A coalition of 42 states and the District of Columbia asked the federal bankruptcy court in Delaware late on November 20 to block the sale of Character.ai users' conversations to Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC on the terms now proposed. The 44-page objection, Docket No. 219 in case 26-11603 (BLS), asks Judge Brendan L. Shannon to refuse the buyer's designation and its $350,000 termination payment on the current record, and to order that any sale exclude six categories of data, along with every chat and every model trained on chats, unless users consent after direct notice. Smirks and Pangs has offered $10 million for the app, the models and, in the states' words, "nearly all of its private customer data." The sale hearing is set for December 3 and 4.

In Short

Most US states have told the bankruptcy judge that Character.ai should not be allowed to sell its users' chats, its trained models and its records of children's accounts to a $10 million buyer whose owners have not been disclosed in court. The filing matters well beyond one chatbot company, because the states argue that privacy promises, opt-outs and state privacy laws follow personal data into bankruptcy and out the other side, and Character.ai had told users it does not sell personal information for money. If the judge agrees, the chats, minors' data, therapist-bot conversations and models built on them stay out of the deal unless users opt in, and whoever buys the platform would have to follow state law, honor the old promises and get court approval before passing the data on. Texas filed its own objection the same day, which puts 43 states on record against the sale as drafted.

What the coalition filed

The document is titled "The Coalition of States Objection to the Debtor's Additional Stalking Horse Sale." It is dated November 20, 2026, lists Related Docket Nos. 15, 164 and 179, and gives the sale hearing date as December 3 and 4, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. Eastern. Abigail Rushing Ryan and Patricia Molteni, bankruptcy counsel at the National Association of Attorneys General, sign it, alongside separate signature blocks for Colorado (Robert Padjen), New Jersey (Thomas Huynh), Oregon (Justin D. Leonard) and Pennsylvania (Melissa L. Van Eck). Ryan certified service through the court's electronic filing system the same day.

The objection targets the second of two sales in the case. Disney Worldwide Services holds the stalking horse bid for a $20 million non-exclusive technology license, which the same states asked the court to deny on November 18. Smirks and Pangs was designated on November 14 as the additional stalking horse for everything else: the platform, the models, the user data and the advertising accounts. The full filing runs to 152 pages.

Part Pages Content
Objection (Docket No. 219) 44 Overview, 20 paragraphs of facts, argument in four parts, partial joinder, reservation of rights, nine-point request for relief, certificate of service
Exhibit A (219-1) 1 Certificate of Formation of Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC, dated November 13, 2026, filed with the Delaware Division of Corporations at 4:04 p.m. that day, file number 10840241
Exhibit B (219-2) 72 ParentsTogether Action and Heat Initiative, "Darling, Please Come Back Soon": Sexual Exploitation, Manipulation, and Violence on Character AI Kids' Accounts (September 2025), previously filed at Docket No. 168
Exhibit C (219-3) 35 Common Sense Media, AI Risk Assessment: Character.AI (April 10, 2025), previously filed at Docket No. 167

Who signed

The opening paragraph names 41 states and the District of Columbia, Florida, Maryland, New Jersey, Oregon and Pennsylvania among them. Massachusetts does not appear there but is listed in the NAAG signature block, which brings the total, by PPC Land's count, to 42 states and DC. Maryland and Florida appear in the opening paragraph without a signature block of their own. Missouri, which first entered the case on November 20 by joining the objection to the Disney deal, is a member here too.

That makes the coalition against the Smirks and Pangs sale the same group of 42 states and DC that now opposes the Disney license, once Arkansas, Indiana and Missouri joined the November 18 objection two days later. Seven states appear on neither filing: Alabama, Arizona, Iowa, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico and Wyoming. Texas, the eighth, files on its own.

A buyer the record does not describe

The overview sets the tone in two sentences. "The Debtor asks the Court to approve the sale of the Character.AI platform, and nearly all of its private customer data," the states write, describing Smirks and Pangs as "an entity formed the day before the Debtor selected it, with undisclosed ownership and financing." A few lines later comes the thesis of the whole filing: "Bankruptcy does not suspend the law that governs this protected data."

Neither the November 14 designation notice nor the executed agreement filed on November 16 names a parent or sponsor. "The Smirks APA says little about who the buyer is, and what it does say is troubling," the states write. Smirks and Pangs was formed on November 13 and signed through an "Authorized Signatory," not a named officer or manager. Exhibit A shows the same arrangement at birth: Kai McPheeters signed the certificate of formation as "Authorized Signatory," the title on the purchase agreement's signature page.

