A Senate Judiciary subcommittee spent more than two hours on November 17, 2026 examining Roblox, the gaming platform where, by the company's own February count, 35% of age-checked daily users are younger than 13. Four witnesses testified, and none of them represented the company. Their written statements converged on one piece of contract language: the binding, individual and confidential arbitration clause that sits more than 9,000 words into Roblox's terms of use, which Roblox is now invoking against children who say they were groomed and exploited on its service.

In Short

Senators heard from two survivors who say they were groomed through Roblox as children, a lawyer from the National Center on Sexual Exploitation and a Northwestern law professor, while Roblox sent no witness. The testimony targeted Roblox's arbitration clause, which the company is using to try to move hundreds of child abuse lawsuits out of public court, and chat features that witnesses say sit outside Roblox's own safety settings. For brands, agencies and ad tech firms building on Roblox's young ad business, the hearing adds legislative risk, with bills on arbitration, platform liability and child safety all named in the record.

The hearing and who was in the room

The Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism convened at 2:30 pm on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, under the title "Roblox and Online Gaming: Digital Playgrounds Endangering America's Children." A location change moved it to Room G50 of the Dirksen Senate Office Building. The archived video runs two hours, 11 minutes and 13 seconds. Every written statement is addressed to "Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, and distinguished members of the Subcommittee." The full committee itself dates to a Senate resolution of December 10, 1816, which created it as one of the chamber's original standing committees.

The hearing page lists four witnesses. No one from Roblox Corporation or Discord appears among them. Roblox chief executive David Baszucki was invited to testify and declined, according to CBS News, which also reported a statement from a Roblox spokesperson describing the claims against the company as misleading and pointing to mandatory age checks for chat, age-based content limits, a ban on sharing photos or videos through chat, and continuous chat monitoring and filtering. According to the same report, Hawley and Durbin introduced a bill titled the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act a day before the hearing. CBS did not give a bill number.

Witness Listed role Written statement Main request to Congress
Michael Schlep Survivor and online safety advocate, Texas 4 pages, submitted November 16 Hold Roblox "publicly accountable" and stop forced arbitration of abuse claims
Woody Doe Survivor and online safety advocate, Texas; US Marine Corps veteran 3 pages, submitted November 16 Protect survivors' right to seek accountability in court
Khari James Senior Legal Counsel, National Center on Sexual Exploitation (NCOSE) Oral statement, written statement dated November 17, and the May 20, 2026 Fairplay and NCOSE request to the FTC as Exhibit A Chat limited to age-verified adults; COPPA, KOSA, STOP CSAM Act and Section 230 reform
Myriam Gilles Catharine Waugh McCulloch Professor of Law, Northwestern Pritzker School of Law 14 pages, 76 footnotes, submitted November 16 Pass the FAIR Act or any bill that bars forced arbitration of children's claims

What follows is testimony. Each account and figure below is a witness's claim or a figure the witness attributes to a named document, not a finding by the subcommittee or a court.

The clause at the centre of the case

Gilles has testified on forced arbitration before the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2013, 2017, 2019 and 2024. This appearance, the written statement says, was different. "I never expected to appear before this body to describe the use of forced arbitration against nine-year-olds."

According to Gilles, Roblox's Terms of Use, in the version effective April 30, 2026, run to nearly 14,000 words. The user terms alone exceed 13,800 words, and together with the creator terms and appendices that the user terms say "apply to all Users," the document runs to 94 pages. Section 11 sits more than 9,000 words in. Gilles called it "a catalog of the devices I have described to this Committee in the past, now deployed against children."

