1), DSA The DSA's hosting exemption, replacing Article 14 of the directive, with a separate awareness standard for damages claims
Article 6(4), DSA Preserves the power of courts and authorities to order a provider to end or prevent an infringement
Article 8, DSA No general monitoring or active fact-finding obligations, replacing Article 15 of the directive

Facebook is designated as a very large online platform under the DSA, the tier for services with at least 45 million average monthly active users in the EU. That status brings risk-assessment and audit duties, but it does not change the hosting exemption in Article 6, which applies to large and small hosts alike.

What Luxembourg has already said

The Court of Justice has addressed parts of this ground before, which is one reason the referral is notable.

In Glawischnig-Piesczek v Facebook Ireland (C-18/18), decided on October 3, 2019, and also brought by a Green politician, the Court held that the ban on general monitoring does not stop a national court ordering a host to remove content identical or equivalent to content already declared unlawful. The condition was that the equivalent content must remain essentially unchanged, and the host must not be required to carry out an independent assessment; automated search tools had to suffice. The wording of the BGH's fourth and fifth questions, with its contrast between automated checks for minor deviations and independent, manual assessment of meaning, follows that line closely and asks what happens when automation is not enough.

The case the BGH waited for in 2025, Russmedia Digital and Inform Media Press (C-492/23), concerned a false advertisement on the Romanian classifieds site publi24.ro offering sexual services, posted on August 1, 2018 with a woman's photographs and phone number. According to the Court of Justice's press release No 150/25 of December 2, 2025, the operator of an online marketplace is a controller, within the meaning of the GDPR, of the personal data contained in ads published on its marketplace. Before publication, it must identify ads containing sensitive data, check whether the advertiser is the person concerned or has that person's explicit consent, and refuse publication otherwise. It must also try to prevent such ads from being copied to other websites, and it cannot escape its GDPR obligations by relying on the hosting exemption in the E-Commerce Directive. A German referral on joint controller notices lodged in April 2026 already cited the judgment.

Russmedia concerned a classifieds marketplace, sensitive data and the old directive. Künast's case concerns a social network, a political meme and both regimes. According to beck-aktuell, the senate said at the October 2026 hearing that it still had doubts whether the Court of Justice's case law, including the marketplace ruling, could be transferred to this case.

Two judgments from 2026 bear on the algorithm questions. In joined cases C-188/24 and C-190/24 (WebGroup Czech Republic and Coyote System), decided on June 16, 2026, the Court of Justice held that algorithmic control over distribution removes hosting protection. A month later, on July 16, 2026, it ruled in C-421/24 that Google could not automatically claim the hosting exemption for YouTube videos from a channel it had reviewed before a revenue-sharing deal, in a case that began with a 750,000-euro fine from Italy's communications regulator. The BGH's second and third questions nonetheless ask, in terms, whether algorithmic curation without knowledge of the content defeats hosting status for a social network. The press release does not say why the senate considers those judgments insufficient.

A Frankfurt chamber has already answered one question

In the same city where Künast's case began, another chamber of the Regional Court reached its own conclusion this autumn. On September 16, 2026, the Frankfurt Regional Court ruled in case 2-06 O 234/25 that Meta could not rely on the Article 6 DSA hosting defence against fake ads using the identity of the finance education company Finanzfluss and its co-founder, because the ad auction and the feed algorithms amount to control. The chamber treated Article 14 of the E-Commerce Directive as the predecessor of Article 6, relied on the WebGroup and Coyote judgment, and set fines of up to 250,000 euros per future breach. It also found that deletion periods of 14 and 20 days for clear violations were not expeditious. That judgment is not final, and an appeal lies to the Higher Regional Court in Frankfurt.

The Finanzfluss case concerned paid advertising, where Meta runs an auction. Künast's case concerns organic posts shared by users. Whether the reasoning that worked for ads also holds for a social network's organic feed is, in substance, what questions 2 and 3 now put to Luxembourg.

Why this matters for advertisers and platforms

The algorithm that ranks a user's feed is the same infrastructure into which advertising is sold. If the Court of Justice finds that selecting, ordering and recommending user-generated content by algorithm is incompatible with hosting status, the notice-based model that underpins how large platforms handle complaints would no longer protect them for the content their feeds promote. The Finanzfluss ruling showed what that looks like in practice in one chamber's reading: about 256 violations in a single month and fines of up to 250,000 euros per future breach.