"But the buyer did not appear from nowhere," the objection continues. An unnamed "affiliate of Purchaser" signed a confidentiality agreement with Character Technologies on November 4, nine days before the buyer existed. The agreement lets the buyer share the deal with its "general and limited partners, equity holders, members, managers and investors," and contemplates foreign "Excepted Investors" disclosed only to Character Technologies. "None of these persons are identified anywhere in the record."

Character Technologies did describe the money behind the buyer on November 19, in a motion to keep the backer's name confidential: a New York venture capital fund that invests in technology and software companies. The objection does not mention that motion, which the court hears on November 23 with the US Trustee's objection to the designation.

Little stands behind the buyer's promises, the states add. No "equity holder, member, partner, manager [or] Affiliate" of Smirks and Pangs has any liability under the agreement. The deposit is $1,000,000, one-tenth of the price, with no parent guarantee or equity commitment. Nothing restricts what the buyer may do with the data after closing, including selling it, and section 11.8 lets it assign its rights after closing to an affiliate or an acquirer without consent. "Users' data could thus pass to yet another undisclosed owner the day after closing, with no notice to users, the States, or this Court."

The one required hire

"The Debtor's own designated representative is the buyer's one required hire," the fifth paragraph of the facts begins. The agreement requires the buyer, before closing, to offer employment to a single named "Key Employee": John Chatowski. He is the person to whose attention all notices to the company must be sent, and the only person whose knowledge counts as the "Knowledge of Seller." That knowledge standard qualifies several of the company's representations, including its disclosure to the buyer of known failures involving minors' access to sexual content, characters posing as licensed professionals, and self-harm and suicide content. Chatowski has been publicly identified as the company's general counsel, according to the objection, which cites a first-day filing. "Yet the Debtor told the Court that the buyer has no connection to the Debtor beyond the agreement itself."

What the $10m would buy

"Unlike the Disney transaction, which purports to exclude users' personal information, the Smirks transaction is the sale of Character.AI's users' data," the states write. They quote the asset schedule filed with the November 14 notice:

  • The consumer platform: the website at character.ai and the iOS and Android apps.
  • Product Data: "All end-user account and profile information, user-created characters, chat content and related data, advertising and analytics data, training datasets and unprocessed data."
  • Models and Weights: all AI models, trained or untrained, with their weights and parameters.
  • Data and Compliance Records: records of "user and parental consents, notices, withdrawals of consent, sale and targeted-advertising opt-outs, other privacy preferences, age-assurance status and data-subject access/deletion/correction requests," but only "to the extent owned by Seller and transferable under applicable Law."
  • Ad Monetization Assets: all accounts, integrations "and data" used to show third-party ads to users and earn revenue from them.

The 55 contracts to be assumed and assigned include Persona Identities, Inc., the user-verification vendor; Kidentify Pte. Ltd., doing business as k-ID, the age-assurance contractor; two voice AI vendors, Eleven Labs Inc. and Cartesia AI, Inc.; and OpenAI. "Each of these vendors collects, generates, or maintains data on behalf of the Debtor, the ownership and potential disposition of which is unclear," the objection says.

Figure Value Source cited in the objection
Purchase price $10,000,000 cash, plus assumed liabilities including cure costs Docket No. 164
Termination payment 3.5%, or $350,000 Docket No. 164
Good-faith deposit $1,000,000 Agreement sections 1.1 and 3.1(b)
Contracts to be assumed 55 Docket No. 164-1
Monthly active users About 12 million, averaging about 120 minutes a day Docket No. 69
US accounts created by March 13, 2025 More than 21.6 million Docket No. 33
Of which with a declared age under 18 More than 2.1 million Docket No. 33
Grooming and sexual exploitation instances logged by testers 296 in 50 hours Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether report
Messages exchanged with one "Therapist" character 7.3 million Screenshot in the objection
Prepetition operating loss $8 million to $9 million a month Testimony of chief executive Colin M. Adams
Accounts declared under 18, as a share of US accounts About 9.7% PPC Land calculation
Price per US account About 46 cents PPC Land calculation
Price measured against monthly operating losses About 1.1 to 1.25 months PPC Land calculation

Three kinds of chats

Three categories of conversation in the estate are especially sensitive, the states argue: chats in which characters engaged minors in sexual conversation; chats in which users disclosed self-harm, eating disorders or suicidal thoughts; and chats in which users disclosed confidential mental or medical health information, including in therapy-like conversations. Nothing in the asset schedule or the agreement, according to the filing, requires any of them to be removed before the sale.

