A website that switched off Google's generative AI features through Search Console has lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions with barely any noticeable change in clicks, according to Brodie Clark, an independent SEO consultant and co-founder of SERP Lens, who described the result in a LinkedIn post today. The site, which Clark did not name, used the Search generative AI control that Google says it rolled out to all websites worldwide on August 31, 2026. Clark published no click figures, no dates for the switch and no traffic chart. The only image in the post shows the Search Console banner that confirms the exclusion.
In Short
A site owner used a Search Console setting to take a website out of Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, and the site lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions while its clicks barely changed, according to SEO consultant Brodie Clark. Publishers and brands weighing the same switch have had almost no public evidence of what it does in practice, so even a single unnamed case draws attention. Google's AI report in Search Console still shows impressions but no clicks, which keeps the trade-off hard to measure until the click data the UK competition regulator requires starts to flow.
What the post says
The post is four short paragraphs and one image. It opens with a reaction rather than a number. "This has been pretty eye-opening to witness," Clark wrote.
The second paragraph sets out what happened. "This site has completely excluded itself from generative AI features (AI Overviews and AI Mode) using the new AI controls in GSC." GSC is Google Search Console, the free tool Google provides for site owners to monitor how their pages perform in Search.
The third paragraph carries the finding. "Hundreds of thousands of daily impressions are gone. The result on clicks? Barely even noticeable."
The last line is a verdict on Google rather than on the site. "Google really needs to figure out how to make its AI features more valuable to websites."
The image beneath the text shows the Search Console page titled "Generative AI features," marked with a grey "Beta" label and an "Export" button. A banner, highlighted in yellow, reads: "Your property is excluded from generative AI features on Google Search." Next to it sit a "Learn more" link and a blue "Include" link that would reverse the setting. The date selector below offers 24 hours, 7 days, 28 days and 3 months, with 3 months selected, and the page reports "Last update: 7.5 hours ago." No chart, metric or site name is visible.
That is the full extent of the evidence. The post gives a direction, impressions down sharply and clicks roughly flat, and a scale, "hundreds of thousands" of impressions a day. Everything else has to be inferred or checked against Google's documentation.
What the control does, in Google's words
The setting Clark refers to is the "Search generative AI control." Its Search Console Help page lists three features it governs: AI Overviews, AI Mode and "Generative AI features in Google Discover." Clark's post names only the first two. Under Google's documentation, an exclusion also covers the third, so the site presumably dropped out of Discover's generative AI features as well, though the post says nothing about Discover traffic. Google adds that it expects "to update this list over time as we develop Google Search."
The Help page defines the two main choices in plain terms.
| Setting | Google's description | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Include | "Your site's content can appear in Search generative AI features, including showing up as links and helping to ground AI responses in these features." "Your site can receive impressions and traffic from these features." | "This is the default control for all properties." |
| Exclude | "Your site's content is prevented from being visible to users in Search generative AI features, including being linked to within these features and helping with grounding AI responses in these features." "You won't receive any traffic or impressions from these features." | Not a default |
| Inherit control from parent | "Your property is following the Search generative AI control value of its parent property." "Any changes made at the parent level will automatically apply to your property too." | "This is the default if your property has a parent property." |
The exclusion goes further than hiding links. According to the same page, "Content crawled from your site won't be eligible to be used as an input to generate an AI response" or a preview in those features. In other words, an excluded site stops contributing to grounding, the process by which an AI answer is tied to retrieved web content, as well as losing its citations.
Google also spells out what the setting does not touch.
| Area | What Google's Help page says |
|---|---|
| Ranking elsewhere in Search | The control "isn't used as a ranking or inclusion signal affecting other parts of Search." |
| Use of content in Search generally | "Your site's content may still be used to power Google Search as a whole." |
| AI model training | "This control doesn't affect AI training; to limit training of the models used to generate responses in Search generative AI features, use Google-Extended." |
| Merchant Center and Google Ads | "This control doesn't override publishers' other choices to participate in particular services, such as Merchant Center and Google Ads." |
| Removal from Search entirely | "To block your content from appearing in Google Search completely, use noindex." |
| Other sites | "Content from other sites will still be available in those features, and it may appear similar to yours." |
That last line matters for any reading of Clark's result. The AI Overview or AI Mode answer does not disappear when one site leaves. The query still gets an answer, built from other sources.
How the control works
According to Google's Search Console Help documentation, the control works in six steps.
- Location. The setting sits "under Settings > Search generative AI in Search Console."
- Choice. The property owner picks Include, Exclude or Inherit control from parent. Include is the default for all properties, and Inherit is the default for a property that has a parent.
