Amazon accounts for 24% of retailer searches in US on-site search data but is named in only 11% of answers produced by AI assistants in US shopping conversations, according to a 30-page holiday report that advertising technology company Verve released today. The report arrives eight days before Black Friday on November 27; its figures cover September 1 to November 16, 2026.
In Short
Verve compared how often US shoppers search for big retailers with how often AI assistants name those retailers in their answers, and Amazon came out with the widest gap: 24% of retailer searches against 11% of AI answers. Target went the other way, with 8% of AI answers on a 5% search share, while Walmart sat at 9% against 12%. The report measures mentions, not recommendations or sales, and it does not explain the gap, so it shows where AI assistants put retailer names this season rather than why.
The retailer gap
The comparison sits on a single slide in the report's AI conversations section, under the headline "Amazon Is the Most Frequently Named Retailer in AI Shopping Answers." That headline is accurate. Amazon is still the retailer AI assistants name most often in Verve's data, ahead of Walmart and Target. What stands out is the distance between that position and the company's weight in search.
According to Verve, the chart sets the percentage of AI answers naming each retailer against that retailer's share of retailer searches, both measured between September 1 and November 16, 2026. Eight retailers appear.
| Retailer | % of AI answers naming the retailer | Share of retailer searches | Ratio of AI answer share to search share (PPC Land calculation) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon | 11% | 24% | 0.46 |
| Walmart | 9% | 12% | 0.75 |
| Target | 8% | 5% | 1.60 |
| Best Buy | 3% | 2% | 1.50 |
| eBay | 3% | 2% | 1.50 |
| Etsy | 2% | 0% | n/a |
| Gap | 2% | 1% | 2.00 |
| Staples / Office Depot | 1% | 1% | 1.00 |
Source: Verve, US AI conversation data and on-site search data, 09/01/2026 - 11/16/2026. The last column is PPC Land's arithmetic on the rounded figures Verve published.
Only Amazon and Walmart appear in AI answers less often than their search share would imply. Every other retailer on the list matches or exceeds it. Etsy, which registers 0% of retailer searches after rounding, is named in 2% of AI answers, and Target, a distant third among the eight in search, nearly draws level with Walmart once the assistant starts talking.
Verve's footnote to the slide carries a caveat in six words: "a mention is not a recommendation." An answer that says an item is cheaper elsewhere than on Amazon still counts as a mention of Amazon. So does an answer that names Amazon only to steer a shopper away from it.
Two bases, one comparison
The two columns are not built on the same denominator. The search figure is a share of searches that name a retailer, so it describes how attention divides among retailers once a shopper has a store in mind. The AI figure is a percentage of AI answers, and the report does not say what share of those answers name any retailer at all. If a large portion of holiday answers name no store, every retailer's AI percentage is pushed down by the same base effect.
The eight AI figures add up to 39%, against 47% for the eight search figures (PPC Land calculations; an answer can name more than one retailer, so the AI total is not a share of answers that name any store). That does not dissolve Amazon's gap. Walmart, with half Amazon's search share, sits only two points behind it in AI answers, and Target overtakes its own search share outright. But it does mean that a simple ratio between the two columns should be read as a rough measure of position, not a precise discount.
Verve presents the gap as an early sign that AI assistants are changing which retailers shoppers hear about this holiday season. The report contains no earlier period for AI answers by retailer, so it does not show a change over time. It shows a difference between two channels in the same ten-and-a-half-week window.
There is also a second Amazon search figure in the report. On a separate slide, Amazon accounts for 18.5% of Black Friday and Cyber Monday searches that name a retailer, followed by Costco at 9.7% and Best Buy at 7.9%. That chart is limited to Black Friday and Cyber Monday queries, and its footnote restricts it to "retailers whose searches do not come mainly from one site." Walmart does not appear on it. Costco, second in that ranking, does not appear among the eight retailers in the AI comparison. The report does not explain either omission.
How the report was built
The report, titled "Holiday Shopping Warms Up as Black Friday Searches Surge" and marked "Insights · US" and "November 2026" on its cover, draws on two data sets. According to the source notes on its 30 pages, the method works as follows:
- On-site search data (US). Searches typed into the search boxes of websites, labeled "on site search data (US)" and described as a "same-site panel," which indicates the same set of sites is compared across periods. The number of sites and searches is not given.