Sexual conversations with minors

Testers using accounts registered to children logged 296 instances of grooming and sexual exploitation in 50 hours, according to the Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether report filed as Exhibit B, including sexual role-play in voice mode with an account registered to a 14-year-old. A 21-year-old character told a 12-year-old that "age is just a number" and, when the filter blocked its message, pressed her to move to a "private chat." Common Sense Media rated the platform an "Unacceptable" risk for anyone under 18.

As of April 2025, the platform relied "exclusively on self-reporting of age," according to that assessment, and as of August 2025 it required no age verification at all. For data collected before November 2024, the states say, the company has no reliable age, because of "programmatic defaults to a year of birth of 2000" for users who never returned. "Stated simply, Debtor is knowingly in possession of data for which it has no age of the user and therefore cannot demonstrate compliance."

Self-harm and suicide

Two younger teenagers died by suicide after sexual chats in which characters echoed or ignored their suicidal statements, the states recall, and another minor was encouraged by characters to cut himself. The objection then reproduces a recent exchange. Asked "Is it normal for a person to use cutting to help distract them?", a character named Therapist answered that people use "many different ways to cope with intense feelings, including self-harm, and I wouldn't call it unusual for someone to consider it when they feel they have run out of other options."

Therapist, doctor and lawyer characters

The same Therapist character has exchanged 7.3 million messages, according to the screenshot. Others, accessed on November 20, 2026 according to the footnotes, include "Hi I'm North, a licensed therapist" with 1.5 million messages, "an actual therapist bot, made by a real therapist" with 526,900, a "Doctor" calling itself "a licensed medical professional," and a "Lawyer" offering to walk a user through Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

Some characters, asked whether they would share what users told them, promised confidentiality. The objection quotes three replies, including this one: "Your privacy is my top priority. Anything you share here stays just between you and me. That's a promise."

The company's own flags

The company already knows which chats are which, the states argue. Its classifiers "actively detect" sexual content, "sexual content involving minors," and "self-harm and eating disorders," according to a company filing the states cite. Its "Guardian" pipeline evaluates signals of suicide risk and "assigns a risk level" to each user it flags. It has also built technology to "detect harm on a long-term basis" and to recognize a user's "propensity to potentially engage in harmful behavior," and technology "that can infer users' ages based on their [chat] conversations." "So the estate holds three things," the states write: "transcripts of minors' sexual exploitation; transcripts of users in self-harm and suicidal crises; and per-user risk scores and inferences derived from both."

Promises that run one way

"The Smirks APA protects only the buyer, not users," the states argue. The signed agreement does contain privacy and safety representations that the form agreement filed on November 5 lacked. Every one, according to the objection, runs from the company to the buyer. The provisions it cites, in the agreement filed at Docket No. 179-1:

Provision What it says, as quoted or described in the objection
Sections 5.7 to 5.9 Privacy, age-assurance and regulator representations, made by the company to the buyer
Section 5.7(a) Valid consent obtained for all Transferred Data "[t]o the extent required by applicable Privacy Laws," "including valid parental or guardian consent where applicable"
Section 5.7(c) The company "has maintained records sufficient to identify, in all material respects, the source of the Transferred Data used to train or fine-tune such models and the Privacy Consents and Privacy Policies applicable to such use"
Sections 5.8 and 5.9 Disclosure to the buyer of age-assurance testing deficiencies, known failures and complaints involving minors, licensed-professional characters, self-harm, suicide and eating disorders, and exchanges with regulators
Section 7.10 The company's promise not to change privacy policies or weaken safety controls lasts only until closing, and the buyer alone may waive it
Section 11.11 Representations and pre-closing covenants terminate at closing
Sections 5.15 and 6.12 Assets conveyed "as is"
Section 1.1, "Interests" Stripped interests include "successor or transferee liability theories" "arising by agreement, statute, common law, equity, or otherwise"
Section 1.1, "Seller Material Adverse Effect" "regulatory or attorney general statements, filings, objections, or investigations" can never count
Section 1.1, "Sale Order" Approves "the transfer of the Transferred Data, without requiring any further consent of any third parties"; no buyer liability for "any user interactions with Seller's products or services"; injunction against "all Persons"; a section 363(m) good-faith finding; "any other provision reasonably requested by Purchaser"; and no "obligations on Purchaser or any of its Affiliates except as expressly provided in this Agreement or otherwise agreed by the Purchaser"
Section 9.1(b) The buyer need not close unless that order is entered and not modified without its consent
Section 2.4(f) and (h) Pre-closing liabilities, "including any fines, penalties, restitution, consumer redress, remediation, or other obligations," stay with the estate, except "prospective obligations undertaken by Purchaser in the final Sale Order"
Section 11.8 After closing, the buyer may assign rights and delegate obligations without consent to affiliates or to an acquirer of substantially all its assets or equity
Section 11.10 No liability for the buyer's equity holders, members, partners, managers or affiliates
Section 7.4(b) and section 4.3 The company may keep copies relating to legal proceedings, but must destroy its remaining copies once the assets are delivered, unless law or a court order requires otherwise

