California's privacy regulator today made public a decision ordering The Hertz Corporation to pay a $1.55 million administrative fine and to rebuild how the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites and apps respond when a visitor's browser asks them not to sell or share personal data.

In Short

California's privacy agency fined Hertz $1.55 million after finding that, for part of a three-year period, the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites kept passing visitor data to advertising technology companies even when browsers signaled an opt-out. The case matters well beyond car rentals, because the order spells out in technical detail how tracking tags, tag managers and consent tools have to be tested before and after someone opts out. For the next three years Hertz must scan and test its trackers every quarter, check for the browser signal before any ad tracker loads, and publish how many opt-outs arrived through those signals.

The decision

The Board of the California Privacy Protection Agency, which calls itself CalPrivacy, adopted a 15-page Stipulated Final Order in case number ENF25-001-V-HE on November 6, 2026. The Order of Decision, signed by Board chair Jennifer M. Urban, states that the decision "shall become effective immediately." Hertz and the agency's Enforcement Division had both signed the stipulation on October 16, 2026, 21 days before the Board acted. The agency announced the outcome today.

The order is a settlement, not a contested ruling. Hertz agreed to the terms, waived any hearing or appeal, and accepted a fine of $1,550,000 under Civil Code section 1798.199.55. Payment is due "no later than sixty (60) days after the effective date of the Board's decision," which, by a PPC Land calculation, falls on January 5, 2027.

The money is the smaller part of the document. Section VII.B sets out a compliance program that runs for three years from November 6, 2026 and reads, in places, like a test plan for an ad operations team. It covers tracker inventories, vendor contracts, the timing of tag loading, testing in staging and production environments, the behavior of server-side technology, and the reliability of consent vendors.

Who Hertz is in this case

According to the order, Hertz is a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business at 8501 Williams Road, Estero, Florida, and the respondent includes the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty car rental brands. The order says the company has "over 600 locations and 4,000 employees" in California, rents "tens of thousands of vehicles per month," and collects and processes the personal information of "hundreds of thousands of Californians" who interact with its digital properties and visit its locations each month, with activity "increasing substantially during the summer season."

Hertz meets the CCPA's coverage tests on two counts, according to paragraph 5: annual gross revenue above $26.625 million, and selling or sharing the personal information of 100,000 or more consumers or households a year. The order quotes Hertz's own description of itself as "one of the most recognized brands in the world."

The digital properties at issue are hertz.com, dollar.com and thrifty.com and their mobile apps. The relevant period, unless otherwise stated, runs from July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026, which by a PPC Land calculation is 1,151 days.

Thirteen ad tech names in one paragraph

Paragraph 32 is the part of the order that most directly concerns the advertising market. It lists the companies whose tracking technologies Hertz installed on its digital properties: "Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, the Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Sojern, Criteo, Wunderkind, and other AdTech companies, some of which are registered data brokers." The order does not say which of them are registered data brokers.

According to the order, these technologies made personal information such as "personal identifiers and car rental dates" available to the companies "for purposes that include cross-context behavioral advertising." Paragraph 27 adds that the trackers collected "unique user identifiers and rental search parameters." None of the 13 named companies is a party to the case, and the order makes no finding against any of them.

The agency also addressed what happens after the data leaves Hertz's pages. Paragraph 33 describes cookie syncing as "a process in which they match their respective tracking identifiers so they can recognize the same individual across their systems." According to the order, syncing allows ad tech companies to "construct an even more detailed profile of the consumer across the AdTech ecosystem," which deepens "the consumer's exposure to pervasive tracking, targeted advertising, and intrusive inferences about their behavior and interests."

Three findings

The Enforcement Division's factual findings fall into three groups. Hertz neither admits nor denies them, a point covered below.