The equivalent-content questions matter to any brand or person dealing with impersonation. Under the current approach, Künast had to find and report each URL herself. An obligation on Meta to locate meaning-equivalent variants on its own would shift that work to the platform, and with it the cost and the risk of error. Meta's warning of overblocking points at the other side of that shift. PPC Land has documented how notice systems are already used to remove material that is merely unwelcome: German businesses have used DSA notice forms to delete critical reviews, and the Düsseldorf Regional Court in January 2025 treated Google as a liable disruptive party, or Störer, over a trademark-infringing ad.

The data protection questions carry their own exposure. If a social network is fully a controller of personal data in every user post and the hosting privilege does not cover Article 82 claims, each post naming a person becomes a potential damages claim against the platform rather than only against the user. German courts have already ordered Meta to pay GDPR damages in tracking cases, including 5,000 euros awarded by the Leipzig Regional Court in July 2025. The same VI. Civil Senate has also set limits: in January 2025 it dismissed a 500-euro GDPR claim because a violation alone did not establish damage.

Regulators are also looking at the same machinery from a different angle. In July 2026 the European Commission issued a preliminary finding that Meta breached the DSA through addictive design features of Facebook and Instagram, including recommender systems. The BGH referral asks a private-law version of a related question: whether recommending content changes what a platform is.

What the press release does not say

The press release sets out the questions but none of the senate's reasons. It does not name the parties, give a Court of Justice case number, state whether the senate asked for an expedited procedure, or explain why the Higher Regional Court rejected the damages claim and how much the Regional Court had awarded. No date for a ruling from Luxembourg has been set.

Key facts

  • Court: Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice), VI. Zivilsenat (VI. Civil Senate), Karlsruhe
  • Decision: Order (Beschluss) of October 27, 2026, case VI ZR 64/24: proceedings suspended, six questions referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union for a preliminary ruling
  • Source document: Press release No. 204/2026, "Bundesgerichtshof legt Gerichtshof der Europäischen Union Fragen zur Haftung des Betreibers eines sozialen Netzwerks für von seinen Nutzern eingestellte rechtswidrige Inhalte vor", published October 27, 2026
  • Source URL: https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2026/2026204.html
  • Hearing announcement: Press release No. 199/2026, October 22, 2026 (hearing October 27, 2026, 9:30)
  • Lower courts: Landgericht Frankfurt am Main, April 8, 2022, 2-03 O 188/21; Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main, January 25, 2024, 16 U 65/22
  • Earlier suspension: after the hearing of February 18, 2025, pending CJEU case C-492/23 (judgment December 2, 2025)
  • Parties: not named by the court; identified in German media as Renate Künast and Meta, operator of Facebook
  • Claims: injunction covering all identical and meaning-equivalent memes without supplying URLs; non-material damages of at least 10,000 euros
  • EU law referred: Article 4(7) and Article 82 GDPR; Articles 12 to 15 and Article 14(1) of Directive 2000/31/EC; Articles 3(g)(iii), 3(i), 6, 6(1) and 8 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065
  • CJEU case number: not given in the press release

Timeline

Summary

Who: The VI. Civil Senate of Germany's Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), in a dispute that German media identify as Green Party politician Renate Künast against Meta, the operator of Facebook. The questions go to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

What: The court suspended the case and referred six questions on whether a social network operator that does not review posts is fully a GDPR controller, whether algorithmic curation rules out the hosting privileges under the E-Commerce Directive and the DSA, whether the ban on general monitoring precludes a duty to assess meaning-equivalent content manually, and whether the hosting privilege applies to GDPR damages claims. The underlying claim concerns a meme falsely attributing a sentence about learning Turkish to the politician, an injunction covering equivalent memes, and at least 10,000 euros in damages.

When: The order is dated October 27, 2026, the day of the oral hearing, and was announced in press release No. 204/2026. The Frankfurt Regional Court ruled on April 8, 2022, the Higher Regional Court on January 25, 2024, and the BGH first suspended the case on February 18, 2025.

Where: Karlsruhe, at the Bundesgerichtshof; the case began in Frankfurt am Main and now moves to the Court of Justice in Luxembourg, whose answers will bind courts across the EU.

Why: The referral will decide how far large platforms answer for what their users post. If ranking and recommending posts by algorithm costs a network its status as a host, and if courts can require platforms to judge reworded copies of unlawful content themselves, the notice-and-removal model that platforms, advertisers and brands rely on would change, as would platforms' exposure to GDPR damages for content they never reviewed.