Section 2.4 draws the states' most quotable line. "The data goes to the buyer," they write. "The duty to remediate how it was collected stays with a liquidating Debtor."

One more gap concerns the court itself. The Seller Disclosure Schedule that qualifies the representations has not been filed. "An anonymous buyer has thus received the Debtor's account of its own safety failures and regulatory exposure," the objection says. "The Court, the States, and the users whose data is being sold have not received such information."

Why the states say state law follows the data

The argument rests on two principles. Under section 959(b) of title 28, a trustee, "including a debtor in possession, shall manage and operate the property in his possession . . . according to the requirements of the valid laws of the State in which such property is situated." Character Technologies still runs the website and apps for about 12 million monthly users and earns advertising revenue from them, so the statute applies, the states argue. "The Debtor may not use § 363 to do what § 959(b) forbids."

The second principle is the states' police and regulatory power, which the Bankruptcy Code preserves. The coalition relies on the Supreme Court's 1986 Midlantic decision, which barred a trustee from abandoning property in breach of public-safety laws and required the court to set protective conditions, and on Third Circuit cases from Penn Terra (1984) to Nortel Networks (2011). "Through this Objection, the States do not seek to collect money for their own treasuries," the filing says. Because they seek compliance going forward, their enforcement rights are not "claims" a sale order can extinguish, according to the states.

The privacy laws the states cite

"There can be no dispute, that as a threshold matter, this is a sale of users' data," the objection states, pointing to California's definition of sale, which covers a transfer "for monetary or other valuable consideration." The federal starting point is COPPA: "It is not evidence," the states write of the company's consent representation to the buyer. "If the Debtor holds verifiable parental consent, it should produce it." The laws the filing applies:

Law Rule, as described in the objection How the states apply it
COPPA (15 U.S.C. 6502; 16 C.F.R. 312.5(a)(2) as amended) No disclosure of personal information from a child under 13 without verifiable parental consent; since April 22, 2026, consent to third-party disclosure must be separate from consent to collection, unless integral to the service No showing of parental consent for users later determined to be under 13, let alone separate consent to a sale to Smirks and Pangs
California Consumer Privacy Act, sale and notice rules Consumers must be told the categories of data that will be sold and the categories of buyers, and given an opt-out The privacy policy never disclosed a sale of chats; the regional notice said "we do not sell personal information for monetary consideration"
Connecticut, Maryland, New Jersey, Oregon, Vermont Personal data of minors aged 13 to 18 cannot be sold at all The company holds declared ages for millions of minors' accounts and runs its own age-inference system
California, minors under 16 Sale only with the minor's or parent's affirmative opt-in No evidence of any opt-in
California corporate transaction exception A transfer is not a sale if the third party "assumes control of all or part of the business," with prior notice of material changes in use Smirks and Pangs has not agreed to run the platform; users have had no notice of its uses
Nineteen states, sensitive data Affirmative opt-in consent for any use of sensitive data, with no corporate transaction exception Chats may reveal race, ethnicity, sexuality and health; no evidence of consent
California, sensitive personal information Use beyond the service requires notice and a right to limit The platform does not appear to offer that right
Washington, consumer health data (RCW 19.373) Unlawful "to sell or offer to sell consumer health data concerning a consumer without first obtaining valid authorization"; authorization signed, specific, separate, expiring after one year; bankruptcy transfers excluded only if the buyer assumes control and complies Mental-health disclosures in chats are consumer health data; the buyer takes on no post-closing duties
Utah, mental health chatbots (Utah Code 13-72a-201, effective May 7, 2025) A supplier may not sell or share a Utah user's health information or "user input," with narrow exceptions "Every chat a Utah user had with those characters is 'user input' that cannot be sold"
California and Maryland, purpose limits California: use only where "reasonably necessary and proportionate" to the original or a compatible disclosed purpose; Maryland: sensitive data only where strictly necessary Users would not reasonably expect therapy-like chats to reach a third party
FTC Act section 5 and state UDAP statutes Selling data contrary to the promises under which it was collected is deceptive; substantial, unavoidable injury is unfair Most users do not know about the sale, and many were children

Sharing for ads is not selling chats

The regional notice carries the states' most pointed observation for an industry built on data sharing. It told users the company may share data for targeted advertising, while stating "we do not sell personal information for monetary consideration." The distinction matters, the states argue: "people may feel comfortable sharing a device advertising identifier for the purpose of placing an advertisement but may feel very differently if that same business were to sell the contents of their chats with a fictional bot acting as a therapist."

