The National Association of Attorneys General today served notice that 35 states and the District of Columbia will depose Character Technologies, the bankrupt company behind Character.ai, on November 30, and listed 15 matters its witnesses must be prepared to answer under oath, from how the company checks users' ages to whether the AI models it plans to sell "can reproduce or reveal users' personal information." The five-page notice of a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition, filed as Docket No. 199 in the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, sets the examination for 9:30 a.m. Eastern, the day before the auction for the company's assets. It is also the first filing by the states to name Smirks and Pangs, the buyer lined up to pay $10 million for the Character.ai app, its models and its users' chats. The two state objections filed on November 18 did not mention that buyer; today's notice names it four times.
In Short
Thirty-five states and Washington, DC, want Character.ai to put a witness under oath on November 30 to explain what data it holds on its users, including children, and where that data has ended up inside the technology it is selling to Disney and to a newly formed company called Smirks and Pangs. The questions go to the center of both deals: whether the tools licensed to Disney were built or tested on users' chats, and whether the AI models offered for $10 million could give users' personal information back out. The testimony is scheduled one day before the December 1 auction and three days before the judge takes up the sales on December 3.
What the notice requires
The notice is short and procedural, and its force comes from the rule it invokes. It is brought under Rules 26 and 30 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, which apply in bankruptcy through Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure 7026, 7030 and 9014. The last of those governs contested matters, the category of dispute that a sale motion becomes once parties object to it, as the states and Texas did on November 18.
According to the notice, the NAAG Client States "will take the deposition of the Debtor, Character Technologies, Inc., by oral examination of its designee(s) under Rule 30(b)(6), on November 30, 2026 at 9:30 am (ET), or at some other time mutually agreed upon by the parties." The examination will take place "remotely via a mutually agreed videoconferencing service and recorded stenographically by a person authorized by law to administer oaths." The notice provides for a stenographic record and does not mention video.
Rule 30(b)(6) is the mechanism for questioning an organization rather than a person. The party serving the notice must describe the matters for examination with reasonable particularity, and the organization must designate one or more officers, directors, managing agents or other consenting people to testify on its behalf about information known or reasonably available to it. Since a 2020 amendment to the rule, both sides must also confer in good faith about those matters. The notice puts it in one sentence: "Under Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(b)(6), Character Technologies, Inc. should designate one or more persons to testify about the following matters."
The deposition is tied to the company's sale motion, Docket No. 15, filed on October 13. That motion sought, in two stages, an order approving bidding procedures and Disney Worldwide Services as stalking horse for the "Disney Target Assets," with authority to designate additional stalking horse purchasers, and then an order approving the sale itself. The first stage is done. The second is what the court will consider on December 3 and 4.
The 15 matters
The full list follows, in the notice's own words.
| No. | Matter, as worded in the notice | What it reaches |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "The categories of personal information and other user data the Debtor collects and maintains, including data relating to minors." | Data inventory |
| 2 | "The Debtor's privacy policies, terms of service, and other privacy representations to users, and any changes to them." | Promises to users |
| 3 | "The Debtor's practices for obtaining and honoring user consents, opt-outs, and access and deletion requests." | Consent and user rights |
| 4 | "The Debtor's age-verification practices and its handling of the data of users under the age of 13 and under the age of 18." | Minors |
| 5 | "The Debtor's use of user data to develop, train or improve its artificial intelligence models." | Model training |
| 6 | "Identify and discuss which databases and buckets hold users' personal data." | Storage |
| 7 | "Identify and discuss which third-party vendors hold and/or process users' personal data." | Vendors |
| 8 | "The user data, models and related assets included in the proposed sale (i) to Disney Worldwide Services, Inc. and (ii) to Smirks and Pangs." | Both sales |
| 9 | "How the personal information of users under 18 and under 13 is included in any assets being sold (i) to Disney Worldwide Services, Inc. and (ii) to Smirks and Pangs." | Both sales, minors |
| 10 | "Notice of the proposed sales to users and their parents if the users are minors." | Notice |