- Property hierarchy. Google names three parent types: a top-level domain property, a subdomain property and a URL-prefix property. A property inherits from "its closest parent that has changed its control to stop inheriting," and otherwise follows its top-level domain property.
- Overrides. Owners of a child property can follow the parent's setting or change it "for the specific child property and its subpages." Owners of the top-level domain property see a notification on the control page when a child property overrides the parent.
- Timing. "Once you change your control in Search Console, it generally takes a few days for your site's content to be excluded from the applicable Search generative AI features." Google adds that content "will be excluded within 1-2 days after the control goes live," but some may take longer "due to caching and propagation across Google systems." The page gives no separate timing for switching back to Include.
- Measurement. Google points site owners to the Generative AI performance report, which it says "can help you get an idea of how changing your control may impact traffic to your site."
The Help page does not state which Search Console permission level is needed to change the setting.
Why impressions fell and clicks did not move
The sixth step is where Clark's anecdote gets complicated. The report Google recommends for judging the impact cannot, on its own, show the impact on clicks.
Google's Help page for the Generative AI performance report (Search) defines its only metric this way: "Impressions are how many times links to your site were shown to a user in a generative AI feature on Google Search." The report covers AI Overviews and AI Mode and can be broken down by pages, countries, dates and devices. When Google launched it, PPC Land reported that Google finally gave Search Console its own generative AI visibility reports with five data categories, none of them clicks or queries. Today's Help page still lists no click data.
So the click side of Clark's comparison must come from somewhere else. The post does not say where. The obvious candidate is the main Performance report, where AI feature data is not separated out: PPC Land reported in June 2025 that Google AI Mode began counting toward Search Console totals, merged into web search figures, and Google's June 2026 announcement said generative AI impressions were included in the overall performance data. If that is the source, the flat line Clark describes would be the site's total clicks from Search, not a measured count of clicks that once came from AI answers.
There is also a piece of arithmetic worth stating. Because AI impressions sit inside the overall totals, removing hundreds of thousands of them a day while clicks hold steady would push the site's reported click-through rate up in Search Console, with no change in how many people actually visited. That is PPC Land's observation from Google's documentation, not a figure Clark reported.
The comments under the post turned to what those lost impressions were in the first place. Arash Kamyab, founder and chief executive of IndexLLM, argued they were never worth much. "Not surprised clicks barely moved. Most of those lost impressions were just AI Mode fanout and scrapers anyway, not real eyeballs," he wrote.
Daniel Kovacik, a global technical SEO specialist at Mann+Hummel, disagreed on the mechanics. "In my understanding, fan-outs, unlike scraping, do not generate impressions, only real citations do," he wrote. Fan-out refers to the extra background searches AI Mode runs to assemble an answer. Kovacik added that such citations tend to appear on informational, non-branded queries, where the chance of a click was low even before AI features.
Google's definition sides with neither comment explicitly. It counts links "shown to a user," which describes a person seeing a result rather than a background query, but the Help page does not mention fan-out at all and does not say whether a link must be scrolled into view to count. Who or what produced those impressions therefore cannot be settled from Google's documentation or from the post.
How the anecdote fits the wider data
A single site with stable clicks after leaving AI features fits a body of research suggesting AI answers send relatively few visitors onward. It does not prove that pattern, and Google disputes the broader conclusion.
| Study | Published | Sample | Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ahrefs (Ryan Law, Xibeijia Guan) | February 2026 | 300,000 keywords, Search Console data, December 2025 vs December 2023 | AI Overviews correlate with a 58% lower CTR for top-ranking pages; position-one CTR fell from 0.073 to 0.016 |
| Saharsh Agarwal (Indian School of Business) and Ananya Sen (Carnegie Mellon) | Paper revised June 17, 2026 | 1,065 desktop Chrome users, 68,089 searches, January 7 to February 10, 2026 | Outbound organic clicks fell 39.8% when an AI Overview appeared; zero-click searches rose 34.5% |
| Seer Interactive | November 4, 2025 | 3,119 queries across 42 organisations | Organic CTR on informational queries with AI Overviews fell 61%; paid CTR fell 68% |
PPC Land covered the Ahrefs figures when it reported that Google's AI summaries now swallow 58% of clicks that once went to websites. The randomised experiment was the subject of researchers finding Google AI Overviews cut publisher clicks 39.8%. In that study AI Overviews appeared on about 41% of observed queries, and engagement measures such as bounce and time on page showed no difference between groups.
The Seer figures surfaced in coverage of how Google began exploring opt-out controls for AI search after the UK regulator demanded change in January.