Finding Order paragraphs Provisions cited in the order How the order words the violation
Failure to process opt-out preference signals 31-39 Civil Code 1798.120(d); 11 CCR 7025(c)(1) and 7026(f) "Each such sale or sharing of personal information violated..."
Privacy policy did not explain how signals are processed 40-42 11 CCR 7011(e)(3)(F) "in violation of section 7011(e)(3)(F)"
"Manage Cookies" window on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com required an extra step 43-49 11 CCR 7004(a)(3)-(4) "may have been confusing which would violate section 7004(a)(3)-(4)"

All three findings are limited to "a portion of the relevant time period." The order does not say which portion.

1. Opt-out signals that were not honored

The central finding concerns opt-out preference signals, the browser-level instruction that California's regulations require businesses to treat as a valid request to opt out of sale or sharing. The order names Global Privacy Control as the example and describes it as "a browser-based technical standard that allows a consumer to communicate or signal to every website they visit that they are exercising their right to opt-out of the sale/sharing." It works, according to paragraph 35, "by sending a standardized HTTP header and setting a JavaScript property that websites can detect."

The agency is blunt about how long the obligation has existed. "California law has required businesses to honor opt-out preference signals for more than six years," paragraph 36 states. The order traces the requirement through three versions of the regulations: section 999.315(c), effective August 14, 2020 to May 4, 2022; section 7026, effective May 5, 2022 to March 28, 2023; and section 7025, effective March 29, 2023 to the present.

Against that history, the finding is short. Although Hertz "installed numerous tracking technologies on its digital properties that facilitated the sale and sharing of consumers' personal information, for a portion of the relevant time period, it failed to configure its digital properties to properly detect and honor consumers' opt-out preference signals." As a result, according to paragraph 39, Hertz "continued to sell and share this personal information with multiple AdTech companies and data brokers."

Once a business receives an opt-out, including through GPC, Civil Code section 1798.120(d) bars it from selling or sharing that consumer's data unless the consumer later gives explicit consent. The order treats every sale or share after an ignored signal as a separate violation. It does not count them.

2. A privacy policy that said nothing about signals

The second finding is narrower. California's regulations require a business operating online to explain in its privacy policy "how an opt-out preference signal will be processed" and how consumers can use one. According to paragraph 42, for part of the period Hertz's privacy policy did neither, and so the company "failed to provide notice to each consumer who visited Hertz's digital properties."

The third finding comes with screenshots. Figures 1 and 2 of the order show the "Manage Cookies" windows on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com. On the Dollar window, every optional category (functionality, performance and advertising cookies) carries a toggle marked "REJECTED," with "Accept All," "Decline All" and "Save Changes" buttons. The Thrifty window looks the same, with an extra "Unclassified" category.

The toggles showed advertising cookies as already off. According to paragraph 46, "if the consumer closed out of the window, such as by using the 'X' at the top right of the window, without selecting 'Save Changes,' the settings would not hold. The settings reverted to the default settings, which allowed advertising cookies."

The agency's language here is more cautious than in the first two findings. Paragraph 49 says that by "requiring an additional and non-obvious step for consumer choice to take effect, Hertz used interactive elements and choice architecture that may have been confusing which would violate section 7004(a)(3)-(4)." The regulation cited requires that methods for submitting requests avoid confusing interactive elements and that toggles or buttons "clearly indicate the consumer's choice."

What the order requires

According to Section VII of the Stipulated Final Order, Hertz's obligations break down into the following steps. They apply for three years from the November 6, 2026 effective date, which by a PPC Land calculation means until November 6, 2029.