| 11 | "Whether any technology, models, classifiers, tools or patents to be licensed to Disney Worldwide Services, Inc. were developed, trained, tuned or tested using user data, including data of minors." | Disney license |
| 12 | "The Debtor's interpretation and application of the exclusions from the Disney license for end-user data, training data, Unprocessed Data and Finished Models, and how the Debtor will ensure that user data and models derived from it are not provided to Disney." | Disney license |
| 13 | "The AI models and weights to be sold to Smirks and Pangs, the user data used to train them, and whether those models can reproduce or reveal users' personal information." | Smirks and Pangs models |
| 14 | "The Debtor's ability to identify, remove or delete user data, including data of minors and users who opted out, from models, training datasets and other technology before any transfer." | Removal before transfer |
| 15 | "Technology, data or models that both Disney and Smirks and Pangs will receive or be able to use, including the patents, and any safeguards for user data that will apply to each." | Overlap between buyers |
The list moves in a clear order. The first five matters ask what the company collected, what it told users and how it used the data. The next two ask where the data physically sits and who else holds it. Matters 8 through 10 turn to the two sales and to whether users and parents have been told. The last five go inside the technology itself.
Smirks and Pangs enters the states' filings
Until today, the states' objections had been aimed at Disney. Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC was formed in Delaware on November 13 and designated the next day as the stalking horse for every asset outside Disney's license, at $10 million in cash plus assumed liabilities, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai users' chats faced a $10m sale to Smirks and Pangs. Its asset schedule takes in the website and apps, all AI models and weights, account data, characters, chat content, advertising and analytics data and training datasets. The signed agreement, filed on November 16, requires a sale order approving the transfer of that data without any further consent, and the privacy and age statements the company made in it end at closing, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai's $10m sale was shown to hinge on moving chats without further consent.
Objections to the designation were due by 9 p.m. Eastern on November 18. The docket lists none. The coalition's 32-page objection, filed that afternoon, concerned the Disney license only, and neither it nor Texas's separate filing mentioned the second buyer, as PPC Land noted when 39 states and DC asked the court to deny Disney's $20m Character.ai deal. The states' first step on Smirks and Pangs is therefore a request for testimony, not for a ruling.
Four of the 15 matters name the buyer. Matters 8 and 9 ask what user data, models and related assets, and what information on users under 13 and under 18, are included in the sale to each buyer. Matter 13 goes to the models themselves. Matter 15 asks about anything both buyers would receive.
Can a model give back what it learned?
Matter 13 is the most technical question in the notice. It asks about "the AI models and weights to be sold to Smirks and Pangs, the user data used to train them, and whether those models can reproduce or reveal users' personal information." The notice does not claim that they can. It asks the company to say, under oath.
The concern has a research basis. In July 2025, PPC Land covered a study arguing that large language models qualify as personal data, which described experiments in which personal details stored in a model's parameters could be retrieved with targeted queries. A model's weights are the numbers it learns during training; if a model has memorized fragments of the conversations it was trained on, selling the weights can move those fragments with them, even where the chat logs themselves are excluded.
Matter 14 asks whether the problem can be fixed before any sale closes. It covers "the Debtor's ability to identify, remove or delete user data, including data of minors and users who opted out, from models, training datasets and other technology before any transfer." Deleting a record from a database does not remove what a model has already learned from it, and the notice asks the company to explain what it can actually do.
The question has been building in the case. In their notice of interest on October 14, the 39 states and the District of Columbia asked for limits on training with chat content without consent and for consumers to be able to delete their data before any sale, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai faced 40 attorneys general over who could buy its users' chats. On November 12, the Consumer Federation of America wrote to the judge that users' chats were built into the company's models and cited legal arguments for deleting models trained on improperly obtained data, as PPC Land reported in what the therapist bot heard. Matters 13 and 14 put both concerns into a form the company must answer on the record.