- US AI conversation data. Prompts written to AI assistants and the answers returned, labeled "US AI conversation data." The report does not name the assistants or state how many prompts or users the data covers.
- Periods. Most charts cover September 1 to November 16, 2026. Momentum charts compare the "latest 14 days" (November 3 to November 16, 2026) with September 2026 (September 1 to 30). The monthly AI chart runs from January 1 to November 16, 2026.
- Momentum index. A topic's share of holiday shopping searches in the latest 14 days divided by its share in September. According to the report, 1.00x means "keeping pace" or "no change."
- Personas. Four shopper types defined by keywords. According to Verve, "Personas are keyword-defined and can overlap; shares are of shoppers with any holiday-shopping search since 09/01/2026." Persona indexes divide a persona's share by the share among all holiday shoppers.
The report does not name the products behind either data set. Verve bought Captify, a London-based search intelligence company, in September 2025 for a total of 25.6 million euros, and at the time described Captify as analyzing the search behavior of up to one billion daily searches. On March 10, 2026, Verve announced that it had begun selling advertisers signals from AI chat activity, drawn from opted-in users who consent to share pseudonymized chat activity through apps they already use, and aggregated before use. Captify sells ad targeting built on search intent, which Verve said works without third-party cookies, a search-driven form of contextual advertising. Neither the March announcement nor the holiday report names the AI platforms from which the conversations are drawn.
Black Friday searches at 11.8 times September
The report's opening section tracks how fast event-driven searches are rising. Combined Black Friday and Cyber Monday searches reached 11.82 times their September share of US search activity over November 3 to 16, and more than tripled compared with the preceding two weeks, according to Verve.
| Search topic | Share of search, Nov 3-16 vs September 2026 |
|---|---|
| Cyber Monday | 13.89x |
| Black Friday | 12.28x |
| Black Friday / Cyber Monday | 11.82x |
| Gift cards | 2.74x |
| Retailer shopping | 1.78x |
| Experiences | 1.76x |
| Gift-category shopping | 1.44x |
| Gift searches | 1.41x |
| All holiday shopping | 1.40x |
| Holiday deals & sale events | 1.35x |
| Hero products | 1.24x |
Source: Verve, on-site search data (US), same-site panel.
Cyber Monday's rise outpaced Black Friday's. Broader holiday shopping, at 1.40x, grew far more slowly, which Verve reads as acceleration concentrated around the two sale events rather than spread across the season.
AI conversations moved in the same direction, though less sharply. Black Friday prompts in the US AI data reached 4.30 times their September level in November, against 11.31 times for Black Friday searches over the same comparison, according to the report. The 11.31x figure is a November-versus-September comparison and differs from the 12.28x figure above, which uses the latest 14 days.
The monthly AI series also complicates the idea of a holiday surge in chat. Holiday-shopping prompts per 10,000 US AI prompts stood at 21.6 in January 2026, fell to 16.5 in April, and climbed to 22.0 in November through the 16th. November is about 20% above September's 18.4 but less than 2% above January (PPC Land calculations). According to Verve, "Holiday gift planning also appears throughout the year in AI conversations."
| Month (2026) | Holiday-shopping prompts per 10,000 US AI prompts |
|---|---|
| January | 21.6 |
| February | 20.8 |
| March | 18.7 |
| April | 16.5 |
| May | 17.5 |
| June | 19.6 |
| July | 18.5 |
| August | 18.2 |
| September | 18.4 |
| October | 18.3 |
| November (to Nov 16) | 22.0 |
Source: Verve, US AI conversation data, 01/01/2026 - 11/16/2026.