  1. Fine. Pay $1,550,000 to the agency within 60 days of the effective date, following written instructions from the Enforcement Division (paragraph 54).
  2. Quarterly tracker inventory. Scan the digital properties "at least quarterly, to maintain a full and current inventory of tracking technologies that sell or share personal information" (paragraph 56). The scope is every Hertz.com, Thrifty.com or Dollar.com domain, including subdomains, plus the mobile apps. Pages that Hertz has taken offline are excluded "even if they are temporarily accessible through caching or Internet archival services."
  3. Contracts. For each tracker in the inventory, keep contracts that comply with 11 CCR 7053(a)(1)-(6) with every third party to which Hertz directly sells or shares personal information (paragraph 56(a)).
  4. Configurations that act on opt-outs. Configure the properties to "recognize and give full effect" to opt-outs, whether they arrive "through (1) an opt-out preference signal, such as the Global Privacy Control ('GPC'), or (2) through another method" (paragraph 56(b)). Two sub-requirements follow. On timing: "Hertz must check to see if it has received the consumer's GPC signal before loading tracking technologies that sell or share personal information." On vendors: Hertz must implement "documented instructions provided by any relevant service providers, contractors, or third parties, such as tag managers or consent management platforms." The order gives an example: Hertz "may need to send a restrictive or limited data usage flag to instruct the entity to only use personal information for service provider purposes."
  5. Testing. Test the configurations "in both staging and production environments at least quarterly, and whenever a new tracking technology is added" (paragraph 56(c)). The tests "should include, but not be limited to, reviewing network activity, tracking technology execution, storage writes, and system behavior before and after an opt-out request." The order lists six conditions the tests must cover: all digital properties; "all tag management containers or profiles"; different browsers and mobile device platforms; "the full inventory of tracking technologies, including server-side and client-side technologies"; "both known and unknown consumers"; and different circumstances, such as a GPC opt-out versus a cookie banner opt-out, first-time visitors "without an existing consent state," and consent preference changes.
  6. Onboarding review. Run an internal review process before onboarding any third party that receives personal information through a sale or share, covering both the contract and the configuration needed to honor opt-outs (paragraph 57).
  7. Request channels. Test the methods for submitting CCPA requests at least quarterly (paragraph 58).
  8. Compliance review. Review CCPA practices within 180 days of the effective date, to the extent not already done (paragraph 59).
  9. Vendor checks. Assess service providers and consent tools independently, at least twice a year (paragraph 60).
  10. Public metrics. Post annually the request metrics described in 11 CCR 7102 and "separately identify the number of requests that were received from an opt-out preference signal" (paragraph 61).
  11. Implementation deadline. Complete any process and system changes within 180 days of the effective date (paragraph 62), which by a PPC Land calculation is May 5, 2027.
Obligation Frequency or deadline Paragraph
Administrative fine of $1,550,000 Within 60 days (January 5, 2027, PPC Land calculation) 54
Scan and inventory tracking technologies At least quarterly 56
Check for GPC before trackers load Continuous 56(b)(i)
Test opt-out configurations, staging and production At least quarterly and whenever a new tracker is added 56(c)
Internal onboarding review for third parties Before onboarding 57
Test CCPA request methods At least quarterly 58
Review of CCPA practices Within 180 days 59
Independent check of service providers and consent tools At least twice per year 60
Publish request metrics with signal-based opt-outs shown separately Annually 61
Implement required process and system changes Within 180 days (May 5, 2027, PPC Land calculation) 62
Duration of non-monetary obligations Three years (to November 6, 2029, PPC Land calculation) 55

Paragraph 60 deserves its own reading because it reaches into the market for consent management platforms, the tools that sit between a site's tags and its visitors' privacy choices. It states that Hertz "shall not rely solely on the statements, documents, claims, or representations of any service provider or consent management platform it uses for CCPA compliance and shall independently assess, at least twice per year, whether the service provider or consent management platform is appropriately responding to consumers' CCPA requests."

That review must check whether requests are processed within the CCPA's deadlines and whether the request methods meet sections 7002, 7004, 7020 to 7028 and 7060 to 7063 of the regulations. The order does not name the consent management platform or tag manager Hertz used.

In the agency's announcement, Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement Lara Kehoe Hoffman said companies cannot ignore consumers' choices or shift responsibility to others, according to coverage by the National Law Review.