The Disney license, tested from the inside
Disney's side of the deal was built to stay away from personal data. The license filed with the sale motion excludes users' data, inputs and outputs, as well as "Unprocessed Data," defined as publicly sourced data not yet cleaned, de-identified or onboarded into training databases, and training data and "Finished Models," including each user-selectable conversational model, as PPC Land reported when Disney budgeted $180m for Character.ai staff and $20m for the bankrupt company. What Disney would license is code behind the company's training, safety and serving systems, plus nine patent entries. Disney would also own whatever it builds from that code, including models, weights and synthetic data, according to the same agreement.
Matters 11 and 12 test whether the exclusions hold. Matter 11 asks whether any "technology, models, classifiers, tools or patents" to be licensed to Disney "were developed, trained, tuned or tested using user data, including data of minors." Classifiers, the systems that sort content into categories such as allowed or prohibited, are usually trained on labeled examples; a safety classifier for a chatbot service would be trained on examples of the content it is meant to catch. Matter 12 asks for the company's "interpretation and application" of the exclusions "and how the Debtor will ensure that user data and models derived from it are not provided to Disney."
These follow the argument the coalition made on November 18: that licensed training infrastructure, evaluation frameworks and safety tools were likely built on real conversations, and that the license's definition of outputs could leave chat material embedded in licensed technology outside the exclusion. Advocacy groups made a version of the same point earlier. On November 12, the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action asked the judge to keep chat-derived data out of the technology license, as PPC Land reported when groups asked the court to treat every Character.ai chat as a child's.
Matter 15 links the two deals. The Smirks and Pangs schedule includes the same nine patent entries that Disney would license, four issued, three pending and two not yet published. Smirks and Pangs would own them, and Disney would hold a perpetual, non-exclusive license to the same nine, drafted to survive a later change of control. The notice asks about "any safeguards for user data that will apply to each."
Databases, buckets and vendors
Matters 6 and 7 ask the company to identify "which databases and buckets hold users' personal data" and "which third-party vendors hold and/or process users' personal data." A bucket is the storage container used by cloud services such as Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud.
The contracts the company proposes to hand to Smirks and Pangs give a partial map. Exhibit B to the November 14 designation listed 55 contracts. Compute comes from DigitalOcean, Nebius and Amazon Web Services, and OpenAI appears under an AI services agreement. On the marketing side, AppLovin holds a services agreement, Moloco a software agreement, and AppsFlyer, a mobile measurement partner, a software agreement with a $16,401 cure cost. Amplitude holds a user analytics agreement and Persona a user verification agreement. DigitalOcean alone carried $2,646,136 of the $2,684,462 in listed cure costs, by PPC Land's calculation. On November 18, DigitalOcean filed a limited objection and reservation of rights to the company's notice of possible contract assumptions (Docket No. 193); the docket entry does not describe its terms.
A list of contracts does not show which vendors hold personal data, which is what matter 7 asks. Answered under oath, it would establish which ad networks, measurement companies, analytics providers and cloud hosts have held Character.ai users' information, and which of those relationships would move to a new owner.
Minors, age checks and notice to parents
Three matters concern children. Matter 4 asks about "age-verification practices" and the handling of data of users under 13 and under 18. Matter 9 asks how their personal information is included in the assets for sale. Matter 10 asks about "Notice of the proposed sales to users and their parents if the users are minors."
The numbers behind these questions come from the company's own records, as cited in the Kentucky complaint filed as an exhibit to the states' October notice: more than 21.6 million US accounts created by March 13, 2025, including more than 2.1 million with a declared age under 18. The signed Smirks and Pangs agreement added a section on age assurance, minors and user safety that did not exist in the form agreement, but its statements end at closing.
On notice, the record so far is thin. The court-approved publication notice ran in USA Today on November 9 and never used the name Character.ai, as PPC Land reported when the sale notice in USA Today left 9 days to object. It was published before Smirks and Pangs was designated.