Google's own account runs the other way. On July 17, 2026, Nick Fox, Google's senior vice president of knowledge and information, wrote on X that Google sends billions of clicks a week to websites through AI features in Search, a claim PPC Land noted came without a denominator when Google touted billions of weekly AI Search clicks as CTR data dropped 58%. In February, Arun Venkataraman, who leads Google's news research partnerships, said Google's internal data showed overall search referrals had not decreased.
Clark's site is consistent with the research rather than with Google's framing: the AI features generated large impression counts and, by his account, very few visits. Whether the same holds for a news publisher, a retailer or a local business is a different question, and the broad rise in zero-click searches does not settle it.
Publishers, brands and the value of a mention
Kamyab's comment drew the line that most of the discussion turned on. "Easy call for publishers to opt out. Way trickier for product brands though, since you still need the mention in the answer even if you aren't getting the click," he wrote.
Jan-Willem Bobbink, a freelance enterprise SEO and developer, asked what the site was trying to achieve. "For website or for generating more revenue via Ads? So do they really care about clicks?" he wrote.
The two comments frame the trade-off the control forces. A site that earns its money from page views loses little, on Clark's evidence, by leaving AI answers that send few visitors. A brand that wants to be named when an AI answer recommends products or explains a category loses the mention itself, and under Google's documentation a competitor's content "may appear similar" in its place. The setting is all or nothing at the property level, with page-level controls not due until 2027.
Clark himself did not expect many sites to make this choice. When the report and control first appeared in June, he wrote on his own site that he doubted even 1% of sites would use the blocking mechanism. Today's post does not say whether the site was his client.
The road to the switch
The control exists because of a UK regulatory decision, and its history explains why measurement lags behind it.
Google first said it was exploring opt-out controls for Search generative AI features on January 28, 2026, after the Competition and Markets Authority proposed conduct requirements. On February 11, Sulina Connal, Google's managing director for news and books partnerships in Europe, called the work a "huge engineering project," PPC Land reported in its piece on how Google said letting publishers skip AI Overviews was a huge engineering challenge.
On June 3, 2026, the CMA imposed its Publisher Conduct Requirement under section 19(1) of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, a decision covered when the UK regulator forced Google to give publishers AI opt-out rights. The same day, Google reacted to the UK order with a Search Console AI opt-out toggle, testing it with a subset of UK site owners. On July 20, Google gave site owners a toggle to exit AI Overviews and AI Mode through formal Help documentation. According to Google's Help page, the control reached all websites worldwide on August 31, 2026.
| Date | Milestone |
|---|---|
| January 28, 2026 | Google says it is exploring opt-out controls for Search generative AI features |
| June 3, 2026 | CMA imposes the Publisher Conduct Requirement; Google begins testing the control and the generative AI reports with a subset of sites |
| July 20, 2026 | Google publishes Help documentation for the control |
| August 31, 2026 | Control rolled out to all websites worldwide, according to Google |
| December 3, 2026 | Substantive obligations of the CMA requirement take legal force |
| January 3, 2027 | First CMA compliance report due |
| March 3, 2027 | Page-level grounding controls due after a nine-month implementation period |
| October 10, 2030 | CMA requirement runs until this date |
The December date is the one that bears directly on Clark's post. Paragraph 7 of the CMA requirement calls for publisher metrics including impressions, click-throughs and click-through rate, delivered through a platform such as Search Console, according to PPC Land's reporting on the decision. The CMA did not require separate figures for AI Overviews and AI Mode, after Google argued the two work as a unified experience. Once that data exists, a site that excluded itself would at least have a baseline for what it gave up, which today it does not.
What the post leaves out
Clark did not identify the site, its sector or country, the date it switched the control, the period compared, or any click or impression totals. The post does not mention Discover, conventional rankings or revenue, and it shows no chart. The account is a single observation from one consultant, with the scale of the impression loss described only as "hundreds of thousands" a day.
Key facts
- Source: LinkedIn post by Brodie Clark, independent SEO consultant and co-founder of SERP Lens, published today (November 22, 2026). URL: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/brodieclark_this-has-been-pretty-eye-opening-to-witness-share-7530248033167519744-sYJ8/
- Reported result: "Hundreds of thousands of daily impressions are gone." Clicks: "Barely even noticeable." No site named, no figures published.
