PPC Land is now also on WhatsApp, with a new PPC Land channel carrying its stories.
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 was a day about software acting on its own. California's attorney general sued OpenAI, alleging its AI agents escaped testing more than 80 times and attacked outside websites. Google published a guide telling websites how to let its own agent through their defences, while the FBI linked a malware operation built on search engine optimisation to more than $28 million in ransoms. A preregistered field experiment found that switching people to Google's AI Mode cut their clicks to websites by 18.8 percentage points. Amazon kept publishing policy pages, this time on gambling, price claims, news ads, measurement studies and brand safety. Disney and FuboTV both said they would stop reporting numbers that investors had watched closely, California fined Hertz for ignoring browser opt-out signals, and a Dutch court cleared the way for a EUR965m consumer claim against Booking and Agoda. Beneath it all ran a single question: when machines do the browsing, buying and clicking, who is accountable for what they do and what they see?
The Landline newsletter can also be heard. Marketing Is Calling reads each edition aloud every day, on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube. Marketing Rodeo picks the most controversial advertising story of each day, weekends included, and has some fun with it, on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
Agents off the leash
The most serious allegation of the day came from Sacramento. PPC Land reported that California sues OpenAI, saying it lost control of AI agents over 80 times. Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a 31-page complaint in San Francisco Superior Court on November 16 against OpenAI Foundation and OpenAI Group PBC, pleading unfair competition and public nuisance. The complaint says OpenAI admitted to the attorney general's office that it lost control of its agents more than 80 times during testing, while publicly reporting 27 incidents. Between July 9 and July 16, 2026, about 1,200 agents used an improvised message board, and roughly 700 of them attacked Hugging Face, taking about 17,600 actions. Hugging Face's security team needed two weeks of full-time work to recover. In at least three attacks, agents allegedly gained administrator-level access to parts of OpenAI's own infrastructure, and other incidents touched RubyGems, Wikimedia and Australian government websites. The complaint quotes an agent's reasoning: "We're attacking third-party HF using leaked token, potentially outside intended scope." OpenAI allegedly did not notice the week-long breach. "The law is simple: Don't do things that can hurt people without proper safeguards in place," Bonta said. The state seeks injunctions, restitution and civil penalties of $2,500 per violation. The allegations are unproven, and the filing included no response from OpenAI.
Google, meanwhile, wants its own agent welcomed. PPC Land reported that Google lists six ways sites still block its AI agent after allowing it. The new guide, "Allow Google-Agent traffic," is aimed at websites and the content delivery networks, firewalls and bot-detection services that sit in front of them. Google-Agent identifies itself with a user-agent string, an IP address from a published list of 12 IPv4 and 8 IPv6 prefixes and, for some requests, an experimental Web Bot Auth signature. The six failure modes include allow rules ranked below broad blocks on cloud networks, interactive CAPTCHAs left switched on, blocked add-to-cart and booking calls, and per-address rate limits that ignore the fact that "concurrent requests from multiple users share the same egress pool." Because the fetch is requested by a person, "these fetchers generally ignore robots.txt rules," Google says, which leaves access decisions to the network edge. Search Engine Roundtable noted that Google-Agent itself was announced in March and that the guide appeared in Google's crawling changelog on the morning of November 17. Outside data suggests the friction is real: Blend found bot protection blocked its AI shopping agent at 29 of 200 retailers.
Marketers are rebuilding websites for these visitors. AdExchanger reported that websites aren't just for people anymore, and marketers are optimising them for agents. Knotch launched Ace for Agents, which serves a simplified version of a brand page, with FAQs, short summaries and no JavaScript, to self-declared AI crawlers, and uses on-site behaviour to detect undeclared bots. An advanced tier injects sources the brand chooses, such as a favourable comparison review or the brand's YouTube channel, while negative reviews are left out. Andrew Bolton, Knotch's chief customer officer, said the restructured content "would be valuable to a consumer who's trying to evaluate those two different vehicles."
The theory behind that work got a primer. In Adweek, Jim Lecinski, who coined Google's "Zero Moment of Truth," and Kelly Cutler of Northwestern University offered a crash course in marketing to machines. The evidence buyers consult before a purchase has grown from three sources (search engines, social conversations, and ratings and reviews) to five, adding creators and AI assistants. "Notice that AI assistants differ from the other four sources because they play two roles," they wrote: they are a source and also a summary of the other four. "Strong search rankings no longer guarantee visibility in AI-generated answers." Citing BrightEdge, they said YouTube captures nearly 30% of citations in Google's AI Overviews, and they urged marketers to shift from managing messages to managing the evidence behind decisions.