The calendar around the deposition
| Date | Step | Source |
|---|---|---|
| November 18, 9 p.m. ET | Objection deadline for the Smirks and Pangs designation; none on the docket | Bidding procedures order; docket |
| November 19 | States file the deposition notice (Docket No. 199); date set in October for the section 341 meeting of creditors, 1 p.m. ET | Docket No. 199; notice of commencement |
| November 24, noon ET | Bid deadline | Bidding procedures order |
| November 26 | Latest date for the ombudsman's sealed report if the sale hearing opens December 3 | PPC Land calculation |
| November 30, 9:30 a.m. ET | Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of Character Technologies | Docket No. 199 |
| November 30, 4 p.m. ET | Company's reply to sale objections due | Bidding procedures order |
| December 1, 10 a.m. ET | Auction | Bidding procedures order |
| December 3 and 4, 9:30 a.m. ET | Sale hearing | Bidding procedures order |
| December 31, 5 p.m. ET | Outside date in the Smirks and Pangs agreement | Docket No. 179 |
By PPC Land's count, the deposition comes 11 days after the notice was filed, on the Monday after Thanksgiving, and on the same day the company's written reply to the sale objections is due.
It also comes after the privacy review should be in. Judge Brendan L. Shannon ordered the appointment of a consumer privacy ombudsman on November 17 and set the report for no later than seven days before any hearing on a sale of personal information. Counsel to the NAAG Client States is among the parties entitled to the unredacted report, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai faced a privacy ombudsman before its users' data could be sold. If the report is filed on that schedule, counsel for the states will have had it for four days by the time of the deposition.
A second deposition of the same company
The states are not the only party seeking testimony from the company. On November 18, the official committee of unsecured creditors filed a notice of service of its own Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of Character Technologies (Docket No. 183), along with notices for Rick Marini, Stan Chudnovsky, Colin M. Adams, Adam Dunayer and Christopher S. Sontchi (Docket Nos. 184 to 188), as PPC Land reported when Character.ai's planned data sale got a $650-an-hour privacy ombudsman. The docket entries do not describe the committee's topics. The states' notice sets out its 15 matters on the public docket.
Today was also the date set in October for the meeting of creditors under section 341 of the Bankruptcy Code, at 1 p.m. Eastern, where a company representative answers questions under oath from the US Trustee and creditors, as PPC Land reported when Character.ai faced creditors under oath on November 19. The docket entries for today do not say whether the meeting went ahead.
Who is behind the notice
The notice is signed by Abigail Rushing Ryan and Patricia Molteni, bankruptcy counsel at the National Association of Attorneys General in Washington. A footnote defines the NAAG Client States as 35 states and the District of Columbia.
The list does not match the coalition behind the November 18 objection. Arkansas and Indiana, members of the October coalition that did not appear in that objection, are back. Colorado, which signed the objection through its own counsel, is listed among NAAG's clients. Maryland and Massachusetts, named in the objection's opening paragraph, are absent. Florida, New Jersey, Oregon and Pennsylvania, which signed the objection through their own counsel, are not part of the notice, and neither is Texas, which objected separately.
Beyond the court's electronic filing system, Molteni certified that copies went by email to the company's counsel at Wilson Sonsini Goodrich and Rosati, to Linda J. Casey of the Office of the United States Trustee, and to the creditors' committee's counsel at McDermott Will and Schulte. Counsel for Disney and for Smirks and Pangs, and the ombudsman, are not on the email list.
Why the marketing community is watching
Character.ai earned about $2.5 million a month from advertising while losing about $8 million a month, and its users' data now sits at the center of a bankruptcy sale. The deposition topics read as a checklist of the questions any acquirer, regulator or ombudsman can put to a consumer app with an advertising business: what was collected, what users were told, which vendors hold the data, whether opt-outs were honored and whether the data can be pulled back out.