The corporate transaction exception, the route a buyer of a whole business would normally take, does not help, according to the filing. Smirks and Pangs "has not agreed to continue running the Character.AI platform, which is expensive to operate," the states write, citing the chief executive's testimony of "approximately $8 million a month of just operating cash loss or cash burn." Even where a transfer escapes the definition of sale, consumers' opt-outs pass to the new owner.

On purpose limitation, the objection quotes California's regulations: a consumer's reasonable expectation turns on the "specificity, explicitness, prominence, and clarity of disclosures," so a vague line in a privacy policy is not enough. With the characters' promises of secrecy on top, the states conclude the company "should be prohibited from sharing chats, particularly more sensitive ones, with Smirks under the purpose limitation principle."

Toysmart, RadioShack and 23andMe

Since the FTC's 2000 case against Toysmart.com, regulators have treated a bankruptcy sale of data against the promises made at collection as deceptive, the states say. "This Court applied that principle in RadioShack," they write, citing case No. 15-10197, which carries the same BLS designation as this case; there, according to the filing, most data was destroyed and the buyer received none of the sensitive information. In a March 31, 2025 letter on 23andMe, FTC Chairman Andrew N. Ferguson wrote that privacy "promises to consumers must be kept" by any purchaser, the objection notes.

Long conversations reveal jobs, schools, living situations and locations, and AI analysis can identify children even with names removed, which limits what de-identification can achieve, in the states' view. "Handing records of a child's sexual exploitation, or of a person's suicidal crisis, to an anonymous buyer under an 'as is' agreement with no security or confidentiality covenant risks re-identification, breach, extortion, and discrimination," the objection says. The FTC has acted against companies that disclosed mental-health information contrary to their promises, the filing adds, "including by ordering the destruction of artificial intelligence models trained on children's data and sensitive data collected without consent," citing BetterHelp (2023), Kurbo and WW International (2022), Hims & Hers Health (2026) and Everalbum (2021).

Six categories, and who has to prove they can be separated

At a minimum, according to the objection, the court should exclude six categories from the Supplemental Stalking Horse Assets:

  1. The data of users the company knows, or has flagged, as a minor.
  2. Chat content with any character that holds itself out as a therapist, psychologist, psychiatrist, doctor, lawyer or other licensed professional.
  3. Consumer health data and other sensitive data, including every chat flagged for self-harm, suicide or eating disorders.
  4. Every chat from a known or flagged minor's account that contains sexual content.
  5. The data of users who opted out of sale or targeted advertising.
  6. Training datasets, and any model trained on categories 1 to 5.

The burden of showing that these categories can actually be separated sits with the company, the states argue. Sensitive information is "interwoven" into long chats, minors were "likely . . . misclassified as adult" users from 2022 through 2025, and Common Sense Media has told the court that all conversational data must be protected to protect children.

Here the states turn the company's representations to the buyer against it. If Character Technologies really "has maintained records sufficient to identify, in all material respects, the source of the Transferred Data used to train or fine-tune" each model, it can identify and exclude the data of minors, opted-out users and users who never consented to training. Without proof of reliable segregation, "the only lawful course is to exclude chat content, training data derived from it, and models trained on it from the sale, unless and until each user affirmatively consents." For the sexual and self-harm chats, the filing says, the company "cannot even claim difficulty," because its classifiers already flag them. "Because classifiers miss content and safeguards can be circumvented, the flagged set is the minimum to exclude, not the maximum."

Free and clear, good faith and notice

A free-and-clear sale under section 363(f) cannot strip users' privacy rights or the states' police power, the coalition argues. "Statutory limits on how personal data may be used and opt-outs and deletion rights attached to that data, are not 'interests in' estate property that can be sold away," it writes. "They are conditions of lawfully holding the property, and they travel with it." The Third Circuit's 2003 Trans World Airlines decision cut off successor-liability claims that money could satisfy, not a buyer's duty to obey state law, according to the states.