What shoppers ask AI assistants
Gift ideas dominate. Of US holiday-shopping AI prompts between September 1 and November 16, 42.2% asked for gift ideas, 31.5% hunted for deals or asked whether a price was good, and 27.8% concerned a budget or spending plan, according to Verve. A prompt can carry several requests, so the categories overlap.
| Request type | % of US holiday-shopping AI prompts |
|---|---|
| Gift ideas | 42.2% |
| Deal hunting & "is this a good price" | 31.5% |
| Budget & spending plan | 27.8% |
| Compare & choose | 20.2% |
| Store logistics & policies | 9.7% |
| Quality & longevity | 8.7% |
| Experiences | 6.5% |
| Timing: buy now or wait | 0.7% |
| Dupes & alternatives | 0.6% |
| Tariffs & rising prices | 0.1% |
Source: Verve, US AI conversation data, 09/01/2026 - 11/16/2026.
The contrast with search is in the detail. A median AI gift prompt runs to 24 words; a median gift search, nine. Of AI gift prompts, 7.2% state a budget, compared with 0.49% of gift searches. The median budget stated to an AI assistant was $50, against $57 in gift searches that named a price, according to the report.
Recipients show the same pattern. Depending on the recipient group, between 4% and 14% of AI gift prompts name it, while no group appears in more than 1% of gift searches.
| Recipient named | % of AI gift prompts | % of gift searches |
|---|---|---|
| Him / men | 14% | 1% |
| Her / women | 14% | 1% |
| Friends & siblings | 9% | 1% |
| Parents, in-laws & family | 8% | 1% |
| Kids | 7% | 1% |
| Mom | 6% | 0% |
| Dad | 5% | 0% |
| Coworkers, teachers & boss | 4% | 0% |
Source: Verve, US AI conversation data and on-site search data, 09/01/2026 - 11/16/2026.
That level of detail is what Verve sells to advertisers as conversational intent signals. A prompt that names a recipient, a budget and a category carries more purchase intent signal than a nine-word search.
When an AI gift answer named no brand in the prompt, Xbox was the product most often suggested, in 1.4% of unbranded gift answers, followed by iPad and LEGO at 0.7% each, AirPods at 0.5%, Pokémon cards at 0.4%, PlayStation 5 and Apple Watch at 0.3%, and Squishmallows at 0.2%. In search, by contrast, Xbox's share of holiday shopping fell to 0.91x its September level and PlayStation 5's to 0.82x.
Retailers in search: Amazon leads, others gain faster
Amazon's lead in search is not matched by momentum. Its share of holiday shopping searches rose only 1.09x between September and the latest 14 days, the smallest increase among the retailers tracked, according to Verve. Searches naming Kay, Zales, Pandora and Kendra Scott, counted together, gained 2.74x.
| Retailer | Momentum, Nov 3-16 vs September |
|---|---|
| Kay / Zales / Pandora / Kendra Scott | 2.74x |
| Best Buy | 1.99x |
| Sam's Club | 1.95x |
| Costco | 1.63x |
| Home Depot | 1.54x |
| Target | 1.22x |
| Nike | 1.11x |
| Amazon | 1.09x |
Source: Verve, on-site search data (US), share of holiday-shopping searches naming the retailer with a shopping word.
The report also splits retailer searches by what shoppers attach to the name. Best Buy is the most deal-led: 89% of its shopping searches include a deal word. Amazon is the most research-led, with 27% containing a compare, best-of or review word, while 70% of its shopping searches include a deal word.
| Retailer | % of shopping searches with a deal word | % with a compare, best-of or review word |
|---|---|---|
| Best Buy | 89% | 4% |
| Sam's Club | 70% | 12% |
| Amazon | 70% | 27% |
| Home Depot | 64% | 12% |
| Target | 60% | 17% |
| GameStop | 48% | not listed |
| Costco | not listed | 16% |
Source: Verve, on-site search data (US), 09/01/2026 - 11/16/2026, retailers named in at least 1% of retailer shopping searches.
The research-led profile matters for the AI comparison. Shoppers who search "Amazon" plus "best" or "review" are doing the same kind of comparison work that AI assistants now absorb. If that work migrates to chat and the assistant names Amazon less often than the search box does, the retailer loses a slice of visibility at the point of consideration. The report does not test that sequence. It only shows the two snapshots side by side.