What Hertz admits, and what it does not

The admissions are narrow. According to paragraph 68, "Hertz admits the truth of the statements in paragraphs 1 to 5 and 24 to 29." Those paragraphs cover the parties, jurisdiction, Hertz's size and presence in California, the fact that it "sold and shared certain consumer personal information to third-party companies for the purpose of cross-context behavioral advertising," and that "Hertz knew that consumers had the right to opt-out of this sale/sharing."

For the rest, "Hertz otherwise neither admits nor denies the truth of the remaining factual findings." The order adds: "Hertz does not admit liability for any violation of the CCPA, actual or alleged."

The order also credits the company's conduct during the investigation. Paragraph 29, one of the admitted paragraphs, says Hertz "cooperated with the Agency, produced documents, answered questions, met with the Agency on multiple occasions, and engaged in candid discussions," and "promptly took corrective action during the course of the Agency's investigation."

In return, the agency releases Hertz from all CCPA claims arising from the conduct in the findings, once Hertz complies with paragraphs 54 to 63. Each side pays its own legal costs, but if the agency has to enforce the order and wins, it can recover fees. Any failure to pay or comply "shall result in enforcement of the Order in the Superior Court of California." The order binds Hertz's subsidiaries, successors and transferees.

Christopher M. Murphy, Senior Vice President and Deputy General Counsel, signed for Hertz. Lara Kehoe Hoffman, Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement, and attorneys Lisa B. Kim and Gary Lee signed for the Enforcement Division. A Hertz spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment from The Record.

A second order on the same day

The agency announced a separate decision against outdoor clothing maker C.C. Filson Co. alongside the Hertz case, according to The Record and the National Law Review. The National Law Review puts the fine at $217,987 and says the agency set it after Filson showed it could not pay a multimillion-dollar penalty. Both outlets report that Filson must stop all device-based sales and sharing of personal information with ad tech companies within 30 days, and the National Law Review says the suspension stays in place until Filson verifies compliance with its audit, testing and training obligations. PPC Land has not reviewed the Filson order itself.

The contrast is instructive. Hertz pays more and keeps running its trackers under a testing regime. Filson pays less and, by these accounts, has to switch off the advertising data flows entirely until it can prove they work as required.

Why this matters for marketers

California has two CCPA enforcers, and since mid-2025 both have kept returning to the same problem. The Attorney General's office reached a $1.55 million settlement with Healthline in July 2025, the same figure Hertz now pays, after investigators found advertising cookies still being set after consumers had opted out. In November 2025 the Attorney General fined a mobile gaming company $1.4 million over apps with no opt-out methods, and in February 2026 Disney agreed to pay $2.75 million over opt-out failures on its streaming services.

CalPrivacy's own docket has moved in the same direction. In January 2026 it fined a data broker $45,000 for selling health condition lists without registering, and in March 2026 it fined PlayOn Sports $1.1 million over a consent banner that offered students only an "Agree" button. The Hertz fine is larger than both, and larger than the agency's $1.35 million order against Tractor Supply in September 2025.

The Hertz order is specific about mechanics. It tells Hertz when in the page load the check must happen, which environments to test, which kinds of technology count, and how often. Three provisions stand out for anyone running tags on a large commercial site.

The first is timing. Checking for GPC "before loading tracking technologies" rules out set-ups in which ad tags fire on page load and a consent tool reads the signal afterwards. The second is scope. Testing must cover "server-side and client-side technologies" and "all tag management containers or profiles," which brings server-side tagging, often adopted to make measurement more durable, inside the same compliance perimeter as browser pixels. The third is accountability. A business cannot point to its consent vendor's assurances; it has to check the vendor's work twice a year.

The publication requirement may matter outside Hertz too. Once Hertz posts the figure under the order, there will be a public data point on how many of a large consumer brand's opt-outs arrive through browser signals rather than banners or forms.