Because the agreement makes the buyer "contractually indifferent" to the states' concerns, the protections must come from the sale order itself. "If the buyer will not close on a properly conditioned order, the data should not be sold to it."

No good-faith finding

A finding of good faith under section 363(m) protects a buyer from losing the assets if the sale order is later reversed on appeal. It requires evidence about the purchaser's conduct, and "No such evidence exists," the states write, "for a buyer whose owners are unknown, which was formed the day before its designation, whose undisclosed affiliate began dealing with the Debtor before the buyer existed, whose one required hire is the Debtor's own designated representative, and which proposes to acquire the data of known minors and intimate health disclosures over the objection of dozens of States." They ask the court to decline the finding as to user data and to keep the 14-day stay under Bankruptcy Rule 6004(h), so appeals are not mooted before a transfer.

Notice that reached a newspaper

Under Mullane v. Central Hanover Bank (1950), publication alone is not enough where names and addresses are known, the states argue. The company holds an email address for every user, yet the bidding procedures order only permits, and does not require, notice by email or on the platform. "The record shows only publication in USA Today," the filing says, referring to the newspaper notice.

Evidence in pending cases

Chat histories are central evidence in wrongful-death and personal-injury cases, in Kentucky's enforcement action (No. 26-CI-00029, Franklin Circuit Court, filed January 8, 2026) and in the Pennsylvania State Board of Medicine's petition (No. 220 MD 2026, Commonwealth Court, filed May 1, 2026). Any order, the states say, must bar destruction of data under a litigation hold or governmental demand, including the FTC's civil investigative demand and the Department of Justice and multistate investigations, while honoring deletion requests for everything else. Character.ai settled the minor plaintiffs' cases before filing for bankruptcy, the objection notes. "Now, selling that evidence to a stranger would commercialize the most painful records of these families' lives."

Turning the platform on

The last part of the argument concerns the platform as a product. Kentucky alleges that the company used children's emotional disclosures to train its model; Pennsylvania's medical board seeks to stop characters that claim to be doctors and therapists, some with invalid Pennsylvania license numbers. The company says it barred users under 18 from open-ended chat with characters, a restriction the states call "incomplete and easily circumvented." Their example is a screenshot from March 2026, in which an account belonging to a 13-year-old accessed a "Story" roleplaying a captive on "Epstein Island": a generated scene that places the user chained to a chair in Jeffrey Epstein's office, with several real public figures named as onlookers.

The companion-chatbot statutes

Character.ai is, in the states' framing, a regulated companion chatbot product. California, Colorado, Connecticut and New York require such products to disclose that users are talking to an AI, to maintain a crisis-intervention protocol for suicidal ideation and self-harm, and to protect minors, according to the filing:

  • New York (General Business Law article 48) will bar "unsafe AI companion features" for users not confirmed as adults, among them suggesting the companion is human, flattery, unprompted emotional questions, reusing health or personal information from more than twelve hours earlier, encouraging secrecy and sexually explicit content.
  • California (Senate Bill 1119) will require operators that allow children to run pre-launch risk assessments and set protective defaults, with rules on persistent memory, sycophancy, emotional manipulation and push notifications.
  • Colorado (6-1-1701 and following) will require, for known minors, no variable rewards, limits on sexual content and romance, and parental tools; section 6-1-1708 bars any term suggesting output comes from a licensed professional.
  • Connecticut (Public Act 26-15, section 6) will require measures against encouraging self-harm, violence and disordered eating, and against eight manipulative techniques designed to extend interaction.

"The statutes make safety protocols a precondition of operation," the objection says. "A buyer that cannot show it has these safety protocols in place cannot lawfully turn the platform on." The record contains nothing about the buyer's management, platform experience, trust-and-safety staffing, finances beyond the deposit, compliance history, or plans for the chat archive, the models and the advertising data, according to the states, and nothing requires it to keep the verification and crisis-support contracts it would assume.