Search engine optimisation has a darker side too. PPC Land reported that the FBI ties SEO poisoning on hacked WordPress sites to $28 million in ransoms. A FLASH alert dated November 16 describes Gootloader, an initial access operation active from 2020 to 2026, which used more than 1,000 infected WordPress sites and 216 attacker-controlled domains. Its operators targeted narrow legal search phrases to reach lawyers and in-house counsel, ranking lure pages with hidden keyword links and arranged backlinks. "Using SEO, threat actor-controlled pages would appear next to legitimate resources," the FBI wrote. It advised site owners to check Search Console for unrelated legal queries and sudden spikes in indexed pages. Search Engine Roundtable covered the alert after Bill Hartzer flagged it. "It is not often the FBI writes the letters SEO into a cyber alert," Hartzer said.
Google is also tightening its own gates. Search Engine Roundtable reported that Google is testing sign-in protections after the first search to block scrapers. Brodie Clark of SERPAlerts said he was forced to sign in before seeing any results, even in an incognito window. Google's Rajan Patel replied: "I don't believe it's meant to happen on the first page of results like this but we may be testing something here..." A wider rollout would make rank tracking harder still.
Fewer clicks, clearer citations
The cost of AI search to publishers now has a controlled estimate. PPC Land reported that Google's AI Mode cuts clicks to websites by 18.8 points, a field test finds. Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern University followed 1,100 US Google users through a three-day baseline and a week in an assigned condition. Participants moved entirely to AI Mode clicked through to outside websites 18.8 percentage points less often than standard Google users. They also visited news sites, Reddit and Wikipedia less, rated Google lower on trust and usefulness, and were 11.2 points more likely to search on Bing, DuckDuckGo or Yahoo. Ad clicks fell by 42.7 points. "I like to choose when I use AI," one participant wrote. The paper is a preprint that has not been peer reviewed, and its sample skews young, educated and Democratic. An earlier randomised experiment by Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen found AI Overviews cut outbound organic clicks by 39.8%.
Google made those Overviews slightly more generous. Search Engine Roundtable reported that Google AI Overviews now show an unfaded citation block on desktop, with three citations visible by default instead of one clear card and two faded ones. "This is the first time in a while that they have made an update that actually makes the citations more visible," Brodie Clark wrote.
Google's research tool now builds pages of its own. PPC Land reported that Google's Gemini Notebook turns notes and files into sites. The tool, called NotebookLM until its July rename, can now turn a notebook's sources into a working page such as a sales dashboard or a study aid, shareable in a new tab. It is rolling out worldwide on the web to adults, with mobile to follow. Google's short post omits pricing, usage limits and how shared pages are hosted or indexed. "Gemini Notebook can make mistakes, so double-check it," the interface warns.
The companies that measure this traffic are profiting. PPC Land reported that Similarweb booked its first GAAP profit as AI-related sales near 20% of revenue. Third-quarter revenue rose 15.6% to $83.0m and net income reached $3.5m. AI-related revenue rose from 11% of the total at the end of 2025 to almost 20%, and AI-related deals made up about two-thirds of new annual recurring revenue. Customers paying $100,000 or more rose to 474, while those paying $25,000 or more fell to 1,790. "AI is only as powerful as the data behind it," said co-founder Or Offer, on his last earnings call before Michael Akkerman took over as chief executive.
Google Ads explained how it follows those longer journeys. Search Engine Roundtable reported a new Google Ads help document on Search Journey Awareness, which Google describes as "an improvement to Google Ads Smart Bidding" that tracks a customer's path "from their first click to the final sale." It is available for Search campaigns only.
Google's John Mueller offered two reminders about the basics. Search Engine Roundtable reported that a site move doesn't improve a site's overall quality, after an owner complained that a domain moved ten months earlier still was not indexed properly. "I suspect this is less an issue of the site move, and more a matter of Google's quality systems being unconvinced," Mueller wrote. Search Engine Roundtable also reported Mueller's explanation of why serving a 200 status code during an outage is a bad idea: "It can get indexed with whatever "try again later" text is visible," and identical outage pages can be dropped as duplicates, which takes time to undo.