What Section 11 says

Provision Section Wording as quoted in the testimony
Scope 11, 11(b)(i) Any dispute "arising under or relating in any way to" the Terms "or the Services" goes to "binding, individual arbitration"
Secrecy 11(b)(iv) "[T]he arbitration proceeding and all records pertaining to it - including ... the hearing, the decision, and the arbitration award - will be confidential."
Delegation 11(b)(vii) The arbitrator has "exclusive authority" to decide whether the agreement is "void or voidable"
Claim-splitting 11(b)(viii) A claim a court finds non-arbitrable "must be severed"; the rest still goes to arbitration
Pre-filing steps 11(a)(i)-(v) Written notice to Roblox's legal department by certified mail or Federal Express, then a "Mandatory Informal Dispute Resolution" process of up to 60 days; a claim filed without it "shall be deemed frivolous"
Time limit 11(c) "[A]ny cause of action arising out of or related to the Services must commence within one (1) year after the cause of action arises or it is permanently barred."
Opt-out 11(b)(ix) A signed "Arbitration Opt-Out Notice" mailed within 30 days of first signing up
Mass claims 11(b)(iv) A special "mass arbitration" framework applies when five or more claims are filed by coordinated counsel

On the opt-out, the testimony is blunt: "It is extraordinarily unlikely that any nine-year-old in America has ever done so." On the one-year limit, Gilles points out that children often disclose abuse years later, and that Congress eliminated the limitations period for civil cases brought by child victims of federal sex offenses in 2022.

What changed on November 1

The testimony records how the contract attached to children before and after Roblox's latest update. Under the April 2026 version, the preamble required every user to "affirm[] that [they] have reached the legal age of majority" and stated that "[b]y permitting a minor to use the Services, a minor's parent or guardian becomes subject to the Roblox Terms." Gilles argued that Roblox knew the first statement was false for most of its users, because its own data said so.

The terms effective November 1, 2026 drop the age-of-majority affirmation. According to the testimony, sections 2.1 and 2.1.1 permit accounts for "[u]sers ages 5 and older," require that a minor's "parent or legal guardian must accept these Roblox Terms on your behalf," and state that "by allowing your minor to use the Services, you are also subject to the Roblox Terms." The children now in court signed up under the older wording, and Gilles told senators that "Roblox is holding them to every word." In one wrongful-death case filed in the Eastern District of Kentucky, Roblox maintains that a girl who first clicked "I agree" at eight and died by suicide at 13 bound herself and her parents to arbitration, and agreed again more than a dozen times, including each time Robux were bought.

The litigation strategy

According to Gilles, Roblox and Discord have moved to force arbitration in every case in which they are named. In the federal multidistrict litigation in San Francisco, In re Roblox Corp. Child Sexual Exploitation & Assault Litigation, MDL No. 3166, Roblox filed an omnibus motion to compel arbitration on September 22, 2026 (ECF No. 452). The two companies proposed a "bellwether" process for those motions and asked that all discovery be stayed until they are resolved. Two co-defendants took a different position. The motion itself records that "Defendants Snap and Meta do not at this time intend to move to compel arbitration." Roblox and Discord also suggested that if they succeed, "the rationale for a MDL may no longer hold."

Discord's arguments in a separate California case drew the sharpest language. The case concerns a 10-year-old girl who, according to the testimony, was groomed on Roblox, moved to Discord and kidnapped. Discord told the San Mateo County Superior Court that "minors have capacity to contract under California law" and that "[f]ailing to read and understand the Terms is immaterial." It argued that she had assented to its terms "on at least three separate occasions, including after filing suit." The trial court denied the motion on February 20, 2026 and called one Discord argument a "hyper-literal, hair-splitting argument." Another San Mateo court had denied a similar motion on November 13, 2025. Both companies appealed, according to Gilles, and Senators Durbin, Blumenthal and Gillibrand filed an amicus brief in the California Court of Appeal on August 28, 2026, arguing that the 2022 law was meant to reach exactly these cases.

Not every court has ruled for families. Gilles cites Garcia v. Roblox Corp., in which the Central District of California compelled arbitration on February 11, 2026, and a law firm alert published 13 days later under the title "Recent Decision Provides a Roadmap to Compel Arbitration of Claims Asserted by Minors." Under the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Coinbase v. Bielski, an appeal from a denied motion to compel automatically stays the case. "The upshot," Gilles wrote, "is that a company can freeze a child's case for a year or more simply by filing a motion to compel arbitration, losing it, and filing a notice of appeal."

Why the 2022 law does not settle it

Congress passed the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) in 2022, and Gilles credits it as the reason the two California courts could deny the motions. The testimony identifies four gaps. The law may not clearly reach exploitation that happens entirely online, such as coerced images or sextortion without physical contact. Courts are split on whether it reaches platforms rather than assailants or employers. It does not clearly cover claims without sexual misconduct, such as self-harm or wrongful death. And companies are testing its edges, as Discord did by arguing that a new account opened after filing suit created a fresh agreement.