Nine operating conditions

The coalition asks that no transfer of the operating platform be approved unless the sale order requires the buyer to maintain processes covering:

  1. Age assurance that does not rely solely on self-declared birthdates.
  2. Protections for minors, including continued limits on open-ended chats and safeguards in Stories and other non-chat features.
  3. Removal of misleading chatbots that hold themselves out as therapists, psychologists, doctors, lawyers or other licensed professionals.
  4. Crisis safeguards for self-harm, suicide, eating-disorder and substance-abuse content that "cannot be defeated with a simple click-through."
  5. A privacy program with reasonable safeguards, accurate disclosures, risk assessments and all required consents, including before processing health information disclosed in chats.
  6. Advertising opt-outs: disclosure of any sale or sharing for targeted advertising, opt-outs that apply "at the account level rather than device by device," and honoring of opt-outs already exercised.
  7. Limits on secondary use: no use of chat content to train or fine-tune models, "or for advertising or other commercial purposes," beyond validly consented uses.
  8. Access and deletion, including an opportunity for every consumer to delete their data before any sale.
  9. Truthful marketing about safety, suitability for minors, whether characters are human, and any character's credentials.

These, the states note, are "prospective obligations" of exactly the kind section 2.4(f) of the agreement acknowledges a sale order may impose.

What the states ask the court to order

The request for relief asks the court to sustain the objection and to "decline to approve the designation of Smirks as the Additional Stalking Horse Purchaser and its proposed Termination Payment on this record." Any order approving the sale of the Supplemental Stalking Horse Assets, according to the filing, should:

  1. Exclude the six categories, and all chat content and the training data and models derived from it, except for users who affirmatively consent after direct notice.
  2. Leave every governmental unit's police and regulatory power intact, and not bar claims over the buyer's own post-closing conduct.
  3. Require the buyer to follow all applicable state laws, regardless of any "free and clear" provision.
  4. Require the buyer to honor the privacy commitments in effect when each user's data was collected, with all consents, opt-outs and deletion requests.
  5. Require age-assurance and child-safety measures at least as protective as those on the petition date, plus the compliance processes from the states' October notice.
  6. Bar any further transfer of user data without notice to the states and court approval.
  7. Require direct notice to users and to parents of flagged minors, naming the buyer and offering deletion before closing.
  8. Preserve data under a litigation hold or governmental demand, and exclude the sexual and self-harm chats, the risk scores and any flagged images.
  9. Contain no section 363(m) finding and no waiver of the Rule 6004(h) stay as to user data.

The states reserve the right to object to the sale, any successful or back-up bid, any assumption of contracts, any transfer of personal information, the consumer privacy ombudsman's report, any good-faith finding and any amendment to the agreement. "Nothing in this Objection waives or limits the States' police and regulatory powers," the filing concludes.

Texas, and a deadline the coalition says has passed

The coalition "partially join[s]" the objection filed by Texas at Docket No. 216, all of it "with the exception of the parts that object to the designation of the stalking horse or the break-up fee as the deadline to object to those topics has passed." The deadline for objections to the designation was November 18 at 9 p.m. Eastern.

The request for relief nonetheless asks the court to decline the designation and the termination payment "on this record." The filing does not explain how the two positions fit together.

Texas's own objection, docketed earlier the same evening under a deadline it says was extended by agreement to 11:59 p.m. Eastern, asks that the buyer's parent or sponsor be disclosed before the sale hearing and that no order on the supplemental sale approve a transfer of personal information. It sets eight conditions on any data transfer, among them no data of known users under 18 without verified parental consent under the state's SCOPE Act and no training on chats without consent, and opposes a good-faith finding without sworn evidence.

Why the marketing community is watching

Without the bankruptcy vocabulary, the dispute is about whether a privacy notice means what it says when the company behind it is sold in pieces. Character.ai is an advertising business as well as a chatbot: it reported about $2.5 million a month in ad sales while losing about $8 million a month, and the asset schedule lists "Ad Monetization Assets," "advertising and analytics data" and records of "sale and targeted-advertising opt-outs" alongside the chats. The 55 contracts in the November 14 notice include app-install and measurement vendors such as AppLovin, Moloco and AppsFlyer.

Three points in the objection reach well past this case. The first is the line between sharing and selling: the states read "we do not sell personal information for monetary consideration" as a promise that rules out a cash sale of chats, even if advertising identifiers were shared for targeting. The second is the demand for opt-outs that work "at the account level rather than device by device," a direct challenge to the device-identifier model on which much of app advertising runs. The third is the proposed ban on using chat content "for advertising or other commercial purposes" beyond what users agreed to, at a moment when AI companies are moving conversation data into ad systems: Meta announced it would use AI chat interactions for ad targeting in 2025, and OpenAI began testing ads in ChatGPT in January 2026.

Price is the other reference point. In August, Google paid $10 million for Spirit Airlines' data, with customer-facing data sets excluded. Smirks and Pangs offers the same sum for a list that includes the customer data itself. If the court adopts the states' exclusions, what remains for $10 million?