- Control name: Search generative AI control, at Settings > Search generative AI in Google Search Console
- Features covered: AI Overviews, AI Mode and generative AI features in Google Discover
- Settings: Include (default for all properties), Exclude, Inherit control from parent (default for properties with a parent)
- Exclusion timing: "generally takes a few days"; content excluded "within 1-2 days after the control goes live," with possible caching delays
- Global availability: "As of August 31, 2026, we've rolled out this control to all websites worldwide," according to Google
- Not affected, per Google: ranking elsewhere in Search, AI training (governed by Google-Extended), Merchant Center and Google Ads participation
- Google documentation: Search Console Help, "Search generative AI control" (support.google.com/webmasters/answer/16908024) and "Generative AI performance report (Search)" (support.google.com/webmasters/answer/16984139); neither page shows an update date
- Report shown in the post: "Generative AI features," labelled "Beta," banner text "Your property is excluded from generative AI features on Google Search."
- Metric available: impressions only; no clicks or queries in the generative AI report
- Regulation: CMA Publisher Conduct Requirement, imposed June 3, 2026 under section 19(1) of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024; obligations in force December 3, 2026; page-level controls March 3, 2027
Timeline
- June 17, 2025: AI Mode begins counting toward Search Console totals, merged into web search data
- November 4, 2025: Seer Interactive reports a 61% organic CTR drop on informational queries with AI Overviews
- January 7 to February 10, 2026: Randomised field experiment on AI Overviews runs with 1,065 Chrome users
- January 28, 2026: Google says it is exploring opt-out controls for Search generative AI features
- February 4, 2026: Ahrefs finds AI Overviews correlate with a 58% lower CTR for top-ranking pages
- February 11, 2026: Google's Sulina Connal calls publisher opt-outs a "huge engineering project"
- June 3, 2026: CMA imposes the Publisher Conduct Requirement; Google starts testing the Search Console opt-out toggle and launches generative AI performance reports
- July 1, 2026: Agarwal and Sen study finds a 39.8% drop in outbound organic clicks
- July 17, 2026: Google's Nick Fox says AI features send billions of clicks a week
- July 20, 2026: Google publishes Help documentation for the opt-out control
- August 31, 2026: Google completes the rollout of the control to all websites worldwide
- November 22, 2026: Brodie Clark reports that a site lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions after excluding itself, with clicks barely changed
- December 3, 2026: CMA requirement's substantive obligations take legal force
- January 3, 2027: First CMA compliance report due
- March 3, 2027: Page-level grounding controls due
Related PPC Land coverage
- Google gives site owners a toggle to exit AI Overviews and AI Mode - details the include, exclude and inherit settings and the one-to-two-day exclusion window.
- Google reacts to UK order with a Search Console AI opt-out toggle - covers the UK-first test of the toggle and the CMA's 2026 and 2027 deadlines.
- UK regulator forces Google to give publishers AI opt-out rights today - sets out the Publisher Conduct Requirement, including the click metrics in paragraph 7.
- Google finally gives Search Console its own generative AI visibility reports - describes the impressions-only reports launched on June 3, 2026.
- Google AI Mode now counts toward Search Console totals - explains how AI Mode data was merged into web search totals in June 2025.
- Researchers find Google AI Overviews cut publisher clicks 39.8% - reports the randomised field experiment with 1,065 Chrome users.
- Google's AI summaries now swallow 58% of clicks that once went to websites - covers the Ahrefs analysis of 300,000 keywords.
- Google touts billions of weekly AI Search clicks as CTR data drops 58% - sets Nick Fox's claim against independent click-through research.
- Google says letting publishers skip AI Overviews is a huge engineering challenge - records Google's February remarks and publisher criticism.
- Google eyes opt-out controls for AI search after UK regulator demands change - covers Google's first statement that it was exploring AI search opt-outs.
Summary
Who: Brodie Clark, an independent SEO consultant and co-founder of SERP Lens, reporting on an unnamed website that used Google's Search generative AI control. The case concerns publishers, brands and SEO teams deciding whether to stay in Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode.
What: The site excluded itself from Google's generative AI features through Search Console and, according to Clark, lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions while clicks were "barely even noticeable." Clark gave no figures, dates or site name. Google's generative AI report shows impressions but not clicks, so the click side of the comparison cannot be checked from that report.
When: Clark posted the account today, November 22, 2026. The control reached all websites worldwide on August 31, 2026, and UK click metrics required by the CMA are due from December 3, 2026.
Where: In Google Search Console, under Settings > Search generative AI, with effects on AI Overviews, AI Mode and generative AI features in Google Discover. The post appeared on LinkedIn.
Why: The case matters because it is one of the few public accounts of what the opt-out does to a real site, and because Google still withholds the click data that would show what AI features are worth to the sites they cite. Clark concluded that Google "really needs to figure out how to make its AI features more valuable to websites."
Discussion