Gilles then set out what any new law would need to do. The written statement announces five requirements and lists six: reach the platform whatever the harm; disregard a parent's purported agreement; leave the question of coverage to judges; keep cases whole rather than split claim by claim; apply to cases already pending; and allow only genuinely voluntary arbitration agreed after a dispute arises. The testimony ties this to the STOP CSAM Act, which would create a civil remedy against platforms that knowingly or recklessly host child sexual abuse material. "The forced arbitration fix is not an add-on to Congress's child-safety agenda; it is the precondition for that agenda to work."

Two survivors, one currency

Robux, Roblox's virtual currency, runs through both survivors' accounts.

Woody Doe served six years in the Marine Corps and is the father of four children under seven. "I was just 11 years old when I was groomed and sexually assaulted by a man I met on Roblox," the statement says. After an administrator removed him from a group whose games used virtual items bought with Robux, another player offered help. "Chris told me I could rejoin the group if I paid Robux. When I told him I didn't have any money, he offered to pay for me if I would send him pictures of myself." Threats followed. According to the testimony, the man gave an address in Venus, Texas, where he assaulted Doe, who then deleted everything connected to Roblox and stayed silent for years.

Doe now has a lawsuit pending against Roblox. "Hundreds of other families have filed similar cases and many of those families are sitting behind me today," the statement reads. On the contract question, it adds: "I am also deeply concerned that Roblox is trying to force many of these cases out of public courtrooms and into secret forced arbitrations." As a parent, Doe monitors the games his children play. "But I know firsthand that even the most attentive parents cannot always see the dangers their children encounter online." The statement closes with two lines: "What happened to me lasted only a short time. The impact has lasted most of my life."

Michael Schlep started playing at eight. "They thought Roblox was a safe, educational game designed for children. That's literally how it was marketed," the statement says of Schlep's parents. At around 12, Schlep met an adult developer named Kevin, who went by the username "Ripull," in an official Roblox chat room. According to the testimony, Kevin made Schlep a "community manager" of his games, sent violent and sexual material, and extorted Schlep by publishing private confidences.

Part of Schlep's account concerns marketing. "Kevin was influential on Roblox. The company even produced an official toy of his avatar, sold in stores across the country." Roblox television commercials showed the same avatar, "constantly reminding me how much power, credibility, and influence my abuser had." After a suicide attempt, Schlep's mother contacted Roblox "and received nothing more than an auto-written response directing her to the suicide hotline."

Schlep later built a YouTube following around a Roblox roller coaster game, then started a second channel, "Schlep," dedicated to exposing predators on the platform. One trigger, according to the testimony, was a $1.6 million lawsuit Roblox filed against Benjamin Simon, one of its most vocal critics on child safety. Schlep testified to finding "predators, sexting groups, porn games, and even child sexual abuse material (CSAM) rings," and said that "Roblox was profiting off the content since this material was being bought and sold with the platform's own currency, Robux." Working with a predator-catching group that, according to the testimony, has more than 400 convictions across the country, Schlep says the evidence gathered over 10 months identified six predators, led to four convictions and produced one five-year prison sentence. Reports to Roblox, by contrast, drew "generic responses telling me to block the predators I identified." Then, on August 8 (the testimony gives no year), Schlep received a cease-and-desist letter from Roblox. It said every account Schlep owned would be terminated. "They also threatened to sue me for computer fraud if I ever accessed their website again." Schlep also testified that "Roblox's chief safety officer Matt Kaufman compared me to child predators." Shortly after that dispute became public, the testimony says, Louisiana's attorney general announced a lawsuit; Louisiana filed its suit on August 14, 2025.

The design case against Roblox

James's testimony for NCOSE moves from individual cases to product design. "Roblox is not simply a video game," the oral statement says. It describes "a billion-dollar virtual world made up of millions of individual games, where children can communicate, and interact with adult strangers."