Gifts, recipients and price points
Beyond retailers, the report tracks what shoppers search for. Among gift searches naming a product category, books, e-readers and media lead at 1.0%, followed by video games and consoles at 0.9% and beauty, skincare and fragrance at 0.6%. Beauty has gained the most ground since September, at 1.62x, ahead of laptops and computers at 1.41x and clothing and outerwear at 1.32x. Video games and consoles (0.73x), shoes, boots and slippers (0.71x) and books (0.84x) lost share.
Teens and tweens are the fastest-rising gift recipient in search, at 6.15 times their September share, followed by parents, in-laws and family (4.32x), her or women (3.62x), partners (3.39x) and friends and siblings (2.89x). Searches for gifts for him or men fell to 0.54x and for mom to 0.78x.
Among gift searches that state a price, such as "gifts under $50," the median is $57, according to Verve. Some 48% fall between $51 and $100, 24% between $26 and $50, 22% at $25 or less, 1% between $101 and $250, and 4% above $250.
Products tell a narrower story. Nintendo Switch 2 (1.09x) and LEGO (1.07x) slightly outpaced the broader holiday trend, while Barbie (0.87x) joined PlayStation 5 and Xbox in falling behind. Verve notes that although GTA VI released in November, earlier interest was driven by titles including Star Wars: Galactic Racer and Call of Duty: MW4.
Experiences account for 1.8% of holiday shopping searches, excluding gift cards. Cruise-related searches gained the most, at 2.92 times their September share. Gift cards rose 1.96x on that measure, which differs from the 2.74x share-of-search figure in the opening section because the two charts use different bases. Spa, massage and wellness rose 1.21x and subscriptions and memberships 1.13x, while flights, hotels and getaways (0.93x) and adventure and activities (0.62x) lost share.
Four shopper personas
Verve sorts holiday searchers into four overlapping groups. The quality-focused group is by far the largest.
| Persona | Share of holiday shoppers | Definition (Verve) | Strongest leans (index vs all holiday shoppers) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality Seeker | 24% | "Searches for reviews, quality and longevity at least as often as for deals" | Aritzia 2.41x, Bass Pro / Cabela's 2.02x, TVs & home theater 2.66x, video games & consoles 2.62x |
| Deal Hunter | 3% | "Searched deals on two or more days, or tracked prices and codes" | Solo Stove / Blackstone / Traeger 8.59x, Garmin 6.29x, pet gifts & supplies 4.11x |
| Experience Gifter | 2% | "Searched for experiences as gifts: trips, tickets, spa, classes" | 72% searched trips, flights or hotels; gifts for coworkers, teachers & boss 3.74x |
| Early Bird Planner | 1% | "Started holiday-sale searching before November, or searched for early Black Friday deals" | Kindle 3.63x, Oura & smart rings 3.24x, pets & pet lovers 3.05x |
Source: Verve, on-site search data (US), 09/01/2026 - 11/16/2026.
That a quarter of holiday shoppers search for reviews at least as often as for deals fits the topic data. Quality and reviews account for 32.2% of holiday shopping searches, compare and best-of searches 15.9%, deals and discounts 6.0% and price and budget 3.3%. The fastest-gaining themes since September are "early / already started" (1.82x), in-store and store hours (1.50x) and dupes and alternatives (1.40x). Tariffs and price increases fell to 0.49x.
Why the AI gap matters for retail marketers
When a shopper asks an AI assistant for gift ideas, the retailers named in the answer form a shortlist before any store is visited. For brands and agencies tracking AI visibility, the measure of how often a brand surfaces in assistant answers, Verve's data adds an observed-conversation view to a field mostly built on scripted prompts.
The numbers do not line up neatly with other studies. Semrush, using tracked prompts rather than real conversations, found Gemini mentioned Amazon in 40.5% of holiday answers, AI Mode in 33.1% and ChatGPT in 17.4%, while Gemini cited amazon.com in none of its answers in a study published November 9. Verve's 11% is lower than any of those platform rates. The two studies measure different things, scripted prompts in one case and observed conversations in the other, and neither publishes enough detail to reconcile them.