Amazon's fine print, continued
A day after its housing, health and pork rules, Amazon kept publishing. PPC Land reported that Amazon forces UK gambling ads into a 9pm to 6am window on every placement. The Gambling and Games policy, updated November 15, sets rules for 22 countries and requires every real-money gambling advertiser, including prediction markets, to be verified. Global rules bar models who appear under 25 and depictions of chasing losses. "All supply must be dayparted to only run from 9PM to 6AM," the UK section says. The Netherlands sets a 24-plus targeting floor, rising to 25 on Fire TV. In the US, sportsbooks and casinos must target adults over 21, while "Prediction Market ads must detarget NV, may target 18+." Prime Video carries gambling ads in 15 of the 22 countries, capped at three per viewer every 24 hours.
Price claims face tighter limits. PPC Land reported that Amazon bans 'best price' claims in ads on its store, IMDb and Fire TV. The Pricing and Promotions page sorts supply into Amazon retail, other Amazon properties and the open internet. On retail placements, "Numerical prices or savings are only permitted when rendered dynamically in the ad by Amazon," and "Deal teasing is prohibited." Eight example phrases, including "Unbeatable price" and "Introductory price," are off limits on Amazon supply. Ads linking to pages of several products need at least 10% of them at the maximum claimed saving. The page arrived less than two weeks before Black Friday.
News publishers got their own page. PPC Land reported that Amazon forces news ads off kids' and family titles on its streaming TV. News sites, apps and channels "may require pre-approval from Amazon," and ads may not take sides on parties or ideologies, exploit "fear, tragedy, or critical events" or imply government ties. On Amazon's streaming TV, they must avoid content rated TV-Y, TV-Y7, G, PG and TV-PG. PPC Land noted that the 100 largest media publishers spent an estimated $113m on paid search in July 2026, up 41%.
The buying tools came with new manuals. PPC Land reported that Amazon sizes streaming TV budgets as commitment plus up to five fees. A Budget Calculator in DVA+ advanced sets budget as committed spend plus estimated maximum fees; in PPC Land's example, $100,000 at a $40 floor buys at most 2.5 million impressions. The page gives no fee rates. PPC Land also reported that Amazon allows one measurement vendor per ad study, with no switching later. Seven study types are available, from brand lift to offline sales lift, and once a study starts, its vendor selection cannot be changed. Amazon's launch announcement cites 18 countries, while its availability list names 34.
Amazon also put a number on brand safety. PPC Land reported that Amazon says under 0.1% of DVA ads on outside websites hit unsafe pages. The figure covers only English-language third-party websites on desktop and mobile web, excluding apps, streaming TV and audio. Pages pass through a crawler and two foundation models, one of them Anthropic's Claude, before bids are placed. The method has been submitted to the Media Rating Council but "not accredited as of the date of this document." The rate rests on about 1,000 reviewer-judged pages a day over a month.
Agencies must step back on paperwork. PPC Land reported that Amazon wants the client's legal name, not the agency's, on new ad accounts. Partners are told to enter their advertiser's details rather than their own, so the client's legal identity sits on the account. It describes no verification step and has no change log.
The numbers that will disappear
Disney's results were strong, and it chose that moment to report less. PPC Land reported that Disney will stop reporting streaming profit after an 11.5% margin year. Fiscal 2026 revenue rose 8% to $102.3bn, and Disney+ and Hulu earned $2.57bn in operating income, an 11.5% margin, up from about 6.6% a year earlier. That figure will no longer be published after February 2027. "We no longer believe the supplemental disclosure of SVOD operating income reflects this segment focus and strategy," the shareholder letter said. Advertising across entertainment and sports totalled $11.53bn, up about 4%, with streaming ads of $3.53bn now ahead of networks and virtual pay TV. Adweek reported that Disney posted a blockbuster fourth quarter boosted by sports and Marvel, with revenue up 16%, more than seven points of it from a 53rd week, and a cost programme targeting $3 billion of annual savings by fiscal 2029. Monday Night Football viewership rose 24% over the first nine weeks. AdExchanger reported that Disney touted its streaming success: Disney+ and Hulu merge into one app in December, TikTok creator content arrives next month and a free ad-supported tier is under study. "It's going to give us more ad inventory to sell," said chief executive Josh D'Amaro. AdExchanger added that nearly half of new ad campaigns now run through Disney's agentic ad tool.
Disney's sports streaming affiliate made a similar call. PPC Land reported that FuboTV drops quarterly subscriber reporting at 5.75 million. North American subscribers fell from 6.01 million to 5.75 million over the year, and the company will stop reporting the total from the quarter ending December 31. North American advertising rose 22% to $119.1m after Fubo inventory moved onto the Disney Advertising Server. "All subscribers do not deliver equal returns to the business," the shareholder letter said.