Two of the matters go beyond the usual data-room questions. Matter 13 asks whether a trained model can leak personal data, and matter 14 asks whether data from users who opted out can be removed from models and training sets before a transfer. Those questions apply to any company that has trained models on customer or user data and may one day sell or license them. A sworn answer would create a record of one company's position, in a case that is being watched by regulators in most US states.
What the notice leaves open
The notice does not say who the company will designate, how long the examination will run, or whether the company has agreed to the date; the phrase "or at some other time mutually agreed upon by the parties" leaves room for it to move. The notice includes no document requests. Advertising data, users outside the United States and the content of chats are not named as separate topics, though several matters are broad enough to reach them. Whether the transcript will be filed, sealed or used at the sale hearing is not addressed.
Key facts
- Document: "Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition of Character Technologies, Inc.," Docket No. 199, five pages, dated and filed November 19, 2026
- Case: In re Character Technologies, Inc., Case No. 26-11603 (BLS), US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, Judge Brendan L. Shannon
- Noticing parties: the NAAG Client States: Alaska, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Delaware, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Indiana, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Nevada, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, New Hampshire, Ohio, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, Virginia, Vermont, Washington, Wisconsin and West Virginia (35 states and DC)
- Counsel: Abigail Rushing Ryan and Patricia Molteni, Bankruptcy Counsel, National Association of Attorneys General, 1850 M Street NW, 12th Floor, Washington, DC 20036
- Rules cited: Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 26, 30 and 30(b)(6); Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure 7026, 7030 and 9014
- Deposition: November 30, 2026, 9:30 a.m. ET, or another time agreed by the parties; remote, by videoconference; recorded stenographically
- Related motion: sale motion, Docket No. 15, filed October 13, 2026
- Matters for examination: 15; Smirks and Pangs named in matters 8, 9, 13 and 15
- Buyers referred to: Disney Worldwide Services, Inc. (stalking horse at $20 million for a non-exclusive license and employee claims); Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC (stalking horse at $10 million plus assumed liabilities for the app, models, user data and other assets)
- Service: CM/ECF, plus email to counsel for the debtor, the US Trustee and the official committee of unsecured creditors
- Related filings: committee's Rule 30(b)(6) notice, Docket No. 183, November 18, 2026; DigitalOcean limited objection, Docket No. 193, November 18, 2026; consumer privacy ombudsman order, Docket No. 181, November 17, 2026
Timeline
- March 13, 2025: More than 21.6 million US accounts created, more than 2.1 million with a declared age under 18, according to the Kentucky complaint
- July 24, 2025: Study argues large language models qualify as personal data
- September 18, 2026: Character.ai and Disney sign the agreements behind the $20 million license
- October 13, 2026: Sale motion filed (Docket No. 15); Disney's license excludes user data, Unprocessed Data, training data and Finished Models
- October 14, 2026: 39 states and DC set conditions for any buyer, including deletion before a sale
- October 15, 2026: Notice sets the section 341 meeting of creditors for November 19 at 1 p.m. ET
- October 29, 2026: 39 states and DC say user data needs a privacy ombudsman
- November 3, 2026: Further revised bidding procedures order filed, with the auction on December 1
- November 9, 2026: Sale notice runs in USA Today without naming Character.ai
- November 12, 2026: Consumer Federation of America letter cites model deletion; Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action ask the judge to keep chat-derived data out of the license
- November 13, 2026: Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC formed in Delaware
- November 14, 2026: Smirks and Pangs designated stalking horse at $10 million for the app, models and user data
- November 16, 2026: Signed Smirks and Pangs agreement filed
- November 17, 2026: Judge Shannon orders the appointment of a consumer privacy ombudsman
- November 18, 2026: Lucy L. Thomson appointed ombudsman; creditors' committee files deposition notices (Docket Nos. 183 to 188); 39 states and DC and Texas object to the Disney sale without mentioning Smirks and Pangs; DigitalOcean files a limited objection (Docket No. 193); no objection to the Smirks and Pangs designation on the docket by the 9 p.m. deadline
- November 19, 2026: 35 states and DC notice a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of Character Technologies (Docket No. 199)
- November 24, 2026: Bid deadline, noon ET
- November 26, 2026: Latest date for the ombudsman's sealed report if the sale hearing opens December 3
- November 30, 2026: Deposition at 9:30 a.m. ET; company's reply to sale objections due at 4 p.m. ET
- December 1, 2026: Auction, 10 a.m. ET
- December 3-4, 2026: Sale hearing, 9:30 a.m. ET
- December 31, 2026: Outside date in the Smirks and Pangs agreement, 5 p.m. ET
Related PPC Land coverage
- 39 states and DC ask court to deny Disney's $20m Character.ai deal - the November 18 objections, which concerned the Disney license and did not mention Smirks and Pangs.