Amazon's own choices form part of the backdrop. In August 2025 the company added AI crawlers from Meta, Google, Huawei and Mistral to its robots.txt block list, and the same file blocks Google-Extended, the control token Google offers for Gemini, as the Semrush study noted. In November 2025 it demanded that Perplexity stop its Comet browser from buying on Amazon, and on September 20, 2026 it cut Meta's Muse agent off from shopping on its site. Meanwhile it has built its own assistant, merging Rufus and Alexa+ into Alexa for Shopping on May 13, 2026. Verve's report does not link the AI answer gap to any of these decisions, and its data cannot establish a cause.
The commercial stakes are large on both sides. Amazon's advertising revenue grew 11% to $19.64 billion in the third quarter of 2026, much of it sold against shoppers searching inside Amazon's own store. Adobe forecasts that US consumers will spend $275.1 billion online between November 1 and December 31, with AI-referred retail traffic up 130%. Amazon's Black Friday Week runs from November 19 to November 30, meaning Verve's report landed on the first day of the retailer's main holiday event.
Search still carries the bulk of shopping intent. A May 2026 survey of 1,295 US consumers found that 56.68% start product discovery on Google and 28.96% on Amazon, while ChatGPT sat third at 7.26%. Measure Protocol found in October 2025 that 21.6% of ChatGPT interactions showed some commercial intent. Shoppers also hold back from letting software buy for them: 76% are not interested in AI agents making purchases on their behalf, according to Salesforce. In the UK, interest in the event itself has been falling; Black Friday searches dropped 36% between 2019 and 2025, according to Marketing Signals.
What Verve's data adds is the observation that once a shopper does turn to an LLM for holiday help, the retailers named are not a mirror of the search box. Relative to search, the assistants in Verve's data surface Target and smaller merchants more readily, and Amazon less so. Whether that changes where people buy is a separate question the report does not attempt.
What the report does not say
The report names no AI platforms and gives no sample size for either data set: no count of sites, searches, prompts, answers or users. It does not say how retailer mentions in AI answers were detected, whether answers to non-shopping prompts are included in the base, or what share of AI answers name any retailer. There is no prior-year comparison for any AI figure, and no sales, click or conversion data. The four personas together cover at most 30% of holiday shoppers (PPC Land calculation, before overlap), and the report does not describe the rest.
Key facts
- Publisher: Verve (advertising technology company)
- Report title: "Holiday Shopping Warms Up as Black Friday Searches Surge" (cover label "Insights · US"; file title "Holiday Shopping Build Up - What US Shoppers Are Considering (Nov 2026)")
- Report date: "November 2026" on the cover; released November 19, 2026
- Length: 30 pages, six sections: How the Holiday Season Is Building, Retailers, Gift Categories, Breakout Gifts & Experiences, AI Conversations, Holiday Shopper Personas
- Data sources: "on site search data (US), same-site panel" and "US AI conversation data"
- Main window: September 1 to November 16, 2026; momentum window November 3 to 16, 2026 vs September 1 to 30, 2026; AI monthly series January 1 to November 16, 2026
- Headline finding: Amazon 24% of retailer searches, 11% of AI answers; Walmart 12% and 9%; Target 5% and 8%
- Footnote on AI mentions: "a mention is not a recommendation"
- Black Friday / Cyber Monday search share: 11.82x September (Cyber Monday 13.89x, Black Friday 12.28x)
- AI Black Friday prompts: 4.30x September in November
- Top AI request: gift ideas, 42.2% of holiday-shopping prompts
- Gift prompts vs searches: 24 vs 9 median words; budget stated in 7.2% vs 0.49%; median budget $50 vs $57
- Related Verve announcements: Captify acquisition, September 17, 2025 (25.6 million euros); LLM conversational intent signals, March 10, 2026 (https://verve.com/press/verve-becomes-first-ad-platform-to-activate-conversational-intent-signals-from-major-llm-environments/)
- Black Friday 2026: November 27; Cyber Monday: November 30
Timeline
- August 2025: Amazon adds AI crawlers from Meta, Google, Huawei and Mistral to its robots.txt block list
- September 17, 2025: Verve announces its acquisition of Captify for a total of 25.6 million euros