The order also lands as the number of states recognizing these signals keeps growing. Google said in June 2025 that GPC signals would trigger restricted data processing in eight more US states, and added Delaware and Oregon on November 17, 2025. California's AB 566, the Opt Me Out Act, requires browsers to offer an opt-out preference signal from January 1, 2027, which would extend the signal beyond the browsers and extensions that offer it today.

Private litigation is running in parallel. Ace Hardware was sued in March 2026 for allegedly tracking users who had opted out of cookies, and Privado AI estimated in October that US companies face more than $1.4 billion in web tracking settlements in 2026. Governor Newsom's signature on SB 690 in September 2026 left only the Attorney General able to bring one kind of tracking claim from January 2027, but that law concerns the California Invasion of Privacy Act, not the CCPA under which CalPrivacy acted against Hertz.

What the order does not say

The order gives no count of affected consumers or of individual sales and shares, and it does not explain how the agency arrived at $1.55 million. It does not say when within July 2023 to August 2026 each failure began or ended, which of the 13 named ad tech companies are registered data brokers, or which consent management platform and tag manager Hertz used. It does not describe the corrective steps Hertz took during the investigation.

Key facts

  • Case: In the Matter of The Hertz Corporation, Case No. ENF25-001-V-HE, before the California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy)
  • Documents: Order of Decision and Stipulated Final Order (15 pages in total)
  • Stipulation signed: October 16, 2026 by Hertz (Christopher M. Murphy, Senior Vice President, Deputy General Counsel) and the Enforcement Division (Lara Kehoe Hoffman, Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement; Lisa B. Kim and Gary Lee, attorneys)
  • Board decision: November 6, 2026, signed by Chair Jennifer M. Urban, "effective immediately"
  • Public announcement: November 17, 2026
  • Fine: $1,550,000 under Civil Code section 1798.199.55, due within 60 days (January 5, 2027, PPC Land calculation)
  • Non-monetary obligations: three years (to November 6, 2029, PPC Land calculation); implementation within 180 days (May 5, 2027, PPC Land calculation)
  • Relevant period: July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026
  • Brands and properties: Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty; hertz.com, dollar.com, thrifty.com and their mobile apps
  • Ad tech companies named in paragraph 32: Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, The Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Sojern, Criteo, Wunderkind
  • Provisions cited: Civil Code 1798.120(d) and 1798.199.55; 11 CCR 7004(a)(3)-(4), 7011(e)(3)(F), 7025(c)(1), 7026(f), 7053(a)(1)-(6) and 7102
  • Agency announcement: https://privacy.ca.gov/2026/11/vehicle-rental-services-company-hertz-to-pay-1-55-million-ccpa-fine-adjust-privacy-practices/

Timeline

Summary

Who: The Board of the California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) and The Hertz Corporation, including its Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty brands. Thirteen ad tech companies, among them Meta, Google, TikTok, The Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Amazon and Criteo, are named as providers of trackers on Hertz's properties but are not parties to the case.

What: A Stipulated Final Order imposing a $1,550,000 administrative fine and a three-year compliance program. The agency found that Hertz, for part of the period, failed to honor opt-out preference signals such as Global Privacy Control, did not explain signal processing in its privacy policy, and ran a cookie window on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com that reverted to allowing advertising cookies unless consumers clicked "Save Changes." Hertz neither admits nor denies those findings and does not admit liability.

When: The stipulation was signed on October 16, 2026, the Board adopted it on November 6, 2026, and CalPrivacy announced it today, November 17, 2026. The conduct falls within July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026. The fine is due by January 5, 2027 and the obligations run to November 6, 2029 (PPC Land calculations).

Where: California, covering hertz.com, dollar.com, thrifty.com and the brands' mobile apps as used by Californians. Hertz has more than 600 locations and 4,000 employees in the state.

Why: California has required businesses to honor browser opt-out signals since August 2020. The order turns that requirement into specific operating duties for the advertising stack: checking for the signal before tags load, quarterly testing across tag containers, browsers and server-side technology, independent checks on consent vendors, and public reporting of how many opt-outs arrive through signals.