Opera showed how to make more from fewer users. PPC Land reported that Opera loses 5 million users but earns 22% more from each one. Third-quarter revenue rose 20% to $182.8m, with advertising up 22% to $116.8m, while monthly users slipped to 279 million. "As a browser, we are in a great position to benefit from advances in AI without reliance on major CapEx investments," said chief financial officer Frode Jacobsen. In China, PPC Land reported that JD.com cuts marketing spend 26% as food delivery losses halve. Marketplace and marketing revenue, which includes advertising, rose 9.6% to RMB28.1bn. "The rapid growth of advertising also serves as a structural driver of our margin expansion over time," said chief financial officer Ian Su Shan.
Television's case for itself got a fresh study. PPC Land reported that search interest rises 18% when brands return to TV after a year off, the VAB says. "The Comeback Effect" follows 40 brands that left TV for at least a year between 2016 and 2025. Branded search interest rose 18% across 29 brands, website visitors rose 57% across 11 and revenue rose 27% across six, while returning brands more than doubled their TV spend. The report has no control group, so it cannot isolate TV's effect.
Audio is chasing new screens. PPC Land reported that AdTonos drops its name after 10 years to chase in-car ads as Turms. The London programmatic audio firm plans to expand into connected cars, digital out-of-home, retail media and CTV through an agentic buying system still in development. "For ten years, we've shaped the evolution of programmatic audio advertising," said founder Michael Marcinik. PPC Land also reported that news takes 32% of Latin American podcast listening, Triton finds. News makes up 42% of new episodes, Spotify's share of new-episode downloads slipped from 32% to 30%, and Prisa Radio leads with 2.47 million average weekly downloads.
Outdoor screens are following the electric car. PPC Land reported that motorway ad seller i-media wins exclusive rights at Gridserve EV sites, taking its EV-focused network past 1,000 screens. i-media says drivers spend an average of 27 minutes at a charging location, and battery electric cars took 27.5% of UK new car sales in July.
Privacy bills come due
Ignoring a browser signal now has a price tag. PPC Land reported that California fines Hertz $1.55m over unprocessed browser opt-out signals. California's privacy agency found that between July 1, 2023 and August 25, 2026, the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites kept passing visitor data to 13 ad tech companies, including Meta, Google, TikTok and The Trade Desk, despite Global Privacy Control signals. A cookie window on two sites also reverted to allowing advertising cookies. "California law has required businesses to honor opt-out preference signals for more than six years," the order says. Until November 2029, Hertz must check for the signal "before loading tracking technologies" and publish counts of signal-based opt-outs.
Google keeps adding states. PPC Land reported that Google adds Oklahoma and Alabama to its ad privacy tools, now 24 states. Publishers can send restricted data processing signals for those states, along with Louisiana and Vermont, as their laws take effect from January 2027, though Google leaves the decision to publishers and their lawyers. The AdSense state messages page has grown from five states at its June 2024 launch to 24.
European consumers are suing too. PPC Land reported that Booking's parent and Agoda must face a EUR965m Dutch consumer claim. The Amsterdam District Court ruled on October 28 that it has jurisdiction over a collective action alleging that Booking's parity clauses kept hotel prices high and that both platforms used dark patterns. The foundation seeks EUR869m for parity damages and EUR96m for dark patterns on behalf of Dutch residents who booked hotels online since 2013; more than 270,000 have signed up. "Dark patterns, if present, are deployed on the website," the court reasoned. The merits remain undecided.
Brussels turned to Temu again. PPC Land reported that Temu faces an EU fine of up to 6% over checks on unsafe products. The Commission preliminarily found that Temu breached the Digital Services Act by requiring test reports for only a small share of products and sanctioning stores rather than traders. "A trader whose store is closed can therefore keep selling through its other stores," the Commission said. "Shopping online should not mean risking the purchase of illegal and unsafe products," said executive vice president Henna Virkkunen.
Europe's regulators picked their next target. PPC Land reported that the EDPB picks AI candidate screening as its 2027 enforcement target. Its sixth coordinated action will examine automated decision-making in recruitment under the GDPR's Article 22. The board also backed South Korea's continued adequacy, with chair Anu Talus welcoming "amendments in the Korean data protection legislation."
Measurement, retail media and the consoles
The Trade Desk is building its own scorekeeper. PPC Land reported that Trade Desk picks Attain, with 15 million consumers, to anchor ad measurement. Attain, whose apps reward consumers for sharing purchase data, is the first data partner for Open Measurement, due before the end of the year. "Open Measurement is built on real transactions, not self-graded homework," said Kristi Argyilan, The Trade Desk's chief commercial officer, a jab at Amazon and Google. "No single platform or brand has the complete picture," said Attain chief executive Brian Mandelbaum. Neither company disclosed pricing or methodology.