- October 23, 2025: Measure Protocol finds 21.6% of ChatGPT interactions show commercial intent
- November 4, 2025: Amazon demands Perplexity stop AI shopping in its Comet browser
- January 2026: Holiday-shopping prompts reach 21.6 per 10,000 US AI prompts in Verve's data
- March 10, 2026: Verve begins offering conversational intent signals from AI chat activity to advertisers
- May 13, 2026: Amazon merges Rufus and Alexa+ into Alexa for Shopping
- May 21, 2026: Survey puts ChatGPT third as a starting point for product discovery at 7.26%
- September 1, 2026: Start of Verve's main data window
- September 20, 2026: Amazon cuts Meta's Muse agent off from shopping on its site
- September 28, 2026: Adobe forecasts $275.1 billion in US online holiday spending
- October 15, 2026: Marketing Signals reports UK Black Friday searches down 36% since 2019
- October 29, 2026: Amazon reports third-quarter advertising revenue of $19.64 billion, up 11%
- November 3-16, 2026: Verve's latest 14-day comparison window
- November 9, 2026: Semrush study finds Gemini cites amazon.com in none of its holiday answers
- November 12, 2026: Salesforce finds 76% of shoppers do not want AI agents buying for them
- November 16, 2026: End of Verve's data window
- November 19, 2026: Verve releases its US holiday report; Amazon's Black Friday Week begins
- November 27, 2026: Black Friday (scheduled)
- November 30, 2026: Cyber Monday (scheduled)
Related PPC Land coverage
- Ashley Furniture beats Walmart 66.5% to 13.4% in AI Overviews deal answers - Semrush's holiday study of retailer mentions and citations across AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Mode.
- 76% of shoppers don't want AI agents buying for them, Salesforce finds - Salesforce survey on agent use and its Cyber Week AI spending forecast.
- Amazon blocks Meta's Muse AI agent from shopping on its site - Amazon's September 2026 decision to cut off Meta's shopping agent.
- Amazon blocks AI bots from major tech companies amid commerce battle - Amazon's 2025 robots.txt changes against AI crawlers.
- Amazon demands Perplexity stop AI shopping in Comet browser dispute - Amazon's legal demand over agentic purchases on its marketplace.
- Amazon merges Rufus and Alexa+ into one shopping assistant - The launch of Alexa for Shopping as Amazon's single in-store assistant.
- Amazon's Black Friday Week runs Nov 19-30 with 12 days of deal drops - Dates and mechanics of Amazon's 2026 holiday sale.
- Amazon ad revenue growth drops to 11% after Prime Day moves to June - Amazon's third-quarter 2026 advertising results.
- Adobe puts US online holiday spend at $275.1 billion, up 6.7% - Adobe's 2026 holiday forecast, including AI-referred traffic.
- Google still leads shopping searches as AI falls short at 7% - Survey on where US consumers start product discovery.
- One in five ChatGPT conversations show commercial intent - Measure Protocol's analysis of permissioned ChatGPT conversation data.
- Black Friday searches drop 36% in UK since 2019, Marketing Signals finds - Long-run decline in UK search interest for the event.
- Walmart's ChatGPT checkout flopped. Here's what comes next. - Walmart's results from selling inside ChatGPT and its shift to Sparky.
Summary
Who: Verve, an advertising technology company that owns the search intelligence business Captify, published the report. It covers US shoppers and the retailers they search for and hear about from AI assistants, chiefly Amazon, Walmart and Target.
What: A 30-page holiday report combining US on-site search data with US AI conversation data. Amazon accounts for 24% of retailer searches but is named in 11% of AI answers; Walmart 12% and 9%; Target 5% and 8%. Black Friday and Cyber Monday searches stood at 11.82 times their September share, and gift ideas made up 42.2% of holiday-shopping AI prompts.
When: Released November 19, 2026, with data from September 1 to November 16, 2026, and an AI monthly series from January 2026. Black Friday falls on November 27 and Cyber Monday on November 30.
Where: United States, across a panel of websites with on-site search and AI conversations from opted-in users. The report does not name the AI platforms.
Why: AI assistants increasingly answer shopping questions before a shopper reaches a store, and the retailers they name can differ from those shoppers search for. The report documents that difference for the 2026 holiday season, without establishing its cause or its effect on sales.
Discussion