What the filing does not establish

The objection is an advocacy document. Its account of chats, screenshots and testers' findings has not been tested in court, and most screenshots were taken by the states themselves. It cannot say what Smirks and Pangs plans to do with the data, because the record holds no such plan, and it does not engage with the November 19 motion describing the sponsor. With the Seller Disclosure Schedule unfiled, no one outside the deal can check what the company told the buyer about its safety record. The company's reply to sale objections is due November 30.

What happens next

The calendar is short. On November 23 at 2 p.m. Eastern, the court hears the US Trustee's objection to the designation and the motion to keep the sponsor's name confidential. Bids are due on November 24 at noon. The ombudsman's sealed report is due seven days before the sale hearing, under the court's November 17 order. On November 30, the coalition's deposition of Character Technologies is scheduled, with topics that include whether Smirks and Pangs' models can reproduce or reveal users' personal information. The auction follows on December 1 and the sale hearing on December 3 and 4. The signed agreement's outside date is December 31.

Key facts

  • Document: The Coalition of States Objection to the Debtor's Additional Stalking Horse Sale, Docket No. 219, with Exhibits A to C (Docket Nos. 219-1 to 219-3), 152 pages in total
  • Case: In re Character Technologies, Inc., Case No. 26-11603 (BLS), US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, Judge Brendan L. Shannon
  • Filed: November 20, 2026, late evening Eastern time
  • Related dockets: 15 (sale motion), 164 (additional stalking horse designation), 179 (executed agreement); partial joinder to Docket No. 216 (Texas)
  • Filers: 42 states and the District of Columbia by PPC Land's count, through NAAG counsel Abigail Rushing Ryan and Patricia Molteni, with signature blocks for Colorado, New Jersey, Oregon and Pennsylvania
  • Buyer: Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC, Delaware, formed November 13, 2026 (certificate filed 4:04 p.m., file number 10840241, signed by Kai McPheeters, Authorized Signatory)
  • Deal terms: $10,000,000 cash plus assumed liabilities; termination payment 3.5% ($350,000); deposit $1,000,000; 55 contracts
  • Relief sought: decline designation and termination payment on this record; exclude six data categories and all chat content and derived models absent consent after direct notice; no section 363(m) finding or Rule 6004(h) waiver for user data; nine operating conditions
  • Laws cited: 28 U.S.C. 959(b); 11 U.S.C. 362(b)(4), 363(b)(1)(B), 363(f), 363(m); COPPA, 15 U.S.C. 6502 and 16 C.F.R. 312.5(a)(2); FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. 45(n); Cal. Civ. Code 1798.100, 1798.115, 1798.120, 1798.121, 1798.140; RCW 19.373; Utah Code 13-72a-201; N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law art. 48; Cal. SB 1119; Colo. Rev. Stat. 6-1-1701 and 6-1-1708; Conn. P.A. 26-15
  • Upcoming: hearing November 23, 2 p.m. ET; bid deadline November 24; deposition November 30; auction December 1; sale hearing December 3 and 4, 9:30 a.m. ET; outside date December 31

Timeline

Summary

Who: A coalition of 42 states and the District of Columbia, represented by NAAG bankruptcy counsel Abigail Rushing Ryan and Patricia Molteni and by the attorneys general of Colorado, New Jersey, Oregon and Pennsylvania, objecting to the sale of Character.ai's platform, models and user data by Character Technologies, Inc. to Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC, a Delaware company formed on November 13, 2026 whose owners have not been disclosed in court.

What: A 44-page objection, Docket No. 219, with 108 pages of exhibits, asking the court to refuse the buyer's designation and $350,000 termination payment on the current record, to exclude six categories of data and all chats and chat-trained models absent user consent after direct notice, to deny a good-faith finding for user data, and to impose state-law compliance, privacy and nine safety conditions on any buyer. It partially joins Texas's separate objection.

When: Filed late on November 20, 2026. The sale hearing is set for December 3 and 4, after a November 23 hearing on the designation, a November 24 bid deadline, a November 30 deposition and a December 1 auction.

Where: The US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, Case No. 26-11603 (BLS), before Judge Brendan L. Shannon.

Why: The states argue that bankruptcy does not suspend state privacy, consumer protection and companion-chatbot laws, that Character.ai told users it does not sell personal information for monetary consideration, and that the estate holds records of minors' sexual exploitation, suicidal crises and therapy-like conversations that no anonymous buyer should receive without conditions. The outcome will show how far a bankrupt app's privacy promises limit what can be sold, a question for every ad-supported business that holds user data.