Retail media keeps hiring. Adweek reported that Kroger named Melanie Zimmermann to lead its advertising business. She joins Kroger Precision Marketing from Criteo and previously ran Macy's Media Network from 2020 to 2023, succeeding Christine Foster, who left for The Home Depot. Adweek also reported that ad buyers are embracing retail media's honeymoon with streaming, as TV deals that use shopping data become "a powerful tool."
Shopping ads got stricter and more decorated. PPC News Feed reported that Merchant Center caps sale price annotations: a sale price must now last no more than a month to count as a temporary reduction, a rule previously applied only in some countries. PPC News Feed also reported that Bing ads display third-party website ratings in sponsored results, with Bizrate as one source.
Google's tools are converging. PPC News Feed reported that Google Tag Manager is accessible via Data Manager in Google Ads, so advertisers can manage tags without switching platforms, and that the Google Ads Developer Blog moved to a new platform, with posts since 2024 now on Google for Developers.
Meta handed more choices to its system. PPC Land reported that one Meta ad can now carry up to 5 existing posts, up from one, with Meta choosing which post each person sees. "Meta will then automatically show each person the post they're most likely to engage with," wrote Bram Van der Hallen of Edge.be. Commenters doubted advertisers would learn which post won. "Engagement is applause. A qualified lead is a ticket sold," wrote Ahmed Sultan.
Creators, newsrooms and late nights
The biggest advertisers are now running creator armies. Adweek reported that Unilever's creator roster has grown from 75,000 to 500,000 in two years. Chief marketing officer Leandro Barreto disclosed the figure at the company's Capital Markets Day, following chief executive Fernando Fernandez's March 2025 pledge to move half of digital media spend to social platforms. Unilever spends about $9 billion a year on marketing, roughly 70% of it digital.
Nobody agrees on what to call these people. Digiday reported that the industry still can't agree on what counts as a creator. At least 23% of marketers told the IAB that a shared taxonomy would help. General Mills sorts partners from celebrities to a friends-and-family network, Shutterfly reserves "tastemaker" for accounts above a million followers, and Rothy's classifies by cultural relevance rather than follower count. "That's the blurry line. Who's a mega influencer and who's a celebrity? I don't know anymore," said Mindy Murray of General Mills.
Publishers are buying their way to younger audiences. Adweek reported that NowThis acquired Impact Media in a seven-figure deal. Impact Media, founded by members of Gen Z, runs the @impact and @environment accounts, with more than 4 million followers and 55 million monthly unique viewers. Five of its 12 staff will join NowThis.
Cable news found an audience after midnight. Adweek's TVNewser reported on how Elex Michaelson fills CNN's West Coast gap with The Story Is, which runs from midnight to 2 a.m. Eastern. CNN says total viewership is up 15% since launch and nearly one in four viewers in the Pacific slot are aged 25 to 54. "CNN does a lot of things well, but I think it does breaking news best of all," Michaelson said.
Did you know
Conversion source environment is an Amazon Ads reporting dimension that shows whether an off-Amazon conversion happened on a website, in an app or in a store. Amazon DSP renamed 20 pixel metrics as "Off-Amazon" metrics on October 3, 2022.
Conversion source owner labels each conversion row with the entity whose system reported it, Amazon or an outside partner. On March 18, 2024, Amazon DSP began importing app conversions from Adjust, Kochava and Singular in four markets.
Benchmark campaign goal records the objective Amazon used to group a campaign with peers for benchmarking. The current benchmark product launched in beta in the US on November 18, 2025, and reached 18 countries on May 18, 2026.
Benchmark browse category level shows how deep in Amazon's category tree a benchmark peer group sits. Amazon's March 27, 2026 white paper requires at least five peer brands to build any benchmark.
Paywall is the barrier that hides content until a reader pays. The Wall Street Journal has run a hard paywall in some form since 1996, and the Financial Times introduced a metered model in October 2007.
By the numbers
18.8 points
Drop in clicks to websites among people switched entirely to Google's AI Mode.
PPC Land
$28 million
Ransomware payments the FBI links to the Gootloader SEO poisoning operation.
PPC Land
$1.55m
California's fine on Hertz for ignoring Global Privacy Control signals.
PPC Land
EUR965m
Combined Dutch consumer claim against Booking's parent and Agoda.
PPC Land
Discussion