The central claim concerns a carve-out in Roblox's own help documentation. According to James, Roblox states that users must confirm their age through facial age estimation or ID verification to chat. But, James testified, the parental controls page also states that "these settings do not apply to chat features developed independently by developers." Developers can build their own chat systems inside experiences, and NCOSE says those systems can look identical to Roblox's native chat. "This is a critical loophole," the oral statement says. "Roblox cannot claim to protect children through age verification while allowing developers to build features that bypass those very protections." NCOSE and Fairplay first identified the gap during research in January 2026, according to the testimony, and found it still open in November 2026.

NCOSE's adult researchers, all over 30, say they created accounts posing as five-year-olds without parental consent or age verification. On those accounts, party chat and the ability to be added to party groups were on by default, even though age-based restrictions appeared to apply to experience chat. The testimony also says five-year-old accounts were steered toward experiences involving romantic roleplay, "home alone" scenarios and one featuring "get your death penalty."

Content and parental controls by age, as described by NCOSE

Age band Experiences available Chat Parental control
5 to 8 Rated "Minimal" or "Mild" Off by default unless age-verification and parent-linking requirements are met Parents can manage all settings through age 12 in most regions
9 to 12 "Minimal," "Mild" or "Moderate" Subject to age verification Same as above
13 to 15 "Minimal," "Mild" or "Moderate" Subject to age verification Some controls shift to the child; parents keep select settings
16 to 17 All content-rating categories On by default Parents lose most settings; limited view of activity and spending
18 All On by default Parent account automatically unlinked

Three built-in chat types sit under these rules: experience chat, party chat and direct chat, each with separate controls. A parent who turns off experience chat and direct chat has not necessarily turned off party chat or any developer-built chat. A "parent mode" that lets parents manage settings without their own account was, in NCOSE's description, being rolled out "gradually" as of November 2026. "A safety system that requires parents to be cybersecurity experts does not adequately protect children," James said.

The testimony quotes Roblox's 2025 annual report to argue that the company's incentives run the other way. Among risks to monetization, Roblox lists that "Measures intended to make our Platform more attractive to older users create the perception that our Platform is not safe for younger users." The same report says "a large number of our users are under the age of 13," and that "we depend on our creators to create digital content that our users find compelling, and if we fail to properly incentivize our creators to develop and monetize content, our business will suffer." James's conclusion: "Roblox needs to stop making child safety so complicated."

NCOSE's requests were specific. Roblox, it said, "can eliminate chat for minors and reserve that feature for adults who have verified their age." Congress should support COPPA, Section 230 reforms that would sunset liability protections for platforms like Roblox, the Kids Online Safety Act and the STOP CSAM Act of 2025. Voluntary measures, the statement adds, "can be changed, weakened, or removed by Roblox at any time."

The numbers witnesses put on the record

Figure Value Source cited in testimony
Daily active users (Roblox, February 2026) 144 million Roblox newsroom, February 5, 2026 (Gilles)
Share of those users who completed an age check 45% Same
Age-checked users under 13 / 13 to 17 / 18 and over 35% / 38% / 27% Same
Daily users under nine (2023) 21% Roblox 2023 annual report, as cited in a federal complaint (Gilles)
Daily active users, Q2 2026 About 123 million, about 10% higher year on year Roblox Q2 2026 shareholder letter (James)
Revenue, Q2 2026 $1.5 billion, up 36% year on year Same
Hours on platform, Q2 2026 About 29 billion Same
Users under 18 Nearly 73% Icon Era, a third-party statistics site (James)
Roblox reports to NCMEC 675 (2019), 13,316 (2023), 65,381 (2025) NCMEC data and the subcommittee's August 12, 2026 letter (Gilles)
State attorneys general suing Roblox At least 10 Louisiana, Kentucky, Texas, Florida, Iowa, Tennessee, Nebraska, Indiana, Oklahoma, Arkansas (James)
Active experiences More than 14 million Roblox 2024 annual report, via the FTC request

Gilles calls the NCMEC trend a "nearly hundredfold increase in six years," but the testimony's own footnote adds a caveat that matters: "these figures count reports, not distinct victims, and some of the increase may reflect changes in Roblox's detection and reporting practices." The 144 million and 123 million daily-user figures describe different quarters rather than a conflict.

The economy inside the game

The FTC request attached to James's testimony, filed by Fairplay and NCOSE on May 20, 2026 and joined by seven other groups, describes the money flows that sit behind both survivors' accounts. It asks the agency to examine three practices under Section 5 of the FTC Act: the marketing of virtual currencies and virtual assets to children, engagement-maximizing design, and representations about safety. It also asks for scrutiny of Roblox's COPPA compliance.

According to the request, Roblox runs a freemium model in which desirable items are sold for Robux. Roblox receives 70% of the profits from Marketplace sales of virtual items and the item's developer receives 30%, and only Premium subscribers can upload and sell items. Roblox says that, on average, 67% of in-experience spending "supports or goes to" developers. Developers can cash out once they hold at least 30,000 Robux, roughly $114 at the exchange rate cited. Premium costs $9.99 a month for 1,000 Robux, and Robux are sold in bundles starting at 500 for $4.99.

The request works through one example in the experience Dress to Impress. A "Rich Girl Set" costs 299 Robux, so a player must buy the 500 bundle and is left with 201. Spending those requires the in-game currency "Cash," sold only in bundles, which in turn requires another 500 Robux. After buying a pair of boots, the player holds 100 Robux and $2,000 in Cash, and the cycle repeats. The request calls this sunk-cost pressure and says the pattern recurs across many of Roblox's most popular games. It also names who supplies the items: individual players, professional studios and "major retail brands."

Why the ad market is watching

Roblox has spent more than two years building an advertising business on top of this audience. It opened video ads to all brands in May 2024. Magnite took exclusive global rights to Roblox's rewarded video inventory in January 2026. In February, Roblox told investors that rewarded video completion exceeded 90% across more than 1,000 brands and that 45% of 144 million daily users had completed age checks, which opened adult audience data to advertisers. SuperAwesome became Roblox's only third-party partner for contextual ads to under-13 users worldwide in June, a kidtech role in which persistent identifiers and behavioural profiling are off-limits. EDO signed Roblox as its first gaming partner for ad measurement the same month. And on the third-quarter call on October 29, Baszucki said developers are increasingly buying ads to acquire traffic.

Several of those deals rest on the age signals and safety settings that witnesses spent the afternoon disputing. The developer-chat carve-out applies to the same creator ecosystem in which, according to the FTC request, major retail brands create and sell virtual items. Schlep's account of an alleged abuser's avatar appearing on a store toy and in Roblox's television commercials puts the company's own marketing into the record. BBB National Programs, the nonprofit that runs the Children's Advertising Review Unit (CARU), framed the hearing the same way on November 18. According to BBB National Programs, nearly 200 lawsuits have been reported against Roblox, and the hearing raised wider questions about who is accountable when third-party developers, advertisers and other businesses operate in children's digital spaces, how platforms expose children to in-game purchases, virtual currencies and advertising, and whether companies can show their protections work rather than simply publish policies.

Roblox is not the only platform in this position. Texas sued Discord in May 2026 over claims it deceived parents, and Discord began opening auction-priced ad buying to studios in September. San Diego County sued AppLovin in October over adult ads shown to children in mobile games. A New Mexico court ordered Meta to fund a $567 million abatement plan in August.

Arbitration clauses, meanwhile, are standard across the industry's own contracts. Amazon reinstated binding individual arbitration for shoppers on August 14, 2026, with a mass-arbitration process that starts at 25 coordinated demands. Roblox's threshold, according to Gilles, is five. Google's advertiser contracts also require individual arbitration, which is why claims over alleged ad overcharges are being filed one by one. And in June, an arbitration ruling obtained by Meta kept former executive Sarah Wynn-Williams from speaking at the Hay festival. A federal rule that carves children's claims out of these clauses would apply to any platform with young users, not only Roblox.

What comes next

Several vehicles are now in play. The Forced Arbitration Injustice Repeal (FAIR) Act passed the House in 2022 and has been reintroduced as H.R. 5350 and S. 2799. The STOP CSAM Act, S. 1829, sponsored by Hawley and Durbin and advanced unanimously by the Judiciary Committee, was added in July 2026 to the manager's amendment for the Senate's fiscal 2027 defense authorization bill, S. 4784, which the Senate has not passed, according to Gilles. The new Hawley-Durbin arbitration bill reported by CBS adds a third.

The calendar is tight. Durbin, the subcommittee's ranking member, is retiring at the end of his term, and the November 3 election reshaped Congress, with the new Congress due to convene on January 3, 2027. Bills that are not enacted before the 119th Congress ends would have to be reintroduced. On the agency side, the FTC has not said publicly what it will do with the May request. In February it gave age verification tools a COPPA enforcement shield, the kind of checks Roblox now uses to unlock chat.

The written record has limits. It contains no statement from Roblox or Discord, and none of the senators' opening remarks or questions, which appear only in the video. Schlep's testimony does not give the year of the cease-and-desist letter. The 73% under-18 figure comes from a third-party site rather than Roblox, and the hearing page lists the session at 2:30 pm while its page metadata says 9:30 am.

Key facts

  • Hearing: "Roblox and Online Gaming: Digital Playgrounds Endangering America's Children," Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism
  • Date and place: Tuesday, November 17, 2026, 2:30 pm, Dirksen Senate Office Building Room G50 (after a location change); video length 2:11:13
  • Chair and ranking member: Senator Josh Hawley (chairman), Senator Richard J. Durbin (ranking member)
  • Witnesses: Michael Schlep and Woody Doe (survivors and online safety advocates, Texas); Khari James (Senior Legal Counsel, National Center on Sexual Exploitation); Myriam Gilles (Catharine Waugh McCulloch Professor of Law, Northwestern Pritzker School of Law)
  • Roblox participation: no Roblox witness; CEO David Baszucki invited and declined, according to CBS News
  • Written testimony dates: Gilles, Doe and Schlep submitted November 16, 2026; James dated November 17, 2026, with Exhibit A (Fairplay and NCOSE, Request for Investigation of Roblox Corp., May 20, 2026)
  • Roblox Terms of Use versions: effective April 30, 2026 (Section 11 arbitration); effective November 1, 2026 (sections 2.1 and 2.1.1: accounts for users aged 5 and older; a parent or guardian accepts on a minor's behalf)
  • Federal litigation: In re Roblox Corp. Child Sexual Exploitation & Assault Litigation, MDL No. 3166, No. 3:25-md-03166-RS (N.D. Cal.); Roblox omnibus motion to compel arbitration, ECF No. 452, September 22, 2026
  • State litigation cited: Doe v. Roblox Corp., No. 25-civ-05901 (Cal. Super. Ct. San Mateo Cnty.), Discord motion denied February 20, 2026; appeals Nos. A175211, A175220, A175379 (Cal. Ct. App. 1st Dist.)
  • Bills named: FAIR Act (H.R. 5350, S. 2799); STOP CSAM Act of 2025 (S. 1829); FY2027 NDAA (S. 4784); EFAA (Pub. L. No. 117-90); Kids Online Safety Act; No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act (per CBS News, no number given)
  • Hearing page: https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/committee-activity/hearings/roblox-and-online-gaming-digital-playgrounds-endangering-americas-children

Timeline

Summary

Who: The Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism, chaired by Josh Hawley with Richard Durbin as ranking member, heard from survivors Michael Schlep and Woody Doe, NCOSE senior legal counsel Khari James and Northwestern law professor Myriam Gilles. Roblox sent no witness; its CEO declined an invitation, according to CBS News.

What: Witnesses testified that Roblox uses a binding, confidential arbitration clause to try to move hundreds of child sexual exploitation lawsuits out of court, that developer-built chat sits outside Roblox's age-verification settings, and that the Robux economy creates pressure to spend and a lure for predators. They asked Congress to bar forced arbitration of children's claims and to pass child safety and platform liability bills.

When: The hearing took place on November 17, 2026 at 2:30 pm, with written testimony submitted on November 16 and 17.

Where: Room G50 of the Dirksen Senate Office Building in Washington, after a location change.

Why: Roblox is building an advertising business on an audience that is mostly under 18, and its legal strategy, terms of use and safety design are now before Congress. Any change to arbitration rules or platform liability would affect how Roblox, Discord and other platforms with young users handle claims, and how brands and ad tech partners weigh their exposure.