- Character.ai's planned data sale gets a $650-an-hour privacy ombudsman - the appointment of Lucy L. Thomson and the creditors' committee's deposition notices.
- Character.ai faces a privacy ombudsman before its users' data can be sold - the order setting the sealed report and who may read it.
- Character.ai's $10m sale hinges on moving chats without further consent - the signed Smirks and Pangs agreement and its privacy and age statements.
- Character.ai users' chats face a $10m sale to Smirks and Pangs - the designation, the asset schedule and the 55 contracts, including ad tech vendors.
- What the therapist bot heard: Character.ai's chats are on the block - the Consumer Federation of America letter raising model deletion.
- Treat every Character.ai chat as a child's, groups ask bankruptcy judge - the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action letter on chat-derived data.
- Common Sense Media tells judge AI could unmask kids in Character.ai chats - a letter asking for protection of all conversational data.
- Character.ai sale notice in USA Today leaves 9 days to object - the published notice that never named the app.
- Judge to overrule 40 states' objections to Character.ai's Disney sale rules - the bidding procedures order and the calendar.
- 39 states and DC say Character.ai user data needs a privacy ombudsman - the states' October call for a privacy review.
- Character.ai faces 40 attorneys general over who can buy its users' chats - the October notice of interest and its conditions for any buyer.
- Disney budgets $180m for Character.ai staff, $20m for the bankrupt company - the sale motion and the license exclusions now under examination.
- Disney pays $20m for Character.ai's IP and $180m for its staff - what Disney's license covers.
- Character.ai faces creditors under oath on November 19, a day before bids - the notice of commencement and the section 341 meeting.
- Character.ai loses $8m a month despite $2.5m in monthly ad sales - the advertising revenue and losses behind the sale.
- Study: large language models qualify as personal data - research on retrieving personal details stored in model parameters.
Summary
Who: The NAAG Client States, 35 states and the District of Columbia represented by bankruptcy counsel at the National Association of Attorneys General, noticing the deposition of Character Technologies, Inc., the company behind Character.ai. The matters concern its two proposed buyers, Disney Worldwide Services, Inc. and Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC.
What: A notice of a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition (Docket No. 199) requiring the company to designate witnesses on 15 matters, covering the user data it holds, its privacy promises, consent and opt-out practices, age verification, the use of user data to train models, storage and vendors, what each buyer receives, notice to users and parents, whether the technology licensed to Disney was built or tested on user data, whether the models going to Smirks and Pangs can reproduce or reveal personal information, and whether user data can be removed from models before any transfer.
When: Filed today, November 19, 2026. The deposition is set for 9:30 a.m. Eastern on November 30, the day before the December 1 auction and three days before the December 3 sale hearing.
Where: The US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, case No. 26-11603 (BLS); the deposition is to be held remotely by videoconference.
Why: The states have objected to the Disney license but had not named, in any filing, the separate $10 million sale of the app, its models and users' chats to Smirks and Pangs. The notice seeks sworn answers on where users' data, including children's, sits inside the technology being sold, before the court decides whether to approve either sale. For the advertising and app economy, the answers would put on record which vendors hold an ad-supported app's user data and whether personal information can be separated from trained